4 ms·
I'd add that airport security and passport controls are also deterring me from travelling. I have very little appetite for standing for 45min+ in a queue and wh
by cm2187 11y ago
I'd add that airport security and passport controls are also deterring me from travelling. I have very little appetite for standing for 45min+ in a queue and when you travel international now, you do many of those (security, passports out, passports in and all again on the way back). I don't know if many are like me but I am limiting my travelling to the strict minimum because of that.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoI don't know. When the flight is 12 hours, 45 minutes on either side isn't such a big deal. I did get stuck in a 4 hour immigration line at Heathrow once...I'll just avoid the UK from now on.
- cm2187 11y agoI guess we all have different levels of tolerance to queueing. Mine is pretty low, I would never go to a restaurant where I have to queue, even only for 15min. In airports, these queues are the result of pointless checks (I am not aware that in the history of aviation a single terrorist has been caught at an airport security check) and bad management (long queues at passport checks are often associated with lots of empty desks).
- alkonaut 11y agoThe fact that terrorists/weapons/explosives are rarely caught in security checks isn't really a compelling argument to remove security checks. If you reverse the argument and say they exist mainly to discourage people from trying, you could argue that they are nearly 100% successful. In my experience security is pretty snappy compared to e.g US immigration. I look European and find it tedious and annoying, I can only imagine what it's like if you have a middle eastern type name or look.
- cm2187 11y agoI am not suggesting to completely remove them. But over the years we see even more little rules, taking even more time, bothering grannies with their sun cream, and with, in my opinion, a value added in term of security of zero.
- mikeash 11y agoThe reverse argument doesn't really work, because there are occasional terrorist attacks against airliners that get through security.
- afarrell 11y agoAt the same time, these security checks do create places where 200+ people gather close together in an area where it is totally reasonable for someone to be wheeling around a 35-lbs un-checked bag.
- jlarocco 11y agoSo? There's no shortage of places where hundreds of people gather, where it wouldn't be out of place to have a large package or bag. Adding a few more at airports really isn't a big deal. Not that I agree with all the "security", but that argument against it isn't very convincing.
- Nutmog 11y agoThat means terrorists killing everyone on a plane (the same as everyone in the security queue) is an acceptable risk, as long as they don't crash the plane into even more people like at 9/11. So maybe we don't need airport security at all. Just have the air force ready to shoot down rogue commercial planes before they reach densely populated areas. It happened in China. Muslim terrorists attacked hundreds of people waiting in a ticket hall. No need to go through security.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI agree it's not a compelling argument. The reverse sounds a bit better, but it doesn't stand up to scrutiny. Ultimately, airport security does something. More security does more of something. But security also costs a lot - in money, material, man hours and various secondary effects like deaths from more people opting out of flying and going for cars, etc. Ultimately, it's always about costs and benefits. The costs are huge, and yet they don't seem to buy us much.
- fucking_tragedy 11y ago> If you reverse the argument and say they exist mainly to discourage people from trying, you could argue that they are nearly 100% successful. That would be a weird argument to make, given the known attempts and multiple successful attempts by auditors to bring weapons through airport security.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoI travel a lot, immigration is rarely a bottleneck, if I checked luggage, I rarely don't beat my bag. So every country is different, I mentioned my horrible heathrow experience, I guess India and Bangkok can be bad during peak seasons. Bali will always be chaotic, and someone will offer "express service" for a bribe, but it never lasts that long. Japan moves quickly, austrailia is a breeze for USA passport holders, so is the USA these days if they are using kiosks. The EU has never been anything but fast. China is always a bit slow starting out but they usually open up some extra lanes after all the Chinese are processed. Security in the states at a big airport is a bit more painful than other countries; you have to get into a 15-30 minute line. But that is the only country actually. Heck, in Australia they don't even check your ID. It can get s bit weird in the Philippines where I don't even think they are trying (very minimal security for even an international flight).
- Nutmog 11y agoHandy hint at UK airports. When there's a queue for UK passport holders, and a queue for everyone else, UK passport holders can use either queue. I went to the empty "everyone else" queue by accident and the guy said they don't mind me using the wrong queue to save time. That was 10 years ago, might have changed.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoI don't know. When the flight is 12 hours, 45 minutes on either side isn't such a big deal. I did get stuck in a 4 hour immigration line at Heathrow once...I'll just avoid the UK from now on.
- mschuster91 11y agoSame for me. I rather travel by train/bus instead of feeling like a fucking terrorist every time I want to board a flight. Also, the time saving on national flights is negligible. For example, Munich to Hamburg takes 6 hours via train and 1.5 hours via airplane. Then add transport from Munich Hauptbahnhof to the airport (45min if you're lucky), and from Hamburg Airport to Hauptbahnhof (25min). Another 45min for security controls, checkin, boarding, baggage retrieval... 3.5h minimum. And you don't have (fast) Wifi or 230V on the plane, and it's cramped. Only upside of taking an airplane: no. fucking. loud. kids. (because parents do manage to keep their kids under control on a plane, in contrast to a train)