3 ms·
Hmm. Aside from the debate over whether the speed of light was infinite or not, a common side debate throughout history was whether or not light ori
by CamperBob2 11y ago
Hmm.
Aside from the debate over whether the speed of light
was infinite or not, a common side debate throughout
history was whether or not light originated in the eye
itself or from something else. Among the famous
scientists to believe in the “light emitted from the
eye” theory were Ptolemy and Euclid. Most who thought
this theory correct also thought the speed of light must
be infinite, because the instant we open our eyes, we
can see a vast number of stars in the night sky and that
number does not increase the longer we look, unless of
course we were previously looking at a bright light and
our eyes are adjusting to darkness.
I must be missing something. How dumb would someone have to be to think that light comes from peoples' eyes? All you have do to disprove it is ask someone if an object you're both looking at seems dimmer when you close your own eyes.
- pierrec 11y agoYou're not missing anything, but I'd say you're not clearing your mind of all the stuff you already know about light either. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ray_tracing_%28graphics%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ray_tracing_%28graphics%29 It would be essentially ray tracing. "Light", from our eye, travels though stuff and ends up colliding with an object. We are informed of how the ray was affected and how it collided, perhaps because the ray is an extension of our perception (like a limb of sorts), or perhaps because the final collision always causes it to go back exactly the way it came. It's simpler and more obvious than the idea that there exists a truly massive amount of light emitted though various processes in nature, most of it never perceived by any eye, and the minuscule sample caught by our pupil is still large enough to provide us with so much detail. In the absence of further knowledge on the subject you're studying, Occam's razor can easily mislead.
- CamperBob2 11y agoOh, the ray-tracing-as-reality rabbit hole goes a lot deeper than that. Google "potentially visible set" and suddenly quantum mechanics will make a lot more sense. (In a pass-the-bong kind of way, anyway.) But certainly there was no reason for any serious historical thinkers to speculate along such lines.
- morpher 11y agoOr sit in a dark room, unable to see anything. There is more to it. See, e.g., https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emission_theory_(vision) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emission_theory_(vision)
- CamperBob2 11y agoSure, that's why I didn't suggest that sitting in a dark room would be enough to dispel the theory. ("If this were true, then one could see during the night just as well as during the day, so Empedocles postulated an interaction between rays from the eyes and rays from a source such as the sun.") I guess they could have argued that the rays of light returning from each object were perfect specular reflections that traveled directly back to the eyes that emitted them... but wow, that's still pretty hard to fathom, even for people who never heard of Occam's Razor.
- alejohausner 11y agoI like to explain that ray tracing uses exactly this ancient model of vision: rays are cast from an eye point, and are coloured according to the first object they hit ;-)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- marcosdumay 11y agoWell, you are assuming that the light from one person's eye can be seen by other people. How could people know it by then? That was the beginning of the science. People had just started to question everything they knew, and discovered almost all of it was wrong. And good scientists keep assumptions at check anyway, even now that we have so much evidence.