4 ms·
The Billion-Dollar Telescope Race
- sandworm101 11y agoI'd say that a billion dollars seems like far too much money considering all the problems that money could solve here on earth. It could be spent on general science education, which imho would probably result in greater discoveries over the long term. But LeBron James just inked a deal that could see him earn that much for bouncing a ball.
- Steko 11y agoThe telescopes are actually built here on earth and that money goes to people's jobs just like building anything else. A billion dollars sounds like a lot but if you were to make a list of wasteful billion dollar projects I doubt these would be very high up on it.
- InclinedPlane 11y agoWe spend trillions of dollars a year on solving problems "here on Earth", that does not obviate the ability nor the need to spend money on pure scientific research. Consider how much the advancement of science has contributed to the wealth and health of mankind. Hundreds of billions of person-years in healthy life. Quadrillions. Literally quadrillions of dollars of value and economic activity added due to the understanding of gas laws, thermodynamics, material science, electromagnetism, quantum mechanics, etc. Can you think of anything with such a tremendous return on investment?
- sandworm101 11y agoNobody is calling for an end to astronomy spending, let alone ending blue sky research. But there are always efficients that must be debated. Spending a billion on one telescope (or one LHC) must be weighed against spending 100-million on each of ten. There are certainly discoveries that do need the bigger microscope, but there are a great many areas of science that are underfunded. Seeing a billion go to one device should be a red flag warranting serious debate. There is also a Freudian aspect to any "worlds biggest" project. They are a magnet for waste and competition totally outside the arena of science.
- javiramos 11y agoThis comment reminded me of Stuhlinger's letter: http://www.lettersofnote.com/2012/08/why-explore-space.html http://www.lettersofnote.com/2012/08/why-explore-space.html
- askafriend 11y ago> But LeBron James just inked a deal that could see him earn that much for bouncing a ball. And he absolutely deserves it, 100%. He's created and will continue to create that much value past his basketball career and it's only right that he sees a return from all the value he will create. I only hope you're half-joking about that statement because otherwise it's incredibly misguided.
- sandworm101 11y agoThe value he creates isn't so simple. He didn't invent basketball as an artist of tech guru might invent a new form of entertainment. He exists within a longstanding system involving thousands of other people. He gets his millions because that is the fair market value of his services. I would never criticize him for making that much. But I would certainly criticize a system whereby non-fans of basketball, specifically cable subscribers, are leveraged into supporting sports they never watch. See: http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/12/06/the-sports-bubble-is-about-to-pop.html http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/12/06/the-sports-... Also, taxpayer support of teams through stadium deals, which makes more money available for player salaries. Not James' fault, but his salary is an outcome of factors well outside of on-court talent.
- adventured 11y agoKate Spade didn't invent purses. Amancio Ortega didn't invent womens clothing. Jeff Gordon didn't invent race cars. Bill Gates didn't invent the software industry. It's not relevant at all that Lebron James didn't invent basketball. Lebron's salary is the least interesting aspect of his financial potential. He would be making incredible amounts of money outside of the NBA even if you paid him a $1 salary. That salary will ultimately be a small portion of his lifetime wealth. How can I be confident of that? Because Jordan and numerous other athletes have already demonstrated how that works. Jordan earned a modest NBA salary for most of his career (until the last few years) by today's standards. In no way did that stop him from becoming a billionaire via his off-court dealings. If you hammered the NBA's revenue figures - basically rolled them backwards 20 years - by clipping ESPN's wings through altering the subscriber landscape (which seems inevitable at this point), it wouldn't matter at all to James likely becoming a billionaire. NBA fans would tune in, that would make James famous, and his off-court endorsements (eg the big Nike deal) in this massive global economy would make him a billionaire over time. Those TV subscribers that are paying but not watching, would still be not watching, it wouldn't matter other than for the league salaries.
- mturmon 11y agoAre you familiar with the science case for these three telescopes? Because you wouldn't want to make a statement like that without a passing knowledge of: [TMT science] http://www.tmt.org/science-case http://www.tmt.org/science-case, http://www.tmt.org/sites/default/files/documents/application/pdf/tmt-dsc-2015-release-2015apr29-s2.pdf http://www.tmt.org/sites/default/files/documents/application... [GMT science] http://www.gmto.org/Resources/GMT-SCI-REF-00482_2_GMT_Science_Book.pdf http://www.gmto.org/Resources/GMT-SCI-REF-00482_2_GMT_Scienc... [E-ELT science] https://www.eso.org/sci/facilities/eelt/science/ https://www.eso.org/sci/facilities/eelt/science/ All of this science background is understood in relation to the National Academies Astrophysics decadal study, which was written in 2010 and is being revised at a series of meetings that concludes next month. (http://sites.nationalacademies.org/SSB/CurrentProjects/SSB_161177 http://sites.nationalacademies.org/SSB/CurrentProjects/SSB_1...) Remember that the $1B is in relation to space missions (Hubble, JWST, etc.) costing much more.
- mturmon 11y agoThe TMT, the only telescope of the three that is trying to go into Hawaii, got a major setback days ago when its building permit for its site atop Mauna Kea was denied by the Hawaii State Supreme Court (http://bigstory.ap.org/article/8a57f575c6ed41958de678ade72bc77a/hawaii-supreme-court-denies-telescope-construction http://bigstory.ap.org/article/8a57f575c6ed41958de678ade72bc...)
- antognini 11y agoWhen astronomers decide to build a telescope they do an extensive site selection study to figure out where the best place to build the telescope is. The most important factors are things you would expect: how cloudy the site is, the elevation of the site, latitude, light pollution, etc. But they also consider the political feasibility of building the telescope. [1] Although Mauna Kea is a better site on purely scientific grounds than the Chile site where GMT is going to be built, Mauna Kea has always been dinged in these site selection reviews for the political problems of getting the telescope built. TMT decided to risk the political difficulties for the better site. It seems that the political objections to the TMT were stronger than they anticipated. There are actually some excellent sites in various parts of the world that don't yet have telescopes on them because the infrastructure isn't there yet to support them. If my memory serves right, there is a site in Nairobi that is one of the best in the world scientifically, but it's unfeasible economically and politically to build a large telescope there. There was also a site in Morocco that made the short list as a site for the E-ELT. As economies improve, though, these sites will eventually be developed. In the past 15 years the infrastructure in India has gotten to the point that it was possible to build the Indian Astronomical Observatory on a very good site in the Himalayas. I think China is now building (or at least considering) another observatory somewhere in the Himalayas as well. [1]: For a list of some of the factors considered, see this paper, especially Table 1: http://authors.library.caltech.edu/19568/1/Schoeck2007p8596Workshop_On_Astronomical_Site_Evaluation.pdf http://authors.library.caltech.edu/19568/1/Schoeck2007p8596W...
- mturmon 11y agoYes, the astronomers I know have been fearing this shoe would drop for several years now as the protests have gained strength. Chile is looking pretty good.
- antognini 11y ago> No wonder, then, that many leading astronomers in the 1980s and early > 1990s had written off Nelson’s scheme. A 1993 Los Angeles Times > profile of Nelson, for instance, quotes an anonymous source it > describes as “one of the nation’s top telescope designers.” The > anonymous source rated Nelson an “arrogant fool” and predicted that > the W.M. Keck Observatory’s $200 million price tag would ultimately > just be money down the drain. > Yet when in 1992 the Keck telescope—followed by its cousin Keck II in > 1996—instead delivered on its designers’ promise of ushering in a new > era of 10-meter class astronomy, other observatories around the world > were caught by surprise. I think it should also be noted that Keck was "competing" with a similar-sized telescope which ended up being known as the Large Binocular Telescope (LBT). LBT had a huge number of issues, both with engineering and funding, that lead to almost 20 years of delay. Part of the problem was that LBT is more technically challenging than Keck, since it has two large mirrors on a common mount (like a pair of binoculars). But like Keck, LBT also had difficulties with protesters, but the objections were more environmental than cultural (Mt. Graham is the home to an endangered species of squirrel). All of this is to say that it wasn't unreasonable for the astronomical community to be skeptical of Keck since a project similar in scale ended up far behind schedule and over budget.
- ant6n 11y agoWhatever happened to putting liquid rotating mirror telescopes on the moon? Here's an article explaining the idea: http://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2008/09oct_liquidmirror/ http://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2008/09...