2 ms·
Today someone making $40,000 per year is not paying anything near eg $12,000 per year in income taxes (more like half that). The middle class would not come eve
by adventured 11y ago
Today someone making $40,000 per year is not paying anything near eg $12,000 per year in income taxes (more like half that). The middle class would not come even remotely close to paying back enough of the basic income that they'd be taking out to off-set the vast cost in the bottom third. Taxes would have to go up dramatically on the middle and upper classes.
If you don't have a cut-off, basic income can never work in America. There is no math that can ever get you there. It takes a few minutes to run the numbers, they do not work - unless you raise taxes a lot and reduce the other major federal programs a lot.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> If you don't have a cut-off, basic income can never work in America. If it has a cut off, its not basic income, its a means-tested welfare program. We've got those already. And there's absolutely no validity to the "in America" here. There's nothing inherent about America that makes it different here. A low level BI that doesn't replace all means-tested programs (particularly not Medicaid) or retirement and disability programs, but maybe displaces GA and SNAP is more plausible in the near term.