5 ms·
slightly OT: why is HN not ipv6 yet? why isn't reddit? why pretty much anyone except google and facebook isn't?
by baq 11y ago
slightly OT: why is HN not ipv6 yet? why isn't reddit? why pretty much anyone except google and facebook isn't?
- the_mitsuhiko 11y agoBecause there is no benefit to running IPV6 if you have access to an IPV4 address.
- eeZi 11y agoThere actually is. An increasing number of ISPs is going IPv6-only with central carrier-grade NAT for IPv4. Those gateways are often overloaded, resulting in vastly better performance over IPv6.
- daveguy 11y agoExcept this study shows no difference in performance, but a 9x higher failure rate to establish an ipv6 connection.
- mutemule 11y agoThe study did a good job breaking down the different IPv6 connectivity types, but didn't discuss different IPv4 connections. GP is comparing native IPv6 to IPv4 CGNAT, but the study seems to be comparing differing forms of IPv6 to native IPv4.
- lisivka 11y agoIPv6 traffic is much slower. In my case (I use Miredo client), link to Portsmouth, ServerHouse, GB is up to 30Mbit by IPv4 but no more than 1Mbit by IPv6.
- eeZi 11y agoYou have native IPv4 and IPv6 over a tunnel, so of course IPv6 is going to be slower. The point is that for an increasing number of users, it's the exact opposite.
- scurvy 11y agoNAT v4 addresses are no fun. IPv6 addressing is a big win there. Especially in the mobile space.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y ago> NAT v4 addresses are no fun. Everybody runs behind a NAT anyways, most systems work just find with multiple layers of NATs. I have been running an internal double NAT for months and the only reason I removed one layer from my onion was that back to mac fails badly with multiple layers of NATs.
- scurvy 11y agoNo, not everyone runs behind a NAT system. Ever been to a university where everyone gets an non-RFC1918 IPv4 address? That's how IPv6 is. When I worked at Microsoft, everyone had a routed address on their workstations, too. As you just admitted, NAT breaks things. Double NAT and CGN breaks a lot more. What about people who have no choice or no say in whether or not their Internet is NAT'd? There are ISP's where customers don't get routed IPv4 addresses. They get RFC1918 addresses and lots of double NAT'ing occurs. It's a bad scene.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y ago> No, not everyone runs behind a NAT system. Ever been to a university where everyone gets an non-RFC1918 IPv4 address? That's how IPv6 is. When I worked at Microsoft, everyone had a routed address on their workstations, too. Every normal customer is, every normal business is. Old institutions do not count because they are in a privileged position nobody else on the web is. > As you just admitted, NAT breaks things. And we learned to deal with it for many, many years. For many of us, a NAT is considered a feature not a bug in fact. When I run a server I already have to assume that clients are NATed and as such I design my system to work that way. IPV6 only is a non existing part of the internet and as such not really something to optimize for. I get absolutely nothing currently by enabling IPV6 on my server because I cannot depend on it.
- scurvy 11y agoFacebook says that IPv6 is faster and clients stay on their site longer. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EfjdOc41g0s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EfjdOc41g0s
- rgbrenner 11y agoisnt reddit pretty heavily invested in aws? aws doesn't support ipv6. nor does google compute.
- nandhp 11y agoreddit uses Cloudflare now, so this isn't as big of an issue as it used to be. Some relevant links: - https://www.reddit.com/r/blog/comments/2ftv08/hell_its_about_time_reddit_now_supports_fullsite/ckcoww2 https://www.reddit.com/r/blog/comments/2ftv08/hell_its_about... - https://www.reddit.com/r/ipv6/comments/3cfqrw/cloudflare_supports_ipv6_so_why_isnt_redditcom/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ipv6/comments/3cfqrw/cloudflare_sup...
- darkr 11y agoELBs are dual-stack v4/v6 by default. That's about it though for IPv6 support on AWS. Annoyingly, Route53 supports AAAA records but their nameservers are only reachable via IPv4.
- mutemule 11y agohttps://docs.aws.amazon.com/ElasticLoadBalancing/latest/DeveloperGuide/elb-internet-facing-load-balancers.html https://docs.aws.amazon.com/ElasticLoadBalancing/latest/Deve... Unfortunately, only ELBs in EC2 Classic support IPv6: "Load balancers in a VPC support IPv4 addresses only."
- justincormack 11y agoOh so AWS's only bit of ipv6 support has regressed. Sigh.
- scurvy 11y agoComplete guess here, but their analytics, fraud, spam, etc systems are IP based and don't work well with the v6 address space yet? Cloudflare handles their front end, so it should be as easy as toggling an option in the CF admin page.
- tajen 11y agoHere's the other side of the story: Not a sysadmin, but I'm an independent programmer with an online app. I've set up a Debian vps at OVH with IPv6 and it was unbearably slow. I used to believe it was OVH, but the reason seems to be that most things e.g. package managers wait for the request in IPv6 (or the one to the DNS) timeout before trying IPv4. An apt-get upgrade takes hours. I guess there's some kind of configuration to improve that, but when step 0 of setting up IPv6 starts with problems, I just stick to stacks that I can manage.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y agoThe problem there is probably the DNS resolution. I like the way apple does it: they resolve AAAA and A in parallel. Whatever comes back first is being used for the connection attempt. Much better than waiting for a ~5 second timeout on AAAA before calling back to A.
- scurvy 11y agoThis is no longer the case. Their implementation of Happy Eyeballs now prefers IPv6 over IPv4. This is as of iOS 9 and El Capitan.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y ago> This is no longer the case. Their implementation of Happy Eyeballs now prefers IPv6 over IPv4. This is as of iOS 9 and El Capitan. It prefers, but only if it gets a response within 25milliseconds. It still queries AAAA and A in parallel.
- scurvy 11y ago> It prefers, but only if it gets a response within 25milliseconds. It still queries AAAA and A in parallel Correct. The large technology companies that shape the world are indicating their preference and shift towards an IPv6 world, yet you still claim that you see no benefit? You don't want to be on board with them?
- SFjulie1 11y agobecause some customers of "internet" like me in northern america have an IPv4 only access to the internet. Thanks to teksavvy that blames videotron. Customer services says: not a problem. There is a growing balkanisation between highly dense zone with the critical mass for getting a ROI in IPv6 transition and less dense zone that where equiped with a correct IPv4 backbone. Non mobile land connection is getting less and less connected to the internet, because "mobile" is the future. But mobile data plan and hardware are freakingly expensive as if there was a money divide on the internet between riches and poors. I don't want no smartphone, no mobile connection, no netflix: I just want a 1Megabyte/s clean internet with 100% internet connection. It is really the IPv6pocalypse here. Half baked technologies put on the front, while the basics (100% access, UDP not dropping too much, not too much lags) are decaying (as if equipments where not upgraded). I used to be a QIII player. Nowadays it is excessive lags, spikes everywhere on every continent. My internet sux balls big, QIII was a good reason to have internet. Now, everyone is happy with buggy crashy games that are sloooooowwww in gameplay but with a 4KHD 120fps. Why must I have internet? Because administrative tasks requires me to have it to gather and send forms. Else, I would drop it. 2.8% of mondial energy burnt...for this