6 ms·
To predict the future 1/3 of you need to be crazy
- mizchief2 11y agocheck
- numlocked 11y agoGreat post. This reminds me of a New Yorker article, Groupthink, from a couple of years ago[0]. Essentially, disagreement fosters creativity, not brainstorming platitudes like 'there are no wrong ideas'. An excerpt: ...dissent stimulates new ideas because it encourages us to engage more fully with the work of others and to reassess our viewpoints. “There’s this Pollyannaish notion that the most important thing to do when working together is stay positive and get along, to not hurt anyone’s feelings,” she says. “Well, that’s just wrong. Maybe debate is going to be less pleasant, but it will always be more productive. True creativity requires some trade-offs.” The article is terrific and I'm mentally made note of 3 techniques that I've used over the past few years: 1. Thinking on your own can lead to more solutions than thinking in a group. 2. Dissent and constraints stimulate creativity. 3. Insane, off-the-wall, unproductive ideas can stimulate creativity in everyone else. [0] http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2012/01/30/groupthink http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2012/01/30/groupthink
- ionforce 11y agoI dunno, I'm not totally sold... Often times I've worked with people who I pretty much thought were bad engineers and they were the most boisterous. I'm not saying being boisterous in itself is bad, but it's like it was there primary weapon to make EVERYTHING an issue. Healthy debate is good, but... I dunno. I hate giving bad engineers more ammo to act crazy.
- arbsn 11y agoI believe that the article was talking about disagreement, critique, and debate. Being "noisy" and "boisterous" sounds like something else entirely. Productive debate ought to be calm, civil, rational, and without inflated egos.
- sblank 11y agoGood rebels versus Bad Rebels at work here http://steveblank.com/2015/08/25/why-corporate-entrepreneurs-are-extraordinary-the-rebel-alliance/ http://steveblank.com/2015/08/25/why-corporate-entrepreneurs...
- rukuu001 11y ago> 2. Dissent and constraints stimulate creativity. Re dissent: If you're in an environment that values 'useful' dissent, that's great. If not, you're 'that guy who argues about everything', 'hard to work with' etc.
- hamhamed 11y agoIt goes back to the traditional quote that you if you don't know it's impossible to create X thing, then it might just be possible to create X thing
- tsunamifury 11y agoI think one of the main reasons I've failed to innovate inside a large company, while succeeding at building new things at startups, is because I find it so hard to maintain a positive attitude inside a corporate environment. However, at a startup, when I'm starving, I find optimism in everything and build nonstop. So far this is a bit of a horrifying conundrum where I am a technical startup failure, but in good spirits or a corporate success and in bad mood all the time. I've found when I'm at a startup there is enormous willingness to believe that my crazy ideas might create an opportunity -- likely because C-suite has nothing to lose and everything to gain. While I'm in a corp environment at the top of the market, VP's have everything to lose and very little they can imagine that can get better (other than competitive catchup scenarios). This leads to a really deadly cycle, where large companies shun real innovation because of the perceived risk being 100,000,000x higher than at a startup since one has 0 to lose, and the other has billions. The net-net result here is that big corps never end up being first movers, since they need to see opportunity illustrated by a competitor before they move on it. This sets up the corp team for failure though, as they are assigned to catch up to a competitor already established and building a product on a good foundation and likely years ahead in thinking.
- RankingMember 11y agoWould you say that, for this reason, large companies should maintain small insulated "Google X"-style incubation divisions to attempt to get the best of both worlds (stability of the big company with the risk-taking of the small)?
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoThere has to be someone, or some group, to translate crazy cool ideas into viable products that match a market need. Ideas and inventions on their own are not enough. I know plenty of corps have a skunkworks R&D division. But - with the possible exception of Steve Jobs - I've never seen an equivalent elite skunkinnovation marketing division which exists solely to turn brilliant original ideas into brilliant marketable products for new customer groups.
- eloisant 11y ago
- MDCore 11y agoI like this concept, now how does one tell the difference between a tenacious insider with a crazy idea that just might work, and a tenacious insider with a horrible idea that they just won't let go of?
- ionforce 11y agoPresumably the idea itself has merit? I don't know, but I agree with you that this is a good question.
- jtolmar 11y agoGood crazy ideas revolve around solving one or a handful of extremely hard engineering tasks, which make everything else easier "assuming the crazy thing works." Bad crazy ideas break any part of that description. The single hard thing is new science/research instead of engineering, or the new hard thing won't make the rest easier, or the new hard thing is supposed to get rid of all the other problems.
- mistermann 11y ago"Luckily Houbolt got to make his case, and when Wernher Von Braun changed his mind and endorsed this truly insane idea, the rest of NASA followed." If one can take this literally (and it wouldn't surprise me at all, but who knows for sure), it shows how even the cream of the crop smart people are subject to either group-think or fear of rocking the boat they are sitting in - now imagine if your workplace of relatively average people are subject to or engage in similar behavior. The tenacity of the engineer to stand up to that culture is extremely admirable.
- amitparikh 11y agoThis reminds me a lot of a thesis (sort of) from Peter Thiel's "Zero to One". He calls it The Contrarian Question: What important truth do very few people agree with you on? The question asks us to escape from the mental confines of the past and present to be able to "predict the future" as it were.
- Xcelerate 11y agoI've always thought an interesting idea for trying to curing cancer would be to put the world's best physicists, mathematicians, economists, and software engineers in a room together and see what happens. (Conversely, it would be interesting to see what ideas the world's best medical researchers and biologists come up with for particle physics and software development.)
- crpatino 11y agoIf you invite the economists, you will end up concluding that, in order to stop cancer, you'll need to stop the Demand for cancer.
- Mikeb85 11y ago> If you invite the economists, you will end up concluding that, in order to stop cancer, you'll need to stop the Demand for [whatever it is that] cancer [-ous cells like]. I think we're on to something...
- andrewsNews 11y agoI was hoping that the article would explain the fractions it so arbitrarily threw out. Did I miss a derivation of the numbers or a reference to supporting evidence? Does anyone else have any studies/proofs about such team demographics, etc?
- bchjam 11y agoman but staying crazy can really lead to burn out if your voice is never heard
- jdmichal 11y agoReminds me a bit of the 10th man idea from World War Z. Basically, if all 9 members of a council unanimously agreed on something, it was the 10th man's duty to act as if that thing was a certainty and prepare for it. This all really plays into argumentative theory [0], which is the basic idea that human reason developed as an argumentative tool. Its main function isn't "true" or "logical" ideas, but rather persuasion and defense thereof. One major conclusion is that reason often works to reinforce existent ideals against external challenge, regardless of the merit of those ideas. [0] http://evolution.binghamton.edu/evos/wp-content/uploads/2011/06/Mercier-Sperber-Why-do-humans-reason.pdf http://evolution.binghamton.edu/evos/wp-content/uploads/2011...
- duncancarroll 11y agoSmall correction: It was the 10th man's duty to *disagree with the other 9 and prepare for that outcome.
- esrauch 11y agoThe 10th man in World War Z was based on an actual Israeli military office called the "devil's advocate office".
- knughit 11y agoWhich is based on ancient Jewish judiciary rules about unanimous decisions among a Bet Din.
- suneilp 11y ago"Yet in 1961 LOR was a completely insane idea." It's not that you have to be crazy, it's that most people around you are actually the crazy ones who push conformance on you because they can't hack it. Innovating is difficult due to many people being so very risk averse. Ideally you have a balance between caution and boldness, however, people lose the will to take chances when the "bottom" line is at risk. Of course, when it comes to what NASA does, the bottom line also involves human lives. Although, then NASA's existence would have and probably is still considered crazy by some number of people.
- ableal 11y ago"Luckily Houbolt got to make his case, and when Wernher Von Braun changed his mind and endorsed this truly insane idea, the rest of NASA followed. We landed on the moon on July 20th 1969." 'Chapeau' (hats off). Been paying attention to space and SF for way too many moons, had never read this story.
- Htsthbjig 11y agoI remember when I created my first company. Being young I was so idealistic and did bet everything on it. My parents believed I was nuts: "With no real world experience you should not create a company", they said, "first work for someone else, get experience, and then make a company if you want". My girlfriend thought I was also nuts, she blackmailed me: My (stupid) idea or she. I chose my stupid idea. She wanted to get back a week later but it was too late. My friends could not understand either why take "pies on the sky" when I had good options on a "real work". After creating my company everything took way longer than expected, I started believing it was not a good idea after all, you only have the energy you have after it is depleted. But one day I read a document I wrote when I started my company and was incredibly shocked that everything I wrote down in the past was becoming real in the present!! Things started to roll, I got more confident...in the end it was a huge success precisely because it was such a crazy idea. Had I followed my parents' advice, I would never have never done what I did, "experience in the past" would have blocked the possibilities of the future and the beginners mind.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- meagain20000 11y agoWhat is the name of the company?
- api 11y agoI suspect this is why "collect the best and brightest and lavishly fund them" star-power startups tend to fizzle. The best and the brightest are that way by yesterday's metrics.
- yteicosf 11y agoas a life long contrarian, reading this article gives me relief. 1/3 is definitely crazy, such as dedicating 4 years of my life to a software developed in complete social isolation full time with about 9 customers, mostly mom and pops small businesses paying $19.99/month