8 ms·
A good example of why I am opposed to HN's "original title" policy. (Namely, the title of this submission is no help for deciding whether you might want to clic
by hollerith 11y ago
A good example of why I am opposed to HN's "original title" policy. (Namely, the title of this submission is no help for deciding whether you might want to click on it.)
- dinkumthinkum 11y agoIt shows the website from which it originates, which is good enough in this case, to know it is worth a look. =)
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoAnd knowing it's a Scott Meyers thing, that tells you the context is c++ and so "}" ends a scope and calls dtors, which makes it a really good title.
- sparky_z 11y agoA great title for the blog post, but not a very good title for HN. There's a difference.
- acjohnson55 11y agoEh, if it's upvoted this much, it's probably worth the effort of clicking just to see what it's about.
- chii 11y agothat train of thought just leads to group think imho.
- CapitalistCartr 11y agoSometimes a group thinking produces good results. Any aggregating site is an example of groupthinking. I read HN because I like the way this group thinks and the results.
- intrasight 11y agoIndeed. I hardly look at the titles (takes some training). It's the "group think" that makes HN so interesting and powerful.
- acjohnson55 11y agoGroupthink when it comes to decision making: bad. Groupthink when it comes to choosing whether to click through to an article: ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- Retra 11y ago"Groupthink" is just called 'learning' in some other contexts.
- krick 11y agoMaybe. Or maybe you just aren't interested that much in C++ and don't care if some Scott Meyers guy retires. Or maybe you are very much into C++ world and surely know who is Scott Meyers, but it suffices for you to be notified that he "retires". That's why titles exist, after all: to give you an idea if you actually want to proceed.
- Retra 11y agoThe default fallback mode of reading the comments is really not too obtrusive though.
- mfisher87 11y agoI always thought it should be a simple requirement to include the original title (and to avoid editorializing) like : Scott Myers "retiring from C++" (OT: "} // good to go")
- saurik 11y agoIt is extra-frustrating as titles are written for audiences: this title, in the context of Scott's blog, is amazing. This is an awesome title for someone who is looking through your new content and is presumed to have pre-decided to read the article. In the disconnected context of Hacker News, it barely works: I only clicked on it because I love programming languages and it involved syntax. The article, of course, had no syntax. It turns out I am glad I clicked on it, but it was complete luck. As a content author, I would personally choose a different title for content on Hacker News than I would choose not only on my own website, but for different individual subreddits. On Google+, at least when it launched (I didn't pay much attention to it later), the format didn't encourage or really even support titles. I posted something there (a commentary on some aspects of Google+), and of course submitted it to Hacker News with the title I would have given it were I to give it a title, and I seriously had people who didn't notice I had written the article (which came up when I responded, and they apologized) saying I had editorialized the title somehow... it is utter madness. I don't even know what to do anymore when I post articles: if I expect Hacker News to be an important consumer of my content I have occasionally added an awkward note under the title saying "this is what the title should be on Hacker News". :/
- fahimulhaq 11y agoI understand the intention behind the policy but yes there are exceptions like this one. I missed this and somehow assumed that it has something to do with Go language -- didn't even bother to check the website. Nothing against Go - just not my piece of cake ATM. Instead noticed it on another site where it had a better title and then realized what an important blog I was going to miss.
- dave2000 11y agoThe title has Scott Meyers in it. That's all I needed to know.
- smoyer 11y agoYou don't need to read the post - from the title and link it's obvious that Scott Meyers is also switching to golang.
- lobo_tuerto 11y agoMaybe having an optional, editorialized subtitle for submissions could help?