6 ms·
ISIS Influence on Web Prompts Second Thoughts on First Amendment
- unimpressive 11y ago> “Never before in our history have enemies outside the United States been able to propagate genuinely dangerous ideas on American territory in such an effective way,” Mr. Posner wrote. The Islamic State’s ability to spread “ideas that lead directly to terrorist attacks,” he said, “calls for new thinking about limits on freedom of speech.” This seems to me like the keystone of the argument, and I'm fairly sure a good bout of research into anarchist and communist terrorism/propaganda around the turn of the 20th century would show it false.
- soared 11y agoAlso I'm not sure the logic is totally sound. Is it really the propaganda and spreading of ideas that lead to terrorists attacks, or the other way around?
- reverius42 11y agoIf we, as a society, believe it is possible for an _idea_ to be dangerous -- not a person, nor a thing, but an _idea_ -- then we have already lost the purpose of the right that the First Amendment is supposed to protect.
- alexbecker 11y agoI think most people agree that an idea can be dangerous. As I understand it, the first amendment exists because we believe that this danger is outweighed by the dangers of censorship and the benefits of the marketplace of ideas.
- reverius42 11y agoFair enough. Danger is a spectrum, not binary. I agree, a more nuanced view is that we (should?) view censorship as more dangerous than open communication of dangerous ideas. Or at least that's my understanding of why we have a First Amendment in the first place.
- jon_richards 11y agoAnd ideas are bulletproof.
- busterarm 11y agoThat's exactly it though. We defend against dangerous ideas by dragging them out into the light of day and examining them. Sticking them underground does the exactly opposite of that.
- meowface 11y agoWhat about someone preaching "kill all black people, kill them in the streets and their homes"? This is an idea, and a potentially dangerous one. The right to free speech does not apply to all possible kinds of speech. Of course racist language should not be illegal. But violent-inciting racist language should be. Anti-Christian or anti-Western language should not be illegal, but language recommending non-Muslims should die is illegal. And many of these websites and lectures promote killing of non-Muslim civilians.
- wnoise 11y agoCurrent law (as interpreted by the U.S. Supreme Court) allows even for calling for the murder of people, as long as it is not "imminent". Saying that group X should be killed in general at some indefinite time in the future is perfectly legal, but saying "hey, we need to kill this guy right here in front of us, right now" is not.
- andrewclunn 11y agoWould banning known venues for such communication make it go away? No, it would just make it harder to track. So many officials wanting to appear like they're doing something, but it's all security theater. Now taking it to the point of directly attacking the first Amendment? Scary times.
- patrickaljord 11y agoScarier than you think. Many of these these proposals have already made it in Europe. It may come to the US too in the future given Millennials support for these kinds of measures: http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/11/20/40-of-millennials-ok-with-limiting-speech-offensive-to-minorities/ http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/11/20/40-of-millen...
- meowface 11y agoThere's still a huge difference between a proposal to ban racist speech, and a proposal to ban videos preaching Islamic extremism. The latter is a lot more likely to lead to physical harm and death.
- patrickaljord 11y agoDepends, what's the likelihood of dying from a racist assault compared to a terrorist assault? And how do you measure the effect racist and terrorist speech has on these assaults? And who decides for us what's ok to watch and what's not? And once you decide it's ok to censor, well, we all know where that leads.
- meowface 11y ago>Depends, what's the likelihood of dying from a racist assault compared to a terrorist assault? I think both are incredibly low odds, but globally, the chance of dying in a terrorist assault is probably higher. Most racist media does not advocate violence or death towards minorities; just discrimination and isolation, typically. For example, probably one of the most popular racist websites out there is http://www.dailystormer.com http://www.dailystormer.com, and they have a large disclaimer: >We here at the Daily Stormer are opposed to violence. We seek revolution through the education of the masses. When the information is available to the people, systemic change will be inevitable and unavoidable. Anyone suggesting or promoting violence in the comments section will be immediately banned, permanently. You can find similar disclaimers on websites like Stormfront. But lectures from people like al-Awlaki? They're both more powerful messages, because they're objective directives ("God DEMANDS you do this"), and directly call for violence towards non-Muslims. I think both send awful messages, but the latter is worse for society in general.
- jakeogh 11y agotl;dr The pinnacle of establishment propaganda suggests we should continue to pretend we can trade freedom for safety. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jyoOfRog1EM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jyoOfRog1EM
- ilamont 11y agoBecause a direct challenge to Constitutionally protected speech is unlikely, I predict the Communications Decency Act from the 1990s -- specifically, Section 230 which protects web services from many liability claims associated with comments posted by users (1) -- could be targeted for repeal or a major rewriting. 1. http://technology.findlaw.com/modern-law-practice/understanding-the-legal-issues-for-social-networking-sites-and.html http://technology.findlaw.com/modern-law-practice/understand...
- comex 11y agoAs if marking a certain brand of speech as forbidden, without being able to do more than a tiny smidgen to actually prevent its dissemination (as must be the case given the unfiltered nature of our Internet - unlike in the past with paper materials, not that censorship worked out so well then either), would reduce its effectiveness on vulnerable young people questioning their worldviews, as opposed to making it seem more attractive!
- meowface 11y agoYeah, that's the biggest problem here. Taking down a lecture from a Muslim extremist isn't going to somehow dissuade a young, easily-influenced person from looking for it. They're going to want to learn what "the government doesn't want you to see!", and will find the video through different means. Maybe Youtube should instead modify those videos to still show them, but also provide some kind of pop-up or page inject with links to counter-arguments. This is still invasive, but a lot more reasonable, I think. When something has strong potential to turn some people into mass murderers, I think it's okay to be a little invasive.
- gizmo686 11y agoYoutube already shows you related videos, and on the home page suggests videos based on your viewing history. It would not be difficult to modify those algorithms to attempt to suggest videos with the intent of influences the viewers belief (as opposed to maximizing their time on the site). Similarly, Google can do this with their main search engine as well. Of course, when thought about in the abstract, this seems highly distopian, but the time maximizing goal also has political effects (namely, the "search bubble" and radicalization).
- meowface 11y agoIt does feel a bit dystopian, but it's not trying to prevent supposed societal "ills" like "the gays" or "socialism". Violent terrorism and extremism are real global ills and negatively impact every society. Calls for violence aren't considered valid free speech and can be directly banned. Calls for things that can eventually lead to violence are a much murkier area. They shouldn't be outright banned, but they should be mitigated.
- delinka 11y agoWhy aren't we teaching our children the responsibilities of freedom instead of attempting to take freedom away?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- gregatragenet3 11y agoSince 2001 more more people have died on US soil from toppling vending machines than from terrorist attacks.. Yet we are constantly told we need to scrap the entire bill of rights to stay safe. It's ridiculous. Who does this serve?
- lfam 11y agoDo you have a citation for this? I'd love to share it with a friend of mine who is afraid of being a victim of terrorism in the US.
- yoloswagins 11y agoThe statistic comes from Dr. Cosio, who looked at newspaper reports and talked to emergency room doctors. Unfortunately, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention don't keep track of vending machine deaths, so we're left with Dr. Cosio's less than perfect methods. Full paper: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1602339 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1602339
- jimktrains2 11y agohttp://freakonomics.com/2011/09/08/how-are-sharks-less-dangerous-than-vending-machines-an-exercise-in-conditional-risk/ http://freakonomics.com/2011/09/08/how-are-sharks-less-dange... might be good? You could also remind them that ~90 people die every day from car crashes. Each month more people die from car crashes than have died in terrorist attacks on the US. A similar number of people (to the number that die in car crashes) die from gun violence in the US. Terrorism should realistically be so far down on someone's lists of cars that they shouldn't be able to justify any ounce of worry on it. Driving more cautiously would be a better use of the anxiety.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoDetailed data is here: http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr64/nvsr64_02.pdf http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr64/nvsr64_02.pdf I'm guessing terrorism is under one of the homicides. On most years, slips in bathtubs and bee stings kill more people than terrorists. Drowning, motor vehicles, chemical poisoning, half the crap in the grocery store, too much drugs/surgery... all sorts of things Americans aren't asking for censorship or intervention for that are what kill them en masse. Terrorism? That just kills freedom when we pass laws to stop it. Just as it's partly intended to. ;)
- Animats 11y agoThe US survived the Communist Party of the USA. It survived the German-American Bund and Hitler Youth camps on Long Island. It survived Lindbergh endorsing Hitler. ISIS is a nuisance compared to those. Here's ISIS's magazine.[1] Read what the other side has to say. Their layout, photography, and typesetting are quite good. That's upsetting some people. Most nut groups can't format a newsletter. [1] http://www.clarionproject.org/news/islamic-state-isis-isil-propaganda-magazine-dabiq# http://www.clarionproject.org/news/islamic-state-isis-isil-p...
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoDon't forget the whole eugenics movement. The likes of Lothrop Stoddard and Madison Grant were very popular in their day, but ultimately subsided and in retrospect are derided. The NSDAP did borrow a lot from them, though - Lindbergh was hardly the only one endorsing Hitler, he was an intellectual featherweight relative to many others.
- sitkack 11y agoIf WW2 hadn't occurred we would probably have our own n-tier master race at home by now. Obedient, diligent worker drones powering our own corporate fascist ship.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoWe largely did. The elites just decided it was more profitable to have most of the drones in countries with cheaper labor and looser regulations. ;)
- rsync 11y ago"His proposal would make it illegal to go onto websites that glorify the Islamic State or support its recruitment, or to distribute links to such sites. He would impose graduated penalties, starting with a warning letter, then fines or prison for repeat offenders, to convey that “looking at ISIS-related websites, like looking at websites that display child pornography, is strictly forbidden.”" Christ, what an asshole.
- ccvannorman 11y agoSo, if I trick my friend into clicking on the link, they go to jail? What if I'm a college student who wants to research the site? What if I'm just a thorough investigator who wants to read all sides? What if I'm deeply anti-war and I want to understand the most troubled people in order to reach them and make peace? Should I go to jail because I navigated to their propaganda site? How fucking ridiculous.
- DanBC 11y agoMens Rea. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mens_rea https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mens_rea
- s_q_b 11y agoThis is terrifying. Eric Posner, quoted in the article, isn't some far right nutjob. He's a well respected law professor, son of the famous Judge Richard Posner (7th Cir.), and one of the most cited legal scholars in the country. I'm not one to sound the alarm, but I'm actually worried about the First Amendment for the first time in my life.
- busterarm 11y agoAnd for the former ombudsman of NPR thought that blasphemy should not be constitutionally protected free speech. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2015/02/11/outgoing-npr-ombudsman-seems-to-have-some-words-in-favor-of-restricting-blasphemy/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/201...
- brandonmenc 11y agoThe Founders could not have imagined the internet, so I'm not sure how the 1st Amendment even applies to it. /sarc
- LyndsySimon 11y agoSarcasm or not, that's effectively the argument that's being presented here.
- LyndsySimon 11y agoSarcasm or not, that's effectively the argument that's being presented here.
- mrbill 11y agoThis article apparently presumes that the US "owns" the Internet and that laws passed here apply to people in other countries... As much as I despise Daesh, this is not the right way to do things.
- sitkack 11y agoDon't bury the ISIS message, we should give them 10 minutes a day on VoA at least. I watched the 700 club as a kid, the crystal cathedral, what is the fucking difference?
- panarky 11y ago> what is the fucking difference? Funny, I can't remember Pat Robertson or Robert Schuller putting people in cages, dousing them with diesel and burning them alive.
- sitkack 11y agoDid you have cable?
- JabavuAdams 11y agoOur allies in various counter-insurgencies over the years have done such things, and many of those wars have been enthusiastically supported by the religious right.
- JabavuAdams 11y agoSince this is a technical site, let me point out that if you're down-voting this because you believe that neither we nor our allies have done such things, then you need educate yourself on the modern history and conduct of warfare and counter-insurgency. If this strikes you as an outrageous claim, then your model of the world and of how we wage war is just wrong. If you're down-voting for other reasons, well, have at it.
- sitkack 11y agoJabavu, we are now friends.
- vannevar 11y agoThe only thing historically unique about ISIS is the historical overreaction to it. Posner's absurd histrionics are a case in point.
- nickbauman 11y agoA similar thread ties the San Bernardino shooters, the Paris attacks of a few months ago and the Charlie Hebdo shooters and many others. The attackers weren't known as being particularly devout, but they weren't known for having much of a life outside the Jihadi cause. By the time an impressionable, disheartened recruit is on the Internet looking for violent hate speech to adopt, many things have already failed socially for them: a real sense of belonging, dignified prospects, hope for a future, a nurturing, generative ethos, a stable family. They are a socially shattered coterie. Jihad gave them a sense of significance they never had but always wanted. People underestimate a preference to die on one's feet over living on one's knees. Not to mention fighting for a cause larger than oneself, right or wrong.
- JabavuAdams 11y agoWhy are Americans so afraid? You are the most powerful nation in the history of the planet. You routinely bend the rest of the world to your will. Your military kills civilians with relative impunity. What are you so afraid of? Just chill the fuck out, m'kay?
- discardorama 11y agoRemember, ISIS wouldn't be around if it weren't for the US. And even as late as 2014, the Saudis prevented the US from attacking ISIS. So the US helps create ISIS and stands by while it consolidates power ... and I am supposed to pay for it with my First Amendment?!?
- Chirael 11y agoReminds me of Gaiman's "Why Defend Freedom of Icky Speech" http://journal.neilgaiman.com/2008/12/why-defend-freedom-of-icky-speech.html http://journal.neilgaiman.com/2008/12/why-defend-freedom-of-...
- staunch 11y agoIf ISIS didn't exist, some government agency would have to create it.
- busterarm 11y agoRelated reading: Mike Hume's Trigger Warning. http://www.amazon.co.uk/Trigger-Warning-Offensive-Killing-Speech-ebook/dp/B00QPTAUBE http://www.amazon.co.uk/Trigger-Warning-Offensive-Killing-Sp... I'm actually in the middle of reading it now.
- sharemywin 11y agoI'd like to see the constitutional amendment that would get written. If written in general it could probably be used to throw most of the politicians in jail. Wouldn't advocacy for gun laws be generally inciting violence, how about violent video games? Wouldn't calling for going to war be considered generally inciting violence? The bible talks a lot about violence should it be outlawed?