11 ms·
My simplified response to Paul Graham's simplified essay
- marcusgarvey 11y ago>In the long run this leads to oligarchy and possibly even economic and societal collapse. We are nowhere near there [...] False. We are there. http://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-echochambers-27074746 http://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-echochambers-27074746
- dgregd 11y agoPG:"We will not do a good job of fixing the bad causes of economic inequality unless we attack them directly. But if we fix all the bad causes of economic inequality, we will still have increasing levels of it, due to the increasing power of technology" I still don't get what PG is trying to say. For example few years ago Google and Apple bosses made secret agreement to not hire employees of the competing company. The goal was to transfer wealth from engineers to shareholders and bosses. There are a lot of other examples. That's why the essay had so much negative comments. PG should clearly condemn these practices. PG:"we will still have increasing levels of it, due to the increasing power of technology" That is just narrow VC point of view. Think about what cheap printing technology did for our civilization. There are countless of other examples. Today UK monarchy can only dream about the power they had. I had a dream that the technology (Internet, DVCS ...) will make legislation process more transparent. Tax loophole? Just file a bug, propose a fix, vote for the fix. Think about what Stack Overflow and Github did for software development. Something similar can be done for the law.
- zepto 11y agoHow do you know what the goal of the conspiracy was? Another possible goal was to stop the destabilization of projects by having the leads strategically poached. Neither goal makes it legal, but since you don't know the goal, the example doesn't support your argument.
- nimblegorilla 11y agoIt seems PG is thinking backwards on this. Instead of fixing the bad _causes_ of inequality we should try to fix the bad _consequences_ of inequality.
- GavinB 11y agoSite appears to be down. Google cache version: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:NoON38KY7psJ:blog.rongarret.info/2016/01/my-simplified-response-to-paul-grahams.html+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:NoON38K...
- zepto 11y agoThe only thing I'd disagree with is the statement 'we're nowhere near there' with regard to oligarchy and societal collapse. I think we're quite close. We have an entire generation where a tiny proportion have great prospects and the rest have steadily diminishing prospects and increasing stress, and we have educated people who grew up in the west going to join an expressly suicidal terrorist organization. We have a significant proportion of the population willing to vote for a demagogue whose positions are clearly nonsensical because he represents their (legitimate) anger at their lack of prospects the status quo affords them. The descent from here isn't going to be linear.
- drzaiusapelord 11y ago>I think we're quite close. USA: 5% unemployment, GDP per capita of $55,000, 78.74 years life expectancy, Human Development Index: 8, etc. EU: 9% unemployment, GDP per capita $38,000, 78.82 years life expectancy, Human Development Index: 6 average, etc. Yeah, we're not "close." Meanwhile countries like the BRIC nations, especially authoritarian autocracies like China or Russia, with terrible inequality and 100x the problems the West has strangely get a free pass from these discussions. HN your bias is showing.
- zepto 11y agoI said it isn't going to be linear. {seriously - downvotes? This is HN - surely people can conceptualize non-linear processes such as dams being punctured by small holes that lead to a collapse, or the rapid collapse of an animal population when a new predator is introduced, or the disruption of incumbents when a new technology is introduced e.g. Nokia with the iPhone}
- astazangasta 11y agoThis wealth is based on social cohesion, which can fall apart in a generation or two. Genghis conquered half of Asia and built an empire of great wealth and high culture, but lack of cohesion tore it apart not long after.
- 11y ago
- rcavezza 11y ago<<We tried it. It didn't work. No reasonable person disputes this. Karl Marx would argue that his ideas might have worked if someone else implemented them.
- skeolawn 11y agoMaybe he would, but all the experiments so far have failed for pretty much the same reasons and at enormous human cost. Meanwhile capitalism in whatever form it's tried has proven itself to be an incredible engine of poverty reduction and human/social progress. There's always been tension between capitalism and democracy and we may be at a point where some of the cracks are showing.
- xbejdjched 11y agoIt's worth keeping in mind that we do live in the propaganda bubble of the Soviet Union's arch nemesis. For their KGB, we had our J. Edgar Hoover. For their political purges, we had our House Committee on Unamerican Activities. For their later economic struggles, we had our great depression.
- cmdkeen 11y agoWe never had several deliberately inflicted famines killing millions of people. In every single example you listed Communist countries were demonstrably worse. Humanity is capable of some pretty awful things under any system of government - Communism, or perhaps the way it comes about, has consistently demonstrated that itself better at enabling our worst impulses compared to democratic capitalism. That people, included in the UK elected representatives, make a case for the Soviet Union and Communist China having done more good than bad is a a terrible failure of history.
- the-dude 11y agoHow about your native population? And your police force is still shooting former slaves on a daily basis.
- stcredzero 11y agoRon's First Law: All extreme positions are wrong. :-) Re: His last line about extreme positions -- Any position with "all" in it is extreme. Extreme positions aren't wrong. It's just that they're most often appropriate only in extreme positions.
- cushychicken 11y ago>Re: His last line about extreme positions -- Any position with "all" in it is extreme. Therein lies the joke.
- astazangasta 11y agoThe preface to all further discussion: wealth is power, and nothing else. In our highly capitalist society, monetary wealth is perhaps the only useful form of power, from which all other power (violence, social influence) ultimately flows. The Soviet Union attempted to produce equality of income, but not power: power was highly centralized. The equality I want is one that is diffusive.
- AnimalMuppet 11y ago> The preface to all further discussion: wealth is power, and nothing else. Okay, you made a dogmatic statement. That proves nothing, except that you are capable of making dogmatic statements. Wealth is the promise (perhaps false) of satisfaction, it is (perhaps false) identity, it is security, and it is the freedom not to have to work. I suppose you can say that all those are forms of power, but... If you define everything to be power, then yes, wealth is power, but that tells us nothing interesting except what your definition was. > In our highly capitalist society, monetary wealth is perhaps the only useful form of power, from which all other power (violence, social influence) ultimately flows. Democracy is another form of power. It is influenced by money, but not totally. That is, the little people can in fact vote against the money, and will do so if the money pushes too far. Campaign ads won't be enough if the little people get fed up enough. Social influence largely flows from money, I'll give you that. Violence? Money gives you a greater ability to use violence and still escape the law, but you can't go very far no matter how much money you have.
- astazangasta 11y ago>Wealth is the promise (perhaps false) of satisfaction I think, perhaps, you are speaking of the kind of wealth accumulated by middle class families. I'm speaking of the billions accumulated by Jeff Bezos, which allows him to purchase the Washington Post (etc). You might call this "satisfaction", but at this scale it's raw power - the ability to command resources and bend them to your purpose. >Democracy is another form of power. It is influenced by money, but not totally. Democracy is quite strongly influenced by money. I'm sure you've seen this study: http://scholar.princeton.edu/sites/default/files/mgilens/files/gilens_and_page_2014_-testing_theories_of_american_politics.doc.pdf http://scholar.princeton.edu/sites/default/files/mgilens/fil... which purports to demonstrate that American democracy responds exactly to the interests of economic elites and not to popular will. Popular will is much weaker than the influence of money. There is an entire (unelected) arm of government that is devoted to lobbying and writing legislation on behalf of monied interests; half of Congress leaves and joins this arm when their term is up. I'm not saying these things are inevitable, that monetary wealth cannot be constrained by democratic power, etc., just that this is not how things currently stand.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tomp 11y agoIncome doesn't help you much when most, if not all, of your disposable income is spent on rent.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- astazangasta 11y agoWhy not? How else have they managed to accumulate 40% of the wealth? This must be the case, mathematically. Wealth is the integral of net income over time. And savings rates are heavily skewed by income: http://static1.businessinsider.com/image/513125876bb3f7db40000004-960/moneygame-cotd-030113.jpg http://static1.businessinsider.com/image/513125876bb3f7db400...
- MisterBastahrd 11y agoYep. Money is power when one has the freedom to choose where to spend it.
- scylla 11y ago> For example, I would rather make $500k per year and have $10k net worth, than make $100k per year and have a $1 million net worth. Why? Are you assuming that you'll quickly build up your wealth in the first scenario. Personally, I'd be way more comfortable with the second - no worries around how long your income stream will last.
- tomp 11y agoPG's simplified essay seems like attack on a strawman; he's mainly arguing that inequality is good, but then mostly everybody agrees with that. The issue people see (and PG conveniently ignores) is increasing inequality - not locally increasing (i.e. an enterpreneur becoming rich because of a successful business idea), but globally increasing inequality, which happens because of rent-seeking, tax avoidance, buying political influence, monopolistic behaviour, corruption, nepotism, inheritance... Personally, I'm mostly concerned about the last one - inheritance. I don't have a problem with resourceful people being rich. But I see a danger of the wealth being concentrated over generations unless we introduce proper (non-avoidable) inheritance taxes.
- zepto 11y agoInheritance taxes on their own will do nothing to change the situation because then you'll simply concentrate all the wealth in corporate structures that transcend the death of their owners. Even if you make it impossible to 'pass down' these structures as property, you will have de-facto inheritance through nepotism and clan structures.
- dangerlibrary 11y agoI agree (and I suspect tomp would as well - it's generally best to give others the benefit of the doubt when they've been silent on an issue) that estate taxes are insufficient. I disagree with the implication that they are not a critical component of a solution.
- zepto 11y agoThey may be a critical component of a solution, but given what I said earlier about nepotism and clans, I'd argue that they would make things worse because they would further reduce the ability of the poor and middle classes to gain traction against those with corporate power. This is not dissimilar to the Soviet situation. So, even if they are a critical component, they are irrelevant unless someone can articulate how these other components would work.
- 11y ago
- retube 11y ago> Today, the top 1% control fully half of the planet's wealth This is a meaningless statistic given negative wealth is possible (indeed common). By this simple measure a recent MBA graduate of Harvard with 200k debt and no assets is poorer than a Mumbai slum dweller with 2 rupees in his pocket. I would argue that's not a fair reflection of the actual comparative wealth of the two individuals. A potentially better measure of wealth would be say energy consumption which is highly correlated with living standards. Of course the other point is that whilst inequality may be increasing, if measured in absolute cash terms, is that a bad thing if the living standards of the poor are being universally raised? A billion people in India and China have entered the middle class in the last 20 years. It's ironic that the perceived decrease in wealth of the middle class in the US is exactly because on a global scale inequality, at least amongst the middle 80% is decreasing: an increasing percentage of wealth created is being distributed east-wards rather than remaining concentrated in the historically dominant economic powers of North America and Europe.
- random_rr 11y agoYeah... the example you gave is meaningless. Knowing that wealth concentrates in 1% of human beings is not a meaningless statistic.
- EGreg 11y agoI disagree, simply because it comes down to how much money the MBA graduate has available to him at any given time, given the country's laws. No one is asking him to pay it off all at once. Having a loan you have to pay off over 30 years amortizes your losses, allowing you to have a net profit every month. And if he ever had the situation of the slum dweller, he could declare bankruptcy AND get rid of the student loan by claiming "extraordinary hardship". Finally, the social programs in this country mean that even a homeless, jobless person is richer than some employed people in Africa or Indian slums.
- ksowocki 11y ago> This is a meaningless statistic It's only meaningless if you cherry-pick your examples and draw your opinions from those examples. For 99 percent of the population, wealth is a fair reflection of the actual comparative wealth of individuals.
- FreedomToCreate 11y agoPGs argument does not take into account the majority that make it possible for the few to create things, but instead of being bolstered by those few, are instead being left behind. Its sad to say, but his current social position is definitely influencing his thought process. I turned down a job in Silicon valley. Even a 100K job doesn't mean anything when most of it goes to rent and my free time is spent sitting in a car or on a train commuting. I can imagine the stress the rent hikes are having on everyone else.
- yeukhon 11y agoPerhaps I am an ignorant. A little background about me: * I live in NYC * I live with my parents, still very young as a recent grad * I don't make tons of money, but with overtime I probably make 80K? I don't really count my money these days. * I do spend money on monthly gym membership (I should suspend that to save $100 since I am too busy haven't been there for a few months), netflix and couple other stuff. * I give my parents allowance (almost half of my paycheck) to help with mortgage and stuff * I am single all the way (that seems to be a pretty saving...) * only been working full time for one year And yet, I am still able to afford nice meal if I wanted to, go to nice places if I wanted to. Of course my wallet will bleed and cry if I were to spend too much, but on a daily basis I have a comfortable life, so I don't really feel an economic hardship, I don't make millions and the wealth is still controlled by that 1%. It doesn't bother me, until, if I were to have kids to raise, and a mortgage entirely on me. I think the attitude toward economic inequality needs a context. If you want to go on a cruise 365 days of course we can't afford that. Going to Italy and France once a year? That's gonna bleed for most of us. But in case of affording a good meal? Little but not too much. Then for those who makes significantly less than I make, they will feel the pain the most and I don't see a way out of it.
- burkaman 11y agoI'm in a similar situation to you, but: * One year out of college, you're in the top 30% of the US: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2012/01/15/business/one-percent-map.html http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2012/01/15/business/one-p... * You didn't mention loans, so I'm assuming you were able to graduate college mostly or completely debt-free Just these two points mean you're doing better than most people in the US, and much better than most people in the world. You never have to worry about about food or shelter, you have plenty of disposable income, you can support your family. Your comment seems to be phrased as "I'm as average guy, and I can be happy with what I have", but you're not average. 80K is "tons of money" for most Americans your age, most people aren't so comfortable that they never have to worry about money, most people can't throw away $100 a month without noticing. So you're right, discussion about inequality does need a context, but your context is that you're well into the top half of society.
- EGreg 11y agoThis is pretty silly. Also, Paul Graham's premise, I'm sorry to say, is sensationalized (by invoking concepts like "inequality" and "startups") but wrong. The premise is, basically, "inequality has bad CAUSES, but startups and technology are never one of them." Only at the end does he hint at what I believe to be the more accurate analysis: AUTOMATION and OUTSOURCING lowers demand for expensive human labor, therefore reducing one of the main ways that money trickles down to the middle and lower class. The better and more widespread the technology, the more I can 1) Outsource jobs to regions with a lower cost of living, leading to two losses of trickle-down: 1a) local workers don't get the job, and the money goes to someone in another country 1b) either way my company writes the expenses off its taxable income, but my country doesn't get the tax $$ from the worker's income to spend on social programs, safety nets etc. This by itself is fine, unless you're a nationalist, because it helps reduce poverty where people are poorer, which is outside your country. However, technology also enables: 2) AUTOMATION, which means I now reduce the amount of HUMAN workers, and once again it has two aspects: 2a) Now, the demand for human labor drops, and since the supply of workers remains the same, their average wages drop. 2b) The worst one: monopolies with server farms, contracts of adhesion, and all the power. Like Amazon, Google, Apple, Microsoft, Facebook, Uber, etc. extracting rents from users and providers, until open source disrupts them. By commoditizing the providers and workers, they get squeezed. See Amazon's dealings with wage slaves, and its tactics with publishers (middlemen which it eliminates). But those same workers are also supposed to be spending money back into the economy on things they need. It takes time to invent new industries and educate everyone, there is no guarantee that will happen forever, and there is no guarantee that demand shocks for labor won't be severe. So, there should probably be unconditional basic income, negative tax or some other scheme for people to KEEP BEING ABLE TO AFFORD THE BASICS even if they face no prospects of making money, which a growing unemployed class will. On the bright side, automation will help wean countries from their dependence on an ever-growing population to fund social security schemes. Endless population growth is unsustainable, and countries are currently worried about birth rates mainly because of that. So in a global sense, the solution is: tax the gains from automation, redistribute the proceeds, use condoms.
- vixen99 11y agoEurope as a whole has a <non-replacement> fertility rate of 1.5. In other words: it is dying. Total fertility rate for the US is just below replacement value at 2.09 and the total fertility rate for the world is 2.59, down from 2.8 in 2002 and 5.0 in 1965. Any weaning that goes on will certainly have to be off welfare schemes because they are going to collapse.
- PaulHoule 11y agoIt is like that Laffer curve. If your tax rate is too high, you get less revenue because of the negative effects. It is not just that "taxes kill the economy", but also that when the tax system is corrupt and inefficient people don't pay the tax. For instance the situation is crazy in Italy where officially 30% of the population is unemployed but actually most of them are working "off the books". This is to not to say Laffer was right or wrong that tax rates were too high circa 1980, but there is truism that taxation has good and bad effects. In a "perfect equality" scenario there is not incentive to raise your game, but the same is true in "perfect inequality." We did the experiment in Ithaca where local activist Paul Glover started "Ithaca Hours", a local currency. The system is still there, but it has mostly failed because a few businesses that accepted Hours could not spend the ones they got, so they have accumulated in a small number of places and do not circulate. Also I see people in situations where inequality causes them to "not try". For instance I know people with student debt or who owe a lot of child support who perceive that if they make another dollar it will just get taken away, so there is no point in busting your ass or taking things seriously. I funded a business run by one of them, by a guy who knew his market so well and had many of the skills of an excellent salesmen, and it ended it tears. I know some people, both black and white, who really have been the victims of poverty, discrimination, and such and feel they "can't win." You can point to examples such as Barack Obama and Ben Carson who overcome both real and perceived discrimination to succeed brilliantly, but most don't. Once when I was teaching I had a black student who was intelligent and very much liked by myself and the other teachers and we all wanted him to succeed and we were all proud that he got a respectable grade in the end in one of the most difficult classes at our school but had his own challenges and one day came around and told us we were treating him differently from other students and he was right, yet it was not at all that we did not want him to succeed but that we didn't entirely understand what to do to help him.
- CrowFly 11y agoWhen I read Graham's original essay I laughed. In my mind, he's a force for greater wealth _equality_. After all, he takes money from rich investors and puts it into startup companies, the majority of which do not produce great wealth.
- cryoshon 11y agoI would leave my simplified response at: income inequality prevents creation of startups and is generally bad for society. We don't want more income inequality at the end of the day. Our wildest dream is not to have a world in which everyone passes by but some are opulent, but rather a world in which everyone is opulent-- no inequality. In lieu of this greater dream, merely reducing inequality is a good start... the motions about being able to reduce poverty without changing economic inequality are laughably out of touch, still.
- joshhart 11y agoThere's one thing PG seems to implicitly which is that the movement from small company to large, dominating company in a vertical is a good thing. Ultimately startups seem to be producing winner-take-all companies. I do not believe this is a healthy thing for the economy or even rights of the consumer in the long run. There are a lot of services where if you do not like their terms, there may not be a great practical alternative. I don't want to see much changed, but I do feel the government should be encouraging competition much more than it is today. I do not think Facebook should have been allowed to buy Instagram, and I think WhatsApp should have been fined an enormous amount for blocking the words "Telegram" to stall their competitor. We put in the Sherman Antitrust laws to reign in behavior in the Gilded age and we should have a modern equivalent to encourage not one Google but 10 Googles in a market. I'm clearly asking for too much, but after all the recent Airline consolidation several studies have proven that prices are now higher in certain markets as a result of lost competition. Capitalism doesn't magically prevent monopoly or oligopoly - it is up to us to put the right checks and balances in place.
- bad_user 11y agoThere are natural monopolies and there are government granted monopolies and personally I believe the later are doing more harm than the former. Historically technology has made natural monopolies obsolete, but technology cannot bypass the law. Because when that happens, new trade agreements can be made and the law can simply be changed. If getting rid of monopolies is the goal, we could get rid of patents and copyrights, government granted monopolies which are about creating artificial scarcity.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoThe actual story of the Sherman Act isn't empirically defensible - J.D. Rockefeller became much richer overnight mainly because of the splits and prices don't seem to have changed much. But J.D. Rockefeller was rather single minded, set on reducing cost to the end consumer for Yankee cultural reasons. Higher price may or may not be worse price. With airlines, you live with Robert Crandall's "no airline ever returned its cost in capital" so it's difficult to make any of that make sense :) Many economists warn "never reason from a price change."
- natrius 11y agoYou've reframed the problem to wealth influencing politics, which still isn't something that needs to be fixed by taking money away from people. Redistribution is a decent solution to resource problems, but this isn't that kind of problem. Ending money in politics is hard to do using the levers of democracy since those levers have already been purchased, so I understand the desire to end extreme wealth instead. There is another solution, though. We can end the influence of wealth on our politics without needing the government to do it for us. Instead of trying to get the government to stop excess political spending, we should eliminate the incentive to accept excess political spending. People accept money to influence our democracy because they can use that money to get whatever they want from almost anyone, including you. You can't opt out because economic power is invisible. But we can make it visible, and give every individual the freedom to reject economic power that they feel is misused. This is merit capitalism. http://meritcapitalism.com/ http://meritcapitalism.com/
- edc117 11y agoThis is a very interesting mixture of two ideas I hadn't really considered before. Has this been discussed or brought up here previously? Is the only real obstacle to this adoption? It seems like an extreme transparency, but the lack of a central authority while maintaining reliability is very compelling.
- natrius 11y agoI bring it up in comments here any time it's relevant, but it hasn't had its own discussion. Adoption is the only obstacle, but tools and infrastructure are obstacles to adoption. There's lots of software to write before it's easy for people to install a mobile wallet app that banishes oligarchical influences from their personal economy. A bug/feature that needs to be addressed is that this mechanism can be used to enforce any rule enough people decide to pursue. We've discovered a lot of the ways our form of governance can go wrong over the past few hundred years, and we've even fixed some of them. We have to do the same thing for merit capitalism and limit its use until we know how to use it without causing catastrophes. Luckily, we can use merit capitalism to limit the use of merit capitalism: if someone breaks the "constitution" of acceptable uses, they can be sanctioned. We can slowly evolve the constitution as we learn more.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoPaul Graham, like nearly everyone in today's politics, fails to appreciate the near-universal validity, at least when it comes to social and economic policy, of Ron's First Law: All extreme positions are wrong. I realize this is tongue-in-cheek, but never forget: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_to_moderation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_to_moderation One could say that the modern world is largely a result of continuous middle-ground reforms that have built up into in an unfathomable and pathological state. Some radicalism might indeed be in order.
- ZenoArrow 11y ago> "I realize this is tongue-in-cheek, but never forget: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_to_moderation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_to_moderation " "Vladimir Bukovsky points out that the middle ground between the Big Lie of Soviet propaganda and the truth is a lie, and one should not be looking for a middle ground between disinformation and information.[2] According to him, people from the Western pluralistic civilization are more prone to this fallacy because they are used to resolving problems by making compromises and accepting alternative interpretations, unlike Russians who are looking for the absolute truth." Seeking absolute truth is a fool's errand. To use a physical analogy, truth is not a single point, it's a range. If you seek absolute truth you'll blind yourself to the range of possibilities.
- mattmaroon 11y agoI think that large income inequality has been harmful in the past because of scarcity. If a small number of people had a lot more money than the masses, it meant the masses were starving. Technology has the ability to potentially change this. It hasn't yet; it's mostly just given us the ability to play Candy Crush and look at what our friends ate for dinner while waiting in line at the store. But it will. And it's a mistake to assume that because income inequality in a world defined by scarcity causes social ills, it will necessarily do so in a post-scarcity society. Unfortunately using political influence for rent-seeking is a huge problem. I would like to believe, at least in our humble little democracy, that the masses are slowly awakening to this. At some point billionaires won't be able to use social-issue boogeymen like abortion and gay rights to convince poor people to vote against their own economic self-interest. I hope. I think that's implicit in the argument PG is making. Income inequality has always been bad in the past, but the future is not the past. There are variables that may change that.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoBut human nature is not as variable as human circumstances. Jealousy and envy can be just as strong even if you aren't starving.
- ikeboy 11y agohttp://www.vox.com/2015/1/22/7871947/oxfam-wealth-statistic http://www.vox.com/2015/1/22/7871947/oxfam-wealth-statistic http://fusion.net/story/44648/why-its-silly-to-add-up-wealth/ http://fusion.net/story/44648/why-its-silly-to-add-up-wealth... http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2014/04/04/stop-adding-up-the-wealth-of-the-poor/ http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2014/04/04/stop-adding... Can we just stop repeating that line?
- ThomPete 11y agoIt is also important to realize that startups might produce jobs but they are mostly capital intensive companies NOT labour intensive. This is especially true with technology companies who are notoriously hiring relatively few compared to the capital they spend. This trend will continue as technology removes more and more functions.
- eugenejen 11y agoThe only thing I don't like people to repeat about 1% owns 50% wealth is because that's just a mathematical truth from Pareto principle. If 20% populations owns 80% resources. Just recursively applying Pareto principle. You see 0.8% populations owns 51.2% resources. So we are in fact now efficiently using resources around the world to support 7 billions populations. Of course this ignores our biological tendency of protecting our offspring. So we try to pass down what we have to our children by non productivity related measures (such as lenient estate tax, immigration restrictions). That's the real reasons for the 99% population feels 'unfair'. If we are really fair, we should open first world border to all poor people around the world, right? But we don't. Same as people of wealth want to pass down their wealth to their children as much as possible. Or even try to starting a dynasty.
- ogrisel 11y agoThe Pareto distribution has a parameter (alpha in the mathematical formulation used on Wikipedia). If the value of that parameter evolves over time that might demonstrate an evolution of economic inequality. But indeed access to credit and amount of debt makes it hard to interpret the results on wealth. Income distribution might be easier to interpret.
- joefarish 11y agoI don't understand the obsession with wealth inequality, the focus should be on eliminating poverty not eliminating the number of billionaires.
- soheil 11y agoI read pg more as describing a phenomenon than trying to justify its existence. I'm not sure why so many people are so hostile to a simple explanation of what is.
- jernfrost 11y agoGreat reply, although I disagree with the typical simplified assertions that the Soviet System didn't work. Without doubt the system had major flaws. But it is perhaps much more shocking that the system worked as well as it did given so many obvious problems with it. Taking a primitive peasant society and turning it into a space traveling civilisation was quite astonishing. One has to also keep in mind that for decades the Soviet Union had very impressive GDP growth. The problem with discussing any of this is that the anti-socialism and communism feelings run so deep that people can't have a neutral discussion of the merits and flaws of socialism and communism. Anything positive can so easily be dismissed by the utter tyranny and inhumanity practiced by Stalin. By the irony of this is that Stalin does reflect the nature of socialism nearly as much as people believe. Both China and Russia were terrible and totalitarian societies long before socialism and communism. Still both the Soviet Union and China have turned into far more humane societies during socialism than they were at any earlier times.
- jtome 11y ago>Still both the Soviet Union and China have turned into far more humane societies during socialism than they were at any earlier times What do you mean be this? Surely modern != humane
- jernfrost 11y agoI am comparing to Imperial China and Czar Russia which were rather inhumane societies. Russia had serfdom and peasants were treated terribly e.g. 1980s Russia was a lot more humane society.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoIt's not as astonishing as you describe it. It's basic intuition that the relative growth of something will be greater in real terms the lower your starting point is. Robinson Crusoe finding a second stick to pluck berries with has doubled his capital structure and his output, but that's not particularly impressive. Starting from nothing, you can afford to just pump resources and treat the economy like it's a hydraulic system. It's what you do once you're up to parity that matters. By all means, planning was inefficient. You had chronic surpluses and shortages. The attempt to replace profits and losses with "socialist competition" resulted in a disincentive to create surpluses, because it would quickly be integrated as a benchmark in the next Five Year Plan. This then resulted in the phenomenon of shturmovshchina where laborers would mostly idle and then expend massive crunches of labor during the final quarters. The first seven years of Soviet rule were marked by massive hyperinflation. Wages were determined on a purely piece-rate basis, leading to workers toiling and factory managers manipulating quotas for greater wage returns. Attempted reforms under Khrushchev based on bonuses then only encouraged more homogeneity of production and made wage rates more volatile. The reason Soviet planners could even calculate in a system of purely vertical transfers of resources was because of the establishment of the Comecon in 1949, piggybacking on Western price indexes. Kosygin introduced a reform in 1965 allowing some measure of profitability and sales, resulting in some growth but no movement in aggregate productivity because of the underlying Five Year Plan incentives. More radical reforms involving decentralization and minimization of bureaucracy in 1973 and 1979 were both rejected. The Brezhnev era was marked by a large stagnation. Couple that with oil shocks affecting the key USSR exports, perestroika opening up the flood gates and the failed coup in 1991, the USSR was doomed to its failure. It had nothing to do with Ronald Reagan or anyone "ending communism". It ended itself. The Soviet system was a disaster and I can't imagine how anyone could say otherwise.
- billions 11y agoInnovation is the primary driver for improved quality of life. The kings of 1900 did not fly across the globe in hours, have access to the variety of foods of our lower class, and connect with loved ones in seconds. Basics such as a bed or filtered water came from innovation. Taxing or otherwise slowing innovation will put brakes on quality of life improvements for everyone. When have top-down mandates ever been as efficient at fixing problems as an individual grinding away at a cause they care dearly about?
- ubercow13 11y agoDid you read the article?
- Sealy 11y ago> In the long run this leads to oligarchy and possibly even economic and societal collapse. We are nowhere near there I totally agree with your point. I disagree with your opinion that we are nowhere near there... Just look at what the oligopoly practices of 'big banks' that were 'too big to fail' did to the global economy. They ALL used their money to influence the regulatory rules and the governments that governed them. Goldman Sachs was the worse at this, they were shameless in putting their ex employees into key White House positions. They built a gated community around themselves to protect their giant profits and when it all went south, the TAX PAYERS, US, WE PAID FOR THAT.
- serge2k 11y ago> We tried it. It didn't work. No reasonable person disputes this. I'd dispute that it was really tried, but I still don't think it would ever really work.
- minimuffins 11y agoThe "we already tried that" argument throws all the non state-capitalist ideas down the toilet with Soviet central planning though (it does belong there, of course, but so does American capitalism). There's a pretty wide range of ideas between anarchism and social-democratic capitalism that aren't included in the false binary of US/USSR models.
- jhh 11y agoWhat is the top 1 percent's share of the world's consumption? Wouldn't this be a more useful metric than looking at wealth or income distribution? Consider the following scenario: In a (conventional) socialist society the state controls an overwhelming majority of wealth. However, this would be justified by a (hypothetical) proponent of socialism by referring to consumption products being provided by this capital. Therefore, it seems the same measure should be taken with regards to market economies.
- dccoolgai 11y agoCapitalism is the best system for distributing wealth and governing trade - and simultaneously one of (though perhaps not the) worst forms of government. Societies that lose the ability to maintain that distinction - from either side - are inexorably doomed. We have regressed to a point where our grasp of that dichotomy seems tenuous at best.
- akmiller 11y agoOne step in solving it is adding more marginal tax rates. It's silly that they stop at 400k and 39%. I'd also introduce progressive taxing on capital gains as that's a primary way the wealthiest individuals get around income tax. The estate tax should also be progressive. These ideas aren't popular and would never get passed since the government is ruled by the wealthiest Americans but they would indeed be steps in the right direction.
- mcguire 11y ago"But if we fix all the bad causes of economic inequality, we will still have increasing levels of it, due to the increasing power of technology." This is the sentiment of the man who is certain he will be at the top of the heap when the dust settles.
- malmsteen 11y agoMore simplified summary of the debate : PG: "Startups create economic inequality. But it looks like they drive the economy and create value. I'll defend Startups so let's say that economic inequality is not a core problem" Crowd 1: - "OMG ECONOMIC INEQUALITY IS BAD !" - "OMG you defend concentration of power in rich people !" - "OMG your pinterest wall is more important that educating you children, that's what you call value ?!" - "OMG !" Crowd 2: - "Startups don't create that much economic inequality anyway" - "They don't actually drive the economy either" - "We're not sure they create value" - "Everyone know economic inequality is fine, we should adress poverty" Elon Musk: - When do we go to Mars guys ??!!!!????
- lackbeard 11y agoYes. It's bizarre to see everyone responding to something that wasn't actually said.
- jazzyk 11y agoMost people agree that inequality is not a bad thing in itself. But we have two problems with inequality right now: 1. The sheer amplitude of it. Having people whose net worth is equal to the GDP of a small country poses interesting questions (separate topic). This is caused by the winner-takes-it-all nature of globalized economy. Example: Ads featuring Gisele Bundchen sell to potentially billions of women all over the world, and she gets a cut. A generous one, because the market is global, not local as it was 30 years ago. 2. The fairness. Again, nobody has a problem with Steve Jobs making a lot money, because he produced. But there are people out there who got rich, just because of connections, etc. Al Gore has sat on (among many others) Apple's board of directors. Which part of iPad did he design? Even if you ARE qualified, there almost always is the luck factor. There are many other genetically blessed young women who look at least as good as Gisele Bundchen, but who, for whatever reason, never became the "it" girls. The are not starving (though they look like they do), but they are not raking in millions either. The same applies to more serious industries as well.
- lackbeard 11y agoThis, and Ron's original version, and most of the "my response to Paul Graham's essay" esssays I've seen aren't actually responses to Paul Graham's essay. Here's what I see happened: pg said, "Income inequality is a consequence of freedom and technology. If you want to reduce income inequality, be careful you don't wind up just making everyone less free and more poor." And then a lot of people said: "Paul, you asshole! Rich people can buy political power!" which is totally unrelated, and pg agrees is a bad thing...
- Apocryphon 11y agoPG's simplified essay and a lot of its proponents seem like people, in the middle of a drought, start warning about the potential for flooding. Yes, inequality is inevitable. Yes, the poor you will always have with you. Yes, central planning has been tried and found wanting. But that doesn't mean that the state of things is good, nor does it mean we need further deregulation, less taxes on the wealthy, and so forth. It's really weird to see threads where people argue against that the very existence of progressive taxation is some sort of statist plot. We need less philosophizing, and more evaluation of the current state of affairs and discuss what pragmatic steps need to be taken to alleviate the situation.
- guelo 11y agoGlobalization/free trade has caused wage stagnation in developed countries by allowing capital to more easily move jobs to the developing world. This system has created way bigger profits for capital, increased wages for millions in the developing world, and more wealth overall. All this has been enabled by the great triumph of "free trade" treaties that are the first way that humans have figured out how to create enforceable laws across countries. For example, the US recently repealed meat labeling laws due to a WTO ruling. This mechanism has allowed capital to bypass democratic forces that tend towards protectionism. But the free trade treaties arere heavily rigged towards manufacturer's interests with intellectual property industries now trying to influence them more. If labor had a seat at the negotiation table for creating cross-country enforceable rules the outcome for workers could be better. Some ideas I can imagine off the top of my head, - free movement of labor, not just capital - environmental rules that prevent capital from shopping for the jurisdiction where they can pollute the most - prohibitions on child labor, slave labor, trafficking, etc - all countries provide free education through teenage years - global tax shelter rules to prevent capital from hiding its profits
- ggreer 11y ago> Today, the top 1% control fully half of the planet's wealth. I've seen that statement debated, so I was curious if it was actually true. I had to follow quite a few links before I hit bedrock. Garret links to an NPR piece[1], which links to an Oxfam "study"[2], which references a Credit Suisse report[3], which is 64 pages long and covers way more than global wealth inequality. I finally found the relevant bit on page 10, in a section named, "Distribution of wealth across individuals": > Our estimates for mid-2013 indicate that once debts have been subtracted, an adult requires just USD 4,000 in assets to be in the wealthiest half of world citizens. However, a person needs at least USD 75,000 to be a member of the top 10% of global wealth holders, and USD 753,000 to belong to the top 1%. Taken together, the bottom half of the global population own less than 1% of total wealth. In sharp contrast, the richest 10% hold 86% of the world’s wealth, and the top 1% alone account for 46% of global assets. Finally! Can the author please link to that instead? It would have saved me so much time. So the statement is mostly true, except note that debt is counted. That means a significant fraction of people have negative net worth. Those trading against future earnings (using student loans, car loans, mortgages, etc) will be at the bottom of the wealth distribution. Remember, this is world wealth inequality, not US wealth inequality. What does US wealth look like? According to page 46 of the Credit Suisse report, 40% of US adults are in the top decile of wealth distribution. Heck, 7.5% of US adults are in the top 1% of wealth owners worldwide. There's a graph of US wealth distribution compared to the world.[4] It shows the US as a much more balanced place. More than anything else, "The top 1% control half the world's wealth." is a statement about the inequality of nations, not people. Unless one is advocating wealth taxes to finance foreign aid, it's disingenuous to further a domestic agenda by citing the impoverished masses in developing countries. I think if Garret took the time to be more rigorous, he could build a very good critical companion to PG's essay. But in its current state, it's not something I can really engage with. 1. http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2014/01/20/264241052/oxfam-worlds-richest-1-percent-control-half-of-global-wealth http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2014/01/20/264241052/... 2. It's just a short overview of others' research: https://www.oxfam.org/sites/www.oxfam.org/files/bp-working-for-few-political-capture-economic-inequality-200114-summ-en.pdf https://www.oxfam.org/sites/www.oxfam.org/files/bp-working-f... 3. https://publications.credit-suisse.com/tasks/render/file/?fileID=BCDB1364-A105-0560-1332EC9100FF5C83 https://publications.credit-suisse.com/tasks/render/file/?fi... 4. http://geoff.greer.fm/photos/screenshots/Screen%20Shot%202016-01-05%20at%2009.14.40.png http://geoff.greer.fm/photos/screenshots/Screen%20Shot%20201...
- JohnLeTigre 11y agoThe gist of the original essay is that it is kind of stupid to treat a symptom as a cause. Instead, we should address the problems that promote inequalities. The reply doesn't counter-argue this statement.
- webXL 11y agoToday, the top 1% control fully half of the planet's wealth. That is awfully close to the second extreme. I can't stand this malthusian, historically myopic, zero-sum thinking. Using that same distribution, if I started a business, hired 99 others using half of the equity, then we sold it and I ended up with $500 million, should this inequality be a concern? No. the concern should be whether or not there's real suffering taking place with how that other $500 million is allocated, and the purchasing power it has relative to the past. If you show me an economy that I can easily increase my real wealth by 5% per year, I don't really care what the guys on top are doing. What toys they are buying. I do care about them buying power, and they can only do that with a weak/corrupt political system. As PG reiterated: attack the causes, not the symptoms.
- minimuffins 11y agoNone of you are thinking about class. To you, this is a technical problem with a technical solution. Just a math problem. “How do we align incentives?” “How do we set the tax rate to maximize productivity and growth?” etc. As though simply increasing the number of startups and corporate wealth in the world will eventually eliminate scarcity and poverty. No big changes necessary, just keep up the good work and the great Polynomial Curve of Technology will propel us to the end of history. Some of you are more proactive. We should “attack poverty.” Like it’s a disease, and we can “science the shit out of it” and find a cure. But poverty, and disequal distribution generally are not diseases - unpleasant but inexorable byproducts of our evolution - they are inextricable from our political economy. Why? Because we have a society that is stratified by class! Our capitalist economy does solve the problem of distributing resources to everybody (though not equally or fairly, and not without wrecking the planet), and of creating new resources, new products, driving progress, but it also serves the crucial purpose of maintaining class power. Given the massive forward surge in productivity over the last 50 years, why do most of us now work more and earn less? Surely this isn’t the only way it could be. Even Keynes, the liberal economist thought we’d be working 15 hour weeks by now. So why don’t we? It’s because we’re in the working class, and the working class serves the ruling class. It’s not in their interest for us to work 15 hour weeks, and they’re in charge, so we don’t. That’s really all. Until working people have some democratic control over the economy, we’ll always work more and earn less, and wealth will accumulate at the top, because that’s what this system is designed to do. And it works. Our world is not billions of people on equal footing, freely exchanging goods and labor. It’s not woodworking artisans crafting chairs and selling them to each other. It’s owners and workers. Sure you can start a startup. Make a great app that coordinates precarious workers to take out SF yuppies’ garbage for them (yep, that’s a real one!), and transition from worker to owner. Great. You made it. That’s certainly not the norm though, and it certainly won’t eradicate poverty or scarcity. An on a human scale, it’s hardly progress. We used to have a space program, remember? We can do better than capitalism. Anyway we better, or we’re screwed.
- stillsut 11y agoIf I could summarize PG's thesis (and his critics misunderstanding) in one sentence here it is: Beware any promises to cure social ills that make an appeal to economic inequality, just as you'd be cautious of a surgeon trying to cure you by releasing evil spirits. I don't know why it's taking 100+ comments to get to the bottom of this 1% of the rich "have more wealth" than the Bottom 30%. It's simple: it's a misleading statistic and there's no defending it, or anyone who uses it to make their case. The reason why it's misleading points to the inevitable problems of using summary statistics of wealth inequality to evaluate economic performance.