3 ms·
Then threaten him with legal action (not that I necessarily condone this - I will say that I did like your breakdown down thread to providing another perspectiv
by FireBeyond 11y ago
Then threaten him with legal action (not that I necessarily condone this - I will say that I did like your breakdown down thread to providing another perspective and balance).
It's neither harassment or slander, but it could be tortious business interference, where one party induces a second party to break a contract with a third party.
His contract employers are neither his parents or legal guardians - who have no more power to "ensure" this as anyone else.
As a corollary to this - this is exactly why it's illegal for debt collectors to call your friends and family to "encourage" them, or you by humiliation, to pay up.
- tptacek 11y agoDo you see what a ridiculous no-win situation this is? Option 1: Call the pentest firm he works for. Option 2: Threaten legal action. Option 3: This dude might still be walking around with god knows what shit he's pulled out of S3 buckets or lord knows what else was accessible with those AWS keys or what other keys were in other S3 buckets or wow i'm having a small panic attack just trying to complete that sentence
- three14 11y agoHow about Option 4: calling him?
- tptacek 11y agoI don't know whether they tried, or if they didn't, why they didn't. Like I wrote below[1], I'm wondering what the rest of the story is. This isn't the first person to have submitted an RCE to Facebook, but it's the first person to get Facebook to go nuclear over a submission. Why? [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10754627 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10754627
- Dylan16807 11y agoWhere is option "change the keys that were publicly accessible for who knows how long"?
- tptacek 11y agoThis isn't a single key. It's, like, maybe all the keys? The bad stuff that happened here all happened in a single day, the day that the researcher disclosed the AWS creds for the first time, more than a month after the server he dumped them from was shut down.
- Dylan16807 11y agoI would act as if an unknown malicious party had all the keys at that point. It might not be true, but it might be true.
- tptacek 11y agoOh I 1000% agree about that.