5 ms·
The mobile adblocking apocalypse hasn’t arrived
- putlake 11y agoI run an Alexa top 10K website with an ad-based revenue model. iOS content blocking has not materially impacted overall revenue because 1. Even though mobile accounts for about 50% of traffic, it only accounts for 25% of revenue anyway. 2. iOS devices, for some reason, monetize way lower than Android. 25% mobile revenue breaks out into 10% iOS and 15% Android. Could be because the site uses Adsense and Google knows much more about Android users so can target ads better. 3. Most mobile users don't download apps. I'm too lazy to dig up the research right now but IIRC the number of people who only use stock apps is about 50%. So people just haven't bothered to download content blocking apps; because they don't bother to download any apps. So while the mobile _adblocking_ apocalypse is a nonevent, the fact that mobile monetizes way lower anyway means that over the last few years -- as mobile share of traffic has grown -- revenue per user has slowly eroded. That slow-moving apocalypse has already occurred. Adblocking on iOS hasn't done much to make things worse. Adblocking on desktop continues to hurt, and has a much bigger impact.
- bpodgursky 11y ago> iOS devices, for some reason, monetize way lower than Android I imagine since iOS third party cookies are transient, you're going to have much lower CPMs on ads since they can't do much intelligent targeting on history or external data.
- michaelbuckbee 11y agoI'm curious what you use for analytics? Many of the adblockers on both desktop and mobile are blocking analytics tracking making good numbers hard to come by.
- noinsight 11y agoThe problem is that there aren't good adblockers for mobile, in my experience. On Android, Chrome doesn't support extensions so standard extensions are out. However, you can get Firefox Mobile for it, which is actually my favourite browser on Android, and it supports standard extensions so you can load ublock Origin for it. App-type adblockers seem to require rooting. On iOS, I have yet to see a trustworthy/good blocker. I know of Purify, but the author is Chris Aljoudi and after the ublock thing, I'm never touching any of his code. Then there's the Adblock Plus browser thing, but I don't want to use a separate browser - plus, they soured me with the "acceptable ads" stuff. So basically what I want is ublock for iOS.
- slig 11y agoI've been using Focus by Firefox on iOS for a couple of days, seems to be working fine. HN discussion from 3 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10696378 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10696378
- gtufano 11y agoFocus by Firefox seems pretty good and (IMHO) is trustworthy: https://support.mozilla.org/kb/focus https://support.mozilla.org/kb/focus
- noinsight 11y agoI got the impression it only blocks trackers, not ads, is that not so? Then it could be great.
- kemayo 11y agoThe Brooks Review has a decent comparison of the iOS ones, at least: https://brooksreview.net/2015/12/content-blockers/ https://brooksreview.net/2015/12/content-blockers/ Doesn't necessarily touch the "trustworthy" side of things, admittedly.
- Splines 11y ago> App-type adblockers seem to require rooting. I use Adaway on my Android phone. I do sympathize with content owners, the reason I use Adaway is because it has a significant impact on the mobile browsing experience. Limited screen space, higher sensitivity to network traffic, and less available CPU mean that blocking ads on mobile is even more important to the user experience.
- AdmiralAsshat 11y agoWhat's interesting is that of the vendors interviewed in the article, only The Deck seems to be taking the approach of "Maybe they'll stop blocking us if we make less intrusive ads." Everyone else has seemingly flocked to the "Harasss, circumvent, or stonewall the adblockers" strategy.
- ultramancool 11y agoThe problem is, ads are inherently intrusive. If you want people to see them, for them to have any value they need to be in some way annoying to grab the reader's attention. This is why the idea of "acceptable ads" is an oxymoron at best.
- davestern1 11y agoI'm the guy quoted in the last segment from Slate, and I beg to differ! "We’re improving page load time, removing intrusive ads, and working toward fewer ads, but for those that stay we want them to be more impactful,” Stern said. “We want the kinds of ads that people who read fashion magazines — that’s not me — but the kinds of ads that people say are part of the experience of reading the magazine.”
- filmgirlcw 11y agoThe barrier to entry to installing a mobile ad blocker (and then dealing with managing whitelists when shit doesn't appear correctly) is a lot higher than an ad blocker on desktop. I think that has a lot to do with the disconnect. I also think that mobile ad blocking was something the industry feared -- and that the more in-touch tech community cared about -- but regular users simply don't think about as much. That said -- if mobile ads continue to get worse and if the process of managing a whitelist/using a mobile ad blocker can get easier, then maybe this will switch again. The worst part of this to me -- and I say this as someone who makes my income basically b/c I'm a journalist who works for a publication who relies on advertising -- is that if the ad industry sees this as being much ado about nothing, the ad industry won't actually start trying to force better ad practices/blacklisting awful ad exchanges. And then we all lose.
- doodpants 11y agoI've always been puzzled as to why everyone suddenly thought that the adblocking apocalypse was about to happen. I mean, adblockers have been around for many years. Every browser that supports third-party extensions has adblockers available. Which, until this year, has effectively meant all browsers except mobile Safari. So the one last holdout browser finally gains adblocker support, and this is going to be the tipping point that kills ads as a revenue source for web publishers? Does mobile Safari really have that big a majority of usage among all browsers? And even if it does, is such a huge majority of mobile Safari users going to install adblockers? Though techical people tend to forget this, the internet is now mainstream, and the vast majority of web users are non-technical people. These are people who just use whatever software is built comes with their device, never change defaults, and never install any software whose installation/configuration is any more difficult than pressing "Buy" on the app store. So, again, it always seemed strange to me that mobile Safari in iOS 9 (finally) getting adblocker support resulted in all this panic about the adblocking apocalypse being upon us.
- donohoe 11y agoOne good reason, which I think may still have an impact in long-run is bandwidth. At office or home on your cable/DSL/whatever you really don't care about bandwidth. However on mobile, blocking ads has a bigger impact beyond aesthetics and basic UX * Pages load much much faster * Mobile users typically have data-plans with limits I have an old unlimited plan with AT&T. I've just installed the ad-blocker from Mozilla. Previously when I had Peace I say my data usage drop by 30% (that I can account for. It may be higher). I typically use 3.2GB a month. It was down to 1.8GB (again, there are other factors)
- acdha 11y agoYou're definitely right to point at bandwidth, particularly since at least in the United States the major carriers have been pushing customers back to paid plans. A closely-related issue is the nature of the content: it would be one thing if ads/trackers were just image content but a lot of them ship huge amounts of poorly-written JavaScript and CSS, usually marked as uncacheable or with a short TTL. I'm not talking about fly-by-night operators, either, but places like Google, Twitter, Facebook, etc. which have good web performance teams who are apparently strictly prohibited from talking to the ad / tracking / widget groups. All of that extra bloat has a huge performance impact to begin with but it also dramatically amplifies any network delays. That means that most of the people who read a piece about blockers and try one are likely to notice a big performance win and that initial impression will stick with them for a long time.
- vinceguidry 11y agoMy preferred solution is to pay a middleman, or middlemen to provide metered access to nag-free content. The only thing keeping me from subscribing to NYT, WSJ, The Economist is that they're all expecting me to pay magazine subscription rates when the only articles I'm reading are links from aggregators like HN. I have zero desire to pour enough time into any one outlet to make the friction of managing yet another login worth it. I don't want to see fucking pop ups asking me to subscribe, I don't want to see bitching about my adblocker, no, I'm not giving it up. Hell, even Wikipedia's yearly donation drive is getting annoying. Donating does not stop the nagging. I'm very close to finding a way to block that too, Wikipedia does not seem to offer a yearly donation option, so I need the nag to remind me to donate. I just wish I could switch it off. Just quit fucking bugging me and let me read in peace. How much money do you need to make that happen?
- douche 11y agoI donate monthly automatically, and Wikipedia still nags me. Oh well, that's what Stylish is for.
- LargeCompanies 11y agoOwner of Ars Technica says something to the extent that people have installed adblockers because some sites they visit are too aggressive. Hmm what sites are those ...pirated content streaming sites or bit torrent sites?
- DanBC 11y ago> Hmm what sites are those My local newspaper is pretty bad. ABP blocks 16 items on this page: http://www.gloucestershireecho.co.uk/ http://www.gloucestershireecho.co.uk/ On mobile those 16 items really suck. They use energy which means I need to recharge sooner; they use expensive bandwidth; they use processor power on my underpowered phone. And all I want to do is to read the article (And I'm happy to pay to do that. There's currently no way for me to pay and have the ads turned off.)
- nanny 11y ago>Hmm what sites are those ...pirated content streaming sites or bit torrent sites? TPB is mild, to say the least, when compared to nearly any non-minor news website.
- pjc50 11y agoThe current situation where mobile users have to pay to download ads, and potentially pay much more than the ad displayer recieves, is a good target for consumer rights advocacy. We've already persuaded the EU to clobber unfair roaming. The next step is to forbid mobile carriers from charging for ad downloads and permit them to block them instead (using their existing pornfilters). (Mobile carriers are the one group that might be able to make micropayment-for-view work, but are too greedy to actually do it in a way beneficial for all parties)