5 ms·
The economist podcast covered similar issues, and noted that there is ~4% credit card penetration in India - that the local delivery services had had to work ou
by lifeisstillgood 11y ago
The economist podcast covered similar issues, and noted that there is ~4% credit card penetration in India - that the local delivery services had had to work out how to take cash on delivery as the main means on income - I shudder to think of Amazons CFO shuddering to think of that.
I will be surprised if Amazon can do more than maintain a token presence outside of major cities, but I am sure they have plans.
- pinkunicorn 11y agoThey already do. I live(rather work from home) in a remote village in Southern India. Ordered a Nikon camera recently which the local stores said will take atleast 7 days to procure, and Amazon delivered in 3 days. The item was shipped all the way from Northern India(Nagpur) and guess what, it was 500INR cheaper on Amazon. While on one hand I was more than happy to get it in three days and a little cheaper, I also realized that this won't last forever. Amazon's capital has gotta run out at some point in time and the cheap/fast service will stop there.
- devdas 11y agoNagpur is close to the center of India, not the north.
- pinkunicorn 11y agoYou have my apologies. We often joke that anything northern than Bangalore is North India!
- radmuzom 11y agoWell then Chennai is North India!! A lot of people don't realize that Bangalore is actually south of Chennai.
- lgessler 11y agoPerhaps the poster meant cultural North India, which (in my experience) is only contrasted with cultural South India, which is comprised of the states in which Dravidian languages are spoken by a majority, namely: Kerala, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, AP, and Telangana.
- umanwizard 11y agoI think when people say "North India" what they typically mean is the areas that speak Indo-Aryan languages (as opposed to Dravidian ones).
- adventured 11y ago> Amazon's capital has gotta run out at some point in time They're famous for being willing to push competitors into the ground on margins, at whatever loss is necessary in the relative near-term. It's very likely they're going to seek to squeeze Flipkart on margins until they're struggling to operate due to a very high cash burn (with venture capitalists eventually unwilling to keep pouring red ink down the drain). I'd bet that Amazon views India as a truly massive future market. They really can't crack China properly, and likely never will. India however, they can crack. They'll pour vast resources into it to build out a dominant position. If you told Amazon they can own a dominant position in India for the next 30 years by spending $10 billion today, they'd write that check immediately. They're the world's largest retailer by market valuation, and carry $14.4 billion in cash (with the ability to raise whatever sum they need at any time they need it). Further, AWS has become a cash generating monster, that will fund any adventures Amazon wants to undertake over at least the next decade. No chance they run out of capital.
- jsudhams 11y agoMakes sense once they are able to setup kiosks in villages and have employees there to order on behalf of customer with COD, you have largest profit making reailer in the world. If they can work ith few FMCG like Godreg,Uniliver, P & G and Nestle etc.. along with Indian Postal and local couriers.. you have great monster. Indians does not care about anything other than price (durability/quality) so 1 rupee less than local guy on kiosk then people will buy from kiosk guy. I wish i had some capital to try this out.. EDIT: Also Indians still share in village so even if amazon says they will give only 10 Hamam soaps but at 10% less or 10 Horlicks with 15% less, people will pool and buy.
- vram22 11y ago>Indians does not care about anything other than price (durability/quality) "do not care" That's a solid point :-) and largely true, though a generalization. Changing some at least among the younger generation in cities, though.
- Sven7 11y agoAmazon's threat is Jack Ma. And Jack Ma is bigger than Amazon.
- puranjay 11y agoIndian here. For people from my class (middle to upper-middle), Amazon has largely replaced Flipkart (the market leader), and eCommerce has largely replaced local commerce. Payment is a massive pain in the ass though. Getting credit cards is a nightmare if you don't have a traditional job. You need 2-factor authentication for all transactions, which is just a ton of work. I often end up using 'cash on delivery' just because I'm too lazy to enter my debit card details and do the 2-factor authentication Flipkart still has a better presence outside of the big cities, but Amazon is catching up, fast.
- kbart 11y agoWhy don't use PayPal then?
- pkd 11y agoBecause PayPal doesn't support the two step authentication that Indian banks require.
- JTon 11y agoI use 2FA on my Paypal account.. ?
- firasd 11y agoYou're close: Paypal is a bit hamstrung by regulations in India, but the domestic mobile wallet industry has been growing. My prediction is that China & India will (continue to) leapfrog credit cards in favor of mobile payments. (P.S. not linking here because it's a bit off-topic but I've added links to my article & slide deck about this in my HN profile.)
- neximo4 11y agoPaypal doesn't allow you to hold balances in Indian Rupees. You can only use dollars.
- hsuresh 11y agoMy guess is that India will likely leapfrog from cash to mobile payments - so in the long run that shouldn't pose as much of a problem to Amazon or any other vendor. There is already a lot of startups and established companies offering mobile wallets, and I believe many of then are setting good traction too.
- chronic50 11y agoVery few vendors accept mobile payments. Also consumers are far less likely to use mobile payments for medium sized payments.
- nandemo 11y ago> I shudder to think of Amazons CFO shuddering to think of that. Care to elaborate? Cash-on-delivery is a common payment method in Japan, and Amazon Japan and many other online marketplaces have been using it for years. It can be problematic operationally, but how is it worse than credit card settlement for the finance department? Payment at the convenience store is another common method here, and it's arguably more problematic than COD as the marketplace/merchant has to wait for the payment to go thru before shipping.
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoControl I guess - how to be sure what was due was collected, passing it back up the chain, vulnerable to fraud and violence, and of course no nice customers fronting you billions in free cash each day.
- legulere 11y agoCredit cards aren't the only way to pay on the internet, and also not the best way, as long as you have a working banking system. In Germany for instance credit card ownership rates are fairly low, still Amazon is doing really well using direct debit.