8 ms·
The Myth of Gentrification
- leereeves 11y agoI just stumbled on an amusing use of the term gentrification: Average Silicon Valley millionaires are being displaced by gentrifying billionaires http://www.deathandtaxesmag.com/216500/average-silicon-valley-millionaires-are-being-displaced-by-gentrifying-billionaires/ http://www.deathandtaxesmag.com/216500/average-silicon-valle...
- sanoli 11y agoI still don't know if this is a prank or real.
- mcv 11y agoI'm not entirely sure I understand the issue with Gentrification, and what is gentrification and what isn't. I live in a pretty nice neighbourhood of Amsterdam. 15 years ago, when I moved here, my uncle (who is a cop) warned me not to live here because of all the crime (though the neighbourhood where he lives has a worse reputation). The population at the time was a decent mix. Lots of ethnic minorities, but also students and probably middle class families along the edges. During the past 15 years, loads of new restaurants have opened here, there's a small movie theatre, the dodgy-looking call shops and phone shops have disappeared, the snack bar that changed ownership every year has now turned into a fancy wine bar. Some old buildings have been turn down and replaced, others have been renovated. Generally, this seems to me like a great example of gentrification. And I'm sure housing prices are rising, and I don't doubt the new and renovated buildings are more expensive than the older ones. But the population doesn't seem to have changed all that much. Maybe there are more affluent white people now, but I still see kids from a variety of ethnic backgrounds play in the streets (though I don't see groups of adolescents and young adults hang around the square where that dodgy snack bar used to be), and there are still plenty of Turkish shops (though some have closed, sometimes to be replaced by a new Turkish shop, sometimes not). I don't know how many people have been forced out due to the gentrification. They include my brother-in-law, who had lived there for ages until his house was to be renovated. But for the most part, the population doesn't seem to have changed much, and the neighbourhood seems to be more vibrant, more stuff to do, less need to go to the center of the city if you want to go out. So if this is gentrification, my impression of it is pretty positive, though I don't have any stats to back it up. Of course with those people who hung around on that square, I have no idea who they are or where they are now. It feels safer, but that might be subconscious racism talking.
- pdkl95 11y ago> loads of new restaurants Who is going to staff those restaurants (and other low-wage services) when the housing prices are so high that it isn't realistically possible to find a rent (forget a mortgage) low enough to be affordable for someone making those low wages? This is made worse in places like south-bay/SF area where the private busing and 2nd/"weekend" apartments further distort local taxing/etc and drive prices up even further. > I don't know how many people have been forced out due to the gentrification. That depends on a lot, but when money is involved, there are lots of creative ways people can be forced out. Zoning laws and other "fees" are common. If renting is involved, buying out the landlord and raising the rates on the tenants (sometimes to unreasonable levels designed to not be paid) is a popular move. > Generally, this seems to me like a great example of gentrification. From your description, that sounds like an example of how a town or city should be maintained. There is a difference between rising housing prices from normal inflation and gentrification.
- alistairSH 11y agoThe US also has additional "baggage" that comes from it's past racial problems. I live near DC. Gentrification in the city is almost always wealthy whites displacing poor blacks. There is very much an us-vs-them feeling among those that are being displaced. One ridiculous effect of the gentrification... Historically black churches in the downtown areas now have congregations that have been displaced and commute from the suburbs to attend services. This causes all sorts of problems with parking that didn't exist when the congregation lived in the neighborhood. This in turn causes conflict with new residents, who want to add bike lanes. The congregation doesn't like that because it would reduce on-street parking.
- liotier 11y ago> new residents, who want to add bike lanes. The congregation doesn't like that because it would reduce on-street parking. One can easily imagine the bike lanes being used as stealth exclusionary devices, which depresses me as I would rather see them as empowering people through better urban transportation.
- baldfat 11y agoI hate the word Gentrification. I live in Allentown, PA and we have gotten around 1 billion dollars of investment for our center city. It really has been a BIG change for our city of 120,000 people city. Problems with the city: White flight happened late (1980s) HIGH transient population. 50% of the school district's child will end the school year at a different school then they started the school year with. Over 90% of the district receives free lunches. So much that 100% of students get a free lunch with a 85% poverty level. Claims of Gentrification: The population was being moved out of the neighborhood. Did I already state that we have a 50% transient population? How establishing a population that isn't below the poverty line in a city full of beautiful Victorian three story row homes (I love mine) and dozens of mansions moving an established population? Matter of fact the local Occupy Movement camped at our city hall and was protesting. A city with HIGH poverty was a 1% issue???? The conversations were hysterical with Occupy in our city about what they thought was the Gentrification in our city. After having al
- jinushaun 11y agoDrove through Allentown a few times. Not sure where the "nice part of town" is, but Allentown needs some gentrification. Rows and rows of abandoned houses.
- angdis 11y agoI was a "transient" in Allentown for 2 years because of work. Allentown has a profound sadness about it that I've seen in other rust-belt cities. Gentrification is very much a positive reaction to the vacuum that was created after years of dis-investment. The city has good bones, housing stock that can be restored to stunning with a little love, and a location and infrastructure that is excellent for business. People are only starting realize this now after moving to the exburbs and finding that they don't like driving 10 - 50 miles for virtually all excursions. Hope that Allentown makes it, it never deserved to be abandoned.
- baldfat 11y agoThings have really turned around. The sky line has been transformed and we have a lot of more businesses in center city and a full entertainment center. I moved here 8 years ago and I love this city and feel like everything is so close to me.
- jinushaun 11y agoI love how the article lumps techies in with lawyers and bankers.
- ebiester 11y agoWe make as much as many lawyers.
- spacecowboy_lon 11y agoQuite we are the ones with our noses pressed against the window pane :-) In London take a walk in the inns of fields (compare it to old street) and you will see the massive gap between lawyers and techies.
- bogomipz 11y agoThe piece leads with: "It started in Soho, then moved to Chelsea and the East Village" As someone very familiar with these areas I can tell you this is wrong and inaccurate. The art scene in 80's become very hot in the East Village and the galleries moved out of the storefront galleries to SOHO because there was larger space there. When they were priced out of SOHO, the galleries moved to Chelsea. Why is this important? Namely because it shows that the author's glaring disregard for basic fact checking and attention detail. Two qualities you might think that are important in writing a piece that deal with demography and statistics. To me this makes the whole piece suspect. The pieces then goes on to site data that is now 25 years old? "Sharkey took a close look at black neighborhoods that saw significant changes to their ethnic composition between 1970 and 1990." Gentrification and Hyper gentrification are something that has become something of a phenomenon in the last 10 years or so. The author then goes on to site a study that is now 11 years old: "In 2004, Columbia University economists Lance Freeman and Frank Braconi conducted a similar study of gentrification in New York City in the 1990s" Then the authors drops this nugget: "If gentrification occurs so infrequently—and if it may help rather than hurt existing residents—why are so many people so upset about it? ?" Huh? Nice bit of editorializing there. Journalism like this is dangerous as it is little more than a policy piece disguised(not very well) as real actual journalism. As tired as I am on the ubiquitous gentrification conversation. I have also watched it unfold first hand in three different places I have lived. I doubt that I have somehow imagined this phenomenon.
- bovermyer 11y agoI feel like this kind of fact-checking is one of the most important reasons for reading HN comments. Before I read this comment, I hadn't thought to question the age of the studies cited; my logic was that the author had cited something, and so had at least gone to that much effort. This gave me pause.
- cuillevel3 11y agoI tried to find something on 'hyper gentrification' with google scholar, but nothing came up? Fact is gentrification is being researched for more than fifty years and it's ok to cite 10 year old research. Because the whole theory builds upon these studies and it might still take some years before enough data is available to cross-examine newer studies.
- lsy 11y agoThis doesn't seem to make much sense. The article treats neighborhoods like islands, and doesn't analyze the inflow of residents. Anyone familiar with living in an area with rapidly increasing rent should understand the results here: people move between neighborhoods at generally equal rates all things being equal. In a gentrifying situation, people of less means will try to stay longer because they know they won't be able to get back in later and enjoy the same safety, amenities, etc. Rent control helps with this. But when they choose or are forced to move, the people coming in to replace them are higher-income, as opposed to people in the same income bracket, which this article doesn't address. The way the article analyzes the situation, two working-class neighborhoods exchanging 50% of their low-income population are experiencing more "gentrification" than a neighborhood where 10% of low-income people are replaced by high-income people every year. I don't think anybody thinks of that result as a reasonable measure of gentrification.
- peterwwillis 11y ago> people move between neighborhoods at generally equal rates all things being equal Source? > In a gentrifying situation, people of less means will try to stay longer because they know they won't be able to get back in later and enjoy the same safety, amenities, etc What poor black inner-city neighborhood are you living in that has better safety and amenities than the county surrounding it? People don't want to move because they just don't want to move, and they already had a house paid for, probably for more than a generation. > But when they choose or are forced to move, the people coming in to replace them are higher-income, as opposed to people in the same income bracket, which this article doesn't address. Again: Source? In a lot of neighborhoods in my city, people may have chosen or been forced moved out, but nobody ever moved in. Your generalization doesn't work for all cases. > two working-class neighborhoods exchanging 50% of their low-income population What neighborhood is this? Working class people don't just move around to the next neighborhood all the time. They buy a house and stay put; that's the whole idea behind the fantasy of the American dream and the working class.
- jfoutz 11y ago> Source? a priori. lsy is constructing a model. The foundation of the model is equilibrium. They're going out of their way to highlight the things that are out of equilibrium to explain why people might move for other than random reasons. Imagine a world with only two cities easterland and westerville. If crime, safety, amenities, economy is the same, people are going to bounce around for random reasons. maybe bobby got into westerville state. mabye sue wants to be closer to his family. by the law of large numbers, those random fluctuations are going to balance out. There is no threat of godzilla attacking esterland, thus causing mass exodus to westerland. > Again: Source? if you accept equilibrium, then clearly things can go out of balance in two ways. Demand going up, or demand going down. lsy isn't trying to explain all cases, lsy is explaining the demand going up case. > Your generalization doesn't work for all cases. Yes, but all cases is not the issue at hand. The issue at hand is what happens when demand goes up. You have my sympathies that your neighborhoods are turning into ghost towns. It seems like you have a different problem that's clouding your thinking about the demand going up case, because they're related, but different.
- pistle 11y agoWhat a horrible way to determine if people are being forced out... compare the rate against a worse situation. We noticed that people with HIV died less frequently over the time period than people with HIV and stage IV cancer. Therefore, there is no HIV problem. I guess they are getting the eyeballs the wished for to read through this flame-bait.
- mtalantikite 11y agoJust wanted to note that that third photo in the article, of the graffiti in Williamsburg, has been replaced by construction for an Apple Store...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kingdomcome50 11y agoThe studies the author cites seem to be asking the wrong question. Rather than asking, "at what rate do poor people leave a neighborhood?", the question should be, "at what rate to poor people come to a neighborhood?". The former question above simply does not support the conclusion that gentrification does not force poor people out. Sure, the rate at which poor people leave can fall, but if NO poor people are moving into a neighborhood, they are essentially being forced out.
- peterwwillis 11y agoBaltimore has endless rows of empty buildings. Over 30,000 last I remember. But except for the homeless, housing is not a problem in Baltimore; houses sell for as low as $10K, $20K, $30K. Nobody is buying them (or at least at a very slow trickle). Yet we still have various activist groups talking about the problem of gentrification. One interesting thing to note is how racially divided the city is. There are five or six majority white neighborhoods in the city, surrounded by majority black and latino neighborhoods. Those majority white neighborhoods expand a little bit every year - sometimes just becoming more dense, but sometimes the boundaries expand. When that happens it creates a sort of new market - new stores with higher prices, homes converted to apartments with higher than average rent. At the same time, it also pushes out traditional "black culture" businesses - babershops and hair/nail salons, liquor stores, takeout food, dingy bars. These businesses are the social gathering places for black people in the city, and when they disappear, so does the presence of black people in daily life. There are other issues that come up too, like strained tensions over an increase in (arguably hostile) police activity around majority-white populations. Even as new businesses come into the neighborhood, you don't see an increase in jobs for people who already lived there. It's easy to see how the people moving in are not there to help the impoverished existing residents. And it is true that rents do gradually increase. But at the same time, crime does reduce, and more money is invested in the local community. I haven't seen anyone pushed out of their home due to rising rents around Baltimore, mainly because we have so many god damn empty homes. But could it happen in a crowded neighborhood? If they are renting, abso-fucking-lutely; rents have been raising in neighborhoods around here for years, with one landlord turning the building over to another and raising the price. The question isn't whether this happens, but what happens to the people once they have to move out. Where do they go? Do they have to start at a new school, find a new job? Are they now far away from their families, some of whom they might be supporting, like the elderly or people who need stay at home child care? And can they even afford to move, if their home was multi-generational and they don't have the funds to buy a new one? These are the questions the article doesn't address.
- weatherlight 11y agoDeplorable clickbait journalism here. This piece over simplifies issues, uses a misleading sensational headline and then flat out gets the issue wrong because the author has no real understanding of the issue he is attaching. Gentrification is is no myth. Residential displacement does occur when existing apartment buildings are torn down to clear sites for new development and rising rents in housing stock that remains prices out local residents. Longtime residents who live on fixed incomes can be forced out of their homes due to rapidly rising property values and taxes. The author fails to explain the primary reason why the Columbia studies authors found reduced displacement in some areas. RENT CONTROL. What the data demonstrates is not that gentrification is a myth but that reasonable government actions can mitigate the worst negative impacts of new development. But then how many shares and clicks would that headline generate.