11 ms·
Everything You Need to Know About Your Son and Daughter’s University but Don’t
- ColinWright 11y agoFrom the article: "Hey, you, pay attention! This is important." Say that today and you won't hear anger or shame. You'll hear something like: "Wha...? Oh, sorry sir. My bad. I didn't mean anything." And they don't. They don't mean anything. They are not dissing you; they are not even thinking about you, ... I wonder what students think they are paying for, and what, indeed, they should be paying for.
- Zigurd 11y agoKids these days. We were so much better.
- ColinWright 11y agoWith the massive escalation in fees, and the ubiquity of phones, with instant access to Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and more, do you really think things haven't changed?
- fucking_tragedy 11y agoThe children now love luxury. They have bad manners, contempt for authority; they show disrespect for elders and love chatter in place of exercise.
- kefka 11y agoOk Socrates. Whatever you say. :-) Curmudgeonism for over 2500 years and counting.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoI fear that nobody will understand your reference; if only we had taken more humanities classes...
- zeveb 11y agoY'know, some people read that and think, 'gosh, old folks always complain about kids; kids must not really be getting any worse!' I wonder if kids really have been getting worse for millennia…
- ryanwaggoner 11y agoIronically, that's almost certainly not attributable to Socrates (or Plato), but instead from a thesis written in 1907: http://quoteinvestigator.com/2010/05/01/misbehaving-children-in-ancient-times/ http://quoteinvestigator.com/2010/05/01/misbehaving-children... Maybe if we had all had better humanities classes, we'd know that :)
- marcosdumay 11y agoThey are paying for a piece of paper, with their name written on it.
- gamesbrainiac 11y agoNot just any piece of paper, one thats slightly thicker than your average A4 sheet. But don't worry, with new advancements in academic technology, you will undoubtedly see that certificates thinner and lighter than ever before. In all seriousness though, this is not a liberal problem. Its just that universities just don't provide the cost to benefit ratio that they once did over alternate mediums of learning.
- cmiles74 11y agoNot just a piece of a paper: a credential. The paper itself is unimportant, they simply need the institution to reliably tell possible employers (the rare few that even bother to check) that the credential was duly earned and appropriately filed.
- lordCarbonFiber 11y agoThe lecture part of college in many cases is the least valuable part of the experience. Adding something to your lecture more meaningful that can be gleamed from the book or the completion of home work is nontrivial, and many schools can't afford the rare talent that and provide research and a strong teaching presence. The students are, and have always even in the "good old days", paying for certification, the network, and the time to get a foothold in the world.
- cmiles74 11y agoEven in the nineties, most of my lecture courses where simply terrible. I would skim the reading, attend the discussion section and receive a "B". The classes that had valuable lectures were few and far between. Were I less motivated, I am sure I would have missed them.
- cholantesh 11y agoProbably another boring humanities elective of dubious merit, being taught by someone whose adult life has been preoccupied with empty navel-gazing.
- lintiness 11y agothis, i think, is what he's addressing. if you don't see value in humanities or the arts, i'm afraid you're completely missing the point of being alive. a world run completely by engineers is no place i want to live.
- cholantesh 11y agoThe point of being alive is being forced to spend exorbitant sums of money for the privilege of being talked down to by someone whose entire life is spent in an ivory tower about a subject whose value s/he can't articulate without resorting to esoteric vagaries?
- lintiness 11y agowho's holding a gun to your head? a guy who's read and studied source materials for decades knows more about authorial intent or historical context than you; i'd bet he has an understanding worth thinking about and considering.
- Thriptic 11y agoI agree that the humanities and arts are of profound importance. I've found that the problem with these subjects is often simply how they are taught. Philosophy is a great example. I was one credit shy of a philosophy minor in undergrad. The entire purpose of philosophy is to provide actionable guidelines for how to live life, yet none of my classes actually provided students with this information. Instead, a lecturer would drone on about academicians' opinions on various doctrines, their historical context, and critique each doctrine from a logical perspective without any group discussion or talk of application. Students were then asked to regurgitate the professor's opinions in an essay. It was boring, and eventually I quit. Imagine if all chemistry classes were just the classroom side of organic chemistry, with people sitting in rooms memorizing syntheses and electron pushing without ever even talking about stepping into a lab. Would anyone be surprised if those students then said they thought chemistry was boring?
- bbayles 11y agoThis article is OK overall, but I could do without the "I am so brave for exposing this" trope at the beginning. The author presents some new insights, but complaining about the state universities isn't exactly original.
- jackmaney 11y agoThe author is a non-tenure track faculty member. Expressing his criticism of his university--not to mention a whole class of similar universities--is taking an enormous risk, as he could be fired (aka his contract won't be renewed) for any reason. He was even threatened with just that for expressing his complaints in a colloquium: I tried to illustrate this old-style understanding for colleagues and administrators at a colloquium at my university a couple of years ago by offering a pictorial representation of the university as I thought it should be. First I drew a very large building named “Students,” then another of comparable size named “Professors,” then a still larger one named “Library,” and finally a tiny shed well off to the side named “Administration.” I wasn’t attempting to insult anyone by this, but simply to make a serious point in a mildly amusing way. In the event, my meaning was not lost on one administrator, who, noting the disparity in proportions and considering it necessary to match wits with me, suggested that come time for the renewal of my contract, I would not be found in any one of my fictitious university buildings. How is that for real university debate? Suggest a deficiency in university governance and it’s a pair of cement galoshes for you.
- BatFastard 11y agoTL;DR
- marcosdumay 11y agoGuess what, when you insist on doing only useless work, people start to think your work is useless. Humanities are incredibly important. I'd kill for somebody to help me communicate better at my undergrad, or understand people better, or any deep understanding of politics. Was any of that available? Of course not. There were only boring lessons, full of useless bullshit with professors claiming even objectively false facts. I'd think half the professors at the humanities dept were politically naiver than me at the time, today I think I underestimated it. (Oh, yes, I got some nice lectures about geography at the biology dept - go figure.) Now the writing is on the wall, humanities "uselessness" is almost unanimous. That's a shame, but maybe that causes things to change for once.
- trgn 11y agoI think I know what you are getting at, but there's an important historical dimension. The humanities are useless, in the sense that they do not fit the current idea of what a University's place in society should be. Universities used to teach humanities almost to all students, some years even exclusively; not because it was useful in the olden days, but precisely because it was useless. It was a luxury. A university was a place for the upper tiers of society to park their kids until they got their hormones out of their system and were mature enough to assume their new leadership role in society. By studying the humanities, students connected with the past and it elevated their spirits for the future (meaning, they could make lower class people feel stupid for not having read Goethe). Studying latin, greek, literature, ... has largely been irrelevant for centuries, but this did not matter one bit for the students (or their parents paying for it). For them, this was just a time to learn dedication to hard work, sharpen their mind, network, and hopefully not knock-up too many custodian's daughters. Students who did not follow in their parents situation (factory owners, lawyers, physicians, what have you ...) could end up in Academia, as faculty. It kept them out of trouble, they got paid handsomely, it made for a cute dinner table story when they were rambling about their field trip to Timbuktu. The "set-for-life" (aka tenure, high pay) nature of Academia is the most important give-away that these positions had nothing to do with usefulness, and everything to do with protecting status, about ensuring excess spawn could live comfortable lives and did not embarrass their families. Academia was (is) a different kind of clergy; highly educated, a path to an unencumbered life, but also somewhat irrelevant. The big shift is not that the humanities have become useless - they've always been. The big shift is that the university has become a vocational school. They have become, what used to be the technical and trade colleges, a replacement for the lifetime learning on the job condensed in a few years for the unwashed masses. In this neo-liberal meritocracy or ours (jk), people are widgets, and they need to be jiggered correctly so they can be slotted in to the correct spot and be useful for society. If you explained 150 years ago to Winthrop that in 2015 farmer Joe would send his kids to Harvard to learn how to operate some new fangled bleepy bloopy thingie (aka programming a computer), he'd think your nuts. Yes, the infantile mental state of many humanities professors is baffling. I guess they dedicate themselves to their work because they are passionate about the content, yes, reading&thinking is fun! Some may even think they are useful. "I teach my students to think critically"! As if physics professor or your uncle cannot do that. "I teach my students to understand systemic societal problems!" Sure, but your adherence to those shift with the winds of political expedience, your own age and experience, and maybe that movie you once saw. But what they are really doing is that they've taken up the scraps of a role that no longer exists. IMO, the humanities have a big place in the University - a place for "higher" learning. It elevates us over the day-to-day drab of doing errands and keeping your shoelaces tied, they connect us to some of the most wonderful human achievements of the past. But it is not useful, and has never been so.
- hbosch 11y agoIn all honesty this writer sounds utterly curmudgeonly. He writes passionately about what "real education" is, dispenses some good ol' Hard Facts About Life, and urges us all to put down those dang computer-devices and just learn! This is classic finger-pointing, angsty whining. I'm sorry, but the conceit here flagrantly disregards modern reality. Learning is easier now than it's ever been. People don't need to give undivided attention to professors anymore. Kids today can listen with one ear, read with one eye... Do their research with one tab and chat on Facebook with another. The education system in generally feels like an industry that is just barely stepping into a technological age in terms of format, expectations, and content. I don't think young people need to force themselves to regress to the antique stylings of almost all Universities, I think Universities need to realize their systems do not suit young people. And that's their fault.
- lordCarbonFiber 11y agoThat was my impression as well. I love how, in one anecdote, he talks about how students "don't read" and puts the example that given they know they can get a B without the book, don't bother; some how this is the students' fault. Just the selective blindness to it all, how can anyone be surprised that given no external nor internal motivation any human being is going to be arsed to go out of their way to do things. He is constantly complaining about "declining academic standards" but provides no quantitative evidence to back his claim. Grade inflation is likely a problem, simply because if one institution does it all are forced to inflate along with it or risk devaluing their degrees, but it's incredibly difficult to quantify. Incoming students have the higher standardized test scores, a huge belt of tools between the internet and computers, and an unprecedented network of peers for when the tools are sufficient. Should we surprised scores tend to rise, is it the university's responsibility to crank up the difficulty and keep averages as they were in the 80s? These are the questions dinosaurs like the OP can't and won't answer.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoHuh. 18 out of 230 students bought the text they were studying. That sounds like statistics. 'C' grades for what used to be failing exams - more data. And rising test scores? In what universe is that happening? These are 2nd-tier liberal arts colleges at issue, not Stanford. Tool belt? Its nonsense to imagine googling a subject is as effective as learning it. That's twaddle, and any student who skates over their lack of education by faking papers from online resources is involved in a self-destructive sham. The paper is supposed to demonstrate a mastery of the subject. The paper is not the point. Producing a likely-looking one is not the point. Actually knowing the subject is the point.
- at-fates-hands 11y agoThe main point which hit home for me was that the students are running the asylum now and there is no respect for the professors or faculty attempting to teach them. From the comments: The key to this article is the explicit statement that administrators are aligned with students against faculty. I work at a major university, and my department head has often sided with students without even contacting me to hear my take on the incident. I get an angry email from him saying that a student complained that I say hello (Really! I didn’t say hello!), or that I must give a student the opportunity to do an assignment after the deadline, because she said it was impossible to do it for technical problems. In fact, though, 21 students had completed it successfully, despite the alleged technical problems. Still, I was ordered to allow the student to complete the assignment late, for full credit. I was never consulted, or I would have mentioned that the student spends most of class on facebook, among other things. Another time, a student sent him an email saying that I “diminished her” in class. The head sent her a passage from the student handbook saying that students are to take it up with the professor. She refused, saying that made her “uncomfortable.” Instead, the department head insisted on visiting my class to observe my teaching. At the time, I said that he was spineless -- that she had told him to jump, and he did. That may or may not have been correct, but I’ve since realized that backbone had nothing to do with it. Instead, the head was actively searching for opportunities to baby students. It explains, for example why I was told to teach a student to use a calculator that I do not even require in my class. I feel like this professors experience is fairly consistent with what I know. I had six friends who all went into academia and education. Within a year nearly all had exited the profession and only two remained. They all cited the same thing - the over coddling of students by administration or faculty. The stories they told were eye opening to say the least. The crazy part? This was going on in the early aughts, nearly two decades earlier.
- lordCarbonFiber 11y agoYou come so close to figuring it out there at the end. The truth, it's always been happening. There were no "good old days". The pecking order has always been: research prof > students > teaching prof.
- ginko 11y agoSeems the main problem here is the high tuition fees, which to some degree give the students the impression that they deserve good service for which they have paid. Coming from a country where most of university is state funded (minus a nominal fee of about 300€ per semester), I can see that I might have had other expectations of my professors had I paid ten thousands of dollars per year.
- kaitai 11y agoA great contrast to another article currently trending on HN, with no discussion yet: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10815072 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10815072 I read "Gettin’ bodied by Classics: the joys and challenges of public scholarship" (to whose HN discussion I linked above) and thought, wow, cool, who is Hermes Trismegistus and what's the reference? Hey, those articles on exclusion, inclusion, and the ideas of citizenship from antiquity to today sound really interesting. Wow, a Princeton classicist doing something I can understand! I'm going to look at buying his book, this guy is rad. (Halfway through morning coffee, so excuse the shallowness of the thoughts.) I read this OP and started rolling my eyes again. Right, right, kids these days, telling kids to think about their Halloween costumes is so PC (telling kids to think! can't have that! wait, next paragraph he wants kids to think, just about something else). As I continued to read, I realized why we have such different experiences in part: I teach math. I can see that my students did learn something this semester. Now most of them can discuss geometric Brownian motion. That's cool. As the author here says, Many of the engineers who were painted purple during frosh week are now running the institutions where we teach. And they weren’t kidding when they were pissing on our guitars in the quad. It was a promissory note on the future — a future they could feel in their bones belonged to them, not us. I'm one of them -- the heathen, uneducated STEM people! If I call his thoughts about Camus "fluff" he no longer has any defense! Needing to be polite in his response renders him... gosh, impotent? in the face of such trenchant criticism. Hm. Things are different on the STEM side of campus than the classics side. Many on that side say that they're terrified of their students (http://www.vox.com/2015/6/3/8706323/college-professor-afraid http://www.vox.com/2015/6/3/8706323/college-professor-afraid) but it seems to me that these folks are terrified of discussion -- and the other thing to note is that every single one of them brings up the fear of losing their job over a discussion. It's curious, in one of the only professions in the world with tenure. Why are all these guys afraid of losing their job for challenging the PC SJW orthodoxy or whatever? For professors with tenure, this is a fear entirely unsupported by statistics. The only case even marginally close is when Salaita had a job offer withdrawn because of his views on Israel and Palestine, and I think he was on what would be stereotyped as the PC side at the moment. So, tenure gives golden handcuffs -- you can't move institutions -- but you'll still have your job even if you're a grump. Ok, so why are these profs on the liberal arts side scared? Because of the adjunctivization of higher ed -- no tenure for most (including me). One great discussion here: http://www.vox.com/2015/6/5/8736591/liberal-professor-identity http://www.vox.com/2015/6/5/8736591/liberal-professor-identi... Because of the corporatization of higher ed: more discussion here. http://www.slate.com/articles/life/education/2015/05/college_students_are_not_customers_a_political_shorthand_that_needs_to_die.html http://www.slate.com/articles/life/education/2015/05/college... Because the STEM and business profs are "winning," as the OP said. Because he can't see his own relevance anymore, unlike Dan-el Padilla Peralta. Because he can't connect with his students anymore. It's hilarious that these problems are so acutely felt when more American kids than ever feel required to go to college. The audience is bigger than ever. That means the message can't be as niche, but this is still an opportunity. Hate online education? Why, and what are you going to do about it? Hate telling students they should be thoughtful when considering cultural appropriation? Have the cojones to join the discussion in a more substantive way than "overcoddled kids these days!"
- lintiness 11y agoi found at least one blatant typo, and it takes this guy about 1000 words what can be said in a quarter that. no wonder his students are bored.
- hcayless 11y agoFound at least 2 before I quit paying attention. It's not 100% crap by any means, but there's a disturbing narrow-mindedness to it as well.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- vinceguidry 11y agoI can't count the number of things I learned in college on my fingers because I didn't really learn anything. Nor did I learn good study habits, nor did I cultivate my appreciation of knowledge there. I did all that after I dropped out of college and the ugliness of the work world drove me to cultivate my inner garden. I am exponentially smarter now than I ever was in school. I am a firm believer in the sentiment behind the phrase "Never let your schooling get in the way of your education." The author believes in a fiction that never existed. Professors have always had to fight to earn the attention of students, iPhones weren't the only competitors. What's happened is that reality has gotten so naked that even the absurdly idealistic professors have had to acknowledge it. They were the only ones who ever really believed it. I feel like even parents, for awhile now, pay lip service to the value of schooling without actually believing in it. Education is not, and never was, what academia seems to think it is.
- ladadadabing 11y agoThis essay is absolutely correct in all things. I didn't finish college and, even though I've been highly successful, it was later in life that I noticed things that were missing. Things that would have made other things easier and, especially now, made life a little easier. Those "things" are probably different for everyone but, for me, I wish I had them from the beginning.
- cafard 11y agoThose who become professors tend to spend their college years around those of similar inclinations. Once they become professors they have to deal with the general population, and I think this can be a shock. Very little that I have read about the universities of other years (going far back) suggests to me that there was ever an age in which a large majority of the students were in it for the learning. It is perhaps the case that students read less and so write worse than they did once. But having worked as a copy editor long ago, I can tell you that a lot of Ph.D.s wrote pretty damn badly before most of HN was born. (OK, Ph.D.s in the social sciences and E.D.s are mostly what I'm thinking of.) And "Finally, the very act of employing, empowering, and often elevating such people [term employees] denigrates real scholars and scholarship by definition." I haven't heard of a lot of empowered adjuncts. And if that adjunct happens to have what it takes to teach freshman composition or an introductory survey course, I don't see the denigration. As for real scholarship, well, not everything published in a refereed journal is more than formally scholarship. One could, for example, compile an entertaining anthology of things that writers and highly qualified critics have said about Proceedings of the Modern Language Association. Finally, what does a parent expect who sends a child off to school unable to write well and disinclined to read? It does seem to be a premise of US education that if you keep people in a classroom setting long enough then something will happen. But why should parents believe that?
- jccalhoun 11y agoAs someone who has taught college for over a decade, I can say that while there are a lot of problems in higher education students are not high on my list.
- jseliger 11y agowhile there are a lot of problems in higher education students are not high on my list. I've not taught quite as long as you, but I'll add that I like to tell students that life is going to be their ultimate punishment or reward: If they don't learn how to read and write (I teach English), they'll be the ones who suffer. Not me. Some people of course don't learn anything and are fine. Many however don't learn anything and aren't fine.
- pnathan 11y agoIf this is news to you, dear HN reader, then you really haven't been paying attention to the discourse surrounding education in the last 30 years of the United States. I believe the big work to hit the popular mind initially was Bloom's Closing of the American Mind, which essentially says the same thing, but the disease was slightly less advanced then. As an interesting linguistic note: the liberal arts were conceived of as the arts for free men; rather then the techincal things - technicalities - which were to be done by slaves. A careful reading of michaelochurch's polemics should suggest to you that this has not changed in substance in the general case. No computer science will save you from someone who can out-rhetoric you.
- mooreds 11y agoLoved the reference to 'Gorgias', which, incidentally, I read in my college days at a liberal arts school. Rhetoric isn't the path to truth, but it can sure help with power. Here it is online: http://classics.mit.edu/Plato/gorgias.html http://classics.mit.edu/Plato/gorgias.html Edit: added link to 'Gorgias'.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoFinished reading. The text is cut short on this page, but even after reading what is there, I am left amazed. A few points (mind you, I haven't read anything from the classic besides what they managed to force me to ingest in school, which as you can imagine is not much): - Though I found the discussion overtly long (yay my non-existent attention span), it's surprisingly easy to read; I expected ancient Greek texts to be much more difficult in terms of language and style. - All the whining I see and do about manipulators, liars, salesmen and contemporary advertising industry, Plato has described thousands of years ago. It's like, fuck, why do I bother rediscovering and repeating what ancient philosophers knew all along, and why the society doesn't seem to be learning from those lessons? - I should have learned this already, but I'm still amazed every time I read an old text describing exactly the same problems we have in the contemporary world. Here's me thinking they are unique to our age, but apparently King Solomon is right, and there truly is nothing new under the Sun, at least in human relations - we keep repeating the same patterns, generation after generation. - I guess I'm starting to appreciate the stated reasons for classic education. Thank you for linking to the text.
- geodel 11y agoI have mixed feeling about this article. On one hand I agree with heavy commercialization of education. I feel same about my life where all my education was one step closer to better life in term of money and comforts that money brings. Now after working for more than a decade and having reasonably successful career I feel more and more empty. On other hand I slightly disagree or more accurately, feel sad and scared that online education is not something that will bring any intellectual fulfillment to life. I use to think a few online courses here and there will bring in some content to me.
- Mikeb85 11y agoI was expecting the worst judging from the comments here, but it's actually an excellent essay (or article, or whatever you want to call it). I personally agree. University should be more about learning and becoming better thinkers than simply learning a few facts and getting a piece of paper. Pretty much none of the students I interact with care about 'learning', or any form of critical thinking. They want the profs to teach them a few facts, then base the test on those few facts. They optimize for this so they can get their A, then get the hell out.
- Retric 11y agoIMO, the internet has changed who speaks for the masses. It used to take real effort to speak out. So, you generally only hear from people who do stuff. Now days speaking is easy, it's getting people to pay attention that's hard. And what most speaks to people are simple messages about simple problems. Sadly, this means it's simple messages from whiners that drones out everyone else. There are still plenty of builders, protesters, and politicians, but it's just the drone of first world problems silences them. PS: As to learners, you don't need to speak to your professors if you want to learn something. So, professors are going to hear more from people about there grades than the actual subject.
- kaitai 11y agoA lot of students don't care about critical thinking, but I think that really underestimates these students. What do we offer them, after all? All I had to do was advertise some research opportunities and 10+ students were interested in doing work for no pay and no credit outside of class. Sure, they have no idea what they're doing -- but they know they want to be doing something interesting, and they took the initiative to follow up with me. What is so special about my students? They're pretty career focused, and not in a "learning-for-learning's-sake" kind of field. And yet they want to use what they learn in class to do meaningful analysis on extracurricular topics.
- superuser2 11y agoThis is a matter of institutional culture. You'll find it in schools that are country clubs or low-cost mass-appeal credential factories. You won't find it so much in private schools with reputations for nerdiness and difficulty.
- jackmaney 11y agoThe author and I are in very different fields, but this article echoes a lot of the reasons why I left my tenure track position and ultimately ended up in industry. The final nail in the coffin was an email sent out by some middle-administrator schmuck to all of the faculty, encouraging us to think over the winter break about how to "provide excellent customer service" to our students (or some such horse shit...this was several years ago, so I don't remember the exact words).
- Namrog84 11y agoOn an unrelated topic. Anyone else experience the inability to scroll properly on that page? I am on mobile but even requesting desktop version didn't fix. There are a few seconds of full scroll then it locks into a range. It's not even necessarily the beginning. One time it locked in some middle portion. Is this the fault of poor web design or is something wrong on my phone? Thanks!