9 ms·
How Being Named the 'Best New Restaurant in America' Hurt My Business
- __m 11y agodamn that must be hard. just like that trump guy who grew up in brooklyn with nothing but his hands, his brain and 1 million dollar.
- pheroden 11y agoIt's almost impossible to open a restaurant for less than 100k, so I don't know what you are going on about. Even if the 50k was free money from daddy, and not a business loan mixed with life savings and a a second mortgage, it's not even in the same realm.
- oldmanjay 11y agoDo you have as much antipathy for the various founders who build businesses with nothing but their hands, brains, and millions in investment from billionaires?
- jdavis703 11y agoStarting a business is really hard, these people experienced just one of a near-infinite and surprising way that new companies fail. The good news is that should they try a new concept that is more community-oriented they'll have more leverage with investors and potential partners since they can clearly show they have potential.
- percept 11y agoAnd they continue to beat up on the guy in the comments: "You represent everything that is wrong with the food industry in Los Angeles." Can you imagine that? Who is he, Stalin? (I'm giving Hitler the day off.)
- zzalpha 11y agoThere's a reason south park riffed on this in the latest season. Everyone thinks their opinion is important because the internet has made it easy for people to broadcast their complaints to the world (and yes, I realize I'm literally doing this right now). Review sites like Yelp exacerbate this by making everyone think they're a damn food critic. Throw in a heavy dose of entitlement and its a recipe for disaster.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- csydas 11y agoWell, it's more than that, I think - it's kind of why you never hear comedians lead off with "Here's a really funny joke", and it's because everyone takes stuff like that as a challenge. I haven't seen the negative reviews, but I read the article declaring Alma best new restaurant, and the article is focused a lot on the humble origins and surprisingly very little on the food. The author talks a bit on how some of the pairings were surprising, but more so because the author wasn't expecting it to be this good. I'd like to see some of the actual negative reviews, but if that's the article that brought people in, it's not hard to imagine how some might take the declaration of "best new restaurant" as a challenge instead of as a claim.
- xivzgrev 11y agoAt the end of the day their opinion does matter and is important. For a restaurant that has 1000 reviews the rating and comments are made up of each of those reviews. It's important to potential customers and hopefully the establishment. If they all say this food is underwhelming then that's a wake up call to owner. Its tough feedback but it's real. At the same time people do have a responsibility not to be a jackass. Don't name call, back up general comments with specifics, don't forget to point out what went well, etc.
- Spooky23 11y agoFoodies flexing their Yelp/Tripadvisor power are a obnoxious bunch. Stalin may be worse than this guy :) The best example of these food nuts gone wild can be found in "Mexican" restaurants all over the country. Once a small cabal of folks decide that a place isn't "authentic" or not, forget about it... They'll be whining about the lack of fish tacos or whatever forever.
- Alex3917 11y agoWhy not just write that on the menu? One of the best (and highest rated) restaurants near me often features a rant at the bottom of the menu from the owner, either about politics or the economics of the business or just complaining about the customers being douchebags. It's a little quirky, but it doesn't seem to hurt business any, and at least helps the customers understand his perspective on things.
- hluska 11y agoYou know, at the risk of heaping on the negativity, I read their Yelp ratings and while some are excellent, others are genuinely a sign of a restaurant in crisis. Consider the gentleman from New Zealand who made reservations via an email to the owner five weeks in advance, spent the afternoon walking around downtown LA to avoid rush hour traffic, and then showed up only to be told that they were closed for a wine tasting. Or, there was the reviewer who got the point of the restaurant, but still found the flavours rather difficult. Or heck, consider the endless comments about how poor the service was. I take a couple of things away from this: - No matter how interesting your product is, you still need to please your customers. - When you're emotionally invested in something, it is tempting to set aside criticism as being gratuitously negative. But, sometimes your critics are your best advisers.
- wdewind 11y agoI don't think that actually speaks against the story, though. The story is: we started small to do our own thing, then a national review blew us up and we couldn't handle the stress in order to scale the business. A lot of the yelp reviews sound like scaling issues, especially since the great reviews are interspersed with the bad: they were capable of delivering great experiences just not consistently.
- nols 11y agoThe second paragraph says "the restaurant was never, ever full." So it seems like they expected to handle more business, and in fact the lack of business shut them down. Maybe they had problems with the growth, but if they were never full then they really shouldn't have. Restaurants with growth problems need to serve food quickly so they can get people in and out to make room for more people, this restaurant apparently never had those problems.
- zappo2938 11y agoIt is so easy to criticize food. This is not different than writing or cinematography. This is the same attack against George Lucas. The Phantom Menance wasn't written for 34 year olds who act like children playing pretend in costumes, its target audience is 7 year olds. And, the movie is about growing up, leaving the protection of the protective mother (although gender roles have changed so now this includes the protective father) and join the adults. There are probably a lot of people on HN in academia who after publishing popular papers or gained some fame find themselves with targets on their back for criticism. Anyone dealing with the pressure of criticism should read a very small book that contains 10 letters written by Rainer Maria Rilke to an aspiring poet who went to the same German military school he went to called Letters to a Young Poet. [1] It starts with: "I cannot discuss your verses; for any attempt at criticism would be foreign to me. Nothing touches a work of art so little as words of criticism: they always result in more or less fortunate misunderstandings." I did cook professionally for 17 years. I understand what this chef feels. However, I have learned to not care about what anybody feels or says about my dishes. I do not cook for other people. I cook for myself, because I enjoy the process, intensity, and experience of cooking and the food I make is what I would want to eat. Most of the time I find what I want to eat is also what other people want to eat and in the cases it is not they can move along to next restaurant because I don't care what they think. [1] http://www.carrothers.com/rilke1.htm http://www.carrothers.com/rilke1.htm
- aaronbrethorst 11y agoThe Phantom Menace is objectively a bad film. You want a good film that teaches this to seven year olds? Try Finding Nemo. The Phantom Menace features offensive racial stereotypes, terrible dialog, A poorly-executed subplot about a trade dispute, and characters that I personally could not and cannot identify with. Is it fair to speculate that you were born in 1992, making you the 7 year old you refer to above? Search your feelings, zappo2938, you know this is a bad movie!
- striking 11y agoIt's also a historic piece of cinematography with a world that feels vast and immersive to its fans. (I'm not one, but I am empathetic enough to imagine how they feel.) Objectively it's not perfect, but every movie means something different to everyone and registers on a different level with each person. So you're free to criticize it and rate it based on how well or poorly it portrays the things you think it stands for. But other people have opinions too. And unless you're a filmmaker worth a damn yourself, your opinion doesn't count for anything.
- Gorbzel 11y agoHN is usually pretty good about calling out founders who blame everyone but themselves for failings. This is exactly that, just in a restaurant context. The problem is that Ari thought that Alma's humble origins mattered to people coming in for a good meal such that they would somehow obscure some pretty big problems with the restaurant. I can't imagine ever excusing a product's flaws simply because the founder had difficulty raising capital, and no other restaurant has these deluded expectations. In this case, the founder didn't listen to his customers — instead, he chose to rest on his MVP laurels and never move beyond. We appreciate that you were able to open the place on $50k, but now that you're more well known, could you possibly stop ripping people off with Eastern European wine that didn't pair with any of your tasting menu? I understand that your approach required an "us vs the world" mentality, but perhaps you could improve service that was spotty bordering on rude. When your customers dislike the tasting menu because it lacks many standout flavors beyond the snacks that initially made you famous, it's advisable to step up your dishes, not simply change to an ala carte menu and start blaming the Yelpers. From what I can tell, he raised his own funds to start Alma. Before that, he was fired from an internship at a James Beard award winning restaurant, worked unpaid at a community garden and few other places until he just up and left. The article notes that he's never appeared on any of the cooking shows or anything, and that he was about to have to start working in someone else's place before the permanent real estate "opened up" in Downtown LA (which makes no sense if you've been to the neighborhood). Point being, it's easy to sound blasé about giving a fuck what other people think of your cooking, but it masks the fact that this guy has never had to answer to anyone about some very obvious flaws in his cooking and business skills. Instead, blame your customers and their "shit talking." Good riddance.
- downandout 11y ago>could you possibly stop ripping people off with Eastern European wine that didn't pair with any of your tasting menu?.....Good riddance Perhaps it's my disdain for wine snobs or anyone else that takes ridiculous things seriously, but I find your comment extremely distasteful - especially the quoted part. Unless he is actively misrepresenting the origin or brand of the wine, he isn't "ripping people off". He simply made a menu choice that you vehemently disagree with. If the negative Yelp reviews are similar to your rant here, he absolutely has a point in blaming the positive articles about the restaurant for bringing in the wrong kind of clientele with outlandish expectations and a penchant for publicly deriding others' lifework.
- kazinator 11y agoPeople assume that you pulled some sort of strings or gamed the "system" to be named "best new restaurant"; they don't know you're an accidental victim of overrating. (If that were the case, some of the negativity would be justified.)
- g8gggu89 11y agoThis is why, despite loving all kinds of different foods, I hesitate to call myself a 'foodie.'
- golergka 11y ago> Who is he, Stalin? (I'm giving Hitler the day off.) On a completely unrelated note, I'm so glad that western public opinion views this guys on the same level of evil. If only russian public opinion was like that.
- percept 11y agoWell I should probably be more respectful, in deference to the worldwide audience here. It's not as if Europeans who settled the American continents hesitated to commit genocide, some even using biological weapons when it suited their purpose (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smallpox#Biological_warfare https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smallpox#Biological_warfare).
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoIt's generally good to be understanding of other cultures, but that doesn't require you to be polite about history's greatest monsters. Stalin and Hitler each directly and personally ordered the deaths of millions, and did so within living memory. That does stand out even from the horrific history of American colonization.
- dang 11y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10767524 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10767524 and marked it off-topic.
- golergka 11y agoIt certainly is off-topic. But I didn't know that off-topic discussion, that goes as off-topic as a polite conversation between real people often can, is discouraged by HN.
- 7wQFnQvA 11y agoI think a lot of the commentators here are missing his point. Namely, that he started Alma because he loved cooking, and that before being named the "Best New Restaurant in America," he enjoyed cooking for other people, but afterwards all the wannabe critics ruined his experience. So negative Yelp reviews aren't helpful if he didn't plan on becoming a world-famous restauranteur, but just wanted to run a small, local restaurant. In other words, in a world where Alma never won this accolade, he, his early customers, and all the negative Yelp reviewers would all have been happier (because they wouldn't have known or cared about Alma being overrated).
- j45 11y agoInteresting that they were remarkable when they opened, but when the mainstream media made it remarkable, it was no longer remarkable to a different set of people who were looking for more than what the space was. This reminds me a little of Clay Shirky's article A Group is it's own worst enemy. Not faulting in the restaurant owners (all businesses have growing pains), it raises thoughts about branding and how much "this is how we do it here" is as much about the holes in the walls at the restaurant as it is the food, and how that story was known and told. Was the restaurant's message about who it was clearly known, before outside reviewers came in and interpreted their story and told their story for them? For me, a restaurant bootstrapped on so little money is remarkable and worthy of support, but it might not be for everyone. Some things aren't meant to appeal to everyone and still be successful. Link to essay: http://www.shirky.com/writings/herecomeseverybody/group_enemy.html http://www.shirky.com/writings/herecomeseverybody/group_enem...
- robbiemitchell 11y agoPublic restaurant reviews are simply not helpful. There are better ways to solve discovery for consumers, and it's uniformly terrible for venues. Enabling private feedback to the GM/owner would be better.
- Mikeb85 11y agoRestaurants are hard enough without being compared to restaurants that opened with $10 million and 50+ staff... $50k means you're a neighborhood restaurant, most dive bars and sandwich shops cost more to open...
- spotman 11y agoThis is one of the most important points in the comments here. In LA opening a restaurant with only 50k is irresponsible mathematically. I say this having taken restaurant management courses with the goal of one day opening one myself. It is true that restaurants are one of the most difficult businesses to start. It takes time to find your groove, and 50k no matter what neighborhood your in is not a lot of time. Most people in this situation would start with a food truck or save more.
- pinkrooftop 11y agoI ate there before it was named best restaurant in America. It was ok a bit pretentious with tasting style food and bare interior. I tried to go back months later with a date and the answering machine said they don't take phone calls during dinner service (but they were only opened for dinner) and just hung up. Went to another place downtown instead and drove by Alma, it was empty
- cushychicken 11y agoAnother possible explanation, as an alternative for all the "failing to scale" scorn shovelers who rushed to post: he started this restaurant, and then had it blow up in popularity before he had the chance to shake out all the bugs.
- Mikeb85 11y agoNot to mention, you can't 'scale' a small restaurant. You have a limited amount of space, and sometimes it's just not possible to progress beyond a certain point. Sometimes a neighborhood restaurant just needs to stay that way, it can't become a 'destination' restaurant because it simply doesn't have the logistics to manage.
- tptacek 11y agoI started Matasano with two partners, both from NYC, one of whom had taken a break from software security to go to culinary school. What I heard from them is that stuff like this is also part of the restaurant culture of different cities. The rap on NYC and LA is that they have competitive, take-down cultures (NYC more so than LA).
- Animats 11y ago"The rap on NYC and LA is that they have competitive, take-down cultures (NYC more so than LA)." That's why they're better in the arts. In NYC, they tell you if you suck. In LA, they don't call you back if you suck. In SF nobody says anything and you can suck forever. Go to little theater or art openings and this is quite obvious.
- tptacek 11y agoNeither Chicago nor San Francisco have takedown restaurant cultures, and both have relatively spectacular restaurant scenes. Some of this gets to what you're looking for from a restaurant. If you're looking at food as an art form, and only want to spend time getting exposure to the very best of it, NYC may indeed be a better filter for you. If what you want is a Great Neighborhood Restaurant, which is perhaps Great in ways that make it distinctive regionally or even nationally, I think Chicago is a better bet than LA.
- istorical 11y agoI think you could almost describe this in the context of only positive-reinforcement cultures vs positive-reinforcement and negative-reinforcement cultures. Both approaches seem to work well in the long-term, but the city which also has negative-reinforcement might have 'failures' more often, which could be seen as a positive from the POV of looking at the health of the whole system, but on the other hand could be seen as needlessly cruel to individuals.
- tptacek 11y ago
- crdb 11y agoSeems like an expensive lawsuit was an issue: June 2015: "If you add another $18,000 a month in legal fees ... we just can't absorb it on our own." October 2015: "We're still working with the other party to wrap up the lawsuit. But to maintain the restaurant at this point it would just continue to put us in a substantial amount of debt. [...] as small business owners, we won't be able to afford a trial, and we really can’t even afford to go through the proceedings leading up to a trail. The realization was that the only way to bring this all to a close is to dissolve the business and move on" http://www.grubstreet.com/2015/10/alma-closing-interview.html http://www.grubstreet.com/2015/10/alma-closing-interview.htm..., http://www.grubstreet.com/2015/06/alma-crowd-funding.html http://www.grubstreet.com/2015/06/alma-crowd-funding.html
- dmatthewson 11y agoThanks, those articles are helpful in understanding the real issues. This next article gives the other side of the story regarding the lawsuit. http://www.buzzfeed.com/arianelange/alma-lawsuit http://www.buzzfeed.com/arianelange/alma-lawsuit http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/sites/default/files/custom/Documents/ESQ/Almacomplaint.pdf http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/sites/default/files/custom/...
- crdb 11y agoThanks for these! Very interesting: "... they offered to set up a payment plan to reimburse the money he had spent on the restaurant." Which goes to show - it's a bad idea to do anything before terms have been put down on paper! It is quite amazing when you first start doing business by yourself (as a contractor, entrepreneur, or even chef it seems) how often people "go back on their word". What happens is that both sides have a different idea of the deal, probably picking on whatever hints were in the conversation to interpret them in the most favorable light possible; and in some cases, it's just a case of one side last-minute-changing the deal because they feel the situation has progressed to give them more leverage. In this case, the disagreement could easily have been avoided if they had typed up a term sheet and preferably some kind of legally enforceable shareholder's agreement BEFORE the payments were made. Now begins the PR battle as both sides will try and influence public opinion to protect their reputation.
- everyone 11y agoRestuarants are a very risky business. I'd lump them in with other entertainment ventures like quitting your job to go write a novel or whatnot. You get to follow your dream but are not likely to be financially secure. Its a pity society works like that, rewarding pointless work (like corporate lawyers, middle manager and HR people (no offence intended)), and seemingly punishing people who pursue their calling. I'm planning to do that myself (to make computer games) but I will arrange it so I dont have to make any money doing it and can still survive (I have almost saved enough money to buy a two bed apartment, I'll rent the 2nd room and live off that + my expenses will be extremely low as I wont have to pay any rent myself as I'll own the place)
- yarou 11y agoHonestly, it just seems like they were a mediocre restaurant. Whether or not Yelp and publicity helped or harmed them is debatable, but that doesn't change the fact that their restaurant wasn't anything spectacular to write home about. There are many instances where a genuinely good product or service receives negative publicity (remember the original iPad anyone?), but is still a genuinely innovative product or service. It just seems like they weren't able to deliver an exceptional restaurant experience.
- pbreit 11y agoI have a tough time ginning up a whole to of sympathy here. Most people in business would kill for such attention. Not being able to figure out what to do with it seems like a comparatively small problem.
- deeteecee 11y agofair enough. good points are made, people are brutally indifferent and you just wanted a kind of "secret" identity for your restaurant. yelp reviews didn't treat you the right way. yet, most of what i read irks me because of its raging, venting way. oh well, its not like i haven't written similar things because of bad experiences. best of luck to this guy.
- logn 11y agoPeople go to restaurants for lots of different reasons. That's what a 5-star rating system doesn't capture. I think simply rating "I am/not likely to eat there again" would be more appropriate. A site could aggregate enough of that data to find users with similar tastes to you. I.e., Yelp should be more like Pandora and less like Rolling Stone. I don't know anything about this particular restaurant but it seems like he's accidentally targeting the wrong audience. Wine pairing menus, fancy plating, an article in Vice, Kickstarter... none of these things strike me as targeting his desired customer, which is someone with modest expectations and expecting just dinner, not an event to review.
- ajmurmann 11y agoThis actually is a huge pet peeve of mine. It's most obvious with extendingl extremely specific needs like vegetarians for example. It drives me nuts when I read yelp reviews that rate a restaurant low because they don't offer good vegetarian alternatives. It is obviously an issue, but it should be trivial for yelp to exclude that recite from the rating that they show to non-vegetarians. Less obvious examples that are a related but different issues are reviews by people who clearly don't know what they are talking about. Looking at reviews of high end Spanish restaurants in the Basque country, I really don't care about reviews that start out with "This was my first visit to a restaurant with a Michelin star...". I'm not trying to be snobby, but I'd much rather have the review by someone who had been to a ton of then in the same area weighed much higher. Edit: I wonder if there is a great opportunity for some disruption here. Well be tough do to overcome yelps moat. I would love to work on this!
- jondubois 11y agoWhen you get that much media attention and you still fail, there are no excuses. It means mistakes were made and expectations were not met. I don't think it's the media attention which killed the restaurant. Getting people's attention requires luck, keeping people's attention requires skill.
- cant_kant 11y ago"A year ago, a former friend and advisor who sought to partner with our business sued us. The charges alleged in the suit are serious, including fraud and unjust enrichment. For the past year, Alma has been hit hard with legal fees required to manage and defend the business against this suit." https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/save-alma-restaurant#/ https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/save-alma-restaurant#/
- somberi 11y agoFrom a recent article in Vanity Fair about how some chefs are surrendering their Michelin stars, as they pigeonhole the chefs. http://www.vanityfair.com/culture/2015/09/top-chefs-michelin-stars http://www.vanityfair.com/culture/2015/09/top-chefs-michelin... I do feel bad that they had to shutdown, but I suspect the same thing that hurt them (the accolades) also helped them to land a gig in The Standard. I consider this a success for a young chef, even if it arrived via a perceived failure.
- gonyea 11y agoHere's a great rule of thumb: don't write bad reviews. If a place sucked, oh well. People have bad days. Stop acting like a wannabe gourmet and shitting all over people. I'll only consider a bad review if you give me food poisoning. Cooking your food thoroughly isn't hard. ... Or if your service personally lost me real money. Then it's a legit "beware."
- belleandsebasti 11y ago"Exposure killed my restaurant so I'm writing about it to get exposure for my new restaurant."