7 ms·
Rent Your Place on Airbnb? The Landlord Wants a Cut
- Canada 11y agoIf the landlords are willing to indemnify the tenants for subletting via AirBnB I'd call it a win-win.
- tptacek 11y agoHow is that a win-win? All the other tenants in the building have to deal with a small, unregulated hotel being opened in it.
- brewdad 11y agoWell the incentives will be aligned such that soon the tenants will have a large, unregulated hotel to deal with.
- otterley 11y agoHow is that practically different from how any modern beehive apartment complex operates today? In a building with hundreds of units, neighbor tenant stability is rarely found.
- tptacek 11y agoThe apartment building and its tenants have recourse against abusive tenants: they can break the lease and eject the tenant. That recourse doesn't exist with short-term renters, who are going to leave soon anyways.
- otterley 11y agoTenants have no direct recourse against bad neighbors - their only recourse is to complain to management and pray they do something about it. As for management, they'll have similar, if not identical, recourse in the form of (a) deposit withholding and (b) negative feedback on AirBNB. The ability to provide negative feedback actually gives them greater power, incidentally, than the power innkeepers typically have over ill-behaving guests.
- tptacek 11y agoI do not believe feedback on renters does anything to meaningfully curb abuse, especially because abusive renters will be the ones least likely to groom a profile of positive reviews.
- kamaal 11y agoEvery thing you say about Airbnb can be applied to uber too. Why should there be unregulated cab drivers all over the city? What are legal means for handling abuse by drivers? Why should other cars on the roads deal with every car being a potential taxi? But its funny how this free market thing works though, the hypocrisy is the same people who scream innovation and disruption when it comes to Uber are crying disgust and malpractice when it comes to Airbnb. You can't have these selectively applied to what you like and dislike. If disrupting taxi unions and license issuers was fair, so is this.
- tptacek 11y agoIt very much is a problem with Uber!!!
- Canada 11y agoYou completely missed his point.
- tptacek 11y agoNo, I completely dis-missed his point.
- otterley 11y agoI don't follow your logic. If abusive renters are not "groom[ing] a profile of positive reviews," and offerers are rejecting their applications as a consequence, that suggests to me that the system is working as we'd like it to.
- 11y ago
- Canada 11y agoEven when there's no such thing as AirBNB, tenants who rent have absolutely, positively ZERO recourse against bad neighbors. Zilch. Nada. Absolutely nothing. They can accept it, or find somewhere else. It's great that a landlord is saying, fine, you can sublease the place short term. But we have to regulate that, you have to pay us to do so, and if you can't hold up your end we have the right to put an end to it. This is the only reasonable way I can see to solve the problem of short term rentals.
- tptacek 11y agoYou seem very certain about this, but I don't think you've done much research on it. Not only do boilerplate leases include "quiet enjoyment" clauses that contractually bind landlords into ensuring that tenants aren't disruptive, but state laws also include implied covenants of quiet enjoyment, meaning that there are large areas where it doesn't even matter if you edit that out of your lease. A landlord that fails to ensure quiet enjoyment can be sued by their tenants.
- otterley 11y agoYes, those laws exist. Do they protect the tenant's interest more effectively than penalties against short-term renters? Difficult to say; the verdict isn't in yet and data is scarce. Your mere beliefs are not sufficient. Even with the laws and implied covenants, it takes a significant amount of time to go through eviction proceedings in many states. In California it can take months (unless you stop paying rent altogether, in which case there's a fast-track procedure). Yes, a tenant can sue their landlord as well. Again, however, that can take months and significant expense. When considering these things, we must take into account the actual reality of how rights are exercised, not merely what rights exist in law.
- JVMsOfGor 11y agoCompletely agree here. At least in California, there are strong laws that protect a tenant from their landlord. The only way to be evicted quickly is if you commit a serious violent felony, a sex crime ( I guess that IS a serious felony ), or you stop paying rent ( Ask me how I know !) In just about every other situation, there is a list of 16 reasons you can evict someone, and all of them can lead to a lengthy expensive trial, in which at the end the landlord has spent a significant amount of money and probably regrets every doing anything with their life. https://www.sftu.org/justcauses/ https://www.sftu.org/justcauses/
- xiaoma 11y agoIt's a win-win because the renter wins and the landlord wins. If the neighbors also won, it would be a win-win-win.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- zeveb 11y ago> All the other tenants in the building have to deal with a small, unregulated hotel being opened in it. Is that particularly worse than tenants having to deal with Section 8 tenants in their midst?
- tptacek 11y agoWhat the fuck would make you write something like that? I live on a block with S8 renters. They're real people with families who want a safe bed and decent schools for their kids just like everyone else.
- zeveb 11y ago> What the fuck would make you write something like that? Your own comment some time ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10623102 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10623102 Why do you think that short-term middle-to-upper-class renters are preferable neighbours to medium-to-long-term lower-class renters? I saw your comment elsethread about ease of punishment, which makes some sense, but in my experience small landlords simply don't care. Living above a pair of end-stage alcoholics who importuned people on the sidewalk and called the ambulance for health care every few weeks was far, far more annoying than the flophouse a few doors down. Then there was the poor family with 9 people in a two-bedroom unit, with a couple of teenagers who vandalised and may have been thieves as well (not that upper-class teenagers aren't hoodlums, of course: many of them are too). Then there was the prostitute with the shady clientele. You appear to be opposed to short-term renters, but appear to applaud Section 8. Why the difference?
- tptacek 11y agoYes, that is exactly what I think, and also what the zoning commissioners in virtually every city think, which is why cities have limitations on short-term rentals in residential properties and special zoning rules for where you can put hotels!
- wglb 11y agoI think you are way out of line here. I have family that lives in Section 8 housing. They are a danger or annoyance to no one.
- Canada 11y agoIf the neighbors are harmed, a landlord with means accepts responsibility for either stopping the harm or compensating them in exchange. That's way better than the current situation. What are the neighbors going to get from a tenant who sub leases in violation of the lease agreement? It's the landlord who offers (within the limits of local law) the terms of the lease. I've never seen a lease agreement that allows subleasing without at least right of refusal on reasonable grounds by the landlord. The landlord is within its rights prohibit the tenant from entering into any kind of sub lease entirely. It could (again, within the limits of local law) evict the tenant for even advertising a possible sublease without its written permission. But no, the landlord is very graciously offering to actively support subleasing via AirBnB. If the landlord executes properly, that's a win for the tenant, a win for the landlord, and a win for the neighbors.
- tptacek 11y agoYou've lost me. Exactly how do I benefit as the neighbor of someone who has turned their apartment into a small unregulated hotel?
- Canada 11y agoSaying the neighbor is ipso facto harmed by short term subleasing is like saying that the value of currency is ipso facto damaged by creating more or it so that the share value of a company is ipso facto damaged by issuing more shares. It's certainly true that if these things are done irresponsibly then bad things happen. And bad things do often happen, I'll give you that. But it's not necessarily true. How it's managed is what determines whether the outcome is good or bad and for whom. When short term renters well behaved, then the neighbors aren't harmed at all. If any lease holder has the ability to sublet easily with support of the landlord then that is something of value. A landlord that gets involved like this is going to create an environment with incentives for good short term tenants. I'd rather lease from a company that allows me to do that and also supports me in doing so. I'd rather lease from a company that actively manages subleases than one that sticks its head in the sand that pretends that isn't happening all the time. Short term subleases are here to stay. Trying to stop them is like trying to stop piracy or illicit drug use. It's just not going to happen. edit: also: To call what happens on airbnb an "unregulated hotel" is profoundly misguided. Have you ever lived for a significant period of time out of airbnb??
- pc86 11y agoClick the "web" link under the submission if you hit the WSJ pay wall.
- clamprecht 11y agoWhoa cool, is this new? I've been doing it by hand. It might be better to just do a "site:" search, prepending "site:" to the url. In this case, the search is: site:www.wsj.com/articles/big-landlords-airbnb-discuss-partnerships-1450200473 This brings up 1 result, which is the paywalled article.
- pc86 11y agoNewish, I think they added it a few months ago. I remember dang mentioning it but I can't remember if it was a dedicated post or something similar to my comment above.
- stevesearer 11y agoMy landlords live in a small one bedroom home behind the house my family is in and I was thinking about doing this with them. Essentially, I'd still pay my rent like normal and then have them manage the Airbnb while we're out of town and they'd get a cut of the proceeds. I'd need to check the lease to see if I'm allowed to do it anyway, I assume not, but it seems like a reasonable way for all three parties to win: They collect more rent, I cover some travel expenses, ad someone gets to stay in a cute place close to downtown Santa Barbara.
- pavel_lishin 11y ago> I'd need to check the lease to see if I'm allowed to do it anyway Leases can be amended - it's not a law.
- Kiro 11y agoDepends on what country you're in.
- jmilloy 11y agoI'm curious about this; can you elaborate?
- JonFish85 11y agoI'm not the person you asked it of, but I suspect that what the person means is that you can amend a lease as long as it fits the legal requirements of the location. If you're in a city that doesn't allow short-term subleases, then you presumably can't amend your lease to specifically allow short-term subleasing.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoSure, but is the lease likely to have pointers to laws that forbid that?
- ape4 11y agoOften residential rents are protected. But if you rent out a space then its commercial so residential protection doesn't apply.
- tptacek 11y agoThis is even more ominous than renters violating their leases to let places out on Airbnb, because it means the landlord is incentivized to screw over the rest of the tenants in the building by allowing Airbnb hotels in it; not only that, but they're disincentivized to respond to complaints about it!
- scott00 11y agoThere are also some interesting incentives that go the other way. By getting the big property managers involved, tenants or regulators that are upset by how things are going have a new target for their wrath that: - is making money from the deal (unlike landlords now) - unequivocally knows the subletting is going on (unlike landlords now) - has an explicit contractual responsibility to aggrieved tenants (unlike AirBnB or other tenants) - has a lot of money that can be taken away if they lose a lawsuit (unlike other tenants), and - has valuable unmovable property located in the jurisdictions where the harm is being done (unlike other tenants and AirBnB). I'm not really sure whether these issues outweigh the points you made or not, but if this happens, it probably makes legal action against bad actors using AirBnB much easier.
- brokentone 11y agoNot really. The main landlord could operate one or multiple units on Airbnb now. The reasons they don't likely have to do with their risk at being brought up for violations of hotelling laws where applicable, and their increased need for maintenance and maid service would eat into their easy monthly income from a standard tenant.
- swingbridge 11y agoNot surprising. That's all standard clauses in a lease. For a long list of reasons you can't treat a rented propert like it's your own and just start renting it out without having the real landlord in the loop. Also doesn't get around the usual "hotel" regulations in many cities that forbid short term rentals, also for a long list of reasons.
- OJFord 11y agoPresumably the article's stance is that they'll allow it, rather than it being a violation (assuming no subletting allowed) of the contract. I mention it because the headline reads a bit more like "greedy landlords decide they want your money from letting on airbnb!"
- nemo44x 11y agoAs someone who rents from Equity Residential in NYC I will move to another apartment if they open my building up to this. It is illegal in NYC to rent an apartment for less than 30 days and is enforced by many landlords. If Airbnb is trying to convince landlords to look the other way, I find that disgusting. I don't want my building to be a hotel. I don't want random people in my building. The idea that landlords can rationalize steeply raising rents with the expectation that tenants will find the money by letting someone crash on their couch for a few days every month to make it up is dehumanizing. Will this be exploited by the 20% of affordable housing units in these buildings paying well below market rates?
- bpodgursky 11y ago> I don't want my building to be a hotel. I don't want random people in my building. Here's the thing... it's not your building. I totally understand it being wrong to AirBnB a rental without the landlord's approval. But if the landlord is ok with it... they own the building, that's their call. If you don't like it, find a different apartment.
- OJFord 11y ago> If you don't like it, find a different apartment. That's exactly what parent commenter said he would do, in opening sentence..
- CPLX 11y ago> they own the building, that's their call No, actually it's not. It's against the law to use a residential building as a short term occupancy hotel.
- mikeash 11y ago"My building" is a common English colloquialism to mean "the building in which I reside." It does not actually imply ownership. If you don't like it, find a different language. :P
- digler999 11y ago
- dunk010 11y agoLandlord gets paid twice? Nice work if you can get it!
- pcthrowaway 11y agoPaywall buster: https://www.google.ca/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwjh6qWp5-DJAhVl54MKHdvEAEkQqQIIHDAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.wsj.com%2Farticles%2Fbig-landlords-airbnb-discuss-partnerships-1450200473&usg=AFQjCNEP2uNKg6UQpNEj5Io-eIS5P1D7Sg&bvm=bv.110151844,d.amc https://www.google.ca/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd...
- Namrog84 11y agoThe place I live has recently announced that they are furnishing and renting out the vacant units to people now. Though they seem to imply its meant for families of residents for visiting holidays and such. But it still feels a little like my place is becoming a hotel. Not sure if it will be discontinued past holidays or if non family will occur. I
- littletimmy 11y agoWhy are we allowing these illegal hotels to run anyway? The government needs to step in and ban Airbnb.
- dsfyu404ed 11y agoA problem I see here is that participating landlords are given incentive have their properties or portions "straw rented" by people who will Airbnb the unit in order to avoid hotel regulations and side step rent control (because a unit will supposedly Airbnb at a market rate).