3 ms·
Ex options trader here. Something about the ingenuity of this scheme is familiar. So basically they make two firms, and each quarter swap which firm is doing t
by lordnacho 11y ago
Ex options trader here. Something about the ingenuity of this scheme is familiar.
So basically they make two firms, and each quarter swap which firm is doing the business in order to get privileges that only firms that haven't traded much in the previous period would earn. I wonder how they thought the SEC would not find this out, that there's two companies outside a financial centre with owners of the same name and birthdate, alternating their trades.
I wonder if it's going to be considered a loophole that will be closed or an abuse. I suppose it could be either.
The other thing, gaming the algos, I have a good idea of how it might have happened.
You see, options people (the ones I know) are not as technologically sophisticated as stock people or futures people. Many of them rely on quite simple systems to quote their orders. Several of these are off-the-shelf systems with functions you'd expect: an autotrader than joins the BBO in some size, on every single option, not particularly fast either. This works fine most of the time because options traders are not overly concerned with the action on a specific option; they need to know their delta/gamma/vega, and those can all be thrown in a big bucket to be hedged as appropriate. The spread is normally quite wide, so as long as you're not being gamed on everything, you have ample room to lock in some profits.
People writing sophisticated algos (whom I also know) know how to do an ignore size, ie don't just blindly follow a tiny order.
- SeanDav 11y ago> "I wonder if it's going to be considered a loophole that will be closed or an abuse. I suppose it could be either." This is addressed in the notes at the bottom of the article: > "Specifically, as the SEC says: All orders for multiple accounts beneficially owned or controlled by the same person or entity, and all sub-accounts of a person or entity’s master account, must be aggregated when determining whether the 390-order threshold has been exceeded by that person or entity. If in fact Behruz Afshar controlled both Fineline and Makino, then he should have aggregated them, and by pretending that Shahryar was the sole owner of Makino the twins evaded that requirement. "
- itchyouch 11y agoRegarding the "options people not being as technically sophisticated" One of the stories from the former PHLX Options Exchange, now part of the Nasdaq umbrella is that their rapidfire price protection feature was one of the killer features that was a competitive advantage over the other options exchanges back in the day. Now a days, all the major options exchanges have this feature. A market maker required to quote in say 80% (by self-governance rules) of options in a given underlying has a lot of quotes to update when the market moves. AAPL has 1000+ options, so a market maker may be obligated to quote at least 800 options books. When the market moved, there would be 800 options to update. With order/ack latency around ~30-50u today, but around 400u-1ms 10 years ago, it could take almost half a second to 1 second to get those quotes updated. In that eternity, a fast trader could swoop in and execute against the old quotes to their advantage. Rapidfire implemnted an atomic cancellation of orders if too many options executed on a single side only such as only the bids getting executed. This significantly minimized the risk of getting eaten alive on say a couple hundred contracts every single time the market moved.
- bd_at_rivenhill 11y agoI know that ISE had some sort of automatic cancellation feature from the beginning or very close to the beginning, so not sure if PHLX was the originator of this idea. Also, nearly all electronic options exchanges have a "mass quote" feature that allows changes in prices over a large number instruments at the same time. I would expect that this feature is available on every US exchange and only a few overseas exchanges lack it, and managing the generation of mass quotes vs exchange message rate limits is one of the more complicated parts of designing option quoting systems. Finally, there is also a "cancel by underlying" feature that cancels all options on a specific underlying; if it is the case that the mass quote doesn't allow quotes to be cancelled (i.e. modified to 0 size), then the usual approach is to cancel by underlying and then immediately requote at the new price level.
- reinhardt 11y ago> I wonder how they thought the SEC would not find this out, that there's two companies outside a financial centre with owners of the same name and birthdate, alternating their trades. I'm wondering how harder is to find this out if it's not so blatant, say two owner who are friends and based on different locations. Or for added stealthiness, if there's a third party between them so they never contact each other directly (at least online).
- keithpeter 11y agoOr perhaps 10 companies that all keep their trading level below 390 per day, but happen to be owned through some other company by the same person or a couple of people? I suppose it comes down to the definition of an entity.