3 ms·
This seems to be a repeated theme [that I'm noticing] at present which to my mind hints at a particular flaw in capitalist society - that we end up paying for t
by pbhjpbhj 11y ago
This seems to be a repeated theme [that I'm noticing] at present which to my mind hints at a particular flaw in capitalist society - that we end up paying for things by proxy.
You want a curated suggestion for what to read but instead of paying for a curator to make those suggestions you pay for a book that poorly hints at the worth that you've received from the curators effort. Or you want a particular piece of software but instead of paying directly [in part] for those who conceive of the software and implement it you pay for a support contract, or [gratis Google software] you pay slightly more for many things the advertising of which in part pays for the software that you use. You want to watch a well written movie, you pay for high-priced drinks and popcorn. Et cetera.
It seems that the value being generated gets removed one or more steps from the point at which the money paid that [poorly] feeds back to the system that you find that thing valuable. To me it seems that we lose a lot of the financial value to third-parties that place themselves at the interstices - the publisher's executives takes a large cut of the book price but did little of value, the 'stars' in the movie take a large cut but any one of hundreds of actors could have done that part, the advertising execs take a large cut but much of the output they direct is antagonistic towards those who are really seeking other things.
Just seems a really weird way to go about improving society.
- ghaff 11y agoYou're basically describing the unbundling problem. People aren't accustomed to (and therefore generally unwilling to) pay for news, travel-related advice, recipes, et al. but they were historically willing to pay for such when they were bundled into a physical publication or where the advice was covered by a commission on some other service (like purchasing airline tickets).
- derefr 11y agoPeople do pay for advice, though. Financial advice in particular has an obvious unbundled market (not just in the form of "your guy at the investment bank", but also in the form of stock analysis, industry reports, etc. Bloomberg terminals are pure "advice", if you want to think of things this way.) Slightly more murkily, though, we've got things like fashion advice, where you pay a "fashion consultant" who works with you to select clothes that work for you. You've also got "personal trainers" who curate your exercise experience. You've even got these things called "doctors" who don't even have any medicine in their offices(!), instead just writing down their recommendations for medicine you should buy on a piece of paper! ;) I think the uniting factor in all those cases where we are willing to pay for advice is that the advice is very "interactive": the fashion consultant looks at how clothes fit on you, the personal trainer watches how well your plan is working out and keeps you motivated, and the doctor does a bunch of tests and schedules appointments at intervals for "long-term outpatient treatment" to make sure your medicine is working, adjust dosages, etc. Meanwhile, it seems weird to imagine paying e.g. Netflix for the output of its recommendation engine, or iTunes for a generated Genius playlist; those are able to be created as batch processes from a bunch of data that already existed, namely your watch/listen history. You might imagine paying for the service that provides that capability (like e.g. Spotify), but not for each piece of advice from it.
- ghaff 11y agoDoctors are a special case in that, for better or worse, you have to go through them to get a lot of medicines. (And IMO by and large that system makes sense.) Outside of Bloomberg terminals which are a relative high-end niche, most individual investors get their research and financial advice bundled with transaction and management fees. I basically agree with your other points. But, relatively speaking, things like fashion advice and personal trainers are very much a niche--and, as you say, based on very interactive service. And pretty much for comparatively high-income individuals like other personal services.
- marincounty 11y ago"Along with pet therapists, and personal shoppers?" Quote from some movie. Forgot movie. The actress Mila Kunnas.
- derefr 11y agoI think you're right, but I don't think in this case there's as much of an impedance-mismatch as in those other cases. While I might say "book gallery", the real description of the place might as well be "curator's service with a storefront serving as street-visible advertising." That the curator happens to have copies of the books they will recommend you is just an obvious extra convenience to throw in, from their perspective; the room for stock in their store is less limited than the room for recommendations in their brain. When e-books are free to pirate, basically all of the price you're paying for the book at a store (or a game on Steam, or a song on iTunes) is in appreciation of the value—including the convenience—of the curation service. If both the buyer and the seller know they're exchanging money for curation, but just both happen to call the trade "selling a book", I don't think it's really a problem. On the other hand, in a modern economy, if you actually do want to transfer value to the creator of a piece of IP, you have to explicitly cut out the middlemen entirely. If you really like e.g. a band and want their career to thrive, you don't buy their album at a store; you buy their album online straight from them (usually this means "via Bandcamp"), and you go to their concerts and buy merch, and you support any adaptations that happen to their work so they'll receive royalty payments. In fact, in my own life, I don't think I experience much "bundling"—I'm always either paying solely for the value of the middleman, with the creator receiving at most a pittance, or I'm paying some outsized amount as a show of appreciation to the creator of a thing. (The one exception I can think of is venue tickets. I want that money to go to the people on stage, but almost all of it goes to the people who built the building and the people who run the website that took my money and generated me a PDF of a barcode. Horrible racket, that.) --- > the 'stars' in the movie take a large cut but any one of hundreds of actors could have done that part Actors are paid based on their "star power"—the ability to pull an audience purely by trading on the interest people have in seeing a movie with that actor in it. Effectively, they're getting their royalties for using their name in all the advertising copy, not for actually acting in the movie. If this wasn't true, you can bet there'd be a thriving industry of "actor impersonators"—typecasting taken to an extreme, where directors could just order up "someone who can be That Guy From That Movie, for this movie", and get 100 entirely-qualified applicants. "People who made themselves look and sound like Tom Hanks" would outnumber the world population of Elvis-es. > the publisher's executives takes a large cut of the book price but did little of value This isn't actually a problem; it's a vestige of the old system where publishers were necessary for typesetting, printing, and distribution logistics. The old generation of authors are staid in their ways and still suffering through working with these antequated beasts, but the new generation have switched to buying the services that publishers provide à la carte, with Kickstarter for the "business loan", a contracted freelance editor, software doing most of the typesetting, Lulu for printing, and Amazon for physical distribution. You might need a publisher to get into bookstores... but—just like we're talking about here—who still shops at bookstores?