16 ms·
Suburban Office Parks Increasingly Obsolete; Businesses Choose Walkable Areas
- totally 11y agoDavid Byrne has a book where he rides a bicycle around cities around the world and makes similar observations. http://www.davidbyrne.com/archive/art/books/bicycle_diaries/ http://www.davidbyrne.com/archive/art/books/bicycle_diaries/
- nirmel 11y agoRelated: https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/the-old-suburban-office-park-is-the-new-american-ghost-town/2015/07/20/b8e7653a-1f6e-11e5-bf41-c23f5d3face1_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/the-old-subur...
- colindean 11y agoI couldn't ever work in an office park. When the startup I worked for was acquired, there was discussion of moving our office to an office park about 30 minutes north or south of the city. More than half of the employees threatened to quit, even though maybe only 25% would have seen a materially longer commute. We like having choice come lunch time and being able to do some shopping before, during, and after work.
- cjensen 11y agoWas the issue that the company was moving to away from SF, or that the company was moving to an Office Park?
- kspaans 11y agoYup, saw the same thing happening at an infosec company in Toronto. Office at University & Adelaide, bought by BigCo AV Vendor, moving out to 404 & Steeles: 20% of workforce quits in the year between the announcement and the actual move (at least I remember it being the move, less so the new owners).
- adoming3 11y agoI agree but other than in major central business districts there's only so many places to house thousands of employees such as Google, Facebook, etc. For that reason, I don't think suburban corporate campuses will entirely disappear. Attracting tenants sub 30K square feet (guessing here) I can see this obviously being a big problem.
- avelis 11y agoIn the case of Google & Facebook, those employers have adapted and built office campuses to provide all the amenities the article suggested to stay competitive in a suburban setting. I do agree with your statement but it is also complementing what the article is also suggesting should happen to office parks.
- ghaff 11y agoThis isn't really a new thing though. The company I worked for in the late 80s/90s had a suburban campus and it had multiple cafeterias as well as other things that matter less today (cleaner, ATM, travel agent, insurance office, etc.). If a company in an isolated suburban office park doesn't provide services needed on a typical day, bad on them. But the basic idea isn't especially new.
- Brakenshire 11y agoI suppose if San Franscisco allowed it, Google and Facebook would build skyscrapers in the same vein as the banks in London around Canary Wharf.
- tim333 11y agoOr buildings like Google is building in London http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2950181/Google-scraps-boring-plans-London-HQ-Internet-giant-s-boss-Larry-Page-orders-architects-design-building-worthy-standing-100-years.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2950181/Google-scrap...
- mmanfrin 11y agoOffice parks just feel like monotony to me; everything is the same, same cafeteria, same surroundings, no chance to do anything other than what is given. I love working in downtown SF -- it's easily commutable, I have hundreds of choices for lunch, I can meet up with a huge number of friends who work at different companies for lunch or drinks or coffee. An office park just feels like the end of the line.
- Xcelerate 11y agoI agree. And similar to suburban business parks, the suburbs feel just as bland and banal to me. I enjoyed growing up in one as a kid (it was a safe little bubble with friends nearby), but now that I'm an adult suburban life seems very uninspiring, with little interesting activity nearby. If I had to live in one nowadays, I would at least want it to be close to a major US city.
- eric_the_read 11y agoDifferent strokes, I guess. I hate commuting into the city; I can't afford to eat out every day; none of my friends work anywhere near me, and the commute takes about three times as long as the office park I'm at right now. An office park that has nice walking paths means I can get in and out relatively quickly and still see my family at the end of the day.
- ghaff 11y agoAesthetically, I'm not a fan of office parks and the one I'm in doesn't have great places to walk unless you count parking lots. Having said that, urban company locations are usually great if you live nearby and can take public transit or easily walk/bike. It's pretty horrible/expensive for large cities if you have to drive and/or take a long commuter rail in.
- thrownaway2424 11y agoSome easy math will demonstrate that many more people live within walking distance of big city office towers than live within the same distance of exurban office parks.
- ghaff 11y agoOne should note that what the article is discussing is things like access to public transportation and in-house cafeterias, not urban locations. Which makes sense. There is certainly some percentage of younger employees who prefer true urban locations but this often won't be economically viable for companies nor is it preferred or perhaps even tolerable for those many people who live outside a city and have to commute in. Furthermore, the data in the US around increased urbanization mostly points to a preference for certain very specific urban locations by an educated young demographic. Having said that, office park locations without convenient lunchtime and other amenities in that vein are a pain.
- Johnny555 11y agoI don't understand why they make office parks so overtly pedestrian unfriendly -- I worked in an office park for a while, there were sidewalks along the front of our building, which ended abruptly just after the driveways. The building next door had the same thing - sidewalks to nowhere that never connected to anything. There was a pretty decent deli in the building behind ours, but rather than having a convenient walkway, there was a fence between the two properties, so reaching it meant taking the long way around 2 parking lots. The building across the street had a downstairs area that used to be another deli/coffee shop, but at one point but when rents went up, the owner couldn't afford rent and closed, but it had been sitting vacant for around 3+ years by the time I worked there. The roads in the office park had relatively narrow lanes with wide 20 foot green medians - I suppose the green grass in the medians looked nice, but the narrow lanes meant that bike riding was pretty dicey, there was not really enough room for cars to pass cyclists, and the 40mph speed limit meant that cars traveled at 45 - 50mph, making biking much more dangerous than it needed to be. They had a shuttle to the nearest train station, but it ran on a fixed schedule that didn't even try to sync up with the train schedule, which led to 20 - 40 minute delays while waiting for the shuttle on the way to work or waiting for the train home. I suspect that the management was either required to run the shuttle or got a grant for it, and only ran it because they had to, not to provide a service to workers. My company moved out of the office park as soon as they had enough money to rent space downtown. It wouldn't take too many changes to make office parks more "livable" - add sidewalks, bike lanes, encourage retail/restaurants with lower rents.
- jonknee 11y ago> I worked in an office park for a while, there were sidewalks along the front of our building, which ended abruptly just after the driveways. The building next door had the same thing - sidewalks to nowhere that never connected to anything. That was almost certainly the legal minimum. I have seen (and walked!) similar sidewalks and it is infuriating. Code says they need a sidewalk, but doesn't say it needs to connect to anything.
- alistairSH 11y agoLoudoun County, VA is full of areas like this. County code mandates sidewalks in new developments, but the developers end them at the edge of their land, leaving gaps. It's ridiculous - it shouldn't be that hard (or expensive, over time) to link communities in a sane manner. Heck, Reston, VA managed to stay reasonably walkable/cycle-able and most of it was planned in the 70s.
- rubiquity 11y agoBut office parks are a great place for breweries!
- robotresearcher 11y agoNot unless well-served by public transit.
- wcummings 11y agoI sorta lose it every time I see a brewery advertise "free parking."
- rubiquity 11y agoOr patronized by adults that know their safe drinking limits? Novel idea, I know.
- robotresearcher 11y agoWhere I live the legal drink driving limit is one beer. I can safely enjoy rather more than that if I take the bus.
- darkstar999 11y agoWe must be thinking of different kind of buildings. I think the article is talking about those multi-story office buildings that a lot of people work in. I see lots of breweries in semi-industrial/semi-commercial areas, single story buildings that have a lot of warehouse space and a small office area.
- sqldba 11y agoUnder the desk? I'm in. Sadly my work has a no alcohol policy; both inside of the office and anywhere else during business hours including lunchtime and even at home during standby. It seems that they want to keep things "standard" whether you're operating a million dollar rig, or sitting in the office :-(
- bbarn 11y agoIn ten years, we'll be seeing the same articles about the sprawling hi-rises in downtown areas, as more industry realizes how much cheaper remote work can be. There are certainly jobs that won't work remotely, but there's not a lot of manufacturing and hands-on work going on in high rises.
- loudmax 11y agoIf we're going to project out into the future, then driverless cars promise to be a game changer. Granted, we're talking twenty or thirty years out rather than ten years. Driverless cars can facilitate more single family detached houses without the sprawling roads and parking lots. With any transformative technology, it's hard to predict how things will work out, but driverless cars could, ironically lead to more walking.
- tim333 11y agoThere doesn't seem much of a trend in that direction. Most city office jobs could be done remotely but there are advantages to being central. You can meet people, go to conferences, chat over coffee and the like. It's kind of ironic in a way - you might have thought being able to work form a laptop would lead to people spreading out but it seems to lead more to people thinking they may as well bring the laptop to a cafe or office in central SF, London, NYC or the like.
- Apocryphon 11y agoTell it to San Jose: http://www.bizjournals.com/sanjose/news/2015/08/20/boston-properties-bulks-up-north-san-jose-biz-park.html http://www.bizjournals.com/sanjose/news/2015/08/20/boston-pr... http://www.macrumors.com/2015/12/14/apple-buys-old-semiconductor-plant-for-18m/ http://www.macrumors.com/2015/12/14/apple-buys-old-semicondu...
- Bud 11y agoI lived in that neighborhood in San Jose for 14 years. It's at least plausibly walkable if they put more businesses around there, and I think that will naturally happen if 10,000 tech workers magically show up.
- city41 11y agoIt boggles my mind how many buildings Apple has. Altogether their office space in Silicon Valley probably approaches the size of Microsoft's Redmond campus, yet they make a mere fraction as many products as MS.
- Johnny555 11y agoApple has around 3.3M square feet of office space now, and their new spaceship HQ will contain around 2.8M sq ft: > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Campus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Campus Microsoft's Redmond campus occupies around 11M sq feet, with another 1.6M sq feet in Bellvue. > http://thinkspace.com/office-space-bellevue-how-much-office-space-does-microsoft-occupy/ http://thinkspace.com/office-space-bellevue-how-much-office-...
- davidw 11y agoInterestingly, a couple of companies I worked for in Italy grew, and moved into office parks that were pretty difficult to reach without a car. Here in Bend, Oregon, I'm now at a company with offices downtown, in easy biking/walking distance from where I live. It's kind of ironic as Italy is, generally, a more walkable place than the US. I'm very happy, though, in any event.
- Brakenshire 11y agoI'm not sure that Europe is actually much better than the US in terms of attitudes towards suburban/car-centric design, I think the reason why we have mostly avoided it is down simply to the historic patterns of development. Certainly in Britain, anywhere outside the major cities, most of the development seems to be extremely suburban - estates of tiny detached houses with tiny private gardens/yards, often just off a roundabout on a main road, tacked on to the edge of an existing town or village, without any idea about creating new public spaces, or walkability. Often these estates are mandated to have only one exit or entrance, in order to discourage crime (this is called 'security by design', and naturally kills any sense of a continuous settlement). This is still going full throttle even now.
- syntheticnature 11y agoI have heard that in Europe, taxation on property is based solely on the area, encouraging upward growth, while in the US the value of what you build on it also factors in. Therefore, in the US, a flat parking lot is not as expensive/wasteful as it would be in Europe. I can't speak to it generally, but it did seem my experiences of European downtown areas did not include private parking lots, but rather more parking garages.
- hippich 11y agoLooking at comments, am I the only one being surprised, when getting email from recruiters with one of the perk "office in downtown"? For me it means - constant fight for parking, lines in restaurants, loud? Granted I live in suburbs (and love it)
- mixmastamyk 11y agoDepends on your temperament, city, and age. I remember working at places like Initech in my twenties and hating it. Unfortunately I didn't know why. Trips to NYC and EU made it more clear. If you are fighting for parking downtown you're doing it wrong. Instead take the train/metro.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- CaptSpify 11y agoAssuming where he works has a train/metro. Especially in the US, this is often unfeasible
- eric_the_read 11y agoLike most things in life, it's a tradeoff. My best drive time to downtown is about 35 minutes. My best travel time by train/metro is about an hour. I did that for about a year and a half, and it wasn't awful, but due to transit times, I barely saw my kids.
- mixmastamyk 11y agoYou have options: move. I was once burdened with traffic on the 405 every day and it was a nightmare. Had to pay an extra hundred or two in rent to live on the west side (of LA). Freeing up three hours a day of commuting (to walk in the sunshine) was definitely worth it.
- hippich 11y ago
- hitekker 11y agoThe last time I worked in an office park I didn't have a car. So walking through the giant parking lots meant that my otherwise thirty minute commute, became 40 minutes. I wasn't happy.
- camikazeg 11y agoI can't help but think that there is opportunity here. It seems like most cities have gone through a cycle where industry moved out of cities, a lot of those parts of town got converted in to very affordable housing, industrial lofts, etc. Then because of the cheap rents, artists and young people flocked to these areas and they became the hip parts of town. Shouldn't office parks be easier to convert than industrial buildings?
- andys627 11y agoThere's lot of regulation slowing this - floor area ratios, density caps, parking minimums, etc. Google "sprawl repair" for some interesting reads!
- ocschwar 11y agoIn the Boston area, there is no more industrial space left for illegal lofts. I fully expect bohemians to start illegal squats in unused office parks in the coming years.
- JabavuAdams 11y agoThat would be amazing! I've always wanted an office building to myself.
- stuart78 11y agoThe total impermanence of so much of our architecture is depressing. While I'm glad people are moving to more walking-friendly locations, this is just more detritus to be demolished or forgotten.
- l1ambda 11y agoJames Kuntsler talks about this very thing--the places we are building he describes as "places not worth caring about." https://www.ted.com/talks/james_howard_kunstler_dissects_suburbia?language=en https://www.ted.com/talks/james_howard_kunstler_dissects_sub...
- timdeneau 11y agoJames Howard Kunstler has some pretty good talks/books about suburban obsolescence. Here’s his TED talk from years ago: https://www.ted.com/talks/james_howard_kunstler_dissects_suburbia https://www.ted.com/talks/james_howard_kunstler_dissects_sub...
- JabavuAdams 11y agoThat was great!
- zinssmeister 11y agoOffice Parks are dying because the way our careers are going has changed. Many people change jobs every 2-3 years rather than dedicate their life at a single Big Employer. Living in the Suburbs and working at an office park is a very inflexible setup. Working in SF and commuting in from Oakland for example will enable you to change jobs more frequently without uprooting your life.
- ghaff 11y ago>Working in SF and commuting in from Oakland for example will enable you to change jobs more frequently without uprooting your life. So, in that example, anywhere outside of SF in the South Bay isn't an option. Beyond highly concentrated cities like Manhattan where there's a huge confluence of jobs in a particular industry, job mobility causes issues in any case (especially once the jobs of partners and kids' schools are involved) in any case. It's rare industries and location where you can generally change jobs without commute being a factor.
- mjevans 11y agozinssmeister is viewing the /approximate/ duration of a commute as a 'sunk cost' (in time) for the worker. If the jobs are all centrally located even insane real-estate and urban development practices that drive the workers out to suburbs can make economic sense once the workers are conditioned to put up with that abuse. They are saying that many, in fact most, 'local' jobs exist with relatively little opportunity cost for change. Contrast this with a hypothetical future of (E.G) New York, where in 30-50 years they've gone full caves of steel: banishing cars to the edge and having a multi-layer dense mesh of rapid electric motor powered transit and living which intermingles living, working, recreational and (deep underground) industrial productivity. There the opportunity costs might also be the same, but the cost (in time) of migrating might be less, and favor walking on moving belts for a combination of speed and exercise.
- lucaspiller 11y agoMaybe this is why the European tech industry has been growing so much recently - most of our cities have great public transport :)
- firebird84 11y agoIn defense of office parks, I did enjoy living in lower rent/property price areas in the suburbs near an office park. Downtown living (where I am now) is expensive as hell. However, my employer has plopped their new office right in the middle of the most expensive real estate, and next door to the "Mecca" (as my real estate agent called it) of expensive condos. Great! So it's either hellish commute or expensive rent. I opted for expensive rent. :-\
- rdl 11y agoMy dream office would be wfh as desired (with a physical-separated-from-my-house shed/outbuilding, ideally), and then a choice of physical offices: a downtown SF/Seattle/NYC/Berlin type place, and some kind of lab facility which is essentially a military base layout (gated, guarded, buildings onsite). Second best: living eastside seattle (i.e. Redmond) or SF Peninsula, and an easy (off-peak, or viable mass transit, so basically off-peak) commute in, with flexible wfh. I generally prefer entire-building-for-company vs. shared spaces, but not necessarily at the scale of the googleplex. However, minimum of 200 sf/person and ideally private offices or shared offices per small team, not open plan hell. Suburban office building would be fine (the old vmware/fb/etc. buildings, or current googleplex/apple/etc.), and would be better than the super crowded cobbled together multiple offices of old Facebook or Palantir in downtown Palo Alto). If suburban office parks in good locations (anywhere north of Mountain View) become substantially cheaper than DTPA or SOMA, I'd be happier with 500 ft/person there for $18-24 vs. 100/ft/person for $60-100. The trick would be having Facebook (or, it appears as is better today, Dropbox) quality catering and other amenities onsite, and a $25-50 pax/day shuttle system.
- brudgers 11y agoIf the development pattern is typical, office buildings near Denver's light rail station are likely to be newer. It is typically significantly more expensive to develop infrastructure among existing high level uses such as an office park. In addition there are typically density incentives for locating near mass transit that attract new development which existing automobile centric development cannot utilize without buying out existing leases, i.e. when the new rail station comes existing parking adjacent to buildings cannot be converted because it is already under lease agreement with existing tenants. To go further, low occupancy rates of offices further from mass transit [and that's not quite the same thing as being walkable] may be a sign of impending redevelopment as leases are not renewed and older properties undergo less maintenance in preparation for redevelopment. Given the 30 year cycle that mortgages, depreciation schedules and institutional real-estate investors often operate on, things may not be as cut and dry as the article makes out. I wouldn't discount recent zero interest rates and the bottom falling out of the economy as factors either. [1] Then again, in the big money long time horizon world of real-estate that's usually the case. Stable internal rates of return are the name of the game. [1]: That transportation infrastructure was a major source of "shovel ready stimulus" projects is less direct but plausibly related to the public investment.
- icanhackit 11y agoThere's a neat trick for making spaces more user friendly, more traversed and more desired: Grids. When a space doesn't intuitively tell you which way is North, what is behind the building in front of you, whether the road to the left or right will continue straight or curve and meander, how to find the main road etc, you create a fairly user-hostile space. Cities and even suburbs (usually inner city suburbs) with grid-like layouts tend to have more foot, bicycle and car traffic whereas most other layouts favor only one of those modes. Grids are easier to intuitively interact with than shotgun-spaghetti layouts, removing the primary barrier to increased usage.
- bane 11y agoOne of the problems that happens is that businesses who choose city centers in cities without good public transport end up excluding more experienced employees with families from working there. Those people will more likely live outside of the city in a house and will need to drive in and park, but parking usually isn't available in necessary quantities in city centers. The solution of course is to build more robust mass transport systems, but that seems to be getting harder and harder.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoOf late I've been thinking about the relationships between offices and productivity. Right at the turn of the century people were thinking about "revenue per employee" as a metric for how efficient a business was. That was silly off the charts when you get to some software startups where a group of 15 or 20 people are generating 20 - 30M$ a year in revenue. The thing that stuck out for me is the cost of offices as a cost of doing business. For years folks have been working to fit more and more people into fewer and fewer square feet because the office expense was a serious impediment to profitability, it added to the "loaded cost" of your employees, and that combined with salary was your biggest cost. But here is the thing, if your employees are generating these huge revenue per employee numbers, what that means is that small percentage changes in their productivity has a huge impact on your company's revenue and profitability. Employers need to look at what would be the impact if your employee was 10% more productive, which means your revenue per employee number went up 10%. How much cost would you be willing invest to make that happen? Even at crazy SF levels of $100/sq ft / year, that is $10,000 for an additional 100 square feet for an engineer. $10,000 represents perhaps a 5% increase in the loaded cost of that employee. But if they boost their productivity by 10% they return 200 - 300% on that investment annually. Bottom line, build environments that maximize the productivity of your employees, not ones that minimize your real estate costs. Its a better investment than hiring more people.
- jarjoura 11y agoI remember as a child thinking 1 Infinite Loop would be a dream place to spend my long working days. When I finally got to work there, it originally was. Plenty of parking and Caffe Mac's was pretty premium lunch for what I was used to. Then the company exploded and parking was a nightmare. (They added a valet to cope with the problem.) To eat lunch required standing in long lines no matter what time you went. San Jose/Cupertino had pretty ridiculous rules about buildings being set back from the highways, so the nearest sushi place required quite a hike across several parking lots and a highway to get to. Also friends that got moved around would be shuffled to remote campuses that seemed so far away with disconnected transportation. Not saying any of this would be better in a denser city like SF, but I am saying there were definitely tradeoffs to working in what was basically just another office park. As traffic in the bay has gotten worse, it makes them seem less appealing for sure unless you're okay with moving every time you get a new job. Right now I work and live in the city, so I just walk to work and it's been a dream come true. When friends leave to other city jobs, its easy to meet back up for lunch and coworkers and I can hop on Muni when want to try a new place for lunch. Not perfect by any means, but right now it's way more of an appealing working environment.
- rwhitman 11y agoOne problem we face right now is that America was built on this "urban" vs "suburban" planning mindset. In the 60's to the 90's the city equated overcrowding and crime, the suburbs equaled privacy and freedom. Today we see things quite a bit differently, but it's still city vs suburbs - you walk, bike to work and see your neighbors regularly - or - live your life in the self-imposed isolation of cars and spaced out tract homes. I wish we could get over this idea that it has to be one way or the other. Cities don't have to be densely stuffed with a grid of monstrous mixed use high rises to be a city. Suburbs don't have to zone stores a million miles from housing to be a suburb. Both places can share development patterns and still give people what they want. There's a middle ground that can be found here, but municipal planners and real estate developers seem to be fixated on these narrow visions of growth. What's wrong with tearing up a few office parking lots to add a few shops and houses? What's wrong with building a few 4 floor walk-up apartment buildings instead of yet another block-sized, doorman-guarded fortress? Hopefully the next century of urban development in America is spent at least partly figuring out how to blend these environments together better.
- omegaworks 11y ago>municipal planners and real estate developers seem to be fixated on these narrow visions of growth. It requires a huge amount of capital to build things that have to last 20+ years. They go with what works. Unfortunately, the revolutionary dreams of urban renewal and theme park millionaires[0] never really got us any closer to our ideal human habitat. 0. http://www.esquire.com/entertainment/news/a35104/walt-disney-epcot-history-city-of-tomorrow/ http://www.esquire.com/entertainment/news/a35104/walt-disney...
- TheCoelacanth 11y agoI think typifying cities as nothing but block-sized high-rises is completely wrong. Even large parts of Manhattan are full of 4-6 story buildings.
- rwhitman 11y agoI guess singling out 4 floor walk-ups as something we need more of kind of muddles the point. The scale of the current crop of new apartment buildings is often measured horizontally.. The trend in development these days, in my neighborhood at least, is for developers to scoop up as large a parcel as they can get their hands on, demolish it and build a very large mixed-use complex. Most of them span at least a quarter of a block. Newly constructed smaller buildings get built only when the lot size doesn't fit much else. Increasing density around transit accessible hub areas is a strategy championed by city planners these days, with somewhat good intentions. I just don't think anyone has really thought through what happens when entire neighborhoods are dominated by massive mixed-use condo buildings. What happens if these areas lose property value? What form does a contemporary condo complex take when blight sets in 20 years from now?
- jmspring 11y agoBetween high school, college, and professional life I've worked in cities, rural areas, suburban wastelands, and urban areas like SF. The majority of the time, most of my colleagues were concerned more with commute than "what's around where I work". SF was a bit different, but parking and commute (late 90s early 2000s) were still top of list. When I worked in SF, my getaway area was Grace Cathedral and the park near by. Uphill, no people, no trash, quiet overall. But some office parks have walkable spaces, places to eat, etc. Some are easier to reach commute-wise than others. Suburban does not rule out walkable. Walnut Creek is completely suburban, but the office complexes there have become (or been developed for) being walkable over the years -- one of the places I reference above was part of this. And honestly, depending on the definition of "walkable" many suburban places are more "walkable" than big cities -- traffic, sidewalks, bums spread on the sidewalk etc. Is the end goal a live/work situation where you don't have to commute a long way, have reasonable rent/mortgage, and a good quality of life? Honestly, pick two of three, if you want to be in the bay area. Born here in South San Jose. Grew up/still live in in San Jose, Sacramento, the east bay, and Santa Cruz. Seen a whole bunch of things.
- ptaipale 11y agoReading the comments here, a major part of the problem seems to be that some people move to suburbs because that is the only way to get their kids to a decent school. Myself, I like living in a suburban area (though here in North Europe it's definitely walkable, and cyclable) but people here don't really choose between city core and suburban lower-density houses because of schools. Some love the city core, others prefer suburban areas. (With the recent immigration and development of urban-but-not-nice satellite cities, there are a few areas that people like to avoid if they can afford it, including for reasons of school, but that's not a problem of city cores). So, it looks like a major step in American urban planning would be to fix failing schools.