4 ms·
Homevoters v. the growth machine: Who controls the development of cities?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nwah1 11y agoLeft out the most crucial land reform. Shifting away from taxing improvements, and shifting towards taxing land by value. We must stop encouraging people to enclose valuable land for idle speculative purposes. That land should be available at an affordable rate for those who actually want to make productive use of it.
- aetherson 11y agoMy reading on this subject suggests that it's super hard to figure out the unimproved land value of improved land. That seems like it's an important hurdle.
- bufordsharkley 11y agoThat's an objection that many have raised (Hayek thought it made LVT impractical), though there are schemes to make it better than the current system (county-run assessors, whose values often bear very little connection to reality)-- self-assessment of your land value being one.
- dragonwriter 11y agoSelf assessment doesn't really solve anything, especially if it's for unimproved value (which is the tax basis in LVT), but all other important uses (including, e.g., eminent domain) use as-is, improved value. Self-assessment is arguably efficient for setting tax basis value for things with ad valorem taxes when it serves as a firm and irrevocable offer to sell at the price (e.g., if it were the firm, out upper limit, value for eminent domain purposes.) But when the value taxed if definitionally different from the price expected in any transaction, as it is worth unimproved land value taxes, self assessment is trivially fallbacks to the point of uselessness. In any case, I'm unconvinced that land value tax makes sense in a post-industrial economy; in an agricultural economy out industrial economy, sure, I can see the attraction.
- mjevans 11y agoI would expect that value to be highly speculative. It's like trying to ask the value of a stock/bond. A better way of aligning the tax code would probably be to have a low tax for uses which fulfill the desired criteria of the space, and a high tax (penalty tax) for deviating from that desired use. For high concentration of population urban centers (city cores) I would like to see something closer to caves of steel, where pedestrian levels share a given geographic elevation, and are setup like indoor parks/greenhouses. Building such a feature in to a building should lower the tax rate (as long as the building maintains the park along it).
- nwah1 11y agoWhen taxable income is recorded for income taxes, does that bear much resemblance to reality? Do people really pay sales tax on everything they buy online? And if we could make that happen, is that the kind of internet we'd want? Land taxes are great because they tax something right out in the open that everyone can see. You might not have a perfect idea of the value, but you can get a pretty good idea by looking at surrounding parcels. Self-assessment, as noted below, is one feasible system out of many. LVT can be avoided by not owning land, but all users of land will need to pay, and they cannot avoid it. But in effect they're simply renting from the government rather than a private landlord. The market rent doesn't change. Under-assessment can open up the possibility of subleasing, however, just like when normal landlords fail to charge the full rent for whatever reason.
- ianbicking 11y agoUpzoning and downzoning are fairly different: upzoning often immediately precedes building larger buildings. Downzoning puts an upper bound on growth, but never results in a building being demolished (except in cases of a derelict building, where downzoning makes it impossible to replace – though even then it's usually possible to create replace a building with an equivalent building regardless of zoning in the case of something like a fire).
- marssaxman 11y agoThis would suggest that zoning codes represent a substantial constraint on development, and form a substantial driver of rising rents.
- ilaksh 11y agohttp://runvnc.github.io/tinyvillage http://runvnc.github.io/tinyvillage
- mjevans 11y agoLimiting the vehicle size by weight is crazy. At 300lbs you're specifying nearly the bulk of a normal American adult (we have a lot of obese and nearly obese people; but a lot of strength trainers also qualify). The effort would be better spent more directly attacking the desired result; short-medium (intra small city) transit in extremely lightweight vehicles (bicycles are the traditional solution, but electric scooters are another option). Of course instead of those moving beltways might be a better use of one of the pathways (and promote walking).
- ilaksh 11y agoThere aren't really a lot of people that overweight. Probably needs to be more than 300 lbs, but what I am going for is for there to be a small enough amount of force involved that people will almost certainly survive crashes. So the vehicle has to be very light and that is what I was trying to go for. If the person or vehicle is heavier then maybe it has to move slower to stay safe. You say its better to make it a rule for people to use bicycles or scooters in between towns. Well, I suggested in the same section to use bicycles or velomobiles which is the same thing, except ideally since this is relatively dense and mixed use you don't have to go very far to get to your store or wherever and so its in the same town.