10 ms·
Fairphone 2: world's first modular phone goes on sale
- djsumdog 11y agoIt's about time. There's almost no difference between the Sony Z1c and Z1c except the Z1c is made of metal instead of plastic and is actually a better phone. Why are we replacing our every two years when phones from 2012 should still be able to do most of what we need to? Why are some of our newer phones built worse?! The only thing I'm afraid of is this company won't survive because, after initial purchases, there'll be no reason to buy new phones. They'd need to grow horizontally, pulling in more customers from other brands. They'd also have to push upgrades for cameras, screens, etc to keep existing users buying new parts. Even with an amazing device like this conceptually, capitalism and consumerism will find ways to rear their ugly heads to make this business with a superior product fight for survival while those companies with less durable/upgradeable hardware will tend to make more money because they can always push the latest device to the market.
- detaro 11y agoI don't think the current version of the Fairphone will offer much in terms of upgradeability, unless they get really lucky with the technical evolution (it's going to be pretty hit-or-miss if newer parts are actually compatible enough to be made into exchangeable modules for older phones) It's IMHO more important for repairs.
- gsnedders 11y ago> There's almost no difference between the Sony Z1c and Z1c I wouldn't expect there to be. :)
- djsumdog 11y agoOops Z3C vs Z1C :)
- lovelearning 11y agoURL: https://www.fairphone.com/phone/ https://www.fairphone.com/phone/
- limaoscarjuliet 11y agoIf I can use PC ecosystem as an analog, in grand scheme of things this will offer no price reduction to end consumer. Me and my son just upgraded his PC. It was a 4 yr old PC. We wanted new graphics card and we had to replace entire PC except power supply (barely!) and the case. Even more fun, we wanted to build a PC from the leftover parts for friend of my son who is less fortunate. OK not top of the shelf, but he can play some games. We ended up spending $150 for new power supply, overpriced memory (DDR2), thermal grease, new fan (plastic leg broke off the original) and set of screws (where are they when you need them?). In the end, upgrade = new PC, setting up the old one was still super expensive ($150). Another factor is: these phones get a beating in daily use. While it may still make sense (technically) to keep some components during upgrade, they will be in bad bad shape. It may make sense in context of repairs. Just like a car: I will fix it buying parts as needed, but after N years and M miles I will replace it.
- witty_username 11y agoI'm in India and I purchased a ~50$ 350W power supply (Corsair is the brand) for my computer. (my total PC price is 150$ and it can play older 3D games at medium settings)
- gnufied 11y agoI dunno how are your sourcing those parts: http://pcpartpicker.com/p/wwhHP6 http://pcpartpicker.com/p/wwhHP6 But you seem to be picking very overpriced components. Also You are bit of outlier if your motherboard supports only DDR2 RAM. DDR3 has been in market for like 10 years and it is pretty cheap.
- kayoone 11y ago150$ for the parts he listed is not very expensive if he needs DDR2 which is unfortunate because it is too old and hard to get. But, i had a Q9550 QuadCore in 2009 that used DDR2 too which was quite common just 6 years ago.
- listic 11y agoI don't think price reduction was among the primary goals of this project. Still, would you prefer to not have an option to disassemble the PC and replace it piecemeal? I know I wouldn't: more options is good. Also, in theory modularity creates possibilities for users to create uncommon configurations that would not otherwise be manufactured or cost impractically much (because of their rarity); it is not the case for Fairphone, but is the case for the PC and should be the case for Project Ara. E.g. I have been modifying my PCs for low noise the way that should be outrageously expensive to buy serially. With Project Ara I should be able to assemble a high-end phone without the camera; a phone that goes all-out on battery life at all costs, etc. Fairphone has a noble goal to develop a smartphone with minimal harm to people and the planet, not necessarily a cheap or modular one: it is repairable (called modular here) only as a means to extend it useful life and thus reduce harm to the planet, even at the users' expense.
- chinathrow 11y agoThe cost breakdown is astonishing. Close to 40 EUR or 10% of the average net sales price goes away for IP roalties. http://fairphone.com/costbreakdown/ http://fairphone.com/costbreakdown/ I would love to see which IP holders receive what portion for their IP.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y agoThat seems very low. I wonder if they classify some costs i would expect there into a different category.
- mschuster91 11y agoMost likely the usual suspects: MPEG LA (for hardware video decoding), Microsoft (FAT patents), Google Play license, reference designs for the hardware, WiFi/BT/GSM licenses and patents, ARM and others for the CPU design.
- javajosh 11y agoI find it astonishing that you find it astonishing that we live in a society that expects people to pay for IP. Perhaps you are one of those that think that want to end IP entirely?
- GFischer 11y agoSpecs look good, and the value proposition is interesting, as many articles state, it's about time a manufacturer did something different. My wishlist for this kind of phones: - OS support and updates beyond the standard 1 or 2 years (TBD, but I think they're aiming for a 3 year lifecycle) - upgradable RAM, check :) - upgradable internal memory, check :) - replaceable battery, check :) - glass fixable separately, nope (they do say it's much more sturdy than standard phones though) - alternative OSs, check :) things that don't influence my buying decision that much - fairly traded materials (their original value proposition, which DID appeal a lot to the early backers :) ) Their success depends on appeal beyond their initial core backers, and whether someone comes up with cool or killer app modules :) (they mention some like solar cells, etc.)
- al2o3cr 11y agoFrom what I've read "upgradable RAM" is really more like "upgradable RAM if somebody designs, builds, and gets through certification a module with an upgraded SoC" which really isn't the same thing...
- rloc 11y agoI love the value prop. For the OS support, they cannot commit fully as they work with partners. For the Fairphone 1 (released end 2013) they were able to secure licenses to get the source code and are working hard on making it live for as long as they can even if that means replacing Android: https://www.fairphone.com/2015/09/16/long-term-software-support-fairphone-1/ https://www.fairphone.com/2015/09/16/long-term-software-supp... It's worth noting that they released the "Stagefright" fix very quickly.
- rzwitserloot 11y agoUnfortunately this ships with an already outdated version of android and fairphone has explicitly said they will not guarantee support for Marshmallow. They have solid reasons for this, but that is a pretty big down side as a potential customer. In fact, I'll go so far as to say: If the android OS cannot be kept updated, claiming that this phone has what it takes to last you more than 2 years is ridiculous. Even if you somehow get to keep security updates coming, there will be features in the new OS that are worth upgrading for even if the hardware is still perfectly fine, and apps will begin requiring an OS version you don't have.
- unusximmortalis 11y agoI am looking forward for the similar idea for cars to be realised.
- tbarbugli 11y agogood news, it's already like this. you can buy parts and replace them yourself :O
- unusximmortalis 11y agoyou don't get it...
- voltagex_ 11y agoLooks like about the same price as a Nexus 5X in Australia, excluding shipping. Wouldn't it be more environmentally friendly to keep my current phone or to buy a second hand one?
- nairboon 11y agoGood question, keeping is probably more environmentally friendly. I'm not sure about the second hand market. As by buying one there, you'd give the previous owner some capital and him selling in the first place, could indicate that this capital will be used for a new phone. So what's the chance that the former owner will buy a fairphone? If it's lower than yours, you'd better buy a fairphone yourself. (in terms of environmental impact)
- avtar 11y agoThe order page states "Designed for use and service in Europe only". Hang on to the Nexus 5 :)
- voltagex_ 11y agoI'm fairly sure the bootloader fuse will still be blown on this as it's a retail Qualcomm board - no bootloader upgrades for you.
- justin66 11y ago> the bootloader fuse will still be blown on this What does that mean?
- joenathan 11y agoPractically nothing in this case. In the case of a phone like the S6, Samsung detects if the fuse is blown, indicating modification by the user, and will disable certain features, fingerprint reader, Samsung Pay, etc..
- voltagex_ 11y agoMaybe I've got it wrong in my head, I thought it disallowed modification of the stage 1 loader (in the case of the Nexus 4 and 5, it's LK)
- voltagex_ 11y agoThis phone is too expensive for me right now but this is utterly excellent: http://shop.fairphone.com/catalog/category/view/id/10 http://shop.fairphone.com/catalog/category/view/id/10
- moonbug 11y agoAssuming those are all the parts one needs to construct a full phone, you save around 50% of the list of the assembled unit by building it yourself.
- usrusr 11y agoThat list are the parts of the FP-1, which is an entirely different phone than the recently unveiled second generation. And a much cheaper one, even when it was new, so there is definitely no hidden self-assemble bargain. But things certainly do look good for repair!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- heavenlyhash 11y agoI'm eagerly awaiting the market's return to phones that you can actually fit in your human-sized hands. Bigger is not always better. I recently bought a phone that's so large it takes both hands to operate it. If I'm grasping it reasonably tightly, my thumb can't navigate to over 30% of the screen. If I stretch uncomfortably to try to reach those areas, the phone is likely to slip out of my fingertips entirely. I do not have small hands. I'm not sure what the market standard definition of "phablet" is, but for me, a 136mm x 68mm device has served me fine for years, and this new device (which I'm returning after almost accidentally throwing it across the train for the n'th time in as many days) is 148mm x 76mm. Apparently that extra ten millimeters is a big deal. (Interesting to look at Apple's product page for their sizes. They measured this too, evidentially -- the 6 and 6s went up to exactly 138x67 and aren't budging; they use the Plus series to probe over that line.) The fairphone2 is 143x73 -- it's not as big as some other flagships on the market right now, so huge kudos for winning the miniaturization battles so far -- but I bet they're falling prey to competing on screen size, and frustratingly, though I'm interested in everything else about this phone, I'm honestly not sure I'll be able to hold it in my hand.
- engi_nerd 11y agoAnd as someone with freakishly large hands, I welcome large phones. There are still small phones out there for you. There are large phones out there for me. I am not sure that I see a problem.
- abrowne 11y agoThere aren't really many decent small phones. I have a first-gen Moto E, and it's about as big I as I'd like, but the new versions are larger. Same with the Moto X. The best current options seem to be the Sony Xperia Zx Compact series. Everything else small is also very low-end, with bad screens, too-small storage and old software.
- cannam 11y agoThere really aren't small phones out there. I use a Nokia Lumia 620, a slow, 3-year-old phone with a 3.8" screen. Twice now I've dedicated a week to using only a larger phone (4.5-4.7", so not big by today's standards) and both times at the end of the week I've given up and gone back to the 620. The two most common things I do with a phone are (a) use it on a train platform or strap-hanging on a train, one-handed, and (b) leave it in a jeans pocket and ignore it. Even an iPhone 5 is really a bit too big to be a happy device to use like that. (Previously I had a Nokia 700, with a 3.2" screen. That was fantastic, best phone hardware I've ever used, but it ran Symbian and eventually became too poorly-supported to stick with) What I'd really like to see is a phone of the same size and shape as a 3rd gen iPod touch -- so like a thin version of an iPhone 3G. Maybe one day the market will swing back that way, and hopefully when it does, it'll be with a bit more choice so we can have big or small, rather than producing a hundred-and-fifty examples of devices all basically the same size.
- jkot 11y agoApple is absolute nightmare, but most other makers have pretty serviceable products. Checkout youtube videos for Samsung or Lenovo phones. In amateur conditions it takes about 10 minutes to replace "build-in" battery. Or 30 minutes to replace broken glass or motherboard.
- cbeach 11y agoThat's a bogus argument. Any flagship phone from Samsung or Lenovo will make the same tradeoffs that Apple does between thinness/weight and user-servicability. In any case, you suggest Samsung/Lenovo phones take 10 minutes for a battery replacement. The iPhone 6 takes just four minutes: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UgmtNJuqEHI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UgmtNJuqEHI
- nickpsecurity 11y ago"The iPhone 6 takes just four minutes" Jesus, it's gotten that bad...?
- Fradow 11y agoI like the idea. The execution, on the other hand, not so much (especially compared to Ara project, from the pictures seen so far). From the animation on FairPhone site, I counted 17 screws and 6 standoff. How many people, who would not even try to repair their phone will find this easy enough to start repairing their phone? For comparison sake, there are 10 screws on a Nexus 5 (according iFixit teardown). Sure, the Nexus 5 (or other smartphone) will be a little harder to repair. But the difference is far from huge, and won't make someone take a FairPhone over another "good enough" smartphone, repairability-wise. The upgrade ability? Sure, it might be nice. But, as the PC market as demonstrated (which has a lot less contraints, too), you can only go so far, until you need to replace the whole thing. Since it's not a well-established project, it's not even a sure-bet you'll still find parts at an affordable price in a few years time. And at that price point, it's not a given that FairPhone + upgrades in a few years costs less than one similar phone now, and a similar to the upgraded in a few years. That leaves social impact and openness principles. That might appeal to part of the geeky crowd (the ones that buys Librem), and social-aware persons, if they are not turned off by the price. Let's see if it's enough to sustain a smartphone line. In the current saturated market, I have some doubts.
- zlatan_todoric 11y ago>From the animation on FairPhone site, I counted 17 screws and 6 standoff. How many people, who would not even try to repair their phone will find this easy enough to start repairing their phone? So we developed into society where 17 screws is such a major problem to deal with it... Also people who wouldn't not even try to repair their phone will not try even if there is no screw. In my opinion such phone should appeal to what you call geeky crowd and from there it should initiate some social change (probably via media such as Internet) where changing 17 screws will not be difficult task but highly rewarding in terms of being human and hardware/cost wise. After that it should spread to people and with it the hardware becomes industrial standard (parts at least) so the price of changing goes down both in cost and finding them.
- rsync 11y agoI've been browsing their (extremely heavy, intensive) website trying to figure out "what are the modules" ... and all I can see is that there is a removable battery and that I could replace/repair parts like camera and speaker and so on. But it looks to me that all of the actual functions of the phone are integrated into one big SoC. That misses the entire point of a modular computing device - phone or otherwise. I want a wireless comms module (which contains not just the wifi/bt/cellular antennas, but the chipset itself) that I can remove or hard disable with a switch. I want an inputs module that contains not just the mic and speaker, but their enabling circuitry so I can remove it or hard disable it with a switch. I want a GPS module ... a USB ports module ... a camera module. That's what a modular smartphone is all about. There's nothing modular about a big monster (closed, telco-owned, user-hostile) SoC that contains all of the actual functions.
- jansc 11y agoI disagree (Disclaimer: I'm one of the early backers). The current trend in mobile phones is towards more closed systems. Components are glued together, and often it's not often possible for a user to even change a battery. That's what I would call a big monster. The Fairphone is the first phone to get a 10/10 repairability score from ifixit. Though there could be more components, it's definitely a step in the right direction. The whole point is to a able to use that phone for 4-5 years. If one part breaks (touchscreen, battery), you can replace that part yourself. If a better camera becomes available, I can choose to update just the camera instead of buying a new phone. Cheaper for me as a user and better for the environment.
- Swizec 11y agoAll my iPhones have lasted 4-5 years. Granted I had to get the screen replaced on one of them after my bird dropped it off the counter. Wtf are you people doing with your phones? I downright abuse mine (think longboarding falls at 50kph with phone flying out of pocket) and it survives all.
- jansc 11y agoSeems like you're a lucky guy. My current iPhone 4s is falling apart. One of the speakers doesn't work, battery lasts only half a day, and the power off button is broken. And I guess there won't be any software updates after the current iOS release.
- frik 11y agoIt's a first good step. What I want is freedom of PC hardware of the 1990s in a smaller form factor. A smartphone consists of a system-on-chip (SoC) computer, memory chip, modem, display, cameras, antennas, sensors, card slots, battery - all could be modular. And be of a convinient form factor so that several companies offer such parts. Android took the omnipresence role of Windows 95 on smartphones and tablets (though Android device driver are hard to find). Back in 2006 I had a modular notebook built by an OEM sold under different brands. (picture: http://p-fst1.pixstatic.com/51b62f6dfb04d67b66000b29._w.540_s.fit_.JPEG http://p-fst1.pixstatic.com/51b62f6dfb04d67b66000b29._w.540_... ) What a great hardware platform. In 2016 the notebook market is in a bad shape - business notebooks: lower build quality (no Thinkpad robustness), higher prices and no modular notebook platform. And on PC the trusted computing (UEFI, GPT, Palladium) accelerated by Microsoft is hostile to non-Windows 8+ operating systems. Hopefully, the EFF can do something there.
- watchdogtimer 11y agoHave you considered the pi-top (http://www.pi-top.com http://www.pi-top.com)? It sounds like it has many of the features you are looking for.
- l1feh4ck 11y agoActual phone cost 12K. Repairing cost 13K (INR) I would like to share a terrible experience which I had with Micromax. I got a brand new phone Micromax Canvas A350 (2GB ram, Octa core processor) as a gift. After a week of use I accidentally dropped the phone and broke the screen. I took it to Micromax service center and they asked me for 6K to change the screen. Since the warranty does not cover these type of damages. A local repairing shop fixed the screen for 2K but now the warranty is violated. After a month of use power button failed and GSM signal receiving is too weak. I opened to phone to see that the antina wire was broken. (which connected GSM module to the mother board) I took the phone to Micromax customer care they gave me a list of things to replace: Whole case + GSM module. Total cost : 7K + 6K = 13K. Only things broken was a power button and a simple wire which will not even cost 10 INR. The cost of a new phone is only 12K
- ymse 11y ago10K Indian Rupee (INR) ~ USD $150.
- drewm1980 11y agoIf we really want to get serious about keeping our phones for more than a few years, we need to solve the problem of software bloat. I would love to see an open ecosystem with some sort of distributed benchmark so apps are strongly incentivized to be implemented efficiently. Which of the 1,000 egg timer apps should you pick? The one that doesn't run out your battery before the egg is cooked! But how on earth do you even know which one that is in the current ecosystem?
- vostrocity 11y agoOn iOS, I find that it's mostly the OS that becomes unusable. However, that's an interesting idea.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hackuser 11y agoI think the 'fair trade' aspects are important and should be universal. I'd also like to see equal concern for 'fair trade' for consumers, who shouldn't have to accept being spied upon. I've spent months trying to find a reasonably simple way to have a smartphone where I have end-user control over my data and communications, and it seems impossible (without building my own phone or OS). I know many people don't care; that's fine for them, but I should have the option.
- Animats 11y agoIf the goal is reliability, modularity may not be the right way to get there. Why not just build something tough enough that it doesn't break? There are militarized rugged smartphones.[2] You will break before they do.[3] If you bend the frame on your modular repairable smartphone, you can't fix it anyway. If the goal is upgradability, you don't just need modularity. You need a whole ecosystem building components to some standard. The Fairphone doesn't have that. Google, in 2014, was talking about an upgradable modular phone held together by magnets. It didn't work very well; if dropped, it fell apart.[4] IFixit likes it if you can unscrew and replace every part. This does help maintainability. But do you want to go there? Here's the extreme case of that - a Model 15 Teletype. Every small part, of about 2000 of them, is replaceable. Here's repairing a damaged Model 15 from a dumpster, something I did last year.[1] Just because you can doesn't mean it's an effective use of time. Phones should Just Work. Make them indestructible, not field-modifiable. [1] http://brassgoggles.co.uk/forum/index.php/topic,43672.0.html http://brassgoggles.co.uk/forum/index.php/topic,43672.0.html [2] http://www.catphones.com http://www.catphones.com [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mVPku-xItv8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mVPku-xItv8 [4] http://www.techtimes.com/articles/77985/20150819/googles-project-ara-phone-falls-apart-when-dropped-release-pushed.htm http://www.techtimes.com/articles/77985/20150819/googles-pro...