6 ms·
I don't know whether this is a real difference or not, but Lyft "feels" like a much nicer company than Uber. I'm not thrilled about Lyft's rampant hipster-brand
by ForHackernews 11y ago
I don't know whether this is a real difference or not, but Lyft "feels" like a much nicer company than Uber. I'm not thrilled about Lyft's rampant hipster-branding, but Uber seems like a company run by pricks.
Maybe it's just because they're the underdog, but I'm really rooting for Lyft.
- FatalErrorr 11y agoIf nothing else, I'm rooting for Lyft so that Uber is not the only one out there. I'm scared of what would happen to service / prices if Uber had no real competition. For that reason, I only use Lyft.
- ihsw 11y agoLocal monopolies are usually the rule rather than the exception, with global monopolies rarely (if ever) occurring. This makes me wonder if Lyft can leverage the backlash against Uber and achieve success in areas hostile to Uber but not hostile to ridesharing/Car-as-a-Service services. It is essentially a land-grab but on a global scale, with the measure of success being on-going local dominance on a per city basis. Personally I find it fascinating, the goings-ons of municipalities are usually quite opaque to outsiders and the insight is new.
- discodave 11y agoLocal monopolies are the norm in industries where massive capital investment is required (electricity, cable). Uber is not this type of business. Uber is more like a marketplace (like Amazon or Ebay)... while network effects are strong there is no reason to think that local monopolies are inevitable. Also, if you catch an Uber in SF or Seattle, the driver is likely to be running Lyft and Uber. Sure, Uber can try to give drivers disincentives to use multiple apps. But good luck doing that AND staying out of anti-trust investigations AND convincing everybody that their drivers are still contractors not employees.
- bbarn 11y agoThink back to Uber's beginning. It was incredibly elitist - only black cars, twice what a taxi cost, etc. Even the name reflects that. They're almost at parity now though, at the normal person level in Chicago at least. I get nearly killed by either on my bike just as easily :)
- acomjean 11y ago>I get nearly killed by either on my bike just as easily Glad I'm not the only one who notices these cars randomly driving slowly or parked in the bike lanes waiting for the next ride to come in. Ride safe..
- akgerber 11y agoIn NYC, where Uber/Lyft drivers are required to operate Taxi and Limousine Commission-licensed cars, citizens can file complaints via the web, leading to tickets: https://twitter.com/hashtag/cyclistswithcameras https://twitter.com/hashtag/cyclistswithcameras
- myth_buster 11y agoThey get more distracted by the phones I believe. Specially in between rides when they have to accept ride requests in a timely fashion. I've seen drivers parked in lots when they are awaiting a request but in places where parking is charged such as downtown, I think they prefer to keep looping around blocks. There may be an interesting case study to be made on the environmental impact of these idling cars.
- amyjess 11y agoAlso, some drivers are lazy and don't get proper mounts for their phones. I've had a few Lyft drivers spend much of the ride with their faces buried in their phones because they didn't bother to get a mount and don't want their nav to speak out loud. I also had one reckless idiot spend the whole ride texting while driving, too.
- ebbv 11y agoAll the evidence that I've seen shows the Uber folks don't care about the law, their drivers or the general public. I don't know that Lyft is better, but I haven't seen the same level of disregard for others.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoWhen I was in Colorado Springs, Lyft was much more available than Uber so I used it for the first time after only having ever used Uber for the past year. The major thing I found different was the driver wanted me to sit in the front and was much more enthusiastic about conversation. It wasn't bad but it was definitely different and somewhat offputting. Not sure if that was just a single event, but I wonder if each company encourages those differences in driver interaction.
- dswalter 11y agoThat convivial atmosphere is one of the things that originally set Lyft apart. More recently, they've tried to figure out how to balance that with people who prefer silence. http://thehub.lyft.com/blog/2015/7/14/giving-betterrides-great-conversation-or-golden-silence http://thehub.lyft.com/blog/2015/7/14/giving-betterrides-gre...
- bnj 11y agoSounds like a Colorado Springs effect. Here in NYC I've used both fairly evenly and (unsurprisingly) the experiences are fairly similar and in line with the typical "uber" style of sitting in the back and not talking unless you choose to reach out...
- omm 11y agoFrom my experience in NYC many drivers drive for both Uber and Lyft. In an anecdotal poll I ran with those drivers, they say Uber riders usually like to be left alone while Lyft riders are more chatty.
- ihsw 11y agoI have found the exact same thing in Uber drivers -- questions like "How was your day?" are commonplace, and some have chewing gum or other amenities.
- dpweb 11y agoI've found Uber drivers (all over the country) to be just the right amount of chatty, and very friendly. Haven't tried Lyft yet.
- acomjean 11y agoI haven't used either, but generally competition is good for the consumer. The option to go the competition always makes things better. The software business tends to like monopolies as the price to build the first one is usually quite expensive but the cost to build each additional one is fairly cheep. That combined with the more people (drivers and riders in this case) use the software the better it gets leads to fewer big companies with more users.
- pmorici 11y agoThe big difference for me is that Lyft allows you to tip in the app that's very telling.
- amyjess 11y agoYes, especially since I've heard horror stories about Uber drivers one-starring customers for not carrying cash.
- wavefunction 11y agoI suppose I wonder why I would ever want to pay for a service where I will be rated for my qualities as a consumer of that same service.
- rconti 11y agoI've never heard of anyone tipping an Uber driver. I'm not sure why they'd know if I have cash or not.
- morgante 11y agoYes, it's very telling that Lyft offers a suboptimal experience.
- amyjess 11y agoNot being pressured to carry cash is a suboptimal experience? I refuse to carry cash. If I were to take Uber, I'd have drivers one-starring me and giving me a bad reputation for not tipping them. With Lyft, I can tip in the app and avoid all that mess.
- cballard 11y agoYou're not supposed to tip Uber drivers, that was one of the main selling points of Uber. The fares are higher than yellow cabs to compensate for that.
- 11y ago
- crdb 11y ago> Uber seems like a company run by pricks I recently interviewed with Uber in Asia, spoke to a half dozen people there right up to the head of the region and many Americans who have been with the company for years, and I did not get the job (so, clearly not biased towards the company). Here's my one data point: they were all really nice, professional, competent people I'd actually want to work with. When I say nice, I don't mean polite, but trustworthy and well intentioned. They are working very hard to cope with the massive growth of their app, trying to figure out how to manage 200 offices in parallel with tiny teams whilst keeping the same quality standards and avoiding unsavoury incidents that come when you hire a large number of people in many locations (imagine what would happen if there was a rape or robbery attempt by an Uber driver). They are under extreme press scrutiny and large amounts of negative PR globally, because they are hitting some of the best organised, most entrenched oligopolies. Psychologically, it felt like there was a strong sense of family and purpose, that I haven't really seen since I left commodities trading (whose companies are family owned businesses where long careers are common). They were proud of what they were building, genuinely appreciating the value added to the community by their work. The place also felt meritocratic, with people getting expanded responsibility rapidly after proving themselves (based on the career path of the long timers I talked to - could be survivorship bias). Naturally, I poked a bit towards the "unethical" side of things, suggesting a couple of things as feelers for how they would react. The reaction was overwhelmingly negative - it seems that "dirty tricks" are not looked well in Uber in 2015 at least, fair competition is the name of the game. So, they impressed me enough as people (after impressing me as a service) that here I am putting up a positive word on HN. I suspect much of the negative press is "black" PR from competitors and threatened interest groups.
- aqzman 11y agoJust wondering, do you think the fact that you "poked a bit towards the "unethical" side of things" played any part in you not getting the position?
- crdb 11y agoI wish it was the case (wouldn't that be convenient for my reputation) but it was a more standard culture fit problem, they didn't think we'd work well together. Specifically, the job involved a lot of cross-office coordination and I'm more of a "get the job done", technically focused kind of manager than the more political nature of the managerial role in question (political in the sense that you need to help multiple teams work together harmoniously and efficiently, not House of Cards). They were quite open with feedback which is another reason I have good feelings towards the company. The whole process was very quick - responses in days. Compared to what my friends tell me about Google's sometimes multi-year process, it's a dream. I don't know how much I can say about their internal structure but what I found very cool (especially as a former Rocket Internet employee) was their focus on and methods for detecting and spreading knowledge across the entire organisation, which is sort of decentralised even if many important decisions are made in California. This is something we never got right at Rocket, where companies and regions are much more independent and have wildly differing methods and standards. It was very rare for things to cross over beyond the "startup code" (the PHP e-commerce codebase that is sent over to be deployed when a venture is opened) and some marketing methodology. The other large companies I've been familiar with are better at sharing information, but tend to have a global hub where most of the thinking is done anyway (i.e. knowledge tends to radiate outwards).
- ape4 11y agoThis is a space where "niceness" matters. Since a lot of it is all about human interactions.