6 ms·
The Final Days of the Bitcoin Foundation?
- ue_ 11y agoAre there any examples of where Bitcoin has needed the Bitcoin foundation, aside from promotion? I don't know much about Bitcoin, but I'm imagining the Bitcoin Foundation as being analogous to the Linux Foundation.
- pmorici 11y agoThere are plenty of instance where a "Bitcoin Foundation" would be helpful like in promoting the technology in general to the general public and in mediating things like the current block size debate. The problem is that the current foundation lacked a majority of ethical board members and they pushed out anyone who advocated reform.
- Scarbutt 11y agoWith out a foundation, how do you suggest the direction of the Bitcoin project be managed? (Is not only about promoting Bitcoin).
- icebraining 11y agoDifferent groups develop competing clients, when one proposes an incompatible feature, the other groups and the users in general choose if they want to implement it or not. Whichever direction the majority chooses is the direction of Bitcoin. At least to me, it sounds much more in line with the original conception of Bitcoin than a central foundation managing its direction.
- jgalt212 11y agoThat's true, but an organization board can help those adoptions occur in a more orderly and/or less acrimonious manner in case there are any serious disputes.
- kanzure 11y ago> Whichever direction the majority chooses is the direction of Bitcoin. The whole point of Bitcoin is that you cannot actually measure "majority", because of problems including censorship and sybil attacks. You can measure hashrate and PoW difficulty, which provides sybil resistance (at least, it can put a minimum cost on sybil attacks), but the Bitcoin protocol uses PoW as a dynamic membership multiparty signature which seems to add the requirement of resource requirement minimization otherwise you get fewer and fewer members in the membership set... Otherwise only high-resource (highly-coercible large-scale) entities can participate in the dynamic membership. In the Bitcoin consensus protocol this is restricted to picking transaction ordering and some other details, but I am hoping to stress to you how the same problems apply even outside of transaction ordering and consensus over Bitcoin transaction history, even if PoW doesn't solve those other consensus problems. The same problems (sybil attacks, etc.) apply to measuring "majority" and explain why "number of users" is not being used by Bitcoin Core developers to pick what each Bitcoin Core developer personally wish to work on. (Well, they tend to have their own individual reasons, some that are overlapping with this one, but I want to keep my explanation succinct.) Bitcoin Core developers seem to have little desire to work on hard-fork (in)compatibility changes, although they might be okay with technically-meritorious-uncontroversial hard-forks. This is largely based on a belief of the importance of backwards-compatibility, resource requirement minimization (such as Bitcoin Core node bandwidth requirements), network effects especially in the context of financial asset adoption, decentralization, etc. Also this belief seems to be reinforced by how they don't actually control the Bitcoin network anyway, nor its rules, just one of the clients and their releases which users are free to voluntarily use (or choose not to use). Thankfully there are some alternative methods for increasing scalability which are getting deployed on testnet (or a new testnet?) today or tomorrow or something: https://bitcoin.org/en/bitcoin-core/capacity-increases-faq https://bitcoin.org/en/bitcoin-core/capacity-increases-faq Bitcoin users that disagree with Bitcoin consensus protocol rules should consider not using Bitcoin. There are many people at the moment who are not interested in what Bitcoin offers, and that's okay. Indeed some users were misled into believing Bitcoin had extremely high levels of anonymity, only to later find out that Bitcoin had a blockchain and a largely pseudonymous design.... While many Bitcoin developers wish this wasn't the case, users would be advised to stop using something that doesn't actually fit their requirements...... But "secretly" most Bitcoiners suspect that Bitcoin really does meet reasonable standards or requirements :-) so this is why many don't advocate disgruntled Bitcoin users to leave. Some suspect that the Bitcoin industry could be coerced (such as by government) or influenced (such as by social media sentiment) to participate in a hard-fork, to specifically choose to become incompatible with the existing widely-deployed Bitcoin consensus protocol rules. Social media sentiment syncing is way cheaper than reading the Bitcoin source code, and anybody can use Bitcoin even without agreeing with the concepts behind the protocol or whatever. Anyway, a hard-fork split is not the end of Bitcoin, because even if Bitcoin-original ends up on a minority hashrate side, hashrate attacks (from the other sides of the hard-fork) can be mitigated by migrating to a different PoW function. Perhaps "adoption" will be reduced as a result (indeed perhaps for all sides of the hard-fork, esp. given wallet/merchant difficulties), but the opportunity for low-difficulty PoW mining will be overwhelmingly appealing to an extremely broad audience, plus the ability to sell UTXOs against exchanges participating on the other side of the hard-fork to fund development of -original, possibility of shaking out maladoption, and what I suspect will be an increasing unwillingness to accept payments from others using the social-media-sentiment hard-forked currency because of the difficulty of judging the technical reliability/stability/value of a currency operated by social-media-sentiment-influenced participants willing to increase incompatibility on the money they are about to pay you with. Majority is not how Bitcoin works, not for transaction ordering, and not for what Bitcoin Core developers want to work on. > At least to me, it sounds much more in line with the original conception of Bitcoin than a central foundation managing its direction. Well, you're not wrong :-).
- jsprogrammer 11y agoThe original paper[0] outlines how the project is managed. [0] https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf (See section 5. Network)
- oafitupa 11y agoThe foundation has no say whatsoever in the project.
- pstrateman 11y agoThe Bitcoin Foundation was founded and operated by criminals. Bruce Fenton and others have done huge amounts of work to repair the foundation and I commend them for their efforts. However I cannot support an organization which continues to support bad actors, to quote myself: >As a lifetime Foundation member (and a technical contributor to Bitcoin) I think it's within my rights to ask [that Gavin Andresen be removed as chief scientist] >Consider how frustrating misunderstandings like the below are to me: >“...[Gavin Andresen is] still bitcoin’s official chief scientist, according to the Bitcoin Foundation, the not-for-profit that oversees the project...” >http://www.wired.com/2015/08/bitcoin-schism-shows-genius-open-source/ http://www.wired.com/2015/08/bitcoin-schism-shows-genius-ope...
- mbrock 11y agoAre you claiming Andresen is a criminal? If so, why?
- nickodell 11y agoI assume he's talking about Charlie Schrem and Mark Karpeles being on the board of BF.
- pstrateman 11y ago> Are you claiming Andresen is a criminal? If so, why? No all he did was sell them his reputation. Edit: This is being down voted and I'm honestly not sure why. He quite literally sold the foundation his reputation. He received salary of approximately $200k in 2013 from the foundation.
- chejazi 11y agoHe's not a criminal but he stopped being the lead contributor to Bitcoin Core to join the contentious Bitcoin XT project. The motivation for this project is a debate about whether increasing the Bitcoin blocksize is an acceptable way to address scalability. In general, it showcases dissent in the consensus policy that governs the way Core changes are made. More background on this: https://bitcoinmagazine.com/articles/gavin-andresen-i-might-take-over-lead-of-bitcoin-xt-1448486445 https://bitcoinmagazine.com/articles/gavin-andresen-i-might-...
- joosters 11y agoNow tell us where all the money went...
- pstrateman 11y agoI've got a pretty good idea.. https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1pxiy3/peter_vessenes_biggest_danger_to_bitcoin/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1pxiy3/peter_vesse...
- at-fates-hands 11y agoone of the better quotes from the thread: Just think for a minute how amazing Bitcoin is, that it can not only survive but continue to grow despite the huge number of dipshits and saboteurs so intimately associated with it.
- api 11y agoYears ago I remember a thread where people were bashing the Bitcoin ecosystem for being full of bubbles, scammers, ponzi schemes, criminals, and con artists. Some smart-arse replied "so you're saying Bitcoin is a real currency?" That really stuck with me. :) Because of course none of those things happen with ordinary currencies.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoYeah, that's an... interesting way to look at it. And I guess it's right - the proof that something is significant (for better or worse) is that it attracts scoundrels. Scammers and frauds and power-hungry thugs don't have time to seek random trinkets; they group around things that can help them earn a lot of money and control.
- js8 11y agoI think this can be said about human societies in general. :-)
- as1ndu 11y agoCan someone educate me upon the use of the BTC foundation besides promotion? I thought no one controls BTC!!! :(
- oafitupa 11y agoThe foundation is just a bunch of suits, whose only function is to educate other suits (eg: law makers). No one controls Bitcoin.
- Animats 11y agoAnd nothing of value was lost. It's amazing how well Bitcoin works as a system despite the very high percentage of crooks involved. That's a significant technical achievement.
- Cyberdog 11y ago> the very high percentage of crooks involved Is that really quantifiable as such? Based on my limited experiences with cryptocurrencies, the vast majority of its usage is lawful, but people buying hitmen and crack with bitcoin makes for a better story than people buying pizzas and web hosting, so that's what's in the articles that get written.