3 ms·
That would be because it's not a word used by the general public. It's a men's rights movement offshoot. If you see someone use it seriously, it's a dead giveaw
by TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago
That would be because it's not a word used by the general public. It's a men's rights movement offshoot. If you see someone use it seriously, it's a dead giveaway of where they're coming from.
- Jtsummers 11y agoWell, reading about it has been a bit surreal. They have a different take than the normal men's rights stuff I've read. I get taking time off from relationships. I get feeling hurt. But to conclude from that that all women should be shunned, and you should never have any more relationships, is a bit extreme. I guess I'll have to file this away with other delusional movements of the modern era.
- cubancigar11 11y agoAll the ascetics have historically shunned sex, except Osho who... went in a whole different direction. If you are reading about MGTOW then most probably you are reading a very slanted view of them by people who don't like to here that men are suffering. MGTOWs don't hate women nor they consider feminists as enemies. It is very much a political movement and hence gets shitted upon by political feminism. Not a surprise there. But to listen to ignorant people talking as an expert because they read something written by equally ignorant people with malicious intent is mostly funny, until you realist the very high number of male suicides. As I said earlier, if gender were reversed we wouldn't be having this conversation.
- Jtsummers 11y agoOk, give us a reading list. And explain what the theory of eulogy is and what social experiments we (Americans) conducted in Japan that has lead to this suicide epidemic.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> And explain what the theory of eulogy is ...a very good question, given that all the links on google for the phrase "theory of eulogy" lead back to this comment thread.
- cubancigar11 11y agoWhere exactly I have mentioned that theory of Eugenics is American? I think you have misread my whole comment due to lack of control. 'USA' has been mentioned by people who think MGTOW is an American think, and I have denied it. Eulogy is obviously a misspelling of Eugenics. Forgive me, I am not a native English speaker.
- Jtsummers 11y agoYou wrote theory of eulogy. Since you meant eugenics then your post makes a lot more sense because that's some useful context. I appreciate that it was a mistake, but it was not a leap I (or others, apparently) could easily make from the misspelling to the intended word.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> But to conclude from that that all women should be shunned, and you should never have any more relationships, is a bit extreme. I think its something that it is very common for people to go through as a phase (and, also, the gender-reversed mirror image is common as this), particularly in young adulthood, and its also a thing that historically very common to have groups advocate as a lifestyle (usually incorporating a very negative image of women as part of its justification) -- but to the extent a gender-reversed form is pushed by powerful groups as a lifestyle advocated to women, it is also, if it incorporates a negative view of one gender, with a negative view of women.
- samstave 11y ago>all women should be shunned, and you should never have any more relationships Isn't this why we have the term: Eunuch
- Jtsummers 11y agoNah. Eunuch's were either forced into it or chose it for the political/economic potential of the roles they could fulfill as eunuchs. Also, one reason for their castration (in some cultures) was to allow them access to women, because they could be trusted with them (compared to non-castrated male guards).
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoVoluntary celibacy has been around for a long time. Isn't this just a modern version of that?
- amyjess 11y agoYou'd think so, but then some MGTOWs will start talking about how they're finished associating with American women but will still consider dating Asian women because they want a "submissive" and "traditional" wife. It's creepy as fuck. (also, it's seriously racist: I've had Asian female friends my entire life, and none of them are "submissive" or "traditional"... I can't imagine any of them putting up with that shit)
- Jtsummers 11y agoYes, but. They seem to be taking it to a greater extreme or encouraging people to, where they remove even female friendships and social contact from the table.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoEven removing all contact with women isn't new.
- Jtsummers 11y agoNo. But it is extreme, and in the modern era in western countries (where these groups seem to be) really, really hard to pull off. I've been to Catholic monasteries in the US, plenty of women around most of them. Either working in the gift shops, volunteering with tasks needed around the monastery (often, the monks are aging and needing more help these days than in earlier eras). A totally cloistered existence is possible, but you're making a major sacrifice. Without a religious motivation I'm having a hard time imagining anyone making that commitment.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Without a religious motivation I'm having a hard time imagining anyone making that commitment. As I understand, even the religious groups (including Catholic cloistered religious, which as you note most orders are not) that take isolation to more extreme levels -- of both genders -- tend to do a lot of work to filter out people whose motivations are not religious, so I don't think that a religious motivation is all that essential to choosing such a lifestyle (the typical non-religious motivations may turn out to usually be insufficient to staying with that choice, though...)