10 ms·
Hi, I’m from the games industry. Governments, please stop us
- gus_massa 11y agoThis idea to stalk customers in Facebook is scary, but why don't other companies (let's say the home appliances manufacteres) do the same trick? Is it effective only for some niches?
- voltagex_ 11y agoCould it be that older industries haven't "got" Facebook yet? Hell, lots of companies can barely manage their Twitter accounts, let alone pull off complex online advertising campaigns.
- tl 11y agoThis level of offense is not possible but for the fact that these "games" have access to your Facebook. If Maytag had a plausible justification to stalk people this way, they would. Considering that games outside of Facebook are a lot less terrible (in lots of ways), this is a "Facebook needs regulation" not "ganes need regulation" problem.
- joshschreuder 11y agoPresumably the difference between 'just one more' $2 microtransaction and a $1000 refrigerator is too great for this kind of psychological warfare to work via social media.
- huac 11y agobecause customer engagement in paramount in gaming - it's about attracting whales and getting them to stick with your games / app platform. you want your whales to be playing the game multiple times per day and buying stuff almost daily. that benefits from constant reinforcement advertising. in comparison, even the most engagement demanding 'traditional companies' don't need that same level of saturation / customer understanding - if you buy a home appliance, you will buy another in (say) 5 years. CLV > CAC baby
- Animats 11y agoNest tries to increase your emotional engagement with your thermostat, a tough sell at which they've had some success. Then they can sell you a home monitoring system and additional home automation. The gambling industry is scarily good at this.
- eveningcoffee 11y agoYou can potentially do cool things with cloud connected home control/monitoring devices. In short, I would never ever buy a cloud connected home control/monitoring. Why? Suppose you have an IoT device in your bedroom that uploads CO2 values (of course it may also do something useful too such us showing this data to you or regulating the ventilation). Now the rate of CO2 production depends on bodily activities. More activity means more CO2 production. I suppose that you agree that having this information you more or less are capable to deduce when a couple has sex. This means that we could calculate a metric how much sex is going on and relate it to a specific user. Suppose that we detect that the rate of sex has gone down by 20 (a made up number dependant of our model). We can now sell this information. This information is for example useful perhaps for a psychologist who wants to sell you counselling. But it is even more interesting for the divorce lawyers who now could prey on couples having period of difficulty in their sex lives. Even more, this information could be made more valuable by some additional influence. For example feeding the user with articles related to marital happiness and sex life. The same thing could be probably aslo implemented within a thermostat with a precise enough temperature sensor.
- Xeiliex 11y agoRegardless of the other reasons a customers is trained to expect a dryer last them, with minor repairs, for thirty or more years. Anything less and you lose those customers. I had the unpleasant experience of trying to get people to buy smart Appliances w/ App integration. Quite a few times I was flat out told that their current model works fine and that they couldn't see a use for the feature. NFC/Wifi Controlled dryer settings and timers are a failure point that many are uncomfortable with. In other cases I was told that reliability is or could be an issue. I actually spoke with one person that bought one of the units but was concerned with recommending it to a family member because it failed after two years and required a warranty replacement. Compared to this games are a disposable commodity.
- mahouse 11y agoThis has absolutely no sources. And if you compare what "an anonymous developer" says he does (which may as well be made up) with what a company that spends $40,000,000 in an ad campaign does, you see how this is delusional.
- swiley 11y agoI don't think I've ever thought of "addictive" as a positive attribute to a game. Reddit and HN are addictive, I want entertainment that I can leave when I want and that has depth.
- chejazi 11y agoI don't play games, but my roommate does for several hours every day. I asked him about it and he said he loves being immersed in it, and finds it much more engaging than other forms of entertainment, such as watching a movie. I wouldn't call him "addicted" though. We hang out all the time, and I never see the sort of desperation that the author describes. ... Are there specific genre's of games that have the sorts of traps the author describes? A giant achievement screen sounds like it could be in any game, but I'd be curious to hear of any patterns recognized by others.
- jml7c5 11y ago>Are there specific genre's of games that have the sorts of traps the author describes? Free-to-play games are the obvious example. MMORPGs are another, though I would say they are somewhat less sinister as — while they use many psychological tricks to keep players coming back — they are at the core generally an attempt to produce an interesting or enjoyable game world, which is generally not the primary goal in F2P games. I feel one of the worst (or at least most interesting) offenders for gambling is Valve, through Team Fortress 2 and Counter Strike. In those games people can buy "keys" to open randomly dropped "chests" which may or may not contain valuable items (valuable in the sense that they can be traded to other players for sometimes hundreds of dollars in Steambux). They are essentially running a lottery. I will concede that it's quite similar to Magic: The Gathering's business model (small chance to find something valuable!), but something about the exact implementation (perhaps the ease of trading and valuation of items, or the heavy use of Steambux which can only be redeemed in a Valve store?) Valve uses feels a bit more skeevy.
- chejazi 11y agoAs a former MtG player, I remember the gambler's high I'd get opening every booster pack. But while my cards are sitting in a dusty box somewhere, it sounds like there's a lot of recirculation that happens within the Valve community.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoThis post is a bit rambly and doesn't make its case particularly well. I think the case is better made implicitly by reviews of games like Game of War: Fire Age. They are designed to be addictive and get players to spend literally thousands of pounds (or dollars) on microtransactions. They have ruined lives. Particular attention should be paid to games which advertise microtransactions to children.
- marknutter 11y ago< Particular attention should be paid to games which advertise microtransactions to children. Particular attention should be paid to the parental controls available in every mobile OS out there.
- jml7c5 11y agoNot particularly helpful if the whale is a grown adult.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoEven with parental controls, why should companies be allowed to advertise expensive microtransactions to children? Certain types of advertising aimed at kids are already banned in various countries. Companies are well aware of the power of making kids nag their parents to spend money. But now they have an even worse tool: many kids have almost direct access to their parents' wallets if they borrow their devices.
- marknutter 11y agoBecause parents can just turn parental controls on. I'm sorry, but it's not the state's responsibility to make sure my kids don't nag me for shit.
- ascagnel_ 11y agoMost western nations impose age limits on drinking and the purchase of cigarettes as well as limit advertising targeted at children. If it's addictive and potentially habit-forming, it should be regulated.
- pascalxus 11y agoI don't see any problem with games or any other product spending that much on advertisement if it's beneficial for them. I don't understand what people have against targeted advertisement? So what if the advertisements are tuned for your interests. Wouldn't you rather see relevant ads, rather than the something completely irrelevant to your life? I actually wish, they had more information and were better targetted. Right now, the ads really don't have much of the right information or enough intelligence at all. Also, since when is it to much to ask people to spend responsibly? I mean, we have licences for driving and licences for fishing. Should we also have a licence to spend? Perhaps, all these so called 'victums' you speak of, should go to the a financial therapy class and their spending should be limited by the government. If you dont know how to spend your money, you shouldn't be allowed to have a wallet or money. People need to be responsible for their own spending if they want to grow up and live on their own.
- eveningcoffee 11y agoI don't understand what people have against targeted advertisement? Because you make naive, almost childish assumption that you would be targeted by the products and services that are (most) beneficial for you.
- yrro 11y ago> Wouldn't you rather see relevant ads, rather than the something completely irrelevant to your life? Absolutely not. The cost to my limited time & attention span is not worth it. If I feel there is a problem in my life that I can solve with a product, I am perfectly capable of finding it using sources I trust.
- adrtessier 11y ago> "We need to reign this stuff in. Its not just psychological warfare, but warfare where you, the customer, are woefully outgunned, and losing. Some people are losing catastrophically." I strongly disagree with this statement. I am very aware of the psychology behind marketing and advertising, and anyone with half an interest in it has probably read Vance Packard's The Hidden Persuaders, which was released, oh, 58 years ago. People know what pushes their buttons, too, and we have a name for it: interest. Not "manipulation". Certainly not "psychological warfare". Marketing and advertising might seem to be refined in this dopamine-heavy, short-attention-span social gaming age, but this shit has been around as long as humanity itself has existed. Some people have better impulse control than others; it's not the state's job to regulate the impulses of their populaces, or regulate systems that know how to manipulate them. It's a slippery slope that would take down the entirety of marketing and advertising as an industry, an industry which is pretty much necessary for the vast majority of the citizenry to even know what is out there to purchase. Furthermore, how would one even decide where the line between manipulative consumption and social signaling is? Some people want to own all the capital ships; they have some social hierarchy in some subculture standing upon it. Should I regulate that, too, and force them to have the same consumption values and preferences that I do? Should we take this a step further and ban all vices? Let's see how fast American society would fall apart if we banned alcohol again. FWIW, I hate consumerism and advertising. I block ads everywhere, I hate big branded items, I don't know the last time I bought something from an ad. Just because I feel this way, I don't go around trying to violently force that opinion upon others by begging the state to do it for me.
- pascalxus 11y agoWell Said.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoFunny that this comes up. Donald J. Boudreaux wrote an entry just earlier on the same topic in response to Akerlof and Shiller's recent book: http://cafehayek.com/2015/12/the-role-of-market-forces-in-protecting-against-phishing.html http://cafehayek.com/2015/12/the-role-of-market-forces-in-pr... There's also a bit of a double standard about how advertising is perceived. Banner ads, editorials and similar are frowned upon. Yet it's quite likely you'll interpret someone promoting a work in the comments section of a site you frequent as a friendly recommendation, never mind it's still signaling availability of something in a manner identical to many less invasive ads.
- eveningcoffee 11y ago“We take Facebook stalking to a whole new level. You spend enough money, we will friend you. Not officially, but with a fake account. Maybe it’s a hot girl who shows too much cleavage? That’s us. We learned as much before friending you, but once you let us in, we have the keys to the kingdom.” Discussed previously https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10239931 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10239931
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- marknutter 11y agoI really don't understand the opening rant against Star Citizen. This is a game that quite literally would not even have started production if it weren't for crowd sourcing because the big boys are too busy cramming the next Call of Duty down everyone's throats than taking chances on interesting new IPs. If Star Citizen never materializes it will still have done the gaming industry a huge service by signaling to the other companies out there that a huge, verifiable demand exists for that style of game.
- fbbbbb 11y agoStar Citizen employs microtransaction, you just pay them in advance. There are also whales, like the guy who paid 30000$, and many more who pay between 100$ and 1000$. In comparison with other mentions it is even worse, because this game isn't even completed yet. It fits in the narrative.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- microcolonel 11y agoCliff's comparison of Star Citizen's preorder process to gambling, painted in royal we, is obscene. I don't like to be dismissive, but it sounds like he's mostly upset that their slimy marketing actually works; while meanwhile people haven't even heard of his company. For kicks I looked at his company's website, and their top two titles are "Democracy 3", and "Big Pharma". i.e. he makes video games about regulation and a highly-regulated industry. After seeing these titles, the attitude makes a lot more sense.
- lovemenot 11y agoPerhaps there's a new product idea for Cliff: opt-in self-regulation. Whenever your urges become too strong, phone-a-friend for in-game counseling. Fight the pernicious Facebook-stalking fire with healthier Facebook-stalking fire. Alternatively, a new game called Slimy-Game-Developer, which simulates mind-control of millions of players while you optimise your revenues using too-effective psychological techniques.
- norea-armozel 11y agoI think he picked Star Citizen since you can spend close to thousands of real dollars (US) on items that don't physically exist. It's really no different than running an unregulated lottery since you can't be sure if Star Citizen will ever reach published state (It's been alpha close to two years IIRC). So, I think his comparison is close enough to question the validity of at least Kickerstarting projects like this.
- jnbiche 11y agoYeah, pretty doubtful of the author's initial claim of being "not a big fan of government regulation in general" and "not a friend of regulation". I can only imagine the views on gambling and drugs of anyone who proposes regulation for video game advertising. Suffice it to say this guy is a friend of regulation if he's making this proposal. It's a nice little rhetorical device but most of us are smart enough not to be fooled by this.
- necessity 11y agoAlmost seems like he's... advertising it? Doing some mild "psychological thing" on the readers.
- microcolonel 11y agoHe has two titles at his company called "Democracy 3" and "Big Pharma". He's probably the biggest government regulation fan I've ever seen; at least in the way that you'd imagine somebody who makes games about trains might fancy trains. For reference, here is some of the marketing copy of Democracy 3: (yes I know it doesn't mean he wrote it) >*Ever wanted to run the country? Have you ever wanted to be president? or prime-minister? Convinced you could do a better job of running the country? Let's face it, you could hardly do a worse job than our current political leaders. Crime, Unemployment, National Debt, Terrorism, Climate Change...Have you got the answers to the problems that face western industrialized nations? Here is your chance to find out...”
- kozukumi 11y agoHmm this is a tough one. Firstly I should make it clear that my wife works in the games industry. She works on PC, Console and Mobile titles. She has mentioned several times how there is a lot of pressure put on developers and publishers to "catch the whales". They employ psychologists and gambling specialists to make games, mostly mobile but it is also creeping into PC and Console, super addictive. Personally I am of the opinion that people should be able to do what they want* but my wife is genuinely concerned about just how they go after certain types of people. They do want to get the gambling types. They are the people who spend money. Lots of money. I have seen numbers where people who obviously have more money than we can imagine spending $50-100k on IAPs. Some games even have "limited" IAPs that were designed for just one player as they spend so damn much. However I can't help but feel there is something else behind this post than what the author seems to spin it as. What I am not too sure but it seems quite the ramble and he doesn't actually have any solid sources or data to back up his claim. Of course neither do I outside of what my wife tells me :) * Okay so there has to be some limits. Edit: I would like to make the point clear that while I think people should be able to do whatever they want, I do find this kind of predatory game design unethical. As does my wife. Thankfully nothing she has had to do so far has been totally deplorable.
- skybrian 11y agoI think you've defined the problem better than the original post: what to do about whales? Most people would guess that these are people with psychological problems who need help. But do we know that? Maybe they're billionaires and they're okay with it. I'm pretty sure I wouldn't want to work for anyone who is targeting whales, though.
- bduerst 11y agoClassify micro-purchase games as gambling. The whales aren't much different from the gambling addicts who are drawn in by the blinking lights, noise, and adrenaline shots from winning at chance. The only difference with these Skinner-box games is that people are conditioned to repeatedly put money into a machine that isn't giving any monetary payout.
- 11y ago
- LukeB_UK 11y agoA lot of people here seem to be missing the main point of this post. It's not about crowdfunding or advertising, it's about using hugely manipulative tactics within the games to get people to basically throw money at them. The reason they're called microtransactions is because they're small, usually priced at a point that's negligible. Using these tactics, they entice people to buy over and over again, each time the spend is a negligible amount but over time it adds up to hundreds or thousands.
- wturner 11y agoThe problem is that there is nothing that can be done due to the fact that its all opt-in and is based on ( as the article points out ) psychology. Free to play has gamed the inherit structure of the world wide web.
- LukeB_UK 11y agoGambling is the same yet there are a whole host of things that governments have done to try and help protect consumers.
- wturner 11y agoGambling isn't the same because the money users spend isn't used as a bet for a real-world money return. That is why when this stuff goes to court it gets thrown out.F2P relies on pure psychology and large sums of marketing dollars.
- ZenPsycho 11y agowhat about the gambling apps that, from top to bottom are exactly a slot machine with the only difference being that you can't get money out, only facebook trophies?
- wturner 11y agoAs I said, the reason these things get thrown out of court is because it isn't gambling since no money is expected by the user. If you're asking me a legal opinion I'm not a lawyer. I'm just telling you what I've read. I'm not advocating free to play.
- wturner 11y agoI was momentarily good friends with someone who went on to become a well known entrepreneurs in this space. Right before he got his business off the ground he emphatically told me :"I am going to exploit the living fucking shit out of these people". He wasn't just talking about his users, but the investors and the entire silicon valley ecosystem. It kind of blew my mind when he actually did it. He went on to be extremely successful in the free-to-play space.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- marcoperaza 11y agoThe solution is to teach people to be savvy consumers, to have a skeptical eye to the world, to be able to sort out fact from fiction from opinion, to understand incentives and identify ulterior motives. This skill will never become obsolete. The government can never protect you from everything, but politicians are happy to take your freedom away while they convince you that they can. No consumer protection law can ever supplant caveat emptor.
- PaybackTony 11y agoThis is jealousy, at the core of it. Not just the gaming industry uses these tactics. I work in an industry that does that all the time (I hate it). Certain kinds of games shouldn't be regulated, though I would agree that creating fake profiles on social media in an attempt to gather more information from users should be regulated to some extent. At the end of the day, you have to ask yourself, are you in favor of people having a free will, or do you want to mitigate what a person can and can't do with their free time because in your opinion, it's bad for them?
- daemin 11y agoWell there is actually a middle ground, where society (through te government) can make changes so that people are nudged to a better direction. (Check out UK's nudge unit.) So even though people can smoke, drink, gamble - there should be some form of policy to limit or reduce the harm that comes from these activities. This actually goes double for such free-to-play games with IAP as in some ways they are no better than plain old slot machines - or "pokies" as we call them in Australia. But since they are just "games" on "phones" they are not treated with the same rigor as other pure gambling machines.
- brohoolio 11y agoI was totally and completely addicted to WoW for two years. Almost lost my girlfriend, friends, etc. When I finally quit I had the shakes. Literally. One thing though is I've never saved more money than when I was playing WoW because I never went out. These newer games do seem to have a different financial model that exploits addiction in potentially a much more dangerous fashion.
- pestaa 11y agoI appreciate your honesty.
- ris 11y ago"These newer games do seem to have a different financial model that exploits addiction in potentially a much more dangerous fashion." It's mostly that they're "casual" and, most importantly, primarily mobile. Which means they follow you everywhere as you conduct your life.
- norea-armozel 11y agoWas this before or after Blizzard turned WoW into the semi-F2P crapfest? Because I'll admit I love MMOs and certain other games (single player mostly) where I can spend most of my weekend stuck in front of my PC clicking away like a fool (Damn you, Minecraft!) but I've never had 'shakes' or anything close to a withdraw symptom. Maybe I'm the odd one out here in this regard.
- flink127 11y ago"You think you are not manipulated by ads? Get real, read some of the latest books on the topic." Any book recommendations? Sounds like this would be really interesting to read about
- vslira 11y agoTry Hooked, by Nir Eyal
- mschuster91 11y agoAs someone who worked in the customer-facing ends of the gambling industry (hell, I haven't been able to totally let go, I just ordered a true casino machine for my home... for reverse engineering and pentesting)... that online shit is far worse than "offline" gambling. With gambling offline, well you have to leave your house, gonna dress up, and people will notice if you fuck up your life by gambling every day. Also, maximum losses per machine and hour are usually regulated and you can have yourself banned from gambling venues. Online gambling - and online playing of the "free to play" or "pay to win" sort - however, does not offer any of these advantages. Instant pay-ins of five-figure sums (and instant pay-outs, publically shown)... or just the pleasure of 0wning an opponent because you paid for the "by-cash-only" battleship. No limits at all, disgusting. And no one will see you going down and down, except the pizza delivery guy and the coroner when it's too late.
- JabavuAdams 11y agoYes, and it's amazing how blind freemium game developers are to this. I'm a game developer, and I've done well off of freemium games, but no one wants to have this conversation.
- mschuster91 11y agoI wouldn't call it "blind". From a capitalist POV, they're doing their job very well.
- JabavuAdams 11y agoWell, devs generally admit that there's a spectrum of coerciveness and intrusiveness. It's just that all the devs I've talked to generally believe themselves to be on the "not as bad" end. So it's not purely A) devs don't think they're doing anything wrong or B) they don't care. It's the usual cognitive dissonance of "those other guys are doing something wrong, but we're not as bad, and we need to pay the bills." There is a real problem -- 98-99% of people will play your game but won't pay for it. So, that other 1-2% has to subsidize everyone else. Some other points that I rarely see discussed... Game developers don't have some inalienable right to make games AND be financially successful (unless we as a society decide they do and regulate them and the market). Here I'm drawing an analogy to other jobs that HN readers may be less sympathetic to, e.g. cab drivers or fishermen. They got disrupted. There's no reason why technical creatives are immune to disruption. Second, there's a black-hat / white-hat argument. Humans shipped with mental bugs. Many of these are exploitable. The gambling and game monetization industries basically identify, study, and exploit these bugs. Individuals have a choice to make -- do I work for the black-hats, or do I work for the white-hats? What about studying these mental bugs and inoculating users against being exploited? I know there are some resources for this out there, but this post is long enough and I'm getting too lazy to link.
- vinceguidry 11y agoLook, this is just commerce at work. People are going to use whatever edge they can get to make more money. These edges only go so far. If you think the only reason Game of War is popular because of the million dollar ads, then why isn't every single product, everywhere using these ads? These games fulfill more than just some need to mindlessly click on shit. Just because doesn't do anything for you, that doesn't make the people it does work for stupid or rubes. As soon as something better comes along, all of these games companies are going to be toast, way, way deader than disco. Assuming that any massive success is due to nefarious attention-gaming is pretty much categorically wrong. Video gaming, by the standards of global commerce, is a ridiculously tiny niche. There are billions of people who have never played a video game in their entire life. Game of War is the largest player in a sub-niche of this small niche. Big enough to buy ads on the Super Bowl, sure, but that says a lot more about the declining power of television and advertising in general than it does about the size of the gaming market. That this market needs political attention to curb abuse is utterly laughable. How about we fix oil drilling, or pharmaceutical production first?
- Retra 11y ago>Look, this is just commerce at work. And? Oil drilling and pharmaceutical production is just commerce at work. As is child labor, sex trafficking, drug trade, and slavery.
- vinceguidry 11y agoSo they are. Are you really equating them?
- Retra 11y agoNothing is "just" commerce at work. This is also a prime example of the naturalistic fallacy. Just because these things happen to be legal doesn't necessitate that they should be.
- vinceguidry 11y ago
- foxhop 11y agoWhere do erotic web camera sites that allow tipping and rake money off the top fit in? I'm pretty sure lots of people are addicted to these shows.
- Rumford 11y agoThis is supposedly irresistible "psychological warfare" and yet not one of these shady games companies has gotten a penny from me. At the end of the day the only one who decides to spend your money on stupid shit is you. Nut up and take responsibility for your own choices.
- petke 11y agoI think there would be a better case for regulating in game purchases. Some kind of limit, or a at least a warning at the beginning so people know what they are in for. "This game contains purchasable items. You may spend more than 10 000 dollars in this game." Marketing on the other hand is a different story. We cant really ban that.
- xtian 11y ago> We cant really ban that. Why not?
- fbbbbb 11y agoAnd why not? There are cases over the world where advertising was banned with success. http://www.worldwatch.org/node/5338 http://www.worldwatch.org/node/5338 http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/france/11250670/Grenoble-to-replace-street-advertising-with-trees-and-community-spaces.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/france/1125... This is just the first step.
- CM30 11y agoRandom related question then; how do smaller companies and individuals starting out in business for the first time compete? Because as much as advertising and marketing can be sleazy in its execution, it's also potentially a way that smaller companies can compete with incumbents. Remove that, and what's left? Brand recognition and word of mouth. The former is great for multinational corporations, but kind of bad for anyone trying to dethrone them. The latter can be good for smaller companies and individuals, but can take decades to become effective. Banning certain types of advertising is a good idea, but trying to ban all of it would kill competition.
- sandstrom 11y agoI think what some are missing here is whom the regulation (of gambling, alcohol/tobacco advertising, lending regulation etc) is ment to protect. Pulmonary physicians didn't need regulation to cease smoking[1], people with basic financial schooling probably won't get tricked by usury (which, interestingly, has been banned since medieval times but is now permitted in many countries), and so on. If you're an educated, conscientious person you don't need this (and are sometimes needlessly constrained by it, which can be frustrating). But it was never for you. It's for the struggling single-parent who would otherwise burn their paycheck on an online casino -- and get through the month with 300% payday loans. [1] http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.3322/canjclin.36.1.2/pdf http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.3322/canjclin.36.1.2/p...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- abalone 11y agoHe brings up a bunch of things, only one of which applies to Star Citizen: the "addictive" element of collecting things. Star Citizen is a game with genuinely exciting concepts and visuals exhibited in their marketing. The "addictive" thing that appears to have driven part of their $100M fundraise is prepurchasing cool-looking spaceships. But how would you regulate that? And what would be the impact on Lego kits, Star Wars action figures, Beanie Babies, coins, stamps, and other real-world collectibles? They have the same issues with OCD. Wouldn't it be arbitrary to limit it to software? If found it interesting that the author left the most potentially regulatable thing about Star Citizen untouched: consumer protections for crowdfunding investments.
- rwallace 11y agoOP is rolling two separate claims into one. The first claim is that there is a problem. Yes, I agree. There is. The second claim is that the solution is prohibition. The results of applying that solution to alcohol addiction and then drug addiction were... 'more harmful than beneficial' is much too mild a way to put it. 'Society-wrecking catastrophe' would be more accurate. Given those precedents, any argument that another round of prohibition is the right answer here requires far more justification than OP gives.
- erik14th 11y agoI'd draw the line at the point where the user/consumer can't easily recognize advertisement as advertisement. For example, paying people to write blog posts or to friend your client on social media without making the "I'm being paid to do it" part explicit should be illegal. I know nothing about US law, but shouldn't that be some kind of fraud crime or "confidence trick crime" already?
- oldmanjay 11y agoThat this person is putatively in the games industry does not bolster the point of the article, so I have to assume that used as a manipulative aid to help sell the idea therein. Mildly ironic, I suppose, but it's okay to manipulate when you are doing "the right thing" in some minds.
- JabavuAdams 11y agoI'm glad someone called out this "addicting" as a positive adjective nonsense. First of all, the word is "addictive". Second, how is this a positive for the user? I got addicted to Clash of Clans after starting to play for market research. I spent $400. It didn't hurt me financially, but it was very interesting to observe myself engaging in classic addict behaviour. "I can buy another gem pack because I'll just come in by transit tomorrow, so I won't have to pay for parking." "If I bring my lunch tomorrow, then that will cancel this other item." ... of course, knowing that I wouldn't do any of these things...
- njharman 11y ago> have an incredibly fine tuned and skillful marketing department bent on psychological manipulation. This. This is not specific to games industry. In fact they are rather late bloomers and amateurish. This is consumerism. This is production driven economy (in which goods are produced and post facto demand is manufactured). This is inevitable in any market with unequal ownership of resources (that is any market system were it's possible to profit or "get ahead", i.e. all of them). All advertising is this. Almost all marketing is this. It only varies in it's sophistication and subtleness. I can not fathom why people watch commercials, don't ad block, read advertising based periodicals, go to shopping centers, etc. Why people willingly participate in being psychologically manipulated into beliefs, decisions, and actions.
- fbbbbb 11y agoI think they mostly see the ads (read: products) as things that will influence their life positively. While this is true in the short term, brief entertainment in compensation for their money, it makes the life less significant in the long term, because their time was wasted not improving themselves. You are not the car you drive, you are not the contents of you wallet... Most people are short sighted. (I'm not pretending that this fully answers the question.)
- falcor84 11y agoI wonder how i is that South Park did a great episode[0] on this subject of addiction to freemium games, and neither the post nor anyone in over 100 episodes mentioned this. Is South Park completely passé? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freemium_Isn%27t_Free https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freemium_Isn%27t_Free
- fbbbbb 11y agoIt is becoming more and more current and relevant. I'm assuming you saw the current 19th season. If you didn't see it, or at least the last three episodes that form a "trilogy" or sorts, and talk about online ads and ad-blockers.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pandaman 11y agoI might be reading this wrong but this gentleman's problem seems to be that some companies make way more money than he thinks is "fair". Because all his sources are about who made how much. If this was similar to gambling he might be able to show a story or two of somebody mortgaging their house and/or losing job, taking a loan from mob and unable to pay it etc. etc. over addiction to Candy Crush as we have plenty of such stories about gambling. I have never seen anything similar about f2p games. At most you learn about kids dropping out of school to play DOTA/LoL/WoT/etc but this had been happening ever since there had been video games. Same kids dropped out over EQ/UO/WoW, which are not f2p. Heck, a dude dropped out of my school over a single player PC RPG (was either one of M&M or Wizardry games). I never heard of anybody becoming homeless trying to get their Farmville's dog to lv85. All there is are stories about somebody spending thousands of dollars at once to by some magic crystals in some stupid cell phone game. While it looks pretty stupid it does not seem any more danger to society than people buying pieces of painted canvas for millions and even tens of millions at art auctions.
- xacaxulu 11y agoI'm always wary of people who beg for more government control .
- andrewclunn 11y ago> "I guess at this point we could just say ‘A fool and his money are soon parted’" Yep.
- meanduck 11y agoOnly if the regulation get 90+% votes. I am so waiting for the future when one can switch (mobocratic) government like a house.
- ljbha007 11y agoI think the problem is not addiction itself. People are addictive to all kinds of things all the time, but most times it doesn't hurt people much. For example, being addicted to watching TV, maybe cause people to gain some extra pounds and waste their time, but in the end, it doesn't hurt much. But sometimes it does hurt, like gambling and drug abuse. The reason those things hurt is not just because they're addictive, but also that people are making money depending on how addictive you are. The money-making incentivizes people to manipulate consumer's behavior. Drug does this by the ways of bio-chemistry, gambling does this by the ways of psychology. In this way, addictive social games like Game of War is very similar to gambling. The problem with this kind of manipulation is that, like gambling, those addictive social games are selling people things that don't exist, don't have any actual value, and don't contribute to support a country's economy(it actually does the opposite). People won't want those things have they not been manipulated. Just psychological manipulation itself is not wrong. Even hard-working and honest companies need some kind of ways of spreading the word, and getting consumers to be in their favor in order to sell their products. It's not wrong if the product itself has some kind of actual value to the costumer. But in the case of addictive social games, if we look at it in a perfectly neutral way, the only value of the virtual items and perks they sell to the consumer is in the context of the in-game psychological manipulation context. Does a row of numbers in a MySQL database that doesn't mean anything elsewhere really worth $20 dollars? Obviously not. Does watching a picture of a sword or armor or animation of the building of a building really worth that $20 dollars? Highly doubtful. But that's what those addictive social games actually sells. They conditioned customers to pay for something they don't need even when the actual gameplay has become repetitive and boring long times ago. Let's think back and check: it sells people things of no actual value; it manipulates people to buy things of no actual value; its money-making solely depends on the manipulation. It sounds a whole lot like a fraud to me. If it's not illegal, I can't think of why frauds should be. I'm I missing something?
- ljbha007 11y agoI think the problem is not addiction itself. People are addictive to all kinds of things all the time, but most times it doesn't hurt people much. For example, being addicted to watching TV, maybe cause people to gain some extra pounds and waste their time, but in the end, it doesn't hurt much. But sometimes it does hurt, like gambling and drug abuse. The reason those things hurt is not just because they're addictive, but also that people are making money depending on how addictive you are. The money-making incentivizes people to manipulate consumer's behavior. Drug does this by the ways of bio-chemistry, gambling does this by the ways of psychology. In this way, addictive social games like Game of War is very similar to gambling. The problem with this kind of manipulation is that, like gambling, those addictive social games are selling people things that don't exist, don't have any actual value, and don't contribute to support a country's economy(it actually does the opposite). People won't want those things have they not been manipulated. Just psychological manipulation itself is not wrong. Even hard-working and honest companies need some kind of ways of spreading the word, and getting consumers to be in their favor in order to sell their products. It's not wrong if the product itself has some kind of actual value to the costumer. But in the case of addictive social games, if we look at it in a perfectly neutral way, the only value of the virtual items and perks they sell to the consumer is in the context of the in-game psychological manipulation context. Does a row of numbers in a MySQL database that doesn't mean anything elsewhere really worth $20 dollars? Obviously not. Does watching a picture of a sword or armor or animation of the building of a building really worth that $20 dollars? Highly doubtful. But that's what those addictive social games actually sells. They conditioned customers to pay for something they don't need even when the actual gameplay has become repetitive and boring long times ago. Let's think back and check: it sells people things of no actual value; it manipulates people to buy things of no actual value; its money-making solely depends on the manipulation. It sounds a whole lot like a fraud to me. If it's not illegal, I can't think of why frauds should be. I'm I missing something?
- hackuser 11y agoThe article the author links to is more revealing: http://toucharcade.com/2015/09/16/we-own-you-confessions-of-a-free-to-play-producer/ http://toucharcade.com/2015/09/16/we-own-you-confessions-of-...
- DaveSapien 11y agoI have talked in front of rooms full of my peers about abusing the vulnerable with predatory IAP's. Rooms full of artists (and students) applauded me. While rooms of more 'professional' developers booed me. I found more often than not, the 'professional' people that have a family to feed defended there moral very strongly. I could boil their argument (unfairly?) down to this, its ok to trick the vulnerable out of their money because I need to make money to feed my family. Where the more idealist artisans where more interested in the craft of games and earning the right to make money with good content. Its a weird rational to base your moral actions on. I count myself as an idealist, I care about people before my own ability to buy things. I don't think I have a right to make a living at what I love, an opportunity for sure, but thinking you have an entitlement to make money at making games seems to lead us to a dark place for us all.
- m0nty 11y agoNSFW tag would help.
- JabavuAdams 11y agoTerrible article, but raises some good issues. Would like to see a better discussion of those issues. One problem that I haven't seen mentioned elsewhere is that in my experience a large proportion of people in the games industry are essentially game addicts. They've forgone other opportunities, higher pay, IRL social interactions, family duties, etc. due to their passion for games. It's hard to have a serious conversation about games and addiction without examining this further.
- justinhj 11y agoI've been in the game industry for 20 years and I don't recognize this image you've painted at all
- JabavuAdams 11y agoGlad to hear it.
- CM30 11y agoIf they've foregone other opporunities, it might well be because working conditions in the games industry are (apparently) pretty awful, especially in large development houses. There seems to be an attitude going around that endless crunch is somehow a 'good' thing, so you get massive amounts of overtime and ridiculous working hours. Presumably, this then selects for people who like games so much that they're somewhat able to give up just about everything to make them. If the conditions were more stable and... normal, then you'd probably get a more 'diverse' group in the industry and likely also better games in general.