4 ms·
But isn't it quite clear to anyone booking a Cessna without a commercial licence that it's different? Shouldn't it be okay for someone to say "yeah I get that y
by lordnacho 11y ago
But isn't it quite clear to anyone booking a Cessna without a commercial licence that it's different? Shouldn't it be okay for someone to say "yeah I get that you're not the same as a real pilot" and sign off on that risk themselves?
- TeMPOraL 11y agoIn theory, maybe. In practice, people will unnecessarily die. People suck at taking risk into account when chosing a service. A service like this will be happy to understate risk and overemphasize the price, and it will force regular airlines and air taxi services to compete with companies that don't have to spend (as much) money on safety. Personally I don't see "minimum safety the market can bear" as a right solution for things that can, and do, kill people.
- brk 11y agoI think there is an element of what a "reasonable" person could be expected to evaluate properly. The majority of the public (at least in the US) of a legal driving age possess a drivers license. Even persons without a drivers license are generally familiar enough with cars/vehicles to make a baseline assumption about the safety of the vehicle and/or driver. I'm not saying you can 100% accurately judge this, but that overall most people can make an informed decision about the risk they are undertaking with a ride-sharing service like Uber. Conversely, most people do not have pilots licenses, familiarity with small aircraft, or an ability to properly judge safe vs. unsafe conditions. Couple that with the fact that you are dealing with a method of travel that succeeds only if it can defy gravity without incident for the duration of the trip, and you have (IMO) a much much higher risk than with something like Uber.
- lmm 11y ago> The majority of the public (at least in the US) of a legal driving age possess a drivers license. Even persons without a drivers license are generally familiar enough with cars/vehicles to make a baseline assumption about the safety of the vehicle and/or driver. I'm not saying you can 100% accurately judge this, but that overall most people can make an informed decision about the risk they are undertaking with a ride-sharing service like Uber. And yet people worry a lot about things that are much less dangerous than driving or getting a lift. I don't know how you're defining "informed", but the decisions people make about driving certainly aren't reasonable or rational in an objective sense.
- untog 11y agoSure. But I don't think the fact that people are prone to making irrational choices means we should open up opportunities for them to make more of those choices, in potentially deadly situations.
- lmm 11y agoIf the licensing for a safer activity is much stricter than the licensing for a more dangerous activity then we're clearly doing something wrong.
- VLM 11y agoThe problem with the drivers license analogy is a startup "uber for bus" for example really would need a CDL with passenger endorsements, not just the standard drivers license. The legal logic explaining taxis not needing state licenses vs bus and transit vans needing CDL with endorsements is strictly vehicle weight based. This is essentially the uber loophole. Although state DOT logic would imply "uber general aviation" would be OK, the FAA has never felt the need to obey state DOT logic, which overall is probably good.
- mcguire 11y agoAs soon as you put a low hours, private pilot into the position of flying in conditions they personally are not ready for or of telling a paying customer 'no', you are on shaky ground. The pilot is already acknowledged to be unskilled at making that decision.
- snowwrestler 11y agoHow would a person with no experience in general aviation be able to evaluate the qualifications, experience, or safety of any given pilot that they just met? Often regulations exist to mitigate information assymmetries. That's why they tend to be so much more permissive for a person to put him- or herself at risk, than to put strangers at risk.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>How would a person with no experience in general aviation be able to evaluate the qualifications, experience, or safety of any given pilot that they just met? Now apply this to almost every contract a person enters into. Especially something big like buying a home.
- gamblor956 11y agoPeople spend quite a bit of time on research when buying a home, and the law mandates a number of disclosures that the seller must make to the buyer about the condition of the house. In other words, not even remotely comparable.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Shouldn't it be okay for someone to say "yeah I get that you're not the same as a real pilot" and sign off on that risk themselves? I think at least part of the regulations is to limit the incentive for less-qualified pilots to fly at all. If pilots without commercial licenses are allowed to fly as de facto commercial pilots, they will have additional incentive to fly, and do more of it. The risks the FAA manages are not just those to paying customers; aviation imposes external risks, as well.