6 ms·
How brain architecture relates to consciousness and abstract thought
- collyw 11y ago"The goal was to understand how abstract thought arises from brain structure" Is there any evidence that it does?
- mbrock 11y agoAs a hypothesis, the evidence presented by the article seems to give some support to it. What's the alternative hypothesis?
- pegasus 11y agoExactly. Can one really "prove" a hypothesis that doesn't have an alternative? Is this really science we're talking about?
- Capt-RogerOver 11y agoScience is not about proving, it's about disproving hypothesis. If we can disprove it, this gives us a lot of certain knowledge about the world, and expands our thinking to new hypothesis. If we can't disprove it yet, we just use it as the current understanding of how things work, and try to build new things using that knowledge. This is how all of the technology was created. And yes, this is science. What is your alternative? Just say "must be the almighty" and do nothing? Because doing that is surely more scientific?
- tomhoward 11y agoHey there, I feel the need to point out this is a topic where it's especially important for people to be civil and charitable, as it's a controversial topic that triggers a lot of strong emotions in people, which can cause a potentially really interesting discussion to go off the rails. In that spirit, you'll help things a lot by avoiding making combative, straw-man comments like 'What is your alternative? Just say "must be the almighty" and do nothing? Because doing that is surely more scientific?' That is best practice on HN at all times, but even more so on hot-button topics like this.
- pegasus 11y agoThat's just the problem. How would you even go about disproving this hypothesis? If there's no alternative it means the hypothesis is not falsifiable, right? And if there's nothing to prove or disprove, what's the point of the investigation? edit: I guess I'm playing a bit of devil's advocate here to expose the circularity in some arguments that arise when considering these kind of deeply fundamental questions. In fact, my feeling is these kind of more or less subtle logical traps cannot be avoided in this areas of thought.
- Capt-RogerOver 11y ago> If there's no alternative it means the hypothesis is not falsifiable, right? Well, not really. For example, we don't understand how some brain function works. For some reason we might get a hypothesis that it is governed by a production of a certain neurotransmitter (very simplified here). At that time we have no other version of how the function might work at all. Then we do experiments where we mess with the said neurotransmitter, or a brain region, etc. If the results show that there is no measurable effect on the brain function, then that hypothesis becomes disproven (or at least a certain specific way of understanding that hypothesis). If there is no alternative that might just mean that we haven't found it yet. Or that the current framework we're using is not suitable to the question. But even then working on existing hypothesis might give a lot of information on what framework might actually work.
- tomhoward 11y agoNote that the goal of the study was not to determine IF brain structure produces attract thought, but HOW. The point I think the commenter was making is that the statement "The goal was to understand how abstract thought arises from brain structure" suggests there may be some begging the question in the study design. If you start with the assumption that that brain structure produces abstract thought, your evidence will support it, because you already believed it in the first place. The main challenge to any hypothesis about the nature of thought or consciousness is that our fundamental tool for contemplating the topic is our consciousness - which is precisely what we're trying to understand. On that basis, the argument goes, it's impossible to objectively determine what consciousness really is, because we have no way of separating the consciousness we're studying from the consciousness we're using to study it. Alternative theories to the one that says the brain produces consciousness are that the brain is a carrier or receiver of consciousness, which somehow originates elsewhere. Various forms of such theories have been proposed by reputable scientists including Roger Penrose[1], John Eccles[2] and - somewhat ironically - Karl Popper[3]. I personally don't have any strong opinions about the validity of these theories; it's enough for me to know that they exist and to keep an open mind until someone can develop a truly testable and falsifiable hypothesis. Until then, it's all pretty much philosophy. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roger_Penrose#Physics_and_consciousness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roger_Penrose#Physics_and_cons... [2] http://www.theosophy-nw.org/theosnw/science/prat-bra.htm http://www.theosophy-nw.org/theosnw/science/prat-bra.htm [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind%E2%80%93body_problem#Popper https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind%E2%80%93body_problem#Popp...
- throwupper247 11y agoIs it also impossible to research matter, because we can't seperate the matter we study ... ? Am I missing the analogy?
- jsprogrammer 11y agoDo you think things are possible just because you want them to be?
- Capt-RogerOver 11y agoYes. Do physical damage to the brain and the abstract thinking (along with other kinds) dissapears.
- pegasus 11y agoSure. We've known this for a while. If this settles the argument, what's the point of further investigation? It's clear that the brain is intimately involved in the expression of consciousness. But whether it's the source is really a question outside science. For example, it's role could also be analogous to a radio. Damage the radio and there goes the beautiful music. But seeing the radio as the source would be kinda missing the whole point, wouldn't it?
- amelius 11y ago> It's clear that the brain is intimately involved in the expression of consciousness. But whether it's the source is really a question outside science. There is clearly an interaction between consciousness and physics; a simple proof is that we are now talking about consciousness (its existence somehow loops back into the physical world). Therefore, consciousness should be definitely part of science.
- mbrock 11y agoWell, everyone agrees that the brain acts as a kind of radio: its antennas are the senses and the music is the stream of qualia. Or something like that. Language is also a big part of consciousness, and that's not internal to the brain—it's social. So it's kind of unclear what it means to talk about the "source" of consciousness. Most often I see the radio metaphor invoked in a vaguely mystical way, where the signal of consciousness is supposed to emanate from some totally unknown background source that nobody has any idea at all what it might be, except some people choose to call it "God." All that stuff is totally non-scientific until someone comes up with a clear hypothesis.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Capt-RogerOver 11y ago
- SilasX 11y agoAs opposed to what? Liver structure? Brain non-structural characteristics?
- wyager 11y agoIf you sufficiently disrupt brain structure, it stops producing abstract thought. This means that either the brain is producing abstract thought or that the brain is some sort of dualist mechanism for interacting with a soul of some description. We have a very good theory describing how (in principle) the chemical structure of the brain can lead to observed behavior. The hard part now is figuring out the implementation details. I can tell you how a computer works in general even though I can't tell you how, exactly, a particular model running a particular OS works. On the other hand, we have no physical evidence that dualism is correct (i.e. that thought arises from some non-physical mechanism), and any theory posited to account for this is vastly more complicated than the relatively simple behaviour governing the activity of neurons in the brain. Non sunt multiplicanda entia sine necessitate. It also seems strange to me, if there is a non-physical mechanism of thought, that imbibing certain chemicals can vastly alter the behavior of this mechanism. On the other hand, this makes perfect sense if the source of thought is chemical interaction between neurons.
- throwupper247 11y agoThe discussed paper is http://www.nature.com/articles/srep18112 http://www.nature.com/articles/srep18112 "The global landscape of cognition: hierarchical aggregation as an organizational principle of human cortical networks and functions" Consciousness is mentioned only once: >Our current data-driven results holistically demonstrated expanding amalgamation of function [sic!] over structural depth [...] >Fascinatingly, results suggest why the insular and opercular regions are some of the best candidates for awareness or consciousness [62] [63] or why parts of frontal cortex are involved in higher cognition. Wait, why is function uncountable? >These conclusions are elaborated here: >Sensory regions closest to inputs (bin1) in our hierarchy [include Insula and opercular] >[...] hypothesized to play a role in multi-sensory integration and interoceptive awareness, >[...] since it is the hub of the senses >[...] the coordinating role awareness plays in cognition >Further, middle regions, intermediate in distance from all sensory inputs (bin5) included hippocampus and MTL known for memory and celebrity neurons >Deep regions less connected to and farthest from inputs (bin10) [...] may support more abstract cognitive functions. Aren't the first two quotes contradicting? Surely, awareness or consciousness is an amalgamation of function and distributed. I'd rather thought the hippocampus was deemed central to cognition, as memory seems essential for re-cognition. Self-awareness is deemd a function of higher cognition and therefore an abstract concept. Why is it close to the concrete input stage? They talk about recurrent networks, does the hippocampus give feedback to the "input stage", maybe slowly as in conditioning? They "simplified recurrence into a continuum of statistical connectivity to sensory inputs" to probalisticly show a directional hierarchy. Their methods are interesting, but far beyond me. They seem to build a model of the brain into a NN and test that, where a modified NN is the control group.
- jhedwards 11y agoJean Piaget's theories are pretty in line with this. In his book "Biology and Knowledge" he sets forth the idea that higher level cognitive abilities are built via the coordination and integration of basic sensory/motor behaviors. The progressive construction of higher level behaviors eventually leads to logico-mathematical thought. He even did extensive biological experiments to demonstrate that these concepts are valid interpretations of organic biological phenomena and thus reasonably extendable into the domain of cognitive development. It's a shame his work was reduced to the "stages" theory, which really doesn't do justice to his work as a whole.