3 ms·
Does anyone seriously think that a determined information-seeker in China can't find out whatever information he/she wants? Google's old approach of showing wh
by grandalf 17y ago
Does anyone seriously think that a determined information-seeker in China can't find out whatever information he/she wants? Google's old approach of showing which results are censored was highly empowering for such truth seekers because it showed exactly what their government didn't want them to read.
It's important to take the recent anti-China news in proper context:
1) China has long been a huge buyer of US treasury bills, in order to keep its currency low relative to the dollar. This helps make China's export industry more competitive but harms the Chinese in general. Some Americans dislike this because they think this makes the US vulnerable to China. Other simply dislike competing against extra cheap Chinese manufactured products. This unites two strange bedfellows against China.
2) Obama moved to start a trade war with China by imposing a tariff on tires... this was simply a political handout to the US tire industry... an industry he must have owed something to.
3) Google's move to pull out of China, aside from harming average Chinese people, was a silly, knee-jerk response, and Google will probably be punished by shareholders if it proceeds.
4) Hillary's recent remarks were intended simply to rile up the Chinese government. Does anyone really think that the way to persuade someone else to your line of thinking is to publicly insult them? Hillary knows this, but ramping up some petty friction with China serves her political ambitions.
For those who are wondering, China is a very difficult country to keep stable. After economic reforms, coastal cities have become rich very quickly, leaving inland areas extremely poor, etc. Most of what China does that Americans find offensive is intended to preserve social stability. In that sense it's highly conservative. One can imagine a small public library in the US refusing to install a computer long after the internet age began... out of some slightly misguided notion that it will help stave off social changes the librarian considers unsavory.
In China's case, the danger is widespread, violent riots, etc. Do you think that would be a good thing? What should China's government do if that occurs, acquiesce? So far China's government has done a decent job of instituting more free market policies, at the expense of social freedoms. They've essentially modeled their approach a bit more after Singapore than after the US.
It's hubris to claim that every country should choose exactly the same mix of social and economic freedoms as the US. This situation should remind all of us of when George W. Bush took great pains to convince the world what a bad guy Saddam was, so that he could start a war.
- joe_the_user 17y agoLet's look at some statements in your post: Does anyone seriously think that a determined information-seeker in China can't find out whatever information he/she wants? Google's move to pull out of China, aside from harming average Chinese people. So "determined information seekers" could the information the information that Google wasn't giving but by no longer providing government approved data, Google is harming average Chinese? I know you're teasing out two different groups in China but the argument seems remarkably stretched. China has long been a huge buyer of US treasury bills, in order to keep its currency low relative to the dollar. This helps make China's export industry more competitive but harms the Chinese in general. Given that this policy has allowed China to gain the second largest economy in the world over twenty-odd years, how has it harm average Chinese? I would certainly say this policy is unsustainable and needs to be adjusted for that reason. But that's a somewhat different matter.
- grandalf 17y agoOn the first point: For the average Chinese person, simply having an awareness of government censorship is a good thing. Google is taking this away. The censorship isn't perfect... for example how many times do you think the full WikiPedia is brought into China on laptops every day? I'd guess dozens per day. Google is suffering the "Napster Problem", they are easily vulnerable to a centralized attack (in this case blocking IPs)... but before and after Napster people still got all the illicit mp3s they wanted. On the second point, the economic argument would be: If China were not subsidizing its export industry, the dollars currently used to buy US Treasuries would have likely been spent on useful goods and services. Instead, it effectively sat idle and could not be used to invest in infrastructure, etc. You can point to the result and say it worked, but China has a natural competitive advantage in manufacturing, so it's hard to say how much benefit the policy caused; the harm is easier to imagine. (China probably has some sensible reasons for promoting mercantilist policies, but it's inevitable that they lower prosperity over all and amount to a transfer from one group within china to another. This is the same sort of tradeoff we experience it the US with a wide variety of policies, notably agriculture policy).
- 17y ago