9 ms·
Short answer: yes. I've lived in or around Boston for ~36 of my 41 years. The word "expressway" is no longer farcical, and the hideous rusted green monstrosity
by chrisweekly 11y ago
Short answer: yes.
I've lived in or around Boston for ~36 of my 41 years. The word "expressway" is no longer farcical, and the hideous rusted green monstrosity that used to cut off the waterfront from the rest of the otherwise very walkable city has been replaced by the aptly-named "greenway" linear park.... it's so much better I can hardly believe it. Yes, public transit needs more and better investment. Yes, the BD suffered from corruption and inefficiency. But, this lifelong Bostonian sees it as a messy, expensive, insufficient but necessary step in bringing this awesome little city into modernity.
- colanderman 11y agoAs a new resident of Boston I have to say the linear park is great. Food trucks + eating in and walking through that park during the summer transforms what would be a soul-crushing concrete jungle into a pleasurable place to unwind during lunch.
- tibbon 11y agoSame here. It was expensive and fraught with issues in making it (including poorly glued ceiling panels when they opened it), but now it seems pretty great. I can get from Somerville to Dorchester or the airport in minutes on 93.
- prplhaz4 11y agoI completely agree. I returned to Boston after 10 years away and was floored by the transformation. I see it as flushing away a huge amount of technical debt that we had incurred over the last 100 years, hopefully setting us up for modernization on many fronts - which is quite a big deal when you consider it's competing to be a top tech hub.
- deveac 11y agoI lived in Boston in the mid nineties for about three years, doing shipping logistics that served the downtown & surrounding areas. I didn't have a frame of reference, and really only ever knew the city in the midst of that debacle, having to design courier routes throughout the area. Needless to say I was intimately familiar with the Big Dig. I had the pleasure of returning to the city in 2015 for a brief bit of work with my current company and was utterly blown away at the transformation of the boulevard, the green spaces, the visual beauty...and just the sense of openness and lightness. I felt like I could breath easier just walking down the street. It's a shame to have had to overpaid so dearly for that, but what an amazing result. It was a great city before, but this just felt next-level.
- scarmig 11y ago"Expensive" spans a whole range of values. The Big Dig was $24 billion. For point of comparison, the population of Boston is around 700k, and the per capita income is 33k. That's... $23 billion. I support infrastructure projects, and at this point think we should consider the Big Dig a learning experience and not a political punching bag. But can we really say it's a success, considering the countless other uses of the money that we had to pass on?
- swampthinker 11y agoWhat about the increase in property value, and all the other ways it improved Boston's air quality and overall look?
- Semiapies 11y agoA fair question, but any benefit from property value increases is limited to the landowners.
- abetusk 11y agoThat's really disingenuous. The greater Boston area is 4.5M people [1]. For comparison, it's like saying New York City is only 1.6M (the population of Manhattan [2]) when the population of New York city is 8.5M total. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greater_Boston https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greater_Boston [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manhattan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manhattan
- Johnny555 11y agoSure, it's "worth it" when taxpayers pay for most of the price, but would drivers thing it was worth it if the tunnel had a $5 toll to pay for it?
- zanny 11y agoI personally hate traffic enough that if I had to chose between a commute in bumper-to-bumper congestion in the late 90s across an entire city or paying a $5 daily toll to avoid it, there is no question I'd go with the later, and I imagine a lot of people would agree.
- adrusi 11y agoThis is the kind of project that makes much more sense to be paid for by taxes than tolls. The primary goal wasn't to make commutes faster, it was to improve the city and boost the economy on a significant scale. Tolls are a regressive tax, they tax the working and middle class who have to commute, and the shipping companies who just pass on the expense to retailers and consumers (I'm not sure what the distribution of industrial/commercial shipping volume is, but I imagine that food and other consumables account for the majority). When it's paid for by taxes, you have the corporations who can now hire people from outside the city more easily, the tourism industries, and other entities that are actually reaping the most from the project paying for a proportionally larger amount than your average driver. Not only is that more fair, that the only way such a project could ever get funded.
- Johnny555 11y agoIsn't requiring driving itself a form of regressive tax? Forcing people to purchase and maintain expensive cars, pay for gas, pay for expensive downtown parking, etc? "Here's this nice shiny new road, it's yours for free! All you have to do is pay $500/month in car expenses to use it. For Free!" And improving one road requires further improvements to other roads as traffic increases due to induced demand. City streets (and parking) is extremely expensive to improve, so after you spend billions of dollars to feed cars into downtown more efficiently, how do you address downtown congestion and parking?
- WildUtah 11y agoThe benefits of the Big Dig are confined to the excellent removal of the hated green monstrosity. (Not to be confused with the beloved Green Monster) The new greenway park brings the city back together and makes us ache once more for the West End that was raped and smashed and destroyed by so-called Urban Renewal. The new underground freeway is a waste. Twenty billion dollars were buried for a road that does little for outer suburb traffic and nothing at all for Boston. The best thing would have been to knock down the Central Artery and replace it with nothing at all. Or we could have had a North Station-South Station connector. You could have that as a cheap cut-and-cover subway for 1% the price of the Dig. You could find a way to demolish the new City Hall along the way; that hideous thing has to go. It would be a bit slow and have a turn or two at that price but would be fantastic for transit service.
- givinguflac 11y agoA major reason putting that underground was a goal was to capture and filter emissions, which has definitely helped. Keep in mind too that the whole projects was designed decades before many newly modern construction techniques.