3 ms·
It's certainly an interesting problem. Suppose that an program that needs administrative permissions depends on lib.dll. Should lib.dll have to be bundled with
by Spivak 11y ago
It's certainly an interesting problem. Suppose that an program that needs administrative permissions depends on lib.dll. Should lib.dll have to be bundled with the application and signed with the same key? Why not statically link at that point then?
Since the libraries the application might pull in might not even be available before runtime would you prompt for each load? Maybe prompt for each load that isn't in a system directory -- implying that there isn't prior trust?
You could embed the key the library developer signed the library with but then we have a key revocation problem and updating the library might require updating the application and business critical applications might hold entire departments back from getting security fixes.
I don't think this is really a problem with DLLs or the signature process, but that the old installer tries to load any library in the executable directory.
- digi_owl 11y agoThe constant issue of computer security is perhaps that software can only inspect actions, not intent. And any action taken can be either legitimate or nefarious, given the context of intent.
- marcosdumay 11y agoAt some point, infosec lies on user education. No arguing about this. But the exact point is open to argument. Software need an interfaces that reflect intent - if your browser dumps stuff from unrelated places at the same folder, and then the OS uses those unrelated stuff as if it was related, there's a completely failure from the software data to reflect the user intent. This is a blatant fault of the software stack (but of no party in particular).
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoThe classic way of mitigating the issue of intent, of course, is capability-based security. Standard ambient authority models basically leave the door wide open by decontextualizing all action, such that merely riding on someone's session from their end is sufficient.
- digi_owl 11y agoThat finds me thinking that a issue is perhaps that with modern personal computing, the system/kernel view of state (or some such), and the user view of state, are not lined up.