16 ms·
Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom
- kelukelugames 11y ago>So why doesn't Graham recognize and advocate this? Perhaps it's because two of his biggest golden geese — Uber and AirBnB — are actually relying on exactly the kind of political influence I'm calling out here in order to survive and prosper. Whether this is true or not, we need to realize PG has motives. He doesn't write essays just for his health.
- nostrademons 11y agoHaving read PG's essays since 2002, I suspect his motive is that he wants to have good ideas. The kind that will be remembered after his death. He even said as much in one of his essays [1]. He's writing for legacy, not for profit. YC itself was one of those ideas - it started out as an experiment [2], derived from a talk at Harvard Computer Society [3]. The easiest way to test if an idea is a good one is to go do it, so he did, and it turned out it was, and that led to profit. I don't think it's fair to attribute Machiavellian scheming to PG. There are some other people in Silicon Valley that will take a position and then influence public opinion to make that position come true, but it's pretty rare, and I don't think it's the case here. Rather, it's the same reason all VCs talk their book: they start with a hypothesis about how the world is, then invest their book according to the hypothesis, and then tell everyone what the hypothesis is. The worldview comes first, the investments come second. [1] http://paulgraham.com/speak.html http://paulgraham.com/speak.html [2] http://www.paulgraham.com/bronze.html http://www.paulgraham.com/bronze.html [3] http://www.paulgraham.com/start.html http://www.paulgraham.com/start.html
- paganel 11y agoFrom half a world away I wouldn't say his motives are "Machiavellian", but his style and the subjects he wrote about definitely changed just after reddit and especially YC became important, mostly for the worst/not-interesting. I think I started reading his essays in 2004 or so, and he was a cool guy, not as cool as jwz, for example, but pretty interesting nevertheless because of his story of actually making some good money out of having used LISP (which back then was like a Nirvana-reaching thing, I mean, making big money out of LISP) and for being a programmer who was actually showing interest for other things outside programming, like Renaissance painting (Christopher Alexander and his Turkish rugs' patterns was also a thing back then among programmers). But then reddit launched, YC was founded, somehow they started making money, and things like Arc and trying to make LISP a world-dominating language became things of the past. That's when his writings became a lot less interesting for guys like me, i.e. for average programmers who just wanted to read what other guys smarter than them had to say.
- S4M 11y agoComing also from half a world away from Silicon Valley (Europe), I also think there is a large discrepancy in PG's essays before and after YC became successful. Before YC was successful, I felt that his essays were written by a very smart guy who thought a lot about various topics, and his advice made lots of sense (don't go for prestigious fields for prestige's sake, find what you really love, etc.), while now it feels that he's thinking that everything converge to make startup the only path to success (I'm exaggerating a bit, but not that much). I don't think he does that to bring more and more people to apply to YC, but I can feel the influence on spending lots of time with VCs and startups.
- tptacek 11y agoMy best guess is that Graham writes these "essays" because he is, like a lot of us, simply the kind of dork who enjoys writing stuff like this.
- dang 11y agoIt's closer to "for health" than you'd think. If you talked to PG about this I'm sure you'd come away with the same sense. My impression is that he writes essays as a way of thinking and because it makes him happy. Edit: these are representative of talking to him about it: https://twitter.com/paulg/status/676834210976411648 https://twitter.com/paulg/status/676834210976411648 https://twitter.com/paulg/status/680162174648492032 https://twitter.com/paulg/status/680162174648492032
- kelukelugames 11y agoI bet he writes as a way of thinking and it makes him happy. I bet he has biases, leanings, and motives too. Some of them are private or even subconscious.
- dang 11y agoSure, but you've replaced a very strong (implied) claim with a weak one that would be true of anybody.
- forrestthewoods 11y ago"At the very least, we should strive for a non-regressive tax system, which is what we have now." I'm super pro regressive taxes. Regressive taxes are fantastic for the poor. They get more than they put in AND the elite are less able to avoid paying them. The socialized promised lands of Scandinavia are highly regressive. http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/11/17/why-im-soft-on-sales-taxes/?_r=0 http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/11/17/why-im-soft-on-s...
- monochromatic 11y ago> The socialized promised lands of Scandinavia are highly regressive. No, they aren't. Regressive means that the rich pay less, percentage-wise, than the poor do.
- forrestthewoods 11y agoDid you even read the link I gave?
- zurn 11y agoYour link's graph shows that nordic countries have highest social transfers and highest consumption taxes. This means that they are countering the regressive effects of consumption taxes with other income transfers. What the graph doesn't show is that income tax (and many other fees/taxes) are also quite progressive in these countries. So the graph supports Krugman's claim of high consumption taxes in these countries, but not your claim of on "highly regressive" taxation. Krugman's other reference has a broken link but his text does not sound like your claim either. But in the big picture, income transfers do seem to be more favoured in strong welfare states than progression in the tax system. The US has a mongrel system with EITC because you get a "negative income tax" by social criteria (basis of which are quite 1950's...) - it's more like a social transfer in many respects than a tax progression.
- brbsix 11y agoLets add increased sales tax for all domestic yacht purchases also, it's not like wealthy people can go elsewhere or do other things with their money.
- UK-AL 11y agoUber hired lobbyists because they had no choice. Traditional companies have captured the regulatory system so bad you have idoitic laws designed to protect them. In London one law was proposed for a minmium wait time of 5 minutes. It was directly aimed at uber.
- graeme 11y agoDid YC fund Uber? I had thought they weren't a YC company.
- lisper 11y agoYou're right, they didn't. I've added a correction.
- nostrademons 11y agoI don't think Uber is a YC investment. It's certainly not listed as such under CrunchBase, nor have I seen any public article mentioning them as an investment.
- hkmurakami 11y ago>So once again, let me be clear: I do not want to kill Y Combinator, nor do I want to kill Uber or AirBnB. AFAIK Uber is not a YC portfolio company.
- kelukelugames 11y agohttps://twitter.com/paulg/status/678653529288916996 https://twitter.com/paulg/status/678653529288916996 PG on Uber. "No, just a user."
- lisper 11y agoWow, you're right. I've published a correction.
- rayiner 11y agoMr. Garret quotes Sanders: > The reality is that for the past 40 years, Wall Street and the billionaire class has rigged the rules to redistribute wealth and income to the wealthiest and most powerful people of this country. I am rather puzzled that this idea gets so much traction. Does anyone really believe that if only the rules weren't "rigged" local shops and businesses would be able to compete against Wal-Mart and Amazon? Do people really believe that it's only because of "rigged" rules that big employers are downsizing and shipping production overseas? It's wishful thinking. The rules don't drive rewards to the top. It's intrinsic to the free market.
- nostrademons 11y agoI don't think that the rigged rules lead to consolidation of wealth per se, but I do think people would be much less upset about consolidation of wealth if the rules weren't rigged.
- MrTonyD 11y agoIt took me years to realize that economics isn't physics - and it isn't ruled by physics-like laws. Instead, economics is governed by laws created by our society. And what we think of as "free market" is really just norms of trade which are created by our society. There is no reason why the bulk of the billions taken-in by WalMart should go to the Walton family while their employees live on food-stamps - that is just a legal arrangement. And there is no reason why the Walton family should continue to be allowed to use offshore corporations to loan themselves money to run all their WalMart stores - that is just a legal arrangement which allows them to avoid taxes and hide their billions offshore. Really, when you start to closely examine "free market", you come to realize that is it a chimera made real by those with power and money.
- UK-AL 11y agoDo you believe in property rights? Having a legal/police system to catch people who forcebly take property? Using trade to exchange property? This is the core of our system. And that system will always generate inequality. Not necessarily a bad thing. You can have laws to take the edge off inequality generated, but at the core of the system you can't really avoid it.
- rubyfan 11y ago@pg is basically arguing that fragmentation is leading to the end of oligarchy and this author is arguing we are headed toward it. Who's right? The comments I've read today on a few of these posts today are so divisive that I'm not certain they come from the same universe. FTA: On the other hand, I also want an effective, democratic government to provide infrastructure, protect people from extreme economic contingencies (like war and hurricanes), prevent people from profiting from economic externalities (like pollution) and provide oversight for well-regulated, free and transparent markets. And that's not the direction we're heading. We're heading towards political power being concentrated irreversibly in the hands of a small minority. We're heading towards oligarchy. And that is a problem.
- dovereconomics 11y agoSome decent points, but why can't anyone acknowledge the centralization of capital? Sure, Uber lobbies city mayors, but what about the financial system that gives $6.6B to a single startup? The inception of all problems. Politicians and lobbyists? I'd worry about the Fed.
- tipiirai 11y agoThank you. Glad you wrote this.
- zacharytelschow 11y ago> If the differences in income and wealth were entirely reflective of people's productivity and contributions to society there would be no problem. But they aren't. Instead what is happening is that the ultra-wealthy are using their disposable income to buy political influence, then using that influence to get laws passed that allow them to collect rents. If you're arguing the problem is the ability of the political class to pick winners and losers instead of creating rules that are beneficial to society generally and applied to all equally - amen.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- cjy 11y ago>The Baumol Effect, in case you didn't know, is the tendency of wage increases that come from increases in productivity to "spill over" into jobs where there have been no productivity increases. In other words, it's trickle-down economics under a fancier name. Mr. Garret gets the definition of the Baumol Effect more or less right, but then mislabels it as trickle down economics and proceeds to attack that. Here is an example of the Baumol Effect: As improving technology makes computer scientists more productive they will receive higher salaries in the business world. Meanwhile, computer scientist teachers in academia may not see similar productive gains (they still can only teach X number of students a semester). Nonetheless, universities must increase computer scientist teacher pay to prevent them from leaving academia for the business world. In the context of PG's essay, he is saying that high pay for entrepreneurs forces companies to pay competitive salaries: >anyone who could get rich by creating wealth on their own account will have to be paid enough to prevent them from doing it. If Mr. Garret, or others, disagree with this assertion they should attack it directly. Personally, the logic and direct incentives at work seem self evident to me.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- natrius 11y ago> It is possible to address this problem without killing the golden goose. How? By rolling back some of the legislation that was put in place by undue political influence. Using the political system to reduce the influence of money in politics is prohibitively difficult because the system is already captured by money. We should try, but we need other options when that fails. When government stops responding to the wishes of the people, revolution is the typical answer. Luckily, we don't have to do that. We can end the influence of wealth on our politics without needing the government to do it for us. Instead of trying to get the government to stop excess political spending, we should eliminate the incentive to accept excess political spending. People accept money to influence our democracy because they can use that money to get whatever they want from almost anyone, including you. You can't opt out because economic power is invisible. But we can make it visible, and give every individual the freedom to reject economic power that they feel is misused. This is merit capitalism. http://meritcapitalism.com/ http://meritcapitalism.com/
- cpursley 11y agoIf I could give away all my hn points and apply them as up-votes to this, I would. The op explains very succinctly the problem in this quote: > what is happening is that the ultra-wealthy are using their disposable income to buy political influence, then using that influence to get laws passed that allow them to collect rents. My primary beef with American politics is the "solutions" are always in the form of bandaids - they focus on the effect, not the root cause. The recent healthcare laws are a prime example. How to handle the rise of ISIS is another. Both were caused, or at least compounded by misinformed short-sighted policy. The answer is rarely "more laws". Especially when more laws was what lead to most of these problems in the first place. It's like writing more code around terrible code when what is really needed is a total refactor and proper test coverage. Ending cronyism is fairly straight-forward. But stacking on more law is only going to exacerbate the issue, because like the op explained - the well-connected are just going to buy more political influence and have the laws crafted to benefit them. Taxation is more complex. Increasing taxes is often a solution proposed. Fine, but first - the government needs to prove that they are good stewards of our money before reaching into my back pocket for more. Otherwise, that increase is going to end up as farm subsidies and in the pockets of "defense" contractors.
- vonklaus 11y agoInteresting perspective. I wonder how much "cronyism" costs. It is a problem, but how big? Sort of the issue is that their is a systemic change taking place globally and it moves at a compounding rate. Most governments on a micro scale, are inefficient snd comprised of largely unaccountable people. They make (benevolent/naive view) decisions but are ill equipped with the skills to make the proper ones or (cynical) intentionally extract bwnefit. On a macro stage, we are still dumping money into infrastructure in competition with eachother. If we had all the best engineers working on space for example and collaborating, this would be good, or working to solve things collaboratively. Luckily as PG notes there is a massive defragmentation. I would argue this is great. Agency is redestributed to people in this way and the effects of this will be evident in ~5 years when the laggard affects of technology overtake many legacy industries. Cable is being challenged. The monetary system is being challenged. This election cycle will highlight apathy. It will be realized soon enough that the government will have much less power and is thus, less neccessary. Etc. Also, I just saw The Big Short. The L3 money supply (which is super complicated and I don't pretend to fully grasp) is basically mbs in ~2005.
- gizi 11y agoIt can all be reduced to the problem of man-made law. It is wide open to abuse. So, yes, the ultra-rich abuse man-made law to make more money. But then again, machine guns easily overrule money. That is why there are now islamic insurgencies, in 30+ countries, of which the primary purpose is to get rid of man-made law (and to establish their favoured alternative). The problem goes way beyond the distribution of income. At some point, everybody who believes in the legitimacy of man-made law will have to prove that he is willing to risk his life and die for what he believes in.
- mwcampbell 11y agoWhat alternative to man-made law would you propose?
- gizi 11y agoScriptural law, for example. Each religion enforces its own law. This solution may not be ideal in every possible respect, but to the extent that it puts a halt to the invention of new man-made laws, it will certainly mitigate the problem. Every man-made law represents a reduction in your freedom with the purpose of serving the interests of someone else. Therefore, I am in favour of any alternative solution that will put a halt to people inventing new laws.
- chimericray 11y agoDoes any scripture cover traffic violations?
- gizi 11y agoA consistent set of traffic rules is a mathematical problem. Mathematics emerges from the laws of nature. Traffic rules are a prime example of what would go totally wrong if you tried to solve it with typical man-made laws. Instead of giving priority to traffic coming from the right, we would end up giving priority to traffic of the members of the elite instead. In fact, that is what happens in many countries. Furthermore, in case of a traffic accident they always find man-made "legal" reasons why the elite is right and everybody else is wrong.
- rdtsc 11y ago>> The reality is that for the past 40 years, Wall Street and the billionaire class has rigged the rules to redistribute wealth and income to the wealthiest and most powerful people of this country. > This is the problem. That is a very good way to put it. I agree with that. > So why doesn't Graham recognize and advocate this? He doesn't advocate because it won't help his cause. As I posted in the comment of the original article (which got downvoted, nobody likes pg being accused of manufacturing pr? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10827175 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10827175, hey! it's a submarine ;-). He created a strawman and a narative around how to interpret and think about income inequality to give his followers and those involved in startups a framework. He understands he is part of what can create inequality, and that's bothersome to him and those around the startup culture. Startup environment needs myths to operate. These are promises to investors, promises to early employees, these are things founders are supposed to be telling others ("I want to make the world a better place") and perhaps themselves as well. There has to be a myth created that addressed income inequality, because it is talked about in the media. As a joke, someone wrote (and I forgot who) how the wealthy and powerful in this country are devout Marxist followers. They internalize the rules and assumptions of the class struggle. Except they don't identify with the working class, they identify with the bourgeoisie. They understand there are the two classes and what class they belong to. They will actively try to control and supress the lower classes.
- ThomPete 11y agoIt's a symptom but not as claimed of the ultra-wealthy buying influence. That matters too but it's not the number one reason. If that was the case, other countries with much less ability to affect the political process (like the scandinavian countries) wouldn't be experiencing the same problems (although at a different scale) No. Wealth is a symptom of a system where the winner takes all and the winner is increasingly technologically based companies. Wealth allow you to increasingly affect the political process but only as a function of you being rich to begin with. No one starts with the political system to gain wealth at least they wont' be wealthy for very long if thats how they came to their wealth. Income inequality is increasingly a symptom of systems with little friction to become the first or second in a field but a lot of friction to challenge them.
- stretchwithme 11y agoAs long as technology enables people to scale their efforts to serve vast numbers of people, there will be vast differences in what people can earn. Those that sell to millions will make a lot more than those who only sell to a few. Instead of trying to force equal outcomes, we should be teaching people about how they can benefit from leveraging technology.
- Turing_Machine 11y ago"I think the propaganda of "The Communists" has been drilled into the American public so solidly" You mean the part where communists murdered 100 million people in the last century? That "propaganda"?
- Turing_Machine 11y agoDo you think modding this down is going to make those 100 million corpses go away? 'Cause it isn't.
- thatcat 11y agoyou didn't provide a capitalism death count to compare it to
- merpnderp 11y agoThe 100 million civilians murdered by communist/socialist governments is well documented. What are the numbers for capitalist governments murdering their civilians without even the semblance of a fair legal system?
- collyw 11y agoPinochet is the first person that comes to mind. He was capitalist wasn't he?
- vidarh 11y agoIt's a trap. He's gotten you to apportion numbers. The point is that it is irrelevant in the first place because the people he wants to lump in with mass murderers like Stalin or Mao or Khmer Rouge largely have never supported them or policies anything like theirs. The discussion of numbers is pointless without first getting him to narrow down exactly what ideologies he is referring to by nature of actual policies implemented rather than by massive overloaded names. The debating technique is equivalent to trying to argue that democracy is bad because the Democratic Peoples Republic of Korea is oppressive and tricking us into trying to turn it into a comparison of relative authoritarianism based on flawed, self-selected labels. Instead it is the premise of what is included in the label you must challenge. It unravels quickly.
- pdonis 11y agoIt looks to me like Garret and Graham are actually in violent agreement. :-) Garret wants to keep people from getting rich through political influence rather than creating wealth; Graham wants to make sure people can still get rich through creating wealth, even if they can't get rich through political influence.
- jondubois 11y agoI think one of the biggest problems that we have today is that intelligent, hard-working people are the poorest they've ever been. In the past, if you studied and worked really hard, you would usually achieve something. Today you can study and work very hard for a very long time and still end up with nothing. Being smart or trying hard has very little value, it's all about who you know and what assets you own. Today, most people are just living off of their assets. Assets which they received as a result of a lot of luck and perhaps a bit of hard work. Instead of the government stepping in to protect the people - The government is facilitating this inequality by allowing corporations to carry-out mutually-beneficial deals with one another at the expense of regular people. People are being enslaved; not just less-educated people, but also highly educated people (who can actually see/understand what is happening). I think we have a new economic class in our society, the 'highly educated lower class'.
- dredmorbius 11y agoYou've a peculiarly brief view of "ever". But yes, from a mid-20th century all-time peak, real middle class wealth in the US is declining.
- lsiq 11y agoThere is a very common tendency to focus on consumption, in terms of where rich people's money flows. This argument that the rich spend most of their money on ostentatious goods (e.g. fancy cars) or, in the case of this posting, donations to political or even charitable causes. While there is of course some truth to this, it ignores the elephant in the room which is that the rich DON'T spend most of their money. The vast majority of wealth (individual, corporate, and sovereign) is tied up in investments and other liquid or illiquid assets. One of the biggest symptoms of the current malaise in terms of inequality are the abnormally high asset prices globally (and thus lower yields), and most essential, very low inflation. There are huge sums of money in the economy that have been pumped in since 2008, but inflation has not shown up in 7 years largely because velocity of money is down. The concentration of wealth, and possible talk about technological deflation, are both closely tied up in this. The lower classes which tend to spend all their money - and sometimes money they don't even have - contribute disproportionately to velocity, now likely don't collectively have enough money to really drive economic and monetary trends anymore. Especially, if they are burdened by debt repayments which many in this day are.
- briantakita 11y agoAccess to resources & social attention are key concerns. Some harmful effects of inequality when people do not have access to: * needs (i.e. Maslow Hierarchy); particularly autonomy * ability to express perspective * ability to have perspective considered, paid heed to, & respected * ability to influence local systems * protection from those who are abstracted away from local systems; those who will not feel immediate consequences of their actions If we can create systems where these concerns are prioritized, then inequality of wealth may not matter. Some people are good at playing the game of gaining wealth. Some are good at other games. In the end, we all benefit from respecting and having compassing & empathy for all life & natural systems.
- sytelus 11y agoPg's main point is that the major source of wealth inequality comes from wealth creators as opposed to wealth exploiters. The wealth creators are typical startups and people creating new industries while wealth exploiters are the one playing high frequency trading, lobbing congress, buying up real estate, creating monopolies, investing with insider info and so on. My gut feeling is that wealth creation part is in reality less than 20%. This intuition is based on simple fact that wealthy people have managed to far more disproportionately increase their wealth than what comes from increase in GDP or other measures of productivity. There is plenty of analysis available in Capital book that clearly suggests that wealthy people mainly invests in non-productive investment instruments such as real estate that has nothing to do with increasing productivity of the society. It just constraints the supply side, inflating prices and thus increasing value of the investment. These investment tools enables them to transform themselves to become passive wealth exploiters with a setup that generates massive multi-generational income and wealth increase without proportional need for positive contribution to society. There was a very well written article with data analysis on HN that proved that most increase in wealth for top 1% came from these non-productive investment tools such as real estate. This is like wealthy people grouping up to buy loads of the fresh water and inflating prices so average people now must pay majority of income in buying water. So wealth transfer from common people to rich occurs through inflated water prices. Of course, if wealthy people really did this for water, they will be in trouble and revolutions will break out. However doing this for real state raises no eye brows even though real estate is essential need for humans. A fun fact: Despite of giving billions and without starting any new blockbuster companies, Bill Gates has managed to increase his wealth by more than 50% since he officially retired. He has sure helped few startups but it would be too funny as well as cruel to think that most of his wealth gain comes via helping startups or causing productivity gains in society. Last I checked his billions are managed by hedge fund like setup who typically have goal to maximize returns through non-productive instruments such as real estate, HFT, commodity market games, derivatives etc and they rarely devote more than 20% of portfolio to truely productive activities such as startups. It is also marvelous how some of the wealthiest have outright bought the laws for themselves, for example, middle class in US universally pays almost twice the tax rates than top 1%. This would be unthinkable in previous generation. The entire capital tax gimmic is put in to law with a full knowledge that it does not benefit majority of citizens who have little or no savings, let alone investments for short term trading. It is purely designed to benefit top 1% who derives large chunk of income as capital gains. The most depressing thing is that the field is becoming less and less level playing, for example wealthy can buy out admissions in best universities while average citizens are getting priced out from same institutions. The significant increase in mortgage and student debt load combined with long term stagnant wages now eliminates possibility of savings or investments and therefore risk taking. I suppose this wasn't exactly like this in 70s when many more people had decent savings, had ability for some risk taking and lot of them even actually were able to retire. In our generation most people don't even think of retirement anymore except in tech industry which is probably less than 5% of population. We in tech field are perhaps not so much impacted and so world looks little different from our glasses, especially if you had been college dropout or without family. However for a common citizen with a family, mortgage, healthcare bills, no savings, retirement funds uncertainty and student loans it is much more difficult to cross the chasm than it used to be in 70s.
- rumcajz 11y agoWealth inequality and income inequality are often touted as the incentive for people to do actual useful work. However, if you think about it for a second, it's clear that having more money in a bank or on a payslip doesn't make you work harder. What makes you work harder is the possibility of improving your status, getting richer. So, one would imagine that a society with drastically reduced inequality (both wealth and income) but with extra high social mobility could work perfectly well.
- makeramen 11y agoUm, am I the only one here confused at why this guy is arguing with PG? From what I can tell they are in full agreement. Ron here is saying we shouldn't kill startups (what PG calls "creating wealth"), we should instead fight against practices that actually take money from the poor and give to the rich (what PG calls "zero-sum games"). After reading PG's article, I got the impression that he wants the exact same thing as Ron does. What's there to argue? PG even has a paragraph in his essay that is almost equivalent to the title of the article: > There are lots of things wrong with the US that have economic inequality as a symptom. We should fix those things. In the process we may decrease economic inequality. But we can't start from the symptom and hope to fix the underlying causes.
- rlaferla 11y agoThis is a great discussion on the single most important issue of our day. I like Paul Graham's perspective on this but I would like him to elaborate on how he would curb corruption. In the past, he said that "transparency" was key but they are doing this in the open and they direct the media to put a spin on it which the non-critical thinking masses can't detect. Politics/economics is an imperfect entity. I think the "pragmatic" solution may lie somewhere between Graham's Libertarian view and Sander's Democratic/Socialist view.
- dredmorbius 11y agoAdam Smith, in the second discussion of his title's topic in Wealth of Nations: "Wealth, as Mr Hobbes says, is power." Oddly this insight is lacking from much the rest of economic literature.