8 ms·
The Greatest Unsolved Problem in Theoretical Physics: Why Gravity Is So Weak
- scotty79 11y agoI'm not sure why physicists think gravity is a force and Pauling exclusion principle isn't. Gravity is fake "inertial" force caused by shape of the space time. Why do they insist that it should have gravitons when everything so far show it doesn't fit quantum field models?
- mrfusion 11y agoAnd how do gravitons escape a black hole? Am I right?
- contravariant 11y ago>I'm not sure why physicists think gravity is a force and Pauling exclusion principle isn't. >Gravity is fake "inertial" force caused by shape of the space time. Because all forces are like that? Electromagnetism is just a force created by the shape of the electromagnetic gauge field. In mathematical terms: it is the curvature of the gauge connection. In exactly the same way that gravity is a force created by the curvature of the metric connection.
- hasenj 11y agoI'm not sure if this comparison holds. Space-time is the environment that matter moves through. Curvatures in spacetime affects how matter moves. What is the electromagnetic gauge field? Why does it only affect charged particles? Why does it affect particles differently depending on the type of charge they hold (positive/negative)? It doesn't seem to be the same thing as spacetime.
- contravariant 11y agoGiven the nature of this subject not all your questions have definitive answers, but I'll try to give it my best shot. You should probably consider these answers a subjective interpretation, rather than objective facts. The most consistent interpretation of QFT I've seen so far views gauge fields as principal bundles. This implies that matter not only propagate through space-time but also through the gauge field, and the way it is 'changed' as it passes through the gauge field is related to the charge. Now technically the electromagnetic gauge field (and others) also affects uncharged particles, mainly because it couples to gravity, but perhaps also in more subtle ways (think of the way light can be affected by simply passing through a piece of matter). Admittedly there are quite a few differences (since the metric has a somewhat special position) but there are also quite a few similarities. Unfortunately nobody has yet found a (testable) theory that either unifies the forces or can treat the separately. I'm placing my bets on the 'unification' side though.
- avian 11y ago> I'm not sure why physicists think gravity is a force and Pauling exclusion principle isn't. http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/44712/is-pauli-repulsion-a-force-that-is-completely-separate-from-the-4-fundamental http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/44712/is-pauli-re... http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/141865/how-does-the-pauli-exclusion-principle-create-a-force-in-degenerate-matter http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/141865/how-does-t...
- scotty79 11y ago> It is not a force, since at the particle level forces have carriers that are exchanged between particles so that momentum and energy change. In other words, we couldn't fit it to model of quantum fields and carriers and it fits perfectly other model where it's not a force. Gravity could be described with same exact words. Although I agree that exclusion principle superficially looks much less like a force than gravity does. Still, gravity is exactly same as forces that come from choosing accelerating frame of reference ... are there plans to look for carriers of those forces as well? Or should we expect gravitons popping up once we accelerate that don't exist for stationary observer?
- evanb 11y agoGravitons are usually formulated by perturbing the metric around the flat Minkowski metric, but you can do perturbation theory around any metric, include those that describe accelerating frames. So, you might actually get gravitons in an accelerated frame. What you call background metric and what you call gravitons can get mixed together. However, because gravity is formulated in a generally covariant (ie. invariant under diffeomorphisms) the physical predictions must nevertheless agree when formulated in a frame-independent manner, much as they must in special relativity. Maybe the best example of quantum effects being different for accelerating and stationary observers is the Unruh Effect ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unruh_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unruh_effect ). If an observer accelerates relative to a 0-temperature vacuum, they will see a blackbody background with T ~ a.
- 11y ago
- krastanov 11y agoIt is not true that it does not fit quantum field models. Plenty of meaningful results have been derived from effective QFT (Hawking radiation for instance). The model does break at a certain scale, but that is true for models without gravity too.
- scotty79 11y ago> Plenty of meaningful results have been derived from effective QFT (Hawking radiation for instance). You mean unobservable (yet?) predictions? > The model does break at a certain scale, but that is true for models without gravity too. That's kind of deal breaker when it comes to gravity.
- krastanov 11y ago>> Plenty of meaningful results have been derived from effective QFT (Hawking radiation for instance). > You mean unobservable (yet?) predictions? Unruh effect is observed in accelerators (it warms up the particles in the acceleration rings). Admittedly it has to do more with the principle of equivalence than directly with gravity, but it would be hard to find a physicist that has an issue with this. >> The model does break at a certain scale, but that is true for models without gravity too. > That's kind of deal breaker when it comes to gravity. What do you mean? All our models break at certain energy scales and of course it is a deal breaker for all of them, no matter if we are talking about the Standart Model or an Effective QFT with gravity. Yes, we do not know what happens when curvatures reach the plank scale, but there are plenty of other things that we do not know even if we do not include gravity.
- scotty79 11y ago>>> The model does break at a certain scale, but that is true for models without gravity too. >> That's kind of deal breaker when it comes to gravity. > What do you mean? All our models break at certain energy scales ... I thought that by scale you meant size not energy and that theory breaks at larger distances (larger than typical distance for observable quantum effects). You can see how could I see this as a deal breaker for gravity that only over large distances is strong enough to be measurable).
- joncrocks 11y agoPauli, not Pauling. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pauli_exclusion_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pauli_exclusion_principle
- scotty79 11y agoouch, thank you ... shouldn't have relied on auto correct to guess the right physicist
- wodenokoto 11y agoI don't understand why this is a problem. It might sound silly, but isn't it like asking why blue is blue? If Gravity is a fundamental force, isn't it like a mathematical axiom? We can't really prove or explain it, it's just the basis for all the other rules.
- chriswarbo 11y agoElectricity and magnetism used to be considered separate phenomena, but then they were found to be two aspects of a single electromagnetic force. Electromagnetism and the weak force used to be considered separate phenomena, but then they were found to be two aspects of a single electroweak force. Progress can't be made if we just accept everything as-is and don't investigate more deeply.
- noir_lord 11y agoAgreed, and the interesting fundamental thing we discover this year sometimes has practical applications 30 years down the line. The semi-conductor wouldn't have existed except for such fundamental work in prior decades. I dislike the "well, that's just the way it is" response to our not understanding something (as do fortunately the smarter people than me scientists!).
- riffraff 11y agoI think what grandparent means is that the question in the title is odd, I thought the same thing, maybe the article explains it bit bit otherwise this seems based on a perception and thus noto really more interesting than, say, why is 3 larger than 2.
- leereeves 11y agoEven mathematical axioms are fertile ground for further research. Non-Euclidean geometry, for example, was born when mathematicians asked why Euclid's fifth postulate (the parallel postulate) is true.
- venomsnake 11y agoIt is not silly. The only reason life exists is because gravity is so weak. So it is better if we are able to know more about it. My favorite pet theory - was watching some of the superstructures of the universe - and was thinking how much the light matter represents the protein structure of a foam or a gel. The question is what is the filling since there is the vast bulk of the space in the universe.
- spodek 11y ago> science will never progress unless we try, and that’s what these ideas and searches are: our attempt to move our knowledge of the Universe forward. And as always, as the LHC’s Run II has already begun, I can’t wait to see what — beyond the already-discovered Higgs boson — just might turn up! If they want data from colliders, I would say it's a problem for experimental physics, or physics in general.
- bd 11y agoI remember reading a comment somewhere on the web that made it "click" for me: "Gravity is so weak that force of a tiny fridge magnet is able to counter gravity pull of the whole planet".
- tzs 11y agoThat approach has never really done it for me, because what makes it seem impressive is that the magnet is so much smaller than the planet. If you made the planet more dense, it would be smaller, making the comparison less impressive. Squeeze the planet all the way down to a black hole, and it would be about the size of the magnet. I think it works better to think of it in terms of the minimum force you can get. Imagine two test masses a fixed distance apart. The minimum non-zero electromagnetic force you can get between those two test masses is the force you get if each test mass has a charge equal to that of an electron. I'm not sure what the lowest mass particle is that you could reasonably hold near a test point, but since you can reasonably confine an electron to a small region the gravitational force between two electrons is an upper bound on the minimum gravitational force, and that is a ridiculous number of orders of magnitude lower than the minimum electromagnetic force.
- dhimes 11y agoThe ratio of the electric force to the gravitational force for two protons is a good way to get a numerical feel, but the intuitive "aha!" is what the demos are trying to help with. There's a similar demo for showing the strength of atmospheric pressure. You can boil a little water in a soda can, and quickly invert it into a little bowl of water. The water vapor inside quickly condenses causing a startling implosion of the can. It gives an intuitive feel for what 1 atm actually is. You think of astronauts going to where they have to counteract that pressure, and what would happen on failure, and you think "holy shit." Then you think of James Cameron going to where the pressure is 1000 times as great, and what would happen on failure, and you think "holy fucking shit!!"
- bd 11y ago> Then you think of James Cameron going to where the pressure is 1000 times as great, and what would happen on failure, and you think "holy fucking shit!!" Indeed, see Byford Dolphin diving bell accident (very NSFW/NSFL): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Byford_Dolphin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Byford_Dolphin
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rrggrr 11y agoI like to think of Gravity as a result of mass deforming space in the same way a brown turd deforms toilet water as it spins inevitably toward the outlet during flushing. Standing atop the turd you are affixed to its mass, but the entire system is affixed to the spinning, evacuating forces of the great flush. The Bono/Kurick South Park episode was instrumental in this theory's formulation.
- javajosh 11y agoBut physics doesn't answer this kind of question. We don't know why magnetism, for example, works the way it does - we just measure it's effects and model it with mathematics. OTOH I think it's interesting to imagine universes with stronger or weaker gravity, and to realize that in most of them it's hard to imagine life being possible at all. (Life would not arise without gravity (since you need to smush matter together to get life) but it also wouldn't arise with super strong gravity (since life needs to be able to move around).)
- castratikron 11y agoOne of my favorite possible explanations is the Large Number Hypothesis (LNH) by Dirac https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-o8mUyq_Wwg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-o8mUyq_Wwg
- xyzzy4 11y agoThe reason is because of the anthropic principle.
- adekok 11y agoA related issue is "If electricity and magnetism are so strong, why do we feel the effects of gravity more?" To see why this is the case, let's look at magnetism first. Every magnet is composed of a north pole and a south pole. If you split a magnet in two, you get two magnets, each with a north pole and a south pole. You never get a magnet with more "north" charges than "south". This means that the "north" and "south" portions of the field right are always next to each other. Which also means that when you go very far from a magnet, the net effect of the magnet is zero. Because the two fields cancel each other out. So we should expect that magnetism doesn't have many practical impacts on our daily life. If you're close to a magnet, you might feel it. But if you're far away, you won't be able to feel a magnetic field. Electricity is a bit different. The positive and negative charges can be separated from one another, unlike magnetism. This means that when electrical charges are separated, there is a force pulling them together for differing charges, or separating them for similar charges. The net effect over time is that most objects should be electrically neutral. Because the charges will naturally come together. So we should expect that electricity has an impact on our daily life. We should be able to tell when the charges are separated. This occurs only for a short time, until the charges move and cancel each other out. Gravity is different again. There is no "positive" and "negative" charges with gravity. It's all positive. This means that when two gravitational bodies are separated, there will be a force pulling them together. The net effect is that all objects with "gravitational charge" will tend to clump together. So we should expect that gravity has a huge impact on our lives. We should always be able to tell that gravity exists. Note that these conclusions are independent of the relative strengths of the forces. Magnetism and electricity will generally have net zero impact. Gravity will have net positive impact. If gravity was strong, like the other forces, then gravitational objects would group together. A lot. Which means that the universe would end up as one big clump of matter. It's only because gravity is weak that we have gravitational objects which are separate from each other for any extended period of time.
- rurban 11y agoBeing so weak is not the only disturbing attribute of gravity. It's also being the only far-reaching attracting force. Far reaching, not connected to mechanical forces is only explainable with the wave model, not the mechanical counterpart, and attractive is only similar to electro-magnetism, with a completely different explanation. That's what made Newton think of being a supernatural force created by god to hold all the planets and the universe together. And that's what made Heisenberg say: "Are you silly? An attracting force having the mechanical interpretation, the Higgs boson, which jumps on each other nucleons back to create an attraction?" That cannot be it.
- rurban 11y agoBeing so weak is not the only disturbing attribute of gravity. It's also being the only far-reaching attracting force. Far reaching, not connected to mechanical forces is only explainable with the wave model, not mechanical counterpart, and attractive is only similar to electro-magnetism, with a completely different explanation. That's what made Newton think of being a supernatural force created by god to hold all the planets and the universe together. And that's what made Heisenberg say: "Are you silly? An attracting force having the mechanical interpretation, the Higgs boson, which jumps on each other nucleons back to create an attraction?" That cannot be it.