2 ms·
> ...if only S. Wolfram would finally have the most obvious insight that he's totally missing: > Open-source it! Agreed. But I think the main reason for doing
by e12e 11y ago
> ...if only S. Wolfram would finally have the most obvious insight that he's totally missing:
> Open-source it!
Agreed. But I think the main reason for doing so, is in service of open, reproducible research. I'm sure if you're modelling blast patterns for a rocket to replace the Hellfire, you don't really care if your model stands upon series of locked, proprietary stuff -- as long as it is useful.
But if you're modelling influence effect of various ways to organize voting in democratic government, or doing publicly funded fusion research -- it's much more important that your results are transparent and easily reproducible (now, and in the future, which could be decades, or even centuries, away).
And I think that exploratory research and experimentation is exactly one of the strengths of Wolfram. But it needs to be much better than open solutions for it to even make sense to recommend a closed tool over various open tools -- for producing open research.
Consider if Einstein's research was locked up in some proprietary platform, rather than presented as simple text. While we'll see many papers and innovations in the space that is readily covered by human readable equations and text -- we're already firmly in a world were there are real discoveries that are made and proven only with the help of code.
I really can't see any future for a closed system in such an academic setting (but I can certainly see that closed systems can sell, and be used as tools in companies... provided that those tools continue to be taught and used in universities...).