4 ms·
> (Added bonus: no PHP.) It uses Java, a pile of (insert swear word) so high that nothing comes close.
by mschuster91 11y ago
> (Added bonus: no PHP.)
It uses Java, a pile of (insert swear word) so high that nothing comes close.
- mahouse 11y agoAre you seriously comparing PHP with Java? Not saying Java is the best, but dude, at least it was not designed by monkeys.
- mschuster91 11y agoThere's a lot of high-performance, widely used PHP projects: MediaWiki, Drupal (to a certain degree though), Wordpress, Facebook... Now let's take a look at some popular Java apps: Eclipse, SAP's frontend, Lotus Notes, Atlassian JIRA/Confluence, JDownloader... recognize the pattern of slowness? PHP might have been designed by monkeys (and many of the early design mistakes are gone by now, anyway!), but at least PHP kept the 10-abstraction-layers-minimum monkeys away. Also, a PHP web (or CLI, or GUI) app will in most cases eat far less RAM than a Java app of same functionality. Also, PHP projects are far faster to develop because the intermediate step of compiling is removed, and it's far easier (and faster) to deploy PHP projects than a Java web app. Edit: did some quick measurement on a RPi 1, java hello world vs PHP hello world vs C hello world: javac takes 16.8s wall time, 28MB peak RSS. Running the program itself is 1.99s wall time, 13MB peak RSS. PHP in contrast is a single process with 0.7s wall time, 14MB peak RSS. C takes 1.24s wall time for the compile, 15MB peak RSS. The resulting program takes 0.01s wall time, 1MB peak RSS. Versions are openjdk 7u91-2.6.3-1+rpi1, php 5.6.14+dfsg-1+b1 and gcc 5.2.1-23+rpi1. That compile time of javac is simply... wtf.
- mahouse 11y agoYou are right about the slowness, that's not exactly the point I wanted to make. Anyway, calling wordpress or drupal "high performance" is a joke.
- mschuster91 11y ago> Anyway, calling wordpress or drupal "high performance" is a joke. Well, these two platforms are by far the leader in the CMS space. It's either usability, ease of administration or speed that keeps people using WP/Drupal over alternatives in other languages/frameworks.
- creshal 11y agoSeeing it from the point of view of a company with a few hundred Wordpress deployments: Definitely usability (if you want laypersons to be able to author content, there's little competition), largely availability of plugins, a bit ease of administration (it's getting better), but definitely not speed. Wordpress is so mindbogglingly slow that we have to use excessive amounts of caching for anything even remotely resembling medium traffic.
- sbarre 11y agoHonest question: do you not consider caching to be a normal part of a dynamic web application? I've never worked with a CMS or web app - in any language - that didn't include caching as a core part of the performance layer once it reaches a certain amount of load.. I'm sure it's possible, with enough money to throw at hardware, to scale without it, but why would you? Caching is a completely valid optimization approach in my view..
- mschuster91 11y agoWell Wordpress long came without any caching at all, dunno if that's changed by now. Drupal in contrast comes with its own DB caching. Both can be plugged into memcache and friends, and if done right you can put in Cloudflare or other frontend caching systems in front. Biggest performance +1, though, is enabling php opcache.
- creshal 11y ago> Honest question: do you not consider caching to be a normal part of a dynamic web application? We should not be needing bare metal servers with 4 GHz CPUs to serve a non-interactive site with ~4000 visitors a day. Yet, without full-page caching (i.e., bypass Wordpress/PHP entirely and serve .html files straight from nginx), the servers would melt under the load. Rendering twenty images and forty text fields out of database should not take several seconds on a modern server. Yet, Wordpress has no problems taking a dozen seconds even under light load conditions – mind you, that's time purely spent in PHP, for rendering, not on the database.
- creshal 11y ago> There's a lot of high-performance, widely used PHP projects: MediaWiki, Drupal (to a certain degree though), Wordpress, Facebook... Facebook had to develop their own PHP-to-C++ transpiler to achieve something vaguely resembling useful performance. I wouldn't quote that as positive example…
- robryan 11y agoOf which PHP 7 now equals/ surpasses in performance in a lot of areas.
- Killswitch 11y agoFacebook also has 968 Million daily active users. I just don't understand PHP bashers always using Facebook as a metric to bash PHP. "Oh PHP is so horrible, the second (sometimes even first ranked) most visited site on the internet had to write their own PHP-to-C++ transpiler to handle the load. Clearly PHP isn't a good choice for my 3 user site! I need that performance!" Get over yourselves already. Every language has it's strengths and weaknesses.
- creshal 11y agoWhy so defensive? I'm just saying Facebook is not a good example. Of course there's fast PHP software – for example, all I wrote. ;-)
- Killswitch 11y agoBecause elitest attitudes garner idiotic responses and I'm sick of them. Yes, Facebook had to write their own interpreter, but you also know what? Facebook also actively helps the PHP community and is ushering the community too. So anything Facebook creates they open source and PHP7 has taken cues from them. The whole net benefits from it. Not to mention the next biggest website that is powered by PHP is Wikipedia, whom uses stock PHP to serve their sites. Facebook has so much interactions and that, that they warrant the need for what they did. 99.9999% of most people don't need that. Not even Wikipedia. They just render a html page. Done.
- klaussilveira 11y agoSimply not true: "modern" PHP apps, usually built with Symfony or Laravel, might appear simple from their controllers, but their abstraction stack is just as huge as Spring's. Just take some time to read Symfony's HTTP code. Or step-debug one from the first point in the first controller and see how many layers of abstraction you have before the actual application code.
- mschuster91 11y agoIndeed, but in PHP it is at least possible to not use the performance sucker parts of the frameworks. Java? Not so much.
- Gigablah 11y agoWell, Symfony's Security component is actually based on Java Spring. It says so in the readme :) The biggest hits to performance however seem to stem from components that you can happily do without -- annotation magic for example, and the Doctrine ORM.
- mschuster91 11y agoDoctrine may be a complex beast, but it is so dead easy to use... I believe it's worth the performance hit.
- pkd 11y agoJava is used in the back end of several high performance web applications as well. Twitter uses JVM and so does The Guardian, for example. Not sure what your point is. Your criticism of Java for being slow is 1) very 2006 and 2) incorrectly based on desktop apps which require JVM restart and warmup time before they get going. Put Java on the server and see the speeds. Using spark as your web framework, it's possible to achieve rates of over 40k requests per second ( I've seen claims of 160k requests per second after sufficient JVM warmup).
- jenscow 11y agoThe answer to "what's the best language?" should not be "language X", but "what are you making?" Once you've defined the requirements, restrictions, and personal abilities, only then you can have a meaningful discussion on what the "best" language is - and even then there is more than one answer.