3 ms·
I was wondering if instead of having all the miners churning away at a proof-of-work there would be a simpler way to validate a block. For instance, could you
by lordnacho 11y ago
I was wondering if instead of having all the miners churning away at a proof-of-work there would be a simpler way to validate a block.
For instance, could you have a defined chain of authoritative servers, where the authority passes in a way where it cannot be abused?
Example: A mines a block by signing it with a key, throws up random number corresponding to B. B then does the same and nominates C. C stopped working, so authority passes to D.
Is there a way to do this so that the obvious attacks are thwarted?
- sp332 11y agoIt's much easier in a centralized system. The only advantage bitcoin has over previous systems is that it prevents double-spending in a decentralized system.
- droffel 11y agoI'm pretty sure the system you're describing is similar to Proof-of-Stake. In a PoS system, an owner in control of a portion of the monetary base (their "stake") controls the private keys to that portion. Depending on the algorithm used, the keys they hold have a chance of belonging to a set of keys that have the ability to sign the next processed block. Some, I'm not sure if all, PoS algorithms use an additional PoW step that acts as a time-multiplier on whether your key is in the signing set, to ensure a block can always be found in the absence of many people staking, and to create a barrier to the speed of block emission. Additionally, R3CEV (pronounced like receive, the name isn't an acronym as far as I'm aware) is discussing a system where all banks in the consortium sign blocks in a round-robin fashion with trusted keys, negating the need for PoW at all. I have a feeling this will improve the efficiency of many things in the financial sector, but I doubt it will have as big of an impact as a decentralized and trustless system, like PoW and (possibly, if the wrinkles are ironed out) PoS.
- throwaway2048 11y agoif you have defined authoritative servers, they can just hold ballance amount and you can dispense with the rest of the blockchain entirely
- lordnacho 11y agoI don't mean defined as in static. Of course if you did that you could just use an old fashioned database.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nunyabuizness 11y ago>For instance, could you have a defined chain of authoritative servers, where the authority passes in a way where it cannot be abused? Ripple and Stellar use a federated network of validating transactions to reach cascading consensus (validators A, B and C said this txn is good, and I "trust" them, so I will say this txn is good too) that while not completely abuse-proof, is significantly cheaper than PoW and possibly PoS (not certain about PoS costs; since the network of validators can be modeled as a graph, the central-most validators in the graph could censor transactions, but if validators "trust" a wide-enough variety of validators, it won't happen).