7 ms·
Sued Over Old Debt, and Blocked from Suing Back
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- littletimmy 11y agoTL;DR The collections agency can sue you, garnish your bank account without even informing you, and if you want to challenge that, you can only do so in private arbitration and you cannot also be a part of a class-action lawsuit. Despicable. But is anyone surprised anymore? This is a country for the corporations by the corporations. The common folk are just critters to be exploited. Is there a way to incorporate yourself, so that you take a loan not on your person but on your corporate self?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- philipov 11y agoYou're free to set up a corporation provided you can pay the incorporation fee ($100-250), but who's going to loan money to an entity without assets for collateral?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- vijayr 11y agoIs there a way to crowd source this thing? Like, is it possible to build a database of companies and their unethical contract practices? Before signing any contract, a person can simply check this database for any red flags (through a website or an app)? I understand this won't save all cases, but it might help?
- sjg007 11y agosounds like a good idea.
- klunger 11y agoForm an LLC. Not quite a corporation, but accomplishes what you are looking for. http://guides.wsj.com/small-business/starting-a-business/how-to-start-an-llc/ http://guides.wsj.com/small-business/starting-a-business/how...
- jt2190 11y agoThe liability protection of an LLC only covers legitimate business activity. As soon as you've mixed your personal activity with that of the business you've "pierced the [thin] veil" between you and your business, and your personal assets are no longer protected.
- jrs235 11y agoNot only this but most single member LLCs will require personal liability or co-signer [usually from the single member] for any loans or debt. So if the LLC doesn't pay, the single member will have be liable.
- jt2190 11y agoEr, what? The LLC doesn't require personal liability... That would kind of defeat the whole purpose! Perhaps you mean that sometimes those extending loans to single-member LLCs require that the member co-sign the loan? (edit: I'd walk away from that loan, given the issue of piercing the veil I mentioned in my previous post.)
- jrs235 11y agoNo if I were to try to get a loan or credit card (a.k.a. a line of credit) for my LLC (which has basically zero assets), the bank or credit card company would require me, personally [edit: or someone else with assets], to cosign. "Perhaps you mean that sometimes those extending loans to single-member LLCs require that the member co-sign the loan?" Yes. As long of the funds from the loan are used strictly for LLC business purchases and purposes one should be able to keep the corporate veil in place. Even if the LLC defaults on the loan/debt the creditor doesn't need to pierce a corporate veil to go after your personal assets to repay the loan... they have your personal liability signature. Your corporate veil would/should still be in place for any other transactions that the LLC is a party to.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hwstar 11y agoAn imbalance in access to remedies is how you get situations like that armored bulldozer in Colorado smashing buildings, or office shootings. The supreme court justices are too far tilted to the right, hopefully this will change in a decade or two.
- vdaniuk 11y agoAn interesting fact: Marvin Heemeyer, the bulldozer guy, is a hero and a role model for a significant number of people (at least in social networks) in Russia, Ukraine and Belarus.
- pc86 11y agoYour irrelevant SCOTUS comment aside, we need to make sure we're comparing apples to oranges. From the article: > the judge ruled that Encore’s lawsuit to collect the debt was separate from Ms. Thompson’s case accusing the company of violating the law. Disregarding the fact that the original judge should not have awarded a debt that was past SOL, it seems perfectly reasonable to me that Encore taking action to collect a debt it purchased is a separate legal question from a claim that Encore is violating the law. I'm not saying they are related of course, but I have a feeling the arbitration agreement is pretty clear that if you want to sue Encore you have to use arbitration.
- hwstar 11y agoBinding arbitration is an affront on the seventh amendment of the US constitution. If binding arbitration didn't exist, then this party would have had recourse in a real court with a jury, not some privately funded arbitration judge. The reason that corporations like binding arbitration is that it eliminates the jury, and gets rid the option of the jury nullifying the law. Sometimes onerous laws get bought and paid for by corporations, and jury nullification is one of the few tools left to combat this.
- srameshc 11y agoThe question is how would you stay aware of any such debt ? This scares me because I always paid my bills on time and still one fine day got a call for few hundred from collection agency, stating some old outstanding bill from Doctor's office. I was never ever sent any pending bills till I got the call.
- baakss 11y agoPull your credit regularly. Credit score is a huge scam too. Coming out of college I was in the bottom 5th percentile in the nation from random medical debts and such, and within a year I was in the 95th percentile. I spent a lot of time researching and negotiating on the phone to make that happen, but I paid nearly nothing. There are so many tricks that can be used to improve the score that are completely counter intuitive. For instance, you would think it would be a good thing for your credit to pay a delinquent bill? Almost never. It's acknowledgement that you owed the debt to begin with, so it hurts you. In the case of your doctor's office, the best thing to do is NOT pay the debt collector, and then go a different route through the doctor's office instead. Generally you can scare them with a potential HIPAA violation into getting the item removed from your report. Edit: I should clarify, pulling your credit will only help for things that are outstanding and have already been reported as delinquent. The important thing to know is that if you catch it on there, you can negotiate anything. Even if you have to call back many times until you get the 'right' person, you can social hack the process.
- srameshc 11y agoThank you. Your reply is quite informative and an eye opener for me. I would probably have look deep into this credit thing now with urgency.
- toomuchtodo 11y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/personalfinance/wiki/index#wiki_credit https://www.reddit.com/r/personalfinance/wiki/index#wiki_cre...
- pc86 11y ago
- peter303 11y agoI was skeptical about several things in the article. First its hard to sue for past SOL debt- most civil courts recognize this and dont want to be clogged up by it. Second, only four kinds of debt can garnish Social Secuirty: overdue federal taxes, child support, alimony, and student loans. And only for 15% max. Where some people run into trouble if they comingle a SS bank account with other income. A SS-only account is protected by banks.
- jrs235 11y agoHow can the defendant be bound to arbitration if they never signed an agreement or contract with Encore Capital agreeing to such?
- peter303 11y agoWhen you buy or borrow you've clicked or signed an agreement to arbitrate. Its those long documents of legalese on most websites, credit cards applications, etc. Most have successor owner clauses in there.
- pc86 11y agoIt says in the article that Encore's argument is that they buy not just the debt but also the terms and conditions, including the arbitration requirement.
- peter303 11y agoI read a book about the Old Debt Industry called Bad Paper a couple years ago. Its kind of shady employing ex-cons and Payday Loan types. The core document is a spreadsheet listing debtors, SS#, last address, dates, etc. The best you can buy such directly from from lender with mostly recent debt and never worked before. But these spreadsheets trade from dealer to dealer. You dont know if its been worked before and there is any extracted debt left. AnNd they dont have the supporting documents to stand up in a lawsuit. So how do these guys make money then? They locate the debtor and hound them untilr they pay up. It doesnt matter if they are past SOL. Some of these spreadsheets sell for less than a penny on the dollar of debt. So if you can extract three percent, you've doubled your investment. A problem is that debtors tend move around a lot (from not paying their rent), so its hard to locate people, especially with a common surname.
- pc86 11y agoDoes anyone know if it is illegal to pursue a debt that you know to have passed its SOL? I don't mean suing the debtor but for a collections agency to continue calling and writing after the SOL has passed.
- jrs235 11y agoI don't believe it is illegal for a collection agency to try to collect on a debt that is beyond SOL. If you were to not realize the debt was past SOL and made a partial payment the debt would instantly no longer be past SOL. Which is why some agencies will try to get a debtor to pay on debts beyond the SOL. However, if you know that the debt is beyond SOL you may tell the collection agency to stop contacting you. If the collector continues to call you after you send them your letter, they may be violating the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act[1][4] and you may be able to sue the collector for damages[2][3]. [1] http://www.consumerfinance.gov/askcfpb/1405/how-can-i-stop-debt-collectors-contacting-me.html http://www.consumerfinance.gov/askcfpb/1405/how-can-i-stop-d... [2] http://www.fair-debt-collection.com/rules/civil-liability-13.html http://www.fair-debt-collection.com/rules/civil-liability-13... [3] http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/damages-fdcpa-violations.html http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/damages-fdcpa-violati... [4] http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/illegal-debt-collection-practices.html http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/illegal-debt-collecti...
- dredmorbius 11y agoI've been making a somewhat meandering study of political themes and populist reforms of the past few millennia, and am noting some very common patterns. Among them, who makes and judges the law is crucial. From A.H.M. Jones biograpy Augustus, a description of 1st centure B.C.E. Rome's two primary political parties -- a plutonomic obligates, the proletarian populares, and the swing-voting equites, and the fundamental platforms: strong property rights and absolute honoring of debt by the obligates, land reform (democratising the means of production) and grain subsidies (one way to accomplishing what a living wage would provide), and the interests of each in either securing more power for themselves, or of weakening the power of the opposition. Oh, and complete with extrajudicial executions of the unfortunate. It all sound stunningly contemporary. Frighteningly so. <quote> [Gracchus's land distribution bill of 133 B.C.] was the first in a series of violent clashes between two groups who called themselves the optimates and the populares. The nucleus of the optimates was the small clique of nobles … who more or less monopolized the highest offices and dominated the Senate, but they had wide support among the propertied class, even, as Cicero says, propserous freedman; otherwise they could not have maintained their unbroken hold on the higher magistracies. They were conservatives, who regarded the rights of property as sacred, and therefore resisted bitterly any attempts to redistribute land or cancel debt. They were upholders of the constitution and of religion, which could be used to block any revolutionary legislation. Though at times they had to yield to popular pressure, they always remained the government. The populares were a much less well defined group. Their leaders were individual politicians or very small groups of politicians, who at intervals attempted to legislate in the interests of the people, by which they meant the common people.… The populares developed a regular programme of legislation: First came the distribution of smallholdings to landless citizens.… The next … was the provision by the state of corn for the proletariat of Rome at a price that they could afford. From time to time the populares were interested in the problem of debt, which frequently meant agricultural indebtedness. They were early successful in introducing the secret ballot into voting in the assembly, for legislation, elections and trials. They also stood up against the execution of Roman citizens without a lawful trial; the Senate was very prone to ignore this elementary right of the citizen in what it deemed to be political crises. Most populares advocated the grant of citizenship to the Italian allies. They were generally interested in the welfare of the provincials; most of the extortion laws were promoted by populares. Finally, they substituted equites (citizens owning 400,000 sesterces who were not senators) for senators as jurors in the criminal courts. </quote> Compare these with the various demands of the American and French revolutions, the British Chartists, and the revolutions of 1848 (Wikipedia will give you a good overview of each). Title: Augustus. Author: A. H. M. Jones. W. W. Norton & Company, Inc., New York. (c) 1970. SBN 393 04328 2 (The book itself is authoritative and well-researched but exceptionally densely written, to the point of being difficult to parse. There are other biographies, which though longer may well be more accessible.)