8 ms·
Winners and Losers of Globalization (2012)
- sooth 11y agoNot sure what value there is to gain from this article. Income distribution is only one aspect of globalization and is probably the worst measure for where the wins and losses fall. And, as I see it, when you look at income distribution, alone, the results are quite obvious are they not?
- derriz 11y agoThe effect on income is "the worst measure for where the wins and losses fall"? I'm guessing that the billion or so people who have escaped absolute poverty in the last 20 years do not share your attitude that income is irrelevant. Which measures do you think are more important - given i believe that the wellbeing of all mankind is a pretty important concern.
- sooth 11y agoEnvironmental change for one. example Syria losing half its agriculture land due to climate change has a lot to do with their poverty increase which then has other downstream consequences (ISILs numbers grow -> more terrorism -> increased military spending -> govts invasion of privacy). Add on that the shoe has yet to drop for most consequences related to climate change - yet it's still real and happening today. Add to that culture and knowledge exchange effects and I'm pretty sure income distribution, while easily measured, would not be towards the the top.
- chroem- 11y agoIt's funny, because all of the countries which have done extremely well (China, Brazil) have protectionist economies while the countries that have stagnated or suffered (US, EU) have fervently implemented free trade policies. Hell, the US even had a protectionist economy from the founding revolution to the mid 20th century as part of the American School of economics. It's time to critically reevaluate these free trade policies and what they're really doing, not what we're told they're supposed to do.
- TheLogothete 11y agoPeople who implement these policies know very well what they're really doing. What do you expect? Let 3B people in China and India fend for themselves? That just leads to an enormous war, probably the end of the world. You can't be that grumpy, rich old man living on the hill nearby the village. The village is going to storm your mansion.
- chroem- 11y agoThe benefits of protectionism don't come from creating an export economy; they're the result of allowing local industry to develop and become globally competitive without getting smashed before it can even form. If you look at Brazil, they're a good example of a protectionist but not heavily export driven economy. Capitalism is not a zero sum game: everyone can have protectionist policies and still win.
- TheLogothete 11y agoPerhaps the words of Lee Kuan Yew can shed some light on the matter for you. He was a prime minister of Singapore for 3 decades and lead the country from extreme poverty to a 1st world economy. "October, 1985. […] During my official visit, I was given the honour of addressing a joint session of the US Congress. […] I spoke on an issue then at the top of the American agenda - protectionism to safeguard jobs and check growing US trade deficits with newly emerging economies of East Asia. In 20 minutes, I described how the issue of free trade was really the question of war or peace for the world. Nations wax and wane. I argued that if a nation on the rise, with an excess of energy, was not allowed to export its goods and services, its only alternative would be to expand and capture territory, incorporate the population and integrate it to make for a bigger economic unit. That was why nations had empire which they controlled as one trading bloc. It was a time-honoured way for growth. The world had moved away from that after the end of World War II in 1945. GATT, the IMF, the World Bank and new rules made possible a prosperous and dynamic Germany in spite of large numbers of Germans returning from the East into a shrunken land area So also with the Japanese, who had to leave Korea, China, Taiwan and Southeast Asia and be packed into a few Japanese islands. The Germans and the Japanese were able to stay within their boundaries and grow through trade and investments. They cooperated and competed with other nations and were able to prosper and flourish without wars. But if trade in goods and services was blocked, then China would revert to its historical solution of small warring states conquering one another to gain control of more territory and people until they become one colossal continental empire. This tight, logical exposition may have convinced the legislators intellectually, but many found it emotionally difficult to accept."
- lordnacho 11y agoWell I see one simple explanation for this. By simple, I mean short, rather than uncomplicated. It's easy to move capital, but it's hard to move labour. That's the world we've built. So what are the main conclusions? 1) The very wealthy are much wealthier 2) The somewhat wealthy are no better off 3) The formerly very poor are now much less poor. Why would that be? If you're a business, you can move your production to China (of course that gap has moved in a lot over the years). So as the owner you reap the profits of mobile capital. The poor folks in China benefit as well, as they now have better paying jobs utilising the moved capital. They benefit a lot, but actually they would be better off if they could participate in the Western labour market. They can't just come here, so they make do with what opportunities they have. By experience a fair few of these people are just as useful as anyone in the West, but that's how the world is built. The "somewhat wealthy" are the Western middle class. They don't own the capital, the best they can do is hold on to some of the managerial roles if they're upper middle, or lose their jobs if they're outsourced. Since the firms are more profitable having moved production, the managers can do allright, but they're not all buying yachts. The factory workers in the West are a bit buggered. They whole point of moving is to avoid their expense. A lot of people have had to find new things to do.
- force_reboot 11y agoI think there is broad agreement for you explanation across the political and economic spectrum. In management/MBA speak they refer to the change that is occurring as "climbing the value chain". Each nation must apply its labor to higher value-added industries in order to improve it standard of living. This might seem like an impossible task, but there is no in principle reason why most Chinese coal miners might not be cancer researchers in one generation. Or most Western shelf stackers might not become programmers.