12 ms·
C.S. Lewis' Greatest Fiction: Convincing Kids That They'd Like Turkish Delight
- BMorearty 11y agoTurkish Delight tastes like deodorant.
- Someone1234 11y agoI find them pretty tasteless, it is the powdered sugar that gives them taste. This will sound strange, but try taking a Turkish Delight and dipping it in some water. It will remove the powered sugar, and you'll get to taste what the Turkish Delight itself tastes like (very little).
- coldtea 11y ago>I find them pretty tasteless, it is the powdered sugar that gives them taste. Actually there are tons of flavorings, like rose-water, mastic, dates, cinnamon, anise and co. Often combined. And you can get them without powered sugar -- they're still as sweet. (Unless one buys bad mass market imitations, where it would be some chemicals to make it stable + sugar + some cheap artificial flavor).
- ashark 11y agoYou either have delicious deodorant, or you've been eating very bad Turkish Delight.
- griffinmb 11y agoI loved them, so I bought my family boxes of them last Christmas. They complained that the turkish delight tasted like flowers/perfume -- now that's all I can taste, and I don't get it often anymore.
- to3m 11y agoI tried it as a child and it tasted like how I imagine pot pourri would taste. Really not my thing. If you want a sweet Middle Eastern food, I'd definitely suggest baklava. The worst that'll happen there is a bit of coconut. (Or... a swift and painful death, if you're allergic to nuts.)
- coldtea 11y agoOne common flavoring is rose-water, which yes, comes from roses, and smells like them. Then again, it's delicious, and nothing much stranger than smelling like strawberry etc. It's just a matter of taste. If Americans can adapt to all the asian/l.american etc food they eat, they can adapt to turkish delights in a week or so of eating.
- coldtea 11y agoIn the same way that blueberries taste like chicken and flan tastes like gasoline.
- arethuza 11y agoActually, some nice wines, particularly Rieslings, do have a whiff of petrol/gasoline about them.
- decafbad 11y agoBad ones, yes. Unfortunately most of us like to cheat tourists. (Actually, each other too) Buy from specialized shops who sells their own products. There are so many types and flavors, you would find the one you like.
- SwellJoe 11y agoHmm...I never thought it was strange. Turkish Delight is delicious. I pick some up whenever I find myself in a Mediterranean grocery. I'm not fond of every flavor, especially the very sweet ones, but the fruit and nut options are delightful, to me. I find it interesting that it's considered a major disappointment by a lot of folks. I mean, I think every friend I've ever had that's tried it, after my raving about it, has been somewhat less enthused about it than I am, but I don't think anyone has ever said it was repulsive.
- OneOneOneOne 11y agoMaybe I read more into it, but I thought enchantment was also involved? (My imagining was of some light chocolate treat... the kind that melts in your mouth and is almost impossible to overeat.)
- tlrobinson 11y agoIndeed: "Probably the Queen knew quite well what he was thinking; for she knew, though Edmund did not, that this was enchanted Turkish Delight and that anyone who had once tasted it would want more and more of it, and would even, if they were allowed, go on eating it till they killed themselves." http://www.shmoop.com/lion-witch-wardrobe/supernatural-quotes.html http://www.shmoop.com/lion-witch-wardrobe/supernatural-quote... The article actually points that out too, but glosses over it: "(To be fair, it was enchanted. But still, Edmund. Still.)" Seems like an important point though. Yes, Edmund liked turkish delight enough to ask for it in the first place, but once he had the Queen's Turkish Delight he was more hopeless than a heroin addict desperate for their next fix. As an aside, I can't believe we're debating Turkish Delight and "The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe" on Hacker News.
- OneOneOneOne 11y ago"(To be fair, it was enchanted. But still, Edmund. Still.)" Yes. The enchantment would strongly affect Edmund. I am surprised the article author thinks this a trifle.
- anon4 11y agoKind of like saying it's awful how people paint Hitler and Nazism in general in such a dehumanizing evil light, when they rebuilt a war-torn Germany into a well-oiled prosperous country (To be fair, they genocided some minorities¹. But still, people. Still.) ¹ - Assuming that the holocaust happened. It is my understanding that a lot of people deny that any ethnic minorities were killed by the Nazi regime and that the entire thing was fabricated, but the overwhelming opinion is that a number of people perished in the camps and a not insignificant amount of the survivors were severely maltreated.
- 11y ago
- tjr 11y agoNever thought about it much, but reading the book, I imagined it being some concoction based on Turkish apricots.
- kej 11y agoThis is kind of a weird criticism since there's so much variety in Turkish Delight. It would be like saying "cereal is too sweet" or "snack bars have unfamiliar flavors", when both of those things, like Turkish Delight, can be made with all sorts of different flavors.
- rustynails 11y agoAn offbeat topic to challenge my mind. My first experience with Turkish delight was a commercial product in a gold foil wrapper and a purple label (I don't know if it was fry's or not - it was in similar wrapping to the old kitkat - 1/2 paper, 1/2 foil). It was covered in chocolate with a centre that was chewy like a slightly softened beef jerky. It had a fragrant flavour that reminded me of perfume, but it was a resounding yuk. In later years, I came across a gelatinous pink treat covered in a white powder - the texture was about as squishy as jelly. There was a more subtle taste and it was delicious. I never remember associating Turkish delight with Narnia. But, I remember associating gold foil wrappers with willy wonka.
- ashark 11y agoMy experience has been the worse the packaging, the better the Turkish delight. Ideally it'll look like something someone threw together in their home kitchen.
- coldtea 11y agoIf the first was "covered in chocolate" it was decidedly not a turkish delight, but some mass market abomination of such. The second sounds much closer to actual turkish delights. (Which are not just turkish, but all over the arab world + balkans, greece etc. Some of the best are said to be made in the middle east).
- emmelaich 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fry%27s_Turkish_Delight https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fry%27s_Turkish_Delight An abomination it maybe, but it's still delicious. We get it branded by Cadbury in Australia. The real thing is not hard to get in major cities.
- coldtea 11y agoYeah, the "Fry's" + packaging kind of gives the name away that it's not an actual turkish delight.
- umanwizard 11y agoWhat? I'm American and I think lokum is delicious. This guy really wrote a whole article about how he doesn't like a particular type of candy?
- ksenzee 11y agoThe author is a she, and the article is really about childhood fantasy, imagination and disappointment, via the lens of how a bunch of American kids imagined the unknown "Turkish Delight." (Also, the only lokum I ever had tasted like gummy rosewater with nuts. Ew.)
- Shog9 11y agoTo be fair, they don't make Sen-Sen anymore - he may never have had the opportunity to taste a truly vile American candy.
- coldtea 11y ago>Until I first tried real Turkish Delight in my 20s, I had always imagined it as a cross between crisp toffee and halvah–flaky and melting in the mouth. Here's what it really is: a starch and sugar gel often containing fruit or nuts and flavored with rosewater, citrus, resin, or mint. The texture is gummy and sticky, some of the flavors are unfamiliar to American palates, and the whole thing is very, very sweet. (In addition to the sugar in the mixture, it's often dusted with icing sugar to keep the pieces from sticking together.) While some Turkish Delight newbies may find they enjoy it, it's not likely to be the first thing we imagine when we picture an irresistible candy treat. In an era when (white and co) americans devour all kinds of ethnic cuisines, including raw sushi, all kinds of indian, thai, etc. I find this article bordering on the absurd. Unless you're health conscious and don't like sugar, there's not much for an American to dislike about turkish delights -- sugary, gelatinous etc. Kind of the missing link between gummy bears, jelly and marshmallows. They've eaten far more bizzaro foods.
- ra1n85 11y agoWhite and co?
- coldtea 11y agoObviously lots of latin and asian americans are already accustomed to (their) ethnic cuisines. So I wanted to emphasize that even the stereotypically "conservative in tastes" white america has embraced ethnic cuisines in the last 20-30 years.
- duaneb 11y ago> stereotypically "conservative in tastes" white america I've never seen this stereotype before. You sure you aren't talking about brits?
- coldtea 11y agoNo, I'm taking of white americans, who supposedly (and perhaps actually) mainly eat in bland chain restaurants, have watered down ethnic chains, and usually always search for the nearest McDonalds whenever they are abroad.
- nwatson 11y agoA Muslim coworker once told me many believe the Christian apologist CS Lewis was showing an anti-Muslim bias in using Turkish Delight as the temptation ... supposedly it is a warning against the enticements of a non-Christian world view. Does anyone have more info on this angle?
- taberiand 11y agoConsidering The Last Battle, it passes the sniff test
- russnewcomer 11y agoIt's almost assuredly a splitting of hairs, but having read a decent amount of Lewis, and knowing a bit about the times and places he lived in, I think Lewis would admit to having a conscious bias against Islam, but not a conscious one against Muslims. (A bias against the belief system, not against the people that practice it) His use of Turkish Delight is, I have heard, thought of as a personal thing, that Lewis as a young boy would have been mightily tempted by Turkish Delight. Knowing also the yelling that goes back and forth between Christians and Muslims about bits and bobs in the other's corpus of literature and culture, I'd imagine that it is as much planned anti-Muslim bias as unintentional.
- vectorjohn 11y agoI actually love turkish delight. It's funny though, it's true I heard of it from the Chronicles of Narnia. It sounded so good for some reason. I mean, if that kid would throw his family under the bus for some, I want to try it!
- tlrobinson 11y agoWell now I'm hungry for some. Anyone have a good source for Turkish Delight? (online, or in SF)
- khiddy 11y ago"Aplets & Cotlets" are basically Turkish Delight, manufactured in the USA. http://www.libertyorchards.com/ http://www.libertyorchards.com/
- clock_tower 11y agoThere are also some varieties available on Amazon, and elsewhere online. A lot of good Turkish Delight in the US (including Aplets & Cotlets) is made by Armenians, who aren't in any hurry to credit the Turks for it. They typically call the confection by its Turkish name, "lokum" -- which roughly means "delight."
- timv 11y agoFrom the article > The English name, Turkish Delight, is no misnomer Of course it's a misnomer - there is nothing delightful about Turkish Delight.
- jff 11y agoI grew up on "turkish delight" in Washington state, home of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberty_Orchards https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberty_Orchards which makes "Aplets and Cotlets", Turkish Delight flavored with apples and apricots. (It's incredible)
- jasonmp85 11y agoAs much as I like those, it is a veritable sin they won the "official state candy" over Almond Roca.
- jff 11y agoYou can get Almond Roca everywhere but Aplets and Cotlets are a pretty WA-specific thing, I've never seen them outside of the state. Those and the Idaho Spud are my #1 treats when I'm back home.
- khiddy 11y agoAmen to this. The tour of the factory in Cashmere is worth the drive, if only to get to eat free samples!
- djur 11y agoWow, I mentioned Aplets and Cotlets on another thread. I didn't realize that they actually are Turkish Delight (that is, based on a recipe for lokum). They are delicious! As a kid I envisioned it as kind of a sticky, tender, caramel-y confection, like a nutty blond fudge. But from now on I'll think of it as Aplets and Cotlets.
- maaku 11y ago"Aplets and Cotlets" is exactly what I always though Turkish Delights would taste like from the books.. and something I really enjoy myself once I had the chance to try it. I'm a little confused about TFA...
- fisk 11y agoI'm falling for a bit of forum bikeshedding here of commenting on something very important :) but...it's one thing to say "I imagined it was like this, but it was like that. And here's what my friends imagined" and another to start the thing like "man, c.s.l. sure tricked everyone with his weird, weird candy!" I can't remember whether I tried to imagine it or allowed it to be intriguing-but-unknown in my mind.
- alasdair_ 11y agoTurkish Delight is commonly sold in the UK covered in chocolate instead of sugar. You can buy it at just about any place you can buy a snickers.
- fatihpense 11y agoThank you for posting this. It is a relief to see something with good vibes that contains Turkey in it. Reading about Turkey in world news and comments is depressing. Believe me, Turkish people think more about lokum and food than politics. Hacı Bekir company is mentioned in the article. Another interesting point is that it is the oldest operating company in Turkey founded in 1777: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/0c/Ali_Muhiddin_Hac%C4%B1_Bekir_(1777).jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/0c/Ali_Muhi...
- wavefunction 11y agoIf it makes you feel any better, I have wonderful memories of visiting Istanbul with my family when I was a child and would love to go back. The people were wonderful and friendly. Im not keen on the direction that Erdogan has been taking your country but that's something that is only my business in the sense that I can complain about him from the comfort of my own country.
- fatihpense 11y agoThank you. It made me feel better! I would like to host you/have a coffe with you if you come to Istanbul again. On the subject of direction of Turkey, there are more objective and problematic indicators like press freedom. And then there are superfluous statements made by Erdogan just to get some more votes, just to troll opponents etc. Don't mind the latter. Those words are just sauces and masks, not the real stuff. Most people vote for the lesser evil, and Erdogan's party only won in the early elections after forming of a coalition has failed by other parties. Most of the people live modernly and want to live modernly. So I don't think the direction will go to extremes.
- irremediable 11y agoI've never been lucky enough to visit Turkey, though I have some hope of attending a conference in Istanbul next year. I _have_ gotten to stay with two separate Turkish AirBnB hosts here in the UK -- and both times were amazing. I'm sure it's not right to generalise from this small number of examples, but Turkish hospitality is clearly a _big_ deal. Even just visiting Turkish friends in their respective homes, there seems to be this feeling of great pride in hosting a guest. I hope it's something that English culture can learn from. Edit: hope I'm not coming over as patronising here. Just thought I'd share a more positive view.
- squigs25 11y agoGood fresh home made turkish delight is actually awesome. If you ever come across it, try it. The pre-packaged stuff is mostly too sweet and not that good.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoI know when I read it (when I was 7 or 8), I envisioned it as a candied turkey - kind of like the crunchy sweet shell on a honey baked ham. Very disappointing in that context.
- crikli 11y agoAlong similar lines I always imagined a middle eastern variation on General Tso's chicken. Candy never entered my mind, I always assumed it was an entrée of some type.
- maus42 11y agoI have never tasted Turkish Delight, but it sounds like a unimaginably sweet exotic masterpiece of confectionery. I mean, I always imagined that it would be something a sultan in his majestic palace would order, and it would taste about the same as the illustrations of some wondrous palace in Istanbul by the illustrations in the book (by Pauline Baynes) looked like.
- Balgair 11y agoThink Dots (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dots_%28candy%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dots_%28candy%29) or a more pliable Jujubee (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jujube_%28confectionery%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jujube_%28confectionery%29)
- jon-wood 11y agoThe time of publishing may have been a factor - in 1950 Britain was still recovering from the second world war, and rationing was still in force, so there would have been nowhere near the abundance of sweet foods available that there are now. In that context even some Turkish delight could be an exciting treat.
- scott_karana 11y agoYes, that's exactly what the article says. >:/
- Animats 11y agoProduct placement, the early years.
- Steko 11y agoDoes anyone really remember what kid-them thought of when they read these passages about Turkish delight a decade plus earlier? I certainly don't and I read the Narnia books at least twice.
- kbutler 11y agoYes - and the adult that claim her childhood self wanted decadently dark chocolate for the endorphin rush? Unlikely.
- andrewchambers 11y agoI am from New Zealand and I love Turkish delight.
- ctulek 11y agoWell, in Turkey, Turkish Delight is not as popular as people may think. Probably, tourists eat more Turkish Delight than Turkish people... I eat more of this sweet here in US then back in Turkey. Looks like another article that just enjoys stereotyping.
- gotchange 11y agoIf you want to try Middle Eastern sweets, check Kunafa or Baklava instead because Turkish Delights (Lokum) are really for kids not adults and they're served along something like Dragée in special occasions and mainly to kids too. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drag%C3%A9e https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drag%C3%A9e
- encoderer 11y agoSlightly offtopic but I had the fortune to visit Istanbul in October and it was by far the highlight of our European holiday. The culture is fantastic. Turkish breakfast is an amazing thing. Fresh simit pastries are insanely good. I love the hamam, the bazaar, and even turkish delight. If Istanbul isn't on your list, it should be!
- anon4 11y ago> Istanbul Constantinople⁎
- kylehotchkiss 11y agothe first time i flew turkish airlines, they handed out turkish delights and I tried one for the very first time. It was magical. Very magical. I tried to find some more in istanbul airport which were not as magical but I'll buy more one day.
- jinushaun 11y agoI'm Asian American and grew up eating and enjoying a ton of weird shit including rotten fish, pork blood, durian, etc, but even I encountered the same feeling of disappointment after tasting my first Turkish delight. Like the OP, I had imagined this amazing treat in my head after reading those books and seeing those movies/cartoons as a child. It's definitely an acquired taste that I eventually learned to like after finally finding a flavor I enjoyed (pistachio). Most of them taste like powdery gummy perfume. You can't simply blame "uncultured Whities". An analogous "weird" flavor in the West is licorice. I just don't get it.
- jwhitlark 11y agoOne of the Turkish "national" drinks is Rakı, a licorice flavored alcohol. Just thought you might find it amusing.
- purpleidea 11y agoCanadian kids too!
- gaius 11y agoFun fact: in Turkey they just call it "delight".
- viach 11y agoLokum is for the tourists. Baklava is the real thing - delicious and unhealthy.
- gm3dmo 11y agoThe Young Ones nailed it with: Witch: Oh, would you two shut up! Would you like some Turkish Delight, my child? Vyvyan: Not particularly. You got any kebabs? I think the episode is "Flood".