8 ms·
Books Are Getting Longer
- datavision 11y agoUnfortunately I can't even read a book cover to cover, only skim through interesting parts.
- askafriend 11y agoI think this applies to a vast majority of people outside the academic environment (or once they leave that environment). I really wonder why that is. I've definitely noticed my mind wander once I start reading a book. It seems like we can all benefit from training our attention span.
- datavision 11y agoThanks for the reply, after getting down-voted for sharing I was wondering if I am out of touch. I was formerly in an academic environment where you had to read everything at least three times over. After reading densely packed scientific literature and I now just search for the information I am interested in and skim through everything else because I realize how increasingly limited is my time.
- chubot 11y agoI upvoted you for being honest... and I just replied -- I think it's a problem if you can't finish ANY book, but I wouldn't worry about finishing most books. I don't think it is effective to read scientific literature from cover to cover. I think the best scientists skim.
- mandor 11y agoAs a scientist, I am most efficient when I skim with a goal. Typically, I would search for an answer to a very specific question (related to my own research) and just ignore whole parts of the book/article.
- chubot 11y agoI don't actually view it as a problem -- as long as you can finish GOOD books. (I was reading "breadth first" since before 2000, before my and everyone else's Internet addiction...) My usual habit is to check out 5 books at a time from the library, and I end up finishing one. The other 4 I skim through. There's simply not that many books that are worth reading in their entirety. Many books have useful nuggets of knowledge, but there is generally a lot of filler. I have read at least 1000 academic papers in CS and other fields in the last 5 years. And by read I mean mostly skimmed. A good paper will get 3 or 4 re-readings; most papers remain skimmed until something else reminds me of them (a paper or a problem in real life). I think that is the norm. I do find that paper is better for comprehension. I get my books from the library and I print out PDFs of publications. tl;dr The goal is comprehension, not "finishing books"
- jessriedel 11y agoMostly agree with this, but I don't think one should expect there to be a perfect correlation between enjoyment/engagement and worthwhile-ness. Most book and most articles are garbage, but there really are a few that are both painful and worthwhile. Now if only we could convince the rest of the world to make abstracts the norm for books, internet articles, and the like...
- datavision 11y agoAbstracts of everything, to just get the facts. Yes please!
- datavision 11y agoI agree chubot++, the knowledge you gain (ROI) is more important rather spending time reading possibly non relevant "filler". At university, certain professors (aka one really naughty chemistry professor) expected complete mastery of the subject and would have several questions in the examination that were not even covered by the assigned reading. (He expected us to read the entire textbook anyway) I also prefer technical manuals in PDFs and just CTRL+ F through them as needed.
- mbrock 11y ago
- officemonkey 11y agoIt's definitely a training issue. I was reading 15-20 books a year, but two years ago a switch flipped and I'm reading 50-80 books a year. The main thing that people have to give themselves is time. Reading takes time, and a lot of people think 15 minutes before bedtime is enough.
- paozac 11y agoTrue. I've been wondering why mainstream films are getting longer, too. 2-2.5 hours has become the norm.
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoDepending on the exact film/genre I don't have a problem with that.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI've heard Quentin Tarantino's new film "Hateful Eight" is ~3 hours long, and I'm still quite excited to see it.
- guard-of-terra 11y agoI do. Mainstream movies became a caleidoscope of boring repeating scenes. They often lack any sort of plot. Compare "Back to the Future" (any one) with whatever new movie in this genre you can remember.
- icebraining 11y agoIt's not exactly the same genre since it's not futuristic, but last year's The Grand Budapest Hotel is also a light-hearted & fanciful adventures film, and it certainly has a plot - besides being a much better film all around than any of the BttF trilogy, in my opinion. On the other hand, it's also only 100 min. long, so it doesn't exactly fit with trend of longer movies.
- abrowne 11y agoI think 90–100 minutes is perfect. Anything longer and I'd prefer multiple episodes.
- wahnfrieden 11y agoRecently some more films have cropped up that are around 60 minutes - an awkward length somewhere between what you'd typically classify "short film" vs. "feature film". Because it's not clearly classifiable as one or the other, films of this length suffer uphill financing and marketability challenges. Unfortunate, because no length is strictly better than another, it's up to how the film works with the time it has. So it's encouraging to see some filmmakers work with the ~60 minute range now that there're more alternatives for commercially releasing a film these days.
- WalterBright 11y ago> completion rates that can fall as low as 20% for some titles. I have so many books to read, that I don't bother finishing a book unless it's really good. The "some titles" are probably simply poor books. Also, the number of pages isn't necessarily a good indicator of size. The typography can greatly influence the number of words on a page, and the typography can and does vary widely.
- kiba 11y agoI like really long non-fiction series. A 100,000 words is just a starting point. But to get there, it has to keep my interest for that long.
- thrownaway2424 11y agoHere's one that must be a million words https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Years_of_Lyndon_Johnson https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Years_of_Lyndon_Johnson
- sosuke 11y agoWorm Web Serial is pretty good. A couple of 'down' spots but I devoured it in a couple weeks. "It totals roughly 1,680,000 words" https://parahumans.wordpress.com/ https://parahumans.wordpress.com/
- jseliger 11y agoI wonder if this is true of self-published, ebook-first writers. In conversations with agents about my novels, I was told that they needed to be "longer" and that ~70K words wasn't enough or wasn't sufficiently "commercial." But in my view the novels were the appropriate length to the material (see http://jakeseliger.com/my-novels/ http://jakeseliger.com/my-novels/ if you're curious). With ebooks, I don't think readers are subconsciously swayed by length as they are by physical books in bookstores. Indie authors also often point out that they're better off splitting one massive tome into multiple parts. A novel like Neal Stephenson's Seveneves might've been split into three to five parts, with the first one given away and each additional part $.99 – $2.99 in its ebook edition. EDIT: Also, I'm not opposed to being commercial, and indeed if I could think of more / better ways to be more "commercial" I'd do it!
- dalyons 11y agoCounter; installments (if you're a well known author) might mean you make less money, b/c people drop off after the first part & never buy the rest. Whereas before, even if they got bored & didn't finish it, they'd already paid in full. (Installments aside, Seveneves needed heavy editing. Great plot, but probably about 1/3 cruft. I get it; you studied orbital mechanics & it's cool, but the 100th detailed explanation of orbital transfer is too much)
- Selinica 11y agoThat depends on the cut the author would get from a publisher or leftover profit if they deal with the printing and distributing channels themselves. From the view of the buyer, it's really easy to rationalize the low cost of an ebook, and even if the first part is free, as long as it engages people enough most will come back for the latter parts. A regular physical book would need to engage people on the description to start with to convince people of the higher cost of it. Then there would be the people who sit down and read it through in the bookstore, they would need to be convinced enough of re-readability in order to buy it, or they become lost potential income, same as someone dropping a series after the first free ebook due to it not being interesting enough for them.
- 11y ago
- sdenton4 11y agoProbably about half of the novels I read could work just as well as short stories... (especially in science fiction.) It's like Strunk and White said: Omit Needless Words.
- pandres 11y agoFor short bs we now have the internet.
- dionidium 11y agoAaron Swartz had some interesting things to say about the length of most non-fiction: http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/001229 http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/001229
- Joof 11y agoCame to say something along these lines. Often books say very little in as many words as possible. Part of a 'more stuff for your money' philosophy. Textbooks have this problem as well until you hit graduate subjects.
- bubalus 11y agoA lot of the best graduate textbooks are pdfs of lecture notes. 40 pages, no nonsense.
- mertd 11y agoI wonder if Amazon (and other e-book reader vendors) can do something about this. Add a feature to trim the book only to the pages or sections that people have highlighted, shared, spent time on the most.
- mziel 11y agoAnd of course the real title is "The big question: are books getting longer?". Re: article, it's disheartening that good books suffer from this as well. I've recently read "The power of habit" and "Think fast and slow". Both are great, but both would be much better at the half of their size. For most non-fiction content the magazine article is too short (3-8 pages) and only skims over the issue. It's evident when you read an article on something you're very familiar with. However book is too long (300 pages) and introduces filler and repetitions. I find that Special Reports from The Economist are quite good in size and depth (15-30 pages). My ideal would be around 100 pages, but those reports are still my go-to place if I want to read something.
- tedmiston 11y ago> Both are great, but both would be much better at the half of their size. This brings to mind a comment Jason Fried made in Rework: “Writers eliminate good pages to make a great book. We cut this book in half between the next-to-last and final drafts. From 57,000 words to about 27,000 words. Trust us, it’s better for it.”
- wslh 11y agoThis is more extreme now where our attention jumps from link to link. We can't separate this issue from the Internet era.
- RightWingRabble 11y agoWe subconsciously equate size with value. A physical book sitting on a shelf benefits from being (or looking) large, especially if it costs $15. Digital books don't suffer from the misconception and lots of independently written books are shorter than those intended for print. That's my perception, anyway. I'd be curious to see hard numbers comparing book sizes between those intended for print and those that are e-book only.
- dang 11y ago> And of course the real title is "The big question: are books getting longer?". But the body of the article contains nothing to the contrary, so it seems the submitter's edit was in keeping with the guidelines (i.e. change the title if it is misleading).
- aluhut 11y agoI'm pretty sure that I would have put Anathem away if I had it in paper. Unfortunately it wasn't and I was trapped in a good example of an horribly overstretched big book. Sometimes there is a good idea hidden in those kind of books but most of the times it's just a cheap shallow story you've read before in a different setting. I consider it a sign that the author either was forced to write a sequel/prequel or that he's just a bad writer. Most of the times, I don't touch those authors works again.
- jib 11y agoI enjoyed all of Anathem and would have happily read another 500 pages of it. Not sure if Stephenson is the best example, his long book style is quite unique. Usually it works for me (Anathem, Cryptonomicon, I've read both at least twice) other times it doesn't (The baroque series I haven't finished). Snow crash and Zodiac are examples of him writing shorter good books too.
- zem 11y agoStephenson is interesting that way - I think his finest book is "the diamond age", which does not ramble, but his most enjoyable one (slightly more than diamond age even) is cryptonomicon, and the long digressions are precisely what makes it so enjoyable.
- aluhut 11y agoYes, I fell for a urgent recommendation by a person like you ;) I have no idea how you can cope with all that utter irrelevance in this. While reading I started thinking that Stephenson tried to create a "moment" by overstreching. A scenery. Something you see in those slow artistic movies for example. But then there is another problem. Stephenson is unable to describe the environment in which the scene plays. Instead he concentrates on completely irrelevant details in the current area. A good example for this was when the protagonist traveled a region where former cities were. It looked like that: "...traveling along those dead cities we've learned to distinguish the time period in which the cities have been build...". But he describes not a single one. You end up having absolutely no picture of the environment. He tells you that there are launch pads and anti-missile turrets but not how they look. Instead he drags you through several sentences regarding the steel rubble they get from the cities. Spoiler: it's rusty. Same poor writing goes for character development (main character is supposed to be clever according to the context but is plainly stupid and really slow...), basic aspects like the love story or the weird way he describes women. I don't know. Maybe I'm just too demanding but I currently read through some of Alestair Raynolds works and it makes Stephenson look like a rich school boy whos private teacher was afraid to mark the basic mistakes for him. I've read Snow Crash many years ago. When Neuromancer and the art of those times was still in my head. Fortunately because it was exactly the same thing. Please read Snow Crash again and try to focus on the world he un-describes. I had the feeling like Stephenson took it for granted that you've already read Gibson or Sterling and knew how the world is supposed too look like so he can concentrate on world details that are completely irrelevant for the story and make no sense without describing the place they stand in. You see...I fell twice for Stephenson which was a mistake on my side so I'm pretty angry on myself and try do divert the fault to him...
- dudul 11y agoKind of off topic but it always bugs me when I see people using 'average' as a metric. Average is awful, it is a lossy metric that doesn't capture distribution. What if there are only very big books (600+ pages) and very small books (100 pages), we can end up with an average of 325 pages which is actually not any book.
- TheAceOfHearts 11y agoSorta related to this topic, I'd suggest giving audiobooks a chance! They're definitely not for everyone, but I've become a huge fan. Every time I need to drive somewhere or I have to clean around the house, I play an audiobook. They're also great if you lead a sedentary lifestyle (e.g. in front of computer all day). Reading books will probably necessitate more sitting around, but with audiobooks you can be a little bit more active and go out for a jog or walk.
- tedmiston 11y ago+1 audio books For me, I can digest one much quicker than reading. I got a few from Audible this year. The content is great, but their one size fits all credit system is archaic. I would love to see a Spotify-like audio book subscription service.
- TheAceOfHearts 11y agoI'm subscribed to Audible as well; I generally like it. The 2 credit per month plan covers my needs pretty well. In some occasions I've had to buy extra credits, but it still ends up being much cheaper than buying individual audiobooks. It definitely pushes you to strike a balance between longer and shorter books, though. It's kinda crazy that a 4-hour story like The Magic Goes Away and a a 50-hour novel like A Dance with Dragons both end up consuming 1 credit.
- trendroid 11y ago>citing studies showing that only 60% of books bought electronically are ever begun, and completion rates that can fall as low as 20% for some titles. Well, how about the completion rates of physical books? I am sure most people would rather read smaller, to the point books if they could. Moreover, there are also social brownie points associated with buying thick books. If everyone is talking about it, buying that popular book in physical form will increase the aesthetic look of my "home library" and then when people come over, I can show off how well read I am. Also the top comment on the article page importantly notes: "AAARRRGGGGHHH!!! Count the words, not the pages!!!! Some simple typesetting changes can increase or decrease a books page count significantly. A bigger book may look more intimidating, but it may also look like better value for money, and if production/material costs have gone down over the last 15 years, I wouldn't be at all surprised if a publisher bumps up the paragraph spacing and brings in the page margins to make a book appear longer than it is."
- DennisP 11y agoI'm definitely more likely to finish a kindle book, just because I almost always have it with me.
- viraptor 11y agoIsn't this a bit skewed though? I've not read maybe half the books in my library, but that's simply because either I bought something like a humble bundle where I was only really interested in 2-3 of them anyway, or because I bought whole series at discounted price and stopped after first two books. Kind of similar to Steam games - 37% of games were never played. If I can get a set of Witcher 1,2,3 for the price of one + $1, then I'm definitely getting all of them, even if I'm really interested in the third one only right now.
- minimaxir 11y agoFrom the title I was expecting a line chart of average book length over time. Is there an API to get book metadata for all books?
- beambot 11y agoDifficult to assess objectively, but I wonder if the quality has degraded accordingly (eg. due amateur self-publishing)? In my experience, being more concise so as to produce better writing is difficult and time intensive -- a la the famous Blaise Pascal quote: > I would have written a shorter letter, but I did not have the time.
- Joof 11y agoIs there anywhere that extremely well thought out and detailed short stories could thrive? I want to find those. I've read plenty of long books in my lifetime.
- habosa 11y agoThis is strange to me since our attention spans are getting so much shorter. I read only fiction, slightly less than a book a week. This year I've read books between 75 and 1200 pages and I dont think there is any correlation between length and my enjoyment. I do notice that for many authors their self-proclaimed 'masterpiece' tends to be their longest book. And in many cases, not their best.
- cafard 11y agoI think a lot of people read books with only partial attention; this helps to explain the five-star reviews of books stuffed full of absurdities.
- ilzmastr 11y agonah, fonts are getting larger and whitespace is ballooning :) just kidding, I wouldn't know for sure, but this article should have graphs of wordcounts or something.
- MichaelMoser123 11y agoWith some books on history i noticed that the author has reworked his PhD thesis into a book - now that's a long bummer by definition, If that is the case then that makes the book quite long to start with - (i think that's the right thing to do BTW). One example: The PhD thesis: "Political Protest and Dissent in the Khrushchev Era" by Robert Hornsby" (342 pages) the book would be "Protest, Reform and Repression in Khrushchev's Soviet Union" by Robert Hornsby (324 pages)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]