8 ms·
Chemicals linked with severe respiratory disease found in e-cigarette flavors
- cryoshon 11y agoWho could have known that smoking chemicals could lead to respiratory disease?
- refurb 11y agoIt's not smoke, like in a cigarette (from combustion), it's vapor from heating a liquid into a gas (boiling).
- theophrastus 11y agoIn synthetic organic labs we often pass relatively small compounds (very much like the favorants in vape juice) over heated elements in order to generate intermediate "activated"/free-radical compounds for the next step of a complicated reaction sequence. So no organic chemist i know is a bit surprised that vaping exposes the user's lungs directly to significant levels of toxic compounds like diacetyl. And they are often heard to wonder out loud: "Why has the FDA not stepped in to regulate these? I wouldn't let any of my family do this!"
- virmundi 11y agoWhat regulations should they put on this? A warning like, Breathing in stuff not air is bad for you? Should they ban adults from making up their own mind? I'm fine with the former. I despise the later.
- madeofpalk 11y agoWell I mean, there's a threshold - it's not OK to sell an arsenic laced Apple just because it has a warning on it.
- jMyles 11y agoIn theory - why not?
- logicallee 11y agoAnd why require the label, right? The free market means that companies that sell arsenic-laced apples will lose market share as people stop buying from them /s
- jMyles 11y agoI don't understand exactly - are you mocking me? I think most people who have this sort of free-market disposition are moderate enough to think that labeling an arsenic apple is reasonable.
- refurb 11y agoAt least one of the three chemicals was detected in 47 of the 51 flavors tested. Diacetyl was detected above the laboratory limit of detection in 39 of the flavors tested. Acetoin and 2,3-pentanedione were detected in 46 and 23 and of the flavors, respectively. The question is, how much? The lab limit of detection is often in the parts per billion or parts per trillion. The dose makes the poison! Hell, frying foods creates acrolein and acylamide which is toxic as hell (it alkylates glutathione, a key anti-oxidant in the body). However, you'd need to eat kilograms of fried food per day to actually reach a toxic level. Coffee is another great example. It contains 23 known carcinogens.
- madeofpalk 11y ago> ranging from < limit of qualification (LOQ) to 239 μg/e-cigarette. 2,3-pentanedione and acetoin were detected in 23 and 46 of the 51 flavors tested at concentrations up to 64 and 529 μg/e-cigarette, respectively. From the article's abstract http://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/15-10185/ http://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/15-10185/ I have no idea what those numbers mean or if they're bad for you. But there they are...
- refurb 11y agoNice! I didn't know the abstract was available. I guess the question is what is the level of diacetyl in the vapor inhaled? The CDC has set a limit of 25 ppb for short term exposure.
- msandford 11y agoYou don't want to be around any diacetyl at all. If the lab can detect it, it's too much. It's very, very nasty business.
- simplexion 11y agoYou better stay away from beer then...
- gozur88 11y agoReading the article, it's not clear from they detected any of these chemicals in concentrations that are known to be unhealthy. People who got "popcorn lung" were exposed to comparatively massive doses.
- isch 11y agoThere was a study last year that analysed diacetyl concentrations in common e-liquids. They found that 47% of 159 preparations examined were above the safety guidelines for daily consumption >The median daily exposure levels were 56 μg/day ... They were slightly lower than the strict NIOSH-defined safety limits for occupational exposure ... however, 47.3% of DA and 41.5% of AP-containing samples exposed consumers to levels higher than the safety limits. http://ntr.oxfordjournals.org/content/early/2014/09/23/ntr.ntu176 http://ntr.oxfordjournals.org/content/early/2014/09/23/ntr.n... Compared to this recent study, this shows that addition of diacetyl and in what concentration is decreasing.
- symlinkk 11y agoIt's obvious that the government is way behind on researching ecigs and regulating them. It's inexcusable to let these things get as popular as they are and remain almost completely silent on the effects of them.
- refurb 11y agoThe FDA tried to regulate them and got slapped down. The real question is, which is better for you, smoking tobacco or vaporizing nicotine? Even if there are risks with vaping, I'd say they are likely far, far less than smoking.
- wutbrodo 11y ago> The real question is, which is better for you, smoking tobacco or vaporizing nicotine? I disagree; I don't think this is really even a question. I do not have the research on hand at the moment, so definitely check it out yourself before taking this on faith, but there's already research indicating that smoking is way worse for you than vaping. Hell, even the only chemical discussed in this latest news (diacetyl) is present in far, far greater quantities in regular cigarettes than in vaping. The question of cigarettes vs vaping is not really even a question; the real question is the risks of vaping per se (and this is where regulation/study has not yet caught up to usage).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mrbill 11y agoAll the major e-cig juice vendors have been reformulating their stuff over the past year or two to get rid of any flavors with diacetyl due to the possible risk. Here's the Reddit discussion: https://www.reddit.com/r/electronic_cigarette/comments/3vx84p/the_telegraph_ecigarettes_contain_flavouring/ https://www.reddit.com/r/electronic_cigarette/comments/3vx84...
- fein 11y agoYep we've known about this for years. There are even some guys that do chemical analysis of some mixes that result in some very scathing letters regarding acetoin and diacetyl contents. The "bad shit" list for ejuice is usually artificial sweeteners, acetoin, and diacetyl.
- zippoxer 11y agoMany e-juice providers are really responsible and do self-regulation. It's important to know who you're getting your juice from.
- Phlow 11y agoLet's play a game of Guess How Many Shits The Addicted Person Gives. I'll start. I guess 0.
- profmonocle 11y agoA lot of people switch to vaping because they perceive it as less dangerous than smoking cigarettes. So yeah, I'd say people care.
- nikatwork 11y agoWell, this has prompted me to make sure any brand I buy is free from Diacetyl etc. It's not the vaping that's bad per se, it's the chemicals some brands are using in the flavoring.
- Phlow 11y agoA lot of people switch to vaping because they're half-assing quitting. I quit smoking 10 years ago, cold turkey. You either give a shit about your health, or you don't. I don't care if I get down-voted, or appear negative. Sack up, quit the stupid stuff.
- fennecfoxen 11y agoI dunno, plenty of addicted people recognize their behavior is destructive and they care a medium amount about that. They just care about getting the fix more: human brains have a multiplicity of decision-making agents, and the long-term self-control ones don't always win, especially where these types of addictive agents are involved, but also when they're in the sort of life situations which make quick fixes (like de-stressing yourself by smoking) attractive.
- pbreit 11y agoInhaling charred chemicals doesn't sound like the greatest idea.
- morokhovets 11y agoCharred? It is called vaping for a reason.
- pbreit 11y agoSo folks like you don't think it's charred.
- mistermann 11y agoI didn't RTFA,could someone that did comment on how much insight was given into "We selected 51 types of flavored e-cigarettes sold by leading e-cigarette brands and flavors"? Some ecigs (disposables) are manufactured in China where I suspect quality control might be suspect, whereas many juices are manufactured by small startups in the US and I'm quite certain they take ingredients extremely seriously. Any study that "accidentally" doesn't differentiate between the two very different manufacturing scenarios is suspect in my opinion, as it does very little to provide any useful information.
- pcthrowaway 11y agoI'm reposting the top response to this same story on Reddit (https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/3vxbzo/chemical_flavorings_found_in_ecigarettes_linked/cxrq6ro https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/3vxbzo/chemical_fl...) because this person says it better than I can, and no one else here has said made these points yet: Oh boy, time to crosspost for information's sake. Even diactyl containing e-juice still contains 100x less diacetyl than traditional cigarettes. [Citation: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/tox.20153/pdf[1] http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/tox.20153/pdf[1] ] And no smoker to date has ever gotten "Popcorn Lung" (Named because it occurs years after dumping pure uncut diactyl into vats and bins when making cheapo microwave popcorn in the factories.) And despite all that- It's still largely the other factors and chemicals and tar and actual combustion that damages your lungs when smoking is involved. Not diacetyl specifically. Even 100x the amount of diacetyl as e-juice is apparently not enough to cause the "Popcorn Lung" issue related to the compound specifically. So why would 100x less than the amount that does not cause it suddenly start to cause it? Not that it's 100 percent safe (As mentioned by a replier as well- So I have appended my post some for accuracy and fairness.) Just that it's not the immediate or unavoidable threat it's being presented as. And in the span of 7+ years even in the heaviest vape users no one has (yet, mind. For the sake of fairness and caution.) reported any major health issues tied to vaping or the compounds contained in e-juice. If the 75ml a day heavy diactyl juice user doesn't get popcorn lung then I highly doubt popcorn lung is a problem to watch for regarding it. Also there are many many e-juices available without diactyl. So even if it was an issue you can actively avoid it. And most manufacturers have discontinued it's use or clearely state if their juices are diacetyl free so the risk factors that are purely tied to diacetyl are avoidable and preventable. As far as being paranoid about what's put in it- This is purely my opinion but, I think that is razorblades in your kid's halloween candy or "Shadey people handing out drugs for free/Lacing your kid's flintstones vitamins with PCP" levels of unfounded overconcern. Caution is important- But so is research and fact checking. Edit: To append this to- I am not defending the use or previous use of the substance, merely dispelling the immediate "Popcorn Lung" panic around it. I personally don't use e-juice containing it for the sake of risk reduction in general as I like to limit as many potential factors as possible in general. And there are hundreds- if not thousands of brands and types which do not contain diacetyl to choose from which I would recommend. I am also not claiming vaping is 100 percent safe- Just that this instance is an avoidable factor and has been for a while. Personal safety and active research should always be practiced in all facets of life.
- snarfy 11y agoI prefer unflavored e-cig juice with nicotine, but it's actually hard to find.
- devb 11y agoI get mine shipped from Mt. Baker in 8 oz bottles (about $30.. no I don't work for them) and decant those into 30 ml bottles for use. You can even specify what PG/VG ratio you like.
- Mandatum 11y agoDIY, if you have left over bottles it's really easy to buy and mix vegetable glycerin and VG/nicotine mixes. Also ridiculously cheap.
- keeran 11y agoThe vaping enthusiast community have known about this for over a year. The popular vendors have pretty much all converted their recipes to avoid being the black sheep who still ship diacetyl. I'd love to know why this story is being pushed everywhere now - is there a bill / legislation coming up somewhere important?
- simplexion 11y agoWhat about the high levels of diacetyl in cigarette smoke? http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24635357 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24635357
- heroprotagonist 11y agoWhen reading articles like this, I often find it useful to at least skim the paper that the article discusses. The article's opening line seems designed to demonize: "Diacetyl, a flavoring chemical linked to cases of severe respiratory disease, was found in more than 75% of flavored electronic cigarettes and refill liquids tested by researchers at Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health." 75%! Tested by Harvard! This is huge! However, take a look at the actual study. Specifically, page 6, under Methods, e-Cigarette Selection http://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/wp-content/uploads/advpub/2015/12/ehp.1510185.acco.pdf http://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/wp-content/uploads/advpub/2015/12/e... "A convenience sample of 51 e-cigarette flavors was selected for use in this study. Electronic cigarette cartridges, liquids, and their associated devices and batteries were purchased online and in retail locations. We evaluated 51 flavors, including all available flavors from three large cigarette companies (Brands A, B, and C, with 2, 2, and 7 flavors, respectively); 5 flavors from a large independent e-cigarette company (Brand D); and 24 additional flavors from three ecigarette distributors (Brands E, F, and G, 10, 8, and 6 flavors, respectively) that we selected based on their potential appeal to children, teenagers and young adults (Table 2). In addition, we evaluated 11 e-liquid flavors that are inserted into a cartomizer (disposable cartridge and atomizer system) (Brands H and I, 6 and 5 flavors, respectively)" To break this down a bit.. Let's start with convenience sample. A convenience sample is a non-probability sampling technique. It's made up of subjects (in this case, nicotine juice) which are easy to reach. It is _not_ a representative sample of the products offered by the entire industry. You can't make probability statements about non-probability samples. The numbers are worthless in relation to the greater whole. EG, you can't say "Diacetyl was found in more than 75% of flavored electronic cigarettes." It would be like going to a Donald Trump campaign rally to poll public opinion because it's close to your house and then reporting that "75% of Americans believe Donald Trump should be the next President of the United States". Add a couple of words, however, and although your numbers are still worthless, you can use a technicality to slip past whatever fact-checking apparatus is in place that would call you out on a bold-faced lie and you can lend some additional credibility to your prejudicial pseudo-science. "Diacetyl was found in more than 75% of flavored electronic cigarettes tested by researchers at Harvard." The average person is not going to consider the added qualifying statement in the proper context. Technically, it lets the reporter off the hook for generalizing because they have now (importantly) stated that the number is only in relation to what was tested. Effectively, though, it lends a big name institution and all that it represents in support of the reporter's agenda. Most people will read that sentence as "Harvard reports that 75% of flavored electronic cigarettes contain diacetyl, which causes severe respiratory disease'. It does help the article's credibility that this 'research' was indeed performed at Harvard, was under grant from the NIH, and that the probabilistically irrelevant results were posted on a Harvard website in a fairly authoritative manner as a press-release. The writer of the article isn't credited, so this appears to come from the university itself. But anyway, back to the numbers they listed. Their sample size, of the many thousands available, was 51. And it came from... 3 cigarette companies, 1 e-cigarette company, and 3 e-cigarette distributors. They use only seven (convenient, non-representative) sources to paint the industry as a whole. If we ignore the blanketing insinuation of the industry as a whole, though, the number they came up with is still of very limited utility. One company contributed 2 datapoints, another contributed 10. Biased contributions make the overall '75%' figure irrelevant in describing even just those 7 companies comprising their 'research'. If a company uses diacetyl in one of their products, odds are very high that they will use it in their other products. That aside, since the selection of flavors tested are not representative of sales of individual products, there's no point in repeatedly testing the products of a single company once a positive result has been reached. I'm very disappointed and irritated that an institution like Harvard would lend its credibility to a piece like this. It leads me to wonder whether they are acting with an ulterior motivation or simply incompetently. In the end, their intent means little, though; their words will have impact to discourage the spread of e-cigarettes as an alternative or cessation aid for traditional cigarettes. Is that a good thing? I don't know. We need better research into this youthful industry that has a significant potential health impact. We rely on valid research by trustworthy institutions to inform our decision making process. There's an opportunity cost to choosing to perform the wrong research and to performing the right research incorrectly. While some good does come of this, in that specific companies are outed (sort of -- the paper does not list the company names) for their use of dangerous ingredients, the research does not address safety concerns around e-cigarette use in the scenario where a responsible vendor takes precautions by ensuring that known dangerous additives aren't added to their products. I know it's not very sexy to report, and might require some additional effort, but why not look at the impact of the additives that _all_ of the e-cigarette companies are using because they are assumed benign in the absence of evidence to the contrary?