3 ms·
On the contrary, I think math ed types want to keep the actual mathematicians out precisely because the mathematicians recognize how complex the field is. Every
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
On the contrary, I think math ed types want to keep the actual mathematicians out precisely because the mathematicians recognize how complex the field is. Every time I've been told "stay out, you don't know our field", it was because I pointed out complexity or plausible alternative explanations.
For example, a puzzle: why do SAT scores underpredict female performance in Calc 1, and overpredict grades in higher level courses? I suggested girls are more conscientious than boys, and that a study being proposed did not control for such factors. I even suggested a test of this hypothesis: compare grades in classes which are conscientiousness-weighted (25% homework, 10% attendance, tests questions are practice problems with numbers changed) to ability-weighted coursework (50% midterm, 50% final, test questions all new).
I'm not sure my idea was a good one. But rather than explain why either a) this had been tried, and didn't work, or b) why my test wouldn't work, I was simply told to leave the field to experts.
I've come up with plenty of dumb ideas in other areas, e.g., global existence of wave equations. The closest I've ever gotten to "stay out, you aren't an expert" was "Terry tried that and failed, ask him why before spending lots of time on it."
[edit: really confused why you are being downmodded.]
- Retric 17y agoHonestly, SAT scores vs. Performance is the type of (mostly bad) research I am talking about. The SAT is not designed to test math ability. It's focus is on how likely a student is to finish their freshman year of college and it does that fairly well. You can do a lot of useless research in this area and it tells you next to nothing. If you want to predict a highschool students ability in advanced collage math classes you could design a test that did that. But, people have easy access to SAT data so that's what they look at. If you want to see real and useful research look into how long the optimal study period. There are significant and useful study’s which suggest 2 hours of nonstop instruction is less useful than two one hour periods with a moderate break in-between. Yet how many collage lectures follow this approach.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoWhat makes SAT vs performance bad research? The SAT may be worse than some specialized test, but so what? Breast self exams suck in comparison to mammograms, but that doesn't make studies into breast self exams bad research. The methodology is what makes research good or bad.
- Retric 17y agoThe fewer unknowns the better the data and the more accurate the experiment. In terms of predicting how likely someone is to finish their freshman year of collage having a test where you can increase your score significantly with moderate levels of preparation is not a bad thing. However, the fact you can easily game the test means it is a less accurate indicator of a student’s innate capability. The fact you can retake the test creates yet another sort of bias. etc. More generally, it's easy to focus on defects in the test, which are irrelevant in a larger contest and subject to change.
- jimbokun 17y ago"There are significant and useful study’s which suggest 2 hours of nonstop instruction is less useful than two one hour periods with a moderate break in-between." The professor of the last class I took was very conscientious about taking a break at the 1 hour mark of an 80 minute lecture.