5 ms·
This is an incredibly sensationalist and politically-motivated title. It should really read "Automobiles now immensely safer in the US". As the article's own gr
by ocdtrekkie 11y ago
This is an incredibly sensationalist and politically-motivated title. It should really read "Automobiles now immensely safer in the US". As the article's own graph shows, gun violence hasn't really changed much in the last decade and a half, but cars have gotten a lot safer!
- refurb 11y agoGood point. It looks like gun violence is down ~30% since the mid 1990's. Also, how do they define "gun violence"? Does that include accidental shootings? Suicides? From what I remember, suicides account for almost half of all deaths due to guns.
- Retric 11y agoLet's drop things down and say there is only ~500 deaths due to accidental discharge of a firearm per year in the US. That seems reason enough to discourage gun ownership.
- mbeattie 11y agoLets drop things down and say there is only ~500* deaths due to accidental drowning per year in the US. That seems reason enough to discourage pool ownership. *=http://www.cdc.gov/HomeandRecreationalSafety/Water-Safety/waterinjuries-factsheet.html http://www.cdc.gov/HomeandRecreationalSafety/Water-Safety/wa... There are closer to 3,500 accidental drownings per year.
- Retric 11y agoYour joking, but I actually agree with this. I also almost drowned at my parents pool while really young (under 3). Note, discourage != prohibit. Regular PSA's about the dangers of pool ownership higher taxes, and or required fencing could all save lives.
- rbcgerard 11y agoBy that logic we should get rid of swimming pools...http://www.poolsafely.gov/drowning-deaths-injuries/ http://www.poolsafely.gov/drowning-deaths-injuries/ Probably ladders as well...
- Retric 11y agoDon't put words in my mouth, discourage != get rid. Mandating they all be panted in iridescent reflective coatings would discourage ownership, but not actual use. PS: Ladders are covered in safety warnings (which may be ridiculous). Guns, not so much.
- Zancarius 11y agoDon't forget buckets! Those have resulted in more than a few drowning deaths over the years. You've reminded me: The CPSC introduced stop-sale regulation on magnets (remember Buckyballs?) for even fewer deaths than that, and where most of the non-fatal injuries were the result of poor decisions by adolescents. Worse, in my opinion, the relatively small number of deaths that occurred were almost all traceable to irresponsible adults leaving magnets in places where toddlers could pick them up and swallow them. That's still a sore point for me.
- thoth 11y ago>From what I remember, suicides account for almost half of all deaths due to guns. The article says "Today, suicides account for roughly two out of every three gun deaths."
- blang 11y agoAccording to the article it includes accidents, homicides and suicides. I have also heard a figure of 50-70% of all gun deaths are suicides. The argument of the article is that consistent government regulation has helped curve motor vehicle deaths downwards and that consistent gun regulation might be able to do the same.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ocdtrekkie 11y ago"Due to guns?" Do guns make people suicidal?
- Retric 11y agoIt lowers the bar before people succeed. Take some pills and many back out, pull a trigger and your generally out of options.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoEven if you take that to be true (I gather there's plenty of ways to quickly off yourself at any given hardware store), does that make the guns "responsible" for those deaths? Are those deaths "due" to guns? Or are we using our political biases to slant something to meet our agenda, like this article, which shows gun violence isn't really increasing at all.
- SteveLAnderson 11y agoExactly. When Australia changed their gun laws, the suicide rate went down by 65%.
- refurb 11y agoYet Japan has one of the highest suicide rates and almost no gun ownership! Also, prior to enacting gun control, Australia's non-firearm suicide rate doubled (1980-1996) while firearm suicide was cut in half. Not sure there is any correlation.
- SteveLAnderson 11y agoYou may not be sure, but the researchers that study this subject are sure - http://andrewleigh.org/pdf/GunBuyback_Panel.pdf http://andrewleigh.org/pdf/GunBuyback_Panel.pdf And for the US - http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/crime/2013/12/gun_ownership_causes_higher_suicide_rates_study_shows.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/crime/2013/1...
- seivan 11y agoI've noticed "liberals" (regressive left) label the recent Muslim terrorist attack on US soil as a "mass shooting" to hitch on it. Seems like a pattern to paint anything they can get their hands on as a token for guns.
- mtberatwork 11y ago> It should really read "Automobiles now immensely safer in the US". That isn't the main topic of the article though. From the opening sentence: "For the first time in more than 60 years, firearms and automobiles are killing Americans at an identical rate". The headline simply points out the article's main data point of automobile and gun deaths converging.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoThe article's headline and banner strongly promote this concept that guns are an increasing problem. While the title and opening sentence aren't false, they ARE misleading.
- mtberatwork 11y agoThat's purely subjective.
- caseysoftware 11y agoThis is really a thinly veiled attack on the "then we should outlaw cars!" argument. This lays out the case for "reasonable" safeguards and limitations that should be put in place for guns because "reasonable" rules have made cars so much safer. While that may be the claim, the NYT blew their cover with the front page editorial last week where they openly admitted to wanting all guns out of everyone's hands, regardless of the legality. What we understand now is that the "reasonable" laws are the wedge to start going for more and eventual outlawing. The problem is that "gun control advocates" claim that people shouldn't own guns really mean that civilians shouldn't own them. They're still okay with government having guns. Because "tyranny will never come to America..."
- delecti 11y ago> Because "tyranny will never come to America..." If I'm not mistaken, the implication here is that tyranny might come to America, and I 100% agree with that. Of course it might, and in fact I think the increasing surveillance state atmosphere makes it seem increasingly likely. But any implication that civilian gun ownership could make a difference if it happens seems overly hopeful. The US military is the largest in the world by a large margin. If tyranny comes to America then a few civilian shotguns aren't going to help much.
- pdkl95 11y agoYou're making the common assumption that such a situation would be "the standing US military roughly as it exists now" vs "rebel citizens with only small arms". This scenario is unlikely to ever happen. What would be more likely to happen is something like the Civil War where the army itself was also divided. Even more importantly, it is a lot harder to control an army when the targets are the people the army supposedly exists to protect. In a survey[1] of "300 U.S. Marine Corps soldiers" about unit cohesion when working with the UN, the final question asked: 46. The U.S. government declares a ban on the possession, sale, transportation, and transfer of all non-sporting firearms. A thirty (30) day amnesty period is permitted for these firearms to be turned over to the local authorities. A the end of this period, a number of citizen groups refuse to turn over their firearms. Consider the following statement: I would fire upon U.S. citizens who refuse or resist confiscation of firearms banned by the U.S. government. (__) (__) (__) (__) (__) Strongly disagree Disagree Agree Strongly agree No opinion The results of that question suggests a "citizens vs army" scenario is very unlikely. The results [...] with 88.0 percent responding, revealed that 61.66 percent said they would refuse to fire on U.S. citizens, whereas 26.34 percent indicated they would fire. This particular question, unlike the others, elicited form 15.97 percent of the respondents with an opinion, either heavier pen or pencil marks on their response or written comments in the margin space. [...] The responses to this scenario suggests that a complete unit breakdown could occur in a unit tasked to execute this mission. Small groups of people often have some kind of consistency across the group, because the definition of the group self-selects for something. (e.g. the people who choose to attend a chess club tend to like to play chess) As a group grows in size, the makeup of the group tends to become more heterogeneous. Eventually, as the group becomes very large, the makeup of the group tends to resemble the makeup of the general population. The military is a very large group of people, so the individual attitudes and politics of a soldier tends to resemble the attitudes and politics seen in the country in general. When considering a topic that is obviously politically controversial, you should expect that the people serving in the armed forces will be approximately as divided as the rest of the citizens. [1] http://www.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/a293790.pdf http://www.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/a293790.pdf