9 ms·
> The food companies have marched around the grocery store, adding sweetness, engineering bliss points to products that didn’t used to be sweet. This is why is
by dahart 11y ago
> The food companies have marched around the grocery store, adding sweetness, engineering bliss points to products that didn’t used to be sweet.
This is why is now really hard to cut refined sugar out of your diet, because they put it in everything.
> It is no secret that the rise in obesity in America has something to do with food. But how much?
Those first two sentences seriously made me laugh out loud. What are the other possible factors? One might say a more sedentary lifestyle, except I've heard that rates of exercise and outdoor activity have been going up. (I'll see if I can dig up a reference.) But maybe more important is that fact that you can sit in a chair all day and not gain weight if you simply control your calorie intake to match you activity level... Which is the only thing that needs to happen regardless of what you do during the day, inside or outside, lazy or active. Maybe that intro was trying not to come out and blame the food industry for the whole thing in the first 10 words, or leave the reader hanging so they don't stop there, but the probability that out obesity epidemic isn't 100% due to diet is zero.
- subpixel 11y agoI've been giving intermittent fasting a try and it's been quite amazing to me to realize how I've always equated the slightest feeling of hunger with the idea that "I must eat, I'm starving!". I think this is pretty common. With some willpower and practice, I can now eat nothing but a single bowl of cereal in a 24hr period, including 60m of hard exercise, without anything remotely like hunger pangs. It takes getting used to not constantly rewarding the thought of food with food. It's sort of a drastic measure, but the only one that has enabled me to lose real weight - plus there are purported health benefits: http://www.mensjournal.com/magazine/the-benefits-of-occasional-fasting-20121116 http://www.mensjournal.com/magazine/the-benefits-of-occasion...
- benten10 11y agoYou can do even better than a bowl of cereal. Eat something fatty, and even eating a little will significantly reduce your hunger. These days fatty food, such as cheese and creamy yogurt have been a staple of my diet: I can go by for a lot longer without eating much that way. The fruit-fat-nuts diet is _completely_ doable (of course, I eat 'normal' food too, for a more balanced diet, but only in the weekends, etc.)
- CompelTechnic 11y agoI cannot find full fat yogurt in any of my local grocery stores. Is "low fat" as good as it gets? Seems like the low-fat diet craze of the recent past, and the current greek yogurt phenomenon, mean that "zero fat" and "low fat" are the only two options.
- jokamoto 11y agoNot sure if it qualifies as "full fat" per se, but Noosa brand yogurt has roughly twice the fat content of most Greek yogurts I've tried (seems to really help texture/flavor as well).
- ashark 11y ago2% Fage is usually the best I can find. The low fat ones are marketing BS—loaded with sugar so they don't taste like nothing. Unfortunately that's very nearly the only thing available at most stores. Misleading advertising/labelling defeats good food yet again.
- ashmud 11y agoStonyfield and Fage make full fat yogurts, for example. I do not remember seeing any at the grocery chain giants, though. More specialized groceries (e.g., Whole Foods, some "ethnic" stores) may carry a full fat yogurt. http://www.stonyfield.com/products/yogurt/smooth-creamy/whole-milk-plain http://www.stonyfield.com/products/yogurt/smooth-creamy/whol... http://usa.fage.eu/product/fage-total-7-oz http://usa.fage.eu/product/fage-total-7-oz
- benten10 11y agoAssuming you shop at U.S supermarkets, you can _usually_ find full-fats, but they are almost always the store brand. There are very limited flavor options with full-fat though. Ohh, what I'd give for full(even extra!) fat yogurt with not a lot of sugar. : ( The best yogurt I have had, by far, far, is Juju Dhau, from Nepal. It's so heavy and creamy, it feels like a meal in itself. Hey investors, ya hear me? Juju dhau might be the next Chobani! http://tasteofnepal.blogspot.com/2012/02/juju-dhau-king-of-yogurt-from-bhaktapur.html http://tasteofnepal.blogspot.com/2012/02/juju-dhau-king-of-y...
- sopooneo 11y agoI am interested in trying this, but if I don't eat breakfast, I am sometimes so light headed by 11:00am that I am literally almost falling over and my brain doesn't function. Any advice or articles you'd recommend?
- rob_61 11y agoHere is the best summary I've seen on IF... http://antranik.org/intermittent-fasting/ http://antranik.org/intermittent-fasting/ btw, I've been practicing IF for 2+ years and love it.
- pc86 11y agoIF is by definition just about constraining your food intake to a certain window of time. Most people do this later in the day out of necessity or habit (e.g. 2-7), but there's no reason your window couldn't be 6-10. The downside is that you are much more likely to cheat if you do this, because now you have to go all afternoon and evening without eating, and then go to sleep. Psychologically it's much easier to wake up and be able to say "only 6 more hours to eat" and go to bed a few hours after your last meal than it is to eat your last meal, have 12 waking hours left, then try to go to sleep with a grumbling belly. Edit: A lot of people practice IF without even realizing it. The most popular form (mentioned in rob_61's linked article) is 16/8. If you don't eat until lunch and don't do a late dinner, it's very likely you fall in the 16/8 window.
- andy_ppp 11y agoHow much water have you had? Eat something fatty and high in protein. Your body never enters fat burning mode - as you get used to fasting once per week this process will get easier, like anything really.
- ksk 11y agoHave you tried gradually increasing the fasting window over time?
- vinceguidry 11y agoI've done IF and lost 40 lbs with it. My advice is to eat something really small, and see what the smallest breakfast you can get away with is. After a month or so, try stopping breakfast and see how you make out then. My understanding is that the gut and vagus nerve are very sensitive to disruptions, any changes in routine have large initial perceived effects, until a new equilibrium is established. I think this mechanism is why diets are so faddish and people think they have food allergies when they actually don't. So, mitigate the worst of the symptoms, be willing to accept some temporary discomfort, and iterate towards a better diet over time.
- ljk 11y ago> * I've been giving intermittent fasting a try and it's been quite amazing to me to realize how I've always equated the slightest feeling of hunger with the idea that "I must eat, I'm starving!". I think this is pretty common.* Not as extreme, but recently started to eat less for lunch(before: eating out, burger/sandwich + fries + drink, etc, now: homemade food, fruits) and already I don't get the afternoon snooze, and haven't needed coffee in a long time! also haven't been to any fast food restaurants or had soda in a few months, hopefully I can break the one-year mark!
- benten10 11y agoI have a fun story to share about how I created a soda-disgust in myself! In college at one point, I was drinking soda almost every day. It was bad for me and I knew it, but couldn't help. So one day, I froze a bottle of some soda, and then let it thaw, sipping it after. It was the nastiest, sweetest, most awful-headaching thing I've ever put in my mouth. Having discovered what soda 'really' was, I stopped drinking it. I drink it maybe once in a year at most, but that's about it.
- mtreis86 11y agoIt was not until I started a ketogenic diet, that I learned the difference between hungry and thirsty. The signals are very very similar, at least for me.
- vonmoltke 11y agoThe problem is in conflating weight with overall health, which most media reporting does. Weight is primarily controlled by the quantity of food you eat (it is not "100% due to diet" because there do exist conditions that cause people to carry too much weight even with a "normal" diet), but to assume all problems are purely a result of weight is reductionist and incorrect. Being obese is neither necessary nor sufficient to develop metabolic and other health problems. Those problems arise from lack of activity, diet composition, and other factors beyond simply weight. Those problems are also the core plague of the "obesity epidemic", so it would behoove society not to focus so narrowly on weight and to focus on overall health (of which weight is a component).
- adrianN 11y agoThat's like saying "smoking is neither necessary nor sufficient to develop lung cancer".
- vonmoltke 11y agoWhich is also true, but the statements are not equivalent. Tobacco use (and actually, all forms of smoke inhalation) has a specific, acute mechanism whereby use increases the chances of lung cancer and other respiratory problems. We do not have that kind of causal link for obesity-related diseases. There is a correlation between weight and several so-called lifestyle diseases, but the causal link is fuzzy. That lack of causation is why reducing the obesity problem to a simple matter of weight control is a bad idea. There are other mechanisms at play, particularly related to body composition, that appear to be sensitive to diet composition and activity levels. Telling people they can be sedentary as long as they don't eat too much (which is basically what the original post I was replying to was saying) is dangerous.
- chillydawg 11y agoDiet = 99% Other Factors = therest%
- vonmoltke 11y ago
- chongli 11y agoThe rule for shopping in the grocery store is simple: stay out of the aisles, stick with fresh produce and lean meats.
- dayon 11y agoThis will lead to a lot of carbs, some protein, and not enough fat. Consider looking into the Keto Diet. Lots of people are restricting carbs while being liberal with fat, successfully lowering their weight and having more energy. I'm one of those people. The trick is that fat consumption doesn't lead to weight gain. It's glucose production from carbs and sugars that leads to weight gain.
- miguelrochefort 11y agoWhy lean meats?
- sunwooz 11y agoCulture plays a large role. It's become a thing in America where 'fat shaming' is looked down upon. Although, shaming someone should obviously be looked down upon, merely pointing out the fact that someone is getting fat should not be deemed as 'fat shaming'. In Korea, people regularly tell each other if they're getting fat, which is not taken as an insult, but is a factual statement and is classified as 'caring' and a 'worry' rather than 'shaming'.
- Jtsummers 11y agoMy recollection of my time in Korea was that people often lived nearer extended family. This contrasts with my experiences as an American in the US, where many of us do not live near relatives, and a lot of (younger?) folks don't have a significant number (say, more than 3 or 4 locally) of close friends. I'll call this the "intimacy gap". I'm not close enough to anyone that I see on a regular basis that they'd feel comfortable commenting about my weight like that (ok, less true these days with a ton of close friends, but more true a few years back).
- pvnick 11y ago> What are the other possible factors? High-caloric drinks
- wtetzner 11y agoDoes that not count as food?
- pvnick 11y agoYou could argue that, but I wouldn't say so. IIRC (I'd need to go back and dig up the research I read) high-calorie drinks appear to lack the satiating effect that solid foods have, even the high-caloric foods. The point is that high-caloric drinks (sodas, beer, gatoraid, etc) may throw off the body's energy/weight equilibrium more than junk foods.
- dahart 11y agoI will argue that. Coke is definitely, in my mind, part of the "food industry". I speculate the article's author was also including soda manufacturers, due to the use of Dr. Pepper as an example. I personally believe soda is a major contributor to rising negative health problems. This is why I agree completely with and upvoted your previous comment that sugary drinks are a factor.
- enraged_camel 11y ago>>the probability that out obesity epidemic isn't 100% due to diet is zero. Don't be so sure. Stress also causes the body to start hoarding more calories. And if you think about it, people have been working longer and longer hours, and have a lot less job security than they used to in the past. So it is possible that all that extra stress is contributing to the rising obesity rates.
- kuschku 11y agoIndeed. But even then, the body can only hoard calories that you eat. As long as you spend more calories than you eat (even if you feel shit from that), the energy stored in the fat in your body will go down.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoThe problem is the issue of choice. Going to sleep in a choice most of the time, but if you stay up too late your body will make that choice for you. With eating, while it isn't as drastic an effect, having high stress and having the body demanding calories will alter how your mind makes choices related to food. It takes higher levels of willpower to not gain weight when you have more stress. And many people can't just increase their willpower to compensate.
- dahart 11y ago^ True, ^^ True, and ^^^ True, every comment here is valuable! I think @kuschku got the (slightly tongue-in-cheek) intent behind my original comment, but you're right, and the choice/willpower problem is there, and it ranges from difficult to impossible to overcome for many people! This is actually a big part of why the food industry's actions putting sugar and fat in everything in order to make it sell more, regardless of the health effects, is being seen more and more as bordering on malicious and being considered for oversight and regulation. Food manufacturers, as businesses, should be doing whatever they can to sell more, but as providers of basic human needs, their sales tactics are now actively working against our interests. Our physiologies are built to take more food than necessary when its available, so these perfectly engineered high calorie bliss-point foods make willpower harder to fight than ever before!
- beachstartup 11y agodon't forget - people don't cook food anymore. i cook dinner every night (usually roasted vegetables and some protein) and i'm seen as some kind of weirdo. some people get offended if you ask them if they know how to cook. i don't know how american culture got to this point. it's insane.
- Jtsummers 11y ago> i don't know how american culture got to this point. Time. People don't think they have time to cook, and they may not. They also don't know how to reclaim their time for themselves from various work and social obligations. Advertisement. Starting with TV dinners in the 60s (?) and fast food restaurants (also 60s), we have "cheap" and quick ways to get meals that don't require a great deal of personal effort, and it's shown to us constantly on television. EDIT: Words. I can use the right ones sometimes.
- xorcist 11y agoThis is a constantly perpetuated myth. It is the image that advertisers sell us. If it's something Americans have it's time. Do you know how many hours of TV is watched every day, on average?
- function_seven 11y agoUp until about a month ago, that was me. I literally never turned on my oven for weeks on end. My stove was primarily used for boiling the Cup-O-Noodle water. I got fast food (or slow-but-still-bad food) for ~ 90% of my meals. I also have a belly that needs to go, so I decided to start counting calories and staying completely out of the drive-thrus. This has been a real eye-opener! By best estimate is that my former diet was probably about 3,000 C a day. Now that I'm watching what I eat, I'm easily running at 1,800 and not feeling hungry.
- beachstartup 11y agoif you haven't already, get a cast iron pan. get it nice and hot, throw a chicken leg and some vegetables or fruit (cauliflower, brussels sprouts, tomatoes, potatoes, whatever) in there, season and sear, and then throw it in the oven for 30 mins @ 350 and eat. make yourself an adult beverage, or not, while you wait. prep and cleanup is literally 2 or 3 minutes. you don't even have to wash cast iron, you just wipe it off. ~500 calories even if you douse everything in olive oil, and filling. i do this like 3 or 4 nights a week. it's SO much better than a sad sack of takeout.
- kragen 11y ago> What are the other possible factors [than food]? Could be stress levels, perhaps due to imprisonment of family members or economic inequality, both of which have skyrocketed in the US in recent decades. Other aspects of economic inequality, such as a shift toward emergency medical treatment, are also possible causes. It's observable that the social classes most affected by obesity in the US (and, now, worldwide) are the poorest; this might be due to food, but it might not be. Could be infectious diseases, which are always changing, or more generally, microbiome changes. Diet changes (e.g. increase in sugar, or increase in usage of emulsifiers such as methylcellulose: http://www.nature.com/news/food-preservatives-linked-to-obesity-and-gut-disease-1.16984 http://www.nature.com/news/food-preservatives-linked-to-obes...) are one possible cause of microbiome changes, but far from the only one. For example, obesity-associated intestinal microbiomes have been shown to be contagious under some conditions: http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v444/n7122/full/nature05414.html http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v444/n7122/full/nature0... Another possible cause, though: antibiotics are well known to cause microbiome changes (although maybe this is still "has something to do with food", since most of the antibiotics you consume during your lifetime are in meat.) And antibiotics are also known to induce weight gain — that's why they get put in the meat in the first place, to induce the meat animals to gain weight faster, reducing the time to slaughter. Maybe they make you gain weight too, and they might do that by means other than changing your gut microbiome. Antibiotic use, both in humans and in livestock, has undergone substantial changes over the past decades, and their possible effects on obesity are not well understood. Another possible cause: dramatically increased air travel and the ensuing jet lag; circadian rhythm disruption has been shown to induce metabolic dysfunction in a wide variety of animal models. http://www.pnas.org/lens/pnas/111/47/16647 http://www.pnas.org/lens/pnas/111/47/16647 For the same reason: artificial lighting. Artificial lighting color temperature as we switch from incandescent to fluorescent, LED, and computer and TV screens. Sedentary lifestyles are a possible cause — rates of "exercise" are only going up if you don't count manual labor as "exercise", and rates of manual labor are going way down. Worldwide testosterone levels are falling for unknown reasons; testosterone is very well known to reduce body fat. http://www.globalresearch.ca./health-and-the-environment-testosterone-levels-fall-worldwide/30129 http://www.globalresearch.ca./health-and-the-environment-tes... One possible hypothesis advanced for the dramatic testosterone level drop is exposure to environmental contaminants such as pesticides; the pesticides we use, the amount we use, and the places we use them have changed dramatically over the last few decades. Whether or not this affects our testosterone levels, it could easily affect our bodies in other ways, possibly promoting obesity. (Other factors that are known to lower testosterone levels include stress and lack of exercise.) Other environmental contaminants with dramatically changing exposure levels over time and that might reasonably be endocrine disruptors include PCBs, phthalates (as the above article mentions), bisphenol-A, lead, and the halogenated flame retardants used in polyurethane foam, which have been circumstantially implicated in the modern epidemic of feline hyperthyroidism. The lower levels of lead and PCBs in the environment are probably good for us, but sometimes there are surprising interactions. > the probability that out obesity epidemic isn't 100% due to diet is zero. You, you are an arrogant, pompous idiot, too ignorant even to begin to imagine the extent of your own ignorance.