4 ms·
Mega ships bring benefits and challenges to ports of L.A. and Long Beach
- Animats 11y ago18,000 TEU. Wow. So big it has its own container cranes. And LA just had a 15,000 TEU Mersk ship. The rail transportation corridor out of LA's ports can handle only about 12,000 TEU a day, on double-stacked trains. There's not 18,000 TEU of storage space in the entire port, let alone one of the subports. (The Port of Los Angeles is a landlord, not an operator; there are about a dozen private businesses with their own docks and container handling facilities cranes there.) Sorting is a huge problem. Some containers go on truck beds at the port, and can head for a destination. The ones that go on trains may need a further sort; some of that happens inland, Fontana, CA and Coulton, CA being major transfer points.
- njharman 11y agobubblesort?
- civilian 11y agoThe port can't store 18,000 TEU, so bubble sort's memory requirements won't work.
- bkor 11y agoAdding: A container ship doesn't unload and load everything in one go. It goes to multiple ports. Else instead of 18.000 you'd be looking at 36.000 (unload, load.. any trade discrepancy is offset needing to bring back empty containers). Don't have any experience, but heard that US terminals usually are really slow. Unions not looking out for employees but instead to show off their influence/power. Resulting in lower performance. Searching a bit more I noticed one source (http://www.apmterminals.com/en/news/press-releases/2014/12/apmt-los-angeles-pier400-setting-ulcs-call http://www.apmterminals.com/en/news/press-releases/2014/12/a...) mentions that "11,200 containers handled during 56 hours of port operations, including one shift of nine cranes at 29 gross moves per hour.[..]APM Terminals Pier 400 Los Angeles was ranked first in productivity for North American ports in 2014 in the JOC Group’s annual productivity report". I don't consider those stats impressive (the 29). Note that the 11,200 containers mentioned is not a TEU. Could be around 18000 TEU; but then over 56 hours. Regarding the need to sort and maybe sort twice: Any decent terminal should've starting making/initiating improvements various years ago. Yard moves/shiftings and the distance travelled should be one of the standard measures that's looked at IMO. Port itself should make long term plans for this. It is not like these things are unpredictable or unexpected.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- steve19 11y ago> Unions not looking out for employees but instead to show off their influence/power. Resulting in lower performance You might write off the above comment as the opinion of someone who does not like unions, but as someone who has worked for a shipping company, I assure you it is not. The myths surrounding them are not myths, they are a reality. Dock unions are terrible. These unions (or at least many of them around the world) impose regimes of intimidation, violence, sexism, property damage and theft. It is not possible to disrupt them. If you built a port and staffed it with high paid non union staff, I can assure you that dock workers around the world would (possibly illegally) refuse to unload the cargo of ships coming from this port or they would, more subtly, damage the goods unloaded (drop containers to hard onto the ground etc.) until then nobody wanted to use your port anymore because the cost was to high. The international cooperation they have going is fascinating. It's a pity collectism like this (minus the violence and bullying) is not used for good instead if lining the pockets of a few.
- ju-st 11y agoNice post, thanks. So apparently it wouldn't even be possible to disrupt them with automation/robots.
- mc32 11y agoI thought there was a previous discussion[1, found it] on HN where the port of Rotterdam was automating portions of its operations... Perhaps to disrupt (improve) port operations you'd need to do it on both ends of a balanced high throughput lane [to avoid the international unions cooperating on sabotage] [1]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10409226 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10409226
- nols 11y agoMost of the busiest ports are heavily automated
- mojoe 11y agoWe've come a long way from the days of unloading individual items from ships by hand. The NPR Planet Money podcast had a great show on the invention of shipping containers: http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2013/12/04/248883212/episode-500-the-humble-innovation-at-the-heart-of-the-global-economy http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2013/12/04/248883212/episo...
- ghaff 11y agoLevinson's The Box is also a great read on the topic. Many of the issues associated with adopting containers such as standards and existing workers apply to many areas of technology as well.
- gregpilling 11y agoThe Box was an excellent read
- del82 11y agoThe Omega Tau podcast on container shipping is fascinating, as well: http://omegataupodcast.net/2014/04/146-container-shipping/ http://omegataupodcast.net/2014/04/146-container-shipping/