3 ms·
I have a friend working on the Connectome project (http://cbs.fas.harvard.edu/science/connectome-project http://cbs.fas.harvard.edu/science/connectome-project)
by dahart 11y ago
I have a friend working on the Connectome project (http://cbs.fas.harvard.edu/science/connectome-project http://cbs.fas.harvard.edu/science/connectome-project) who told me last summer that all brain logic happens in the outer millimeter of tissue, everything inside is essentially routing.
I'm summarizing his summary, so I'm certain it's more complex than that, but to a first order approximation, I'd guess your guess is correct!
And so it wouldn't be particularly surprising that someone with cavities in their brain could be smart. One might expect deficiencies of some sort, but one might be speculating; I probably wouldn't bet on it.
- mistaken 11y agoThis might even be useful for simulating brains, since the hollow brain model seems to be a lot simpler than a fully connected one.
- amelius 11y agoUhm, but why isn't the routing essential for processing? And why is it there in the first place? In other words, why wouldn't evolution eliminate this costly and unnecessary part of the brain?
- trhway 11y agoit was mentioned that the condition develops gradually from the normal brain. So it seems pretty plausible that in some people the brain successfully rewires in parallel with and in response to the development of the condition so that direct white matter connections get functionally replaced by some kind of mesh-style network in the gray matter layer. While this may suggest that typical amount of white matter may be not strictly necessary, the significantly less than 100% success rate of such rewiring may explain why evolution hasn't gone this way .
- rayedearthstar 11y agoThis is quite unconvincing: the evolutionary advantage of, let's say, all animals the size of lemurs, having human level intelligence is such that pressure to find this rewiring would have been unprecedented. I think more data and research is needed here. My feeling is that when a few dozen of such cases are closely studied, interesting patterns will emerge. It is surprising that these cases exhibit high IQ and no immediate signs of dysfunction, but it would be absolutely extraordinary if no patterns of difference vs. typical brain were found at all.
- ZenPsycho 11y agoevolutionary trees are littered with branches that have thus far been unable to overcome local maxima- Our eyes' retinas for instance, have optic nerves that connect on the light sensitive surface, blocking a huge portion of valuable photons, instead of the logical place to connect them- on the REAR of the retina- as squid and octopus retinas have been connected in their completely independent eye evolution. Once something works "good enough" there's not really any selective pressure to eliminate obvious design flaws if they don't particularly impede reproduction or survival.