9 ms·
Mozilla has really lost touch with its users. Good on them for backtracking on this, but it's a symptom of high level decisions taken without running them past
by scrollaway 11y ago
Mozilla has really lost touch with its users.
Good on them for backtracking on this, but it's a symptom of high level decisions taken without running them past anybody else. Pocket is another one of those symptoms.
There is no reason these things can get past development and the various betas without people yelling out "hey, we should not be doing this, it's damaging to our product". This happens in companies that have become too large to understand their own users.
And it's not limited to Firefox - Mozilla as a whole no longer understands its core mission. Its motto of "Freeing the web". Development on absolutely critical components of a free web such as Persona or a good email client stops, to make way for development on the completely unrealistic Firefox OS.
Not that the world doesn't need a free mobile OS, but Firefox OS is not it. Not only is it doomed to be awful (layers on top of layers on top of layers... browsers are not great for batteries), they're spending decades of manpower trying to match android 2.0, then selling that to users. I had the misfortune of trying out the Flame. What a disaster that was. I can't see myself ever trying out fxos again without a lot of changes and convincing, so go sell that to non-technical users...
- mburns 11y agoMozilla had already committed to decoupling Pocket following a developer summit this Summer, due in part (presumably) to the vocal minority of users that hated the very idea of it.
- scrollaway 11y agoI'm well aware. My point is that if the company knew its userbase, it would not have happened. I don't care about it by the way, I like Pocket and I use the functionality. But it was obvious that there would be drama. Edit: In reply to the dead comment below, no I do not think Pocket should be preinstalled, and I really hope that's not the message that's getting through in my posts.
- ossreality 11y agoI like Google Voice and I use the functionality. Should every single Firefox user have a Google Voice extension pre-installed? It's just painfully stupid in every way. If it was a built in extension that by-default talked to a Mozilla hosted open source Pocket clone, we might be having a different conversation.... but I'd still be annoyed. Just as annoyed as I am that Chromium (yes, Chromium, not Chrome) comes with a god damn Google Docs extension.
- rtpg 11y agoI think you underestimate the diversity of the userbase. Especially in places like Europe until Chrome ate their lunch, Firefox users were basically a random sample of the population.
- x0x0 11y agoRight, but at least in the US, there is a significant contingent of firefox users and advocates that are very privacy sensitive. Call it the Jonathan Mayer wing. FF should have known these people would be very upset.
- rtpg 11y agoI hope so but sometimes tradeoffs have to be made. Compromise is the name of the game, and if BSD development is any indicator, security/privacy focus users are not ones to jump in and help keep lights on in most circumstances That said I'm not sure FF could have done better things, but in their situation I would be trying to find some revenue streams that weren't Google
- scrollaway 11y agoThere was no compromise necessary. Pocket is possible as an extension, cf the work being done right now to integrate it as one. Why was it rushed out before? What was so pressing about it that it needed to be in "the next firefox version" and massively damage Mozilla's reputation, instead of waiting a few months and passing it without a fuss?
- sangnoir 11y ago> Compromise is the name of the game In most cases, I'd agree.However, it's never a good idea to compromize on your mission statement. How does pre-bundled Pocket integration promote an open web? IMO, it goes against it. While they are losing market-share, Mozilla are not running out of cash any time soon and they are not in a death spiral. They can afford to, and should think long and hard about how they diversify their revenue streams, rather than trying random decisions that alienate part of their userbase trying to find anything that sticks - which is the impression I'm getting.
- x1024 11y agoWow, the corporate speak is strong with this one. If they think it's what "the majority" wants - let them just ignore the hater devs and leave it. See how far that gets them. They are removing it because it's a poor idea that's poorly thought out. People won't bite the PR.
- throwaway2048 11y agoThey arn't even removing it, they are turning it into an extension and then still bundling it.
- ossreality 11y agoWow, what a horribly insulting way of putting that. As someone who initially thought Pocket reactions were over the top, I'm just a bit in shock. I don't think you meant it even, but I'd still consider re-wording that if you represent Mozilla in any capacity whatsoever. Install Firefox. Boot it. Laugh at the fucking toolbar because it reminds you of IE6 with a shitton of toolbars installed. It's atrocious.
- pdkl95 11y agoGiven how strongly Mozilla has pushed extensions in the past (traditionally core features pushed into extensions several times), what they should have done is simply offer Pocket as an "officially bundled" extension for the normal download. They could then trivially offer alternative downloads without the extension, making everybody happy. This idea could even be pushed further: they could have several alternative downloads that are simply pre-bundled extensions. Alongside their normal version they could have "minimalist", "dev tools", "max privacy", "social/chat helpers", and the like. Most people would still download the normal version, but this might introduce more people to extensions, who would normally never even know about addons.mozilla.org.
- CaptSpify 11y agoI agree, but i had heard that certain components wouldnt work as an extension. That being said, they should have extended their api to make it work as an extension
- ecnahc515 11y agoThat's exactly why it came bundled as a non extension. So they could figure out how exactly they needed to extend the extensions API after having in built in a for a while.
- epoch1970 11y agoThey could have done such experimentation in an unreleased fork of the browser. Or if they needed wider testing, they could have released this separate, experimental branch and clearly labeled it so that people would know what they were getting into if they installed it. Mozilla didn't need to force Pocket on so many Firefox users who wanted absolutely nothing to do with it.
- sangnoir 11y agoWhy the rush to distribute it first and figure it out later? Couldn't they figure out the API extensions required during development, but before shipping?
- e15ctr0n 11y ago> Although the company emphasizes that Pocket and Telefonica didn’t pay for placement in the Firefox browser, Mozilla Corp. chief legal and business officer Denelle Dixon-Thayer told WIRED that Mozilla has revenue sharing arrangements with both companies. http://www.wired.com/2015/12/mozilla-is-flailing-when-the-web-needs-it-the-most/ http://www.wired.com/2015/12/mozilla-is-flailing-when-the-we... Can you explain what the revenue sharing agreement is, especially after so many Mozilla employees have vehemently denied that Mozilla got money from Pocket for the tie-up?
- rffn 11y agoThis would be outright stupid. While I do not want any default ties to external services like Pocket in the browser I for sure hope that such a data harvesting and customer acquisition effort at least yields money for Mozilla to further fund open source development.
- dao- 11y agoSee https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10681622 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10681622
- cpeterso 11y agoThe work to move Pocket to an add-on is happening in Firefox bug 1215694: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1215694 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1215694
- volaski 11y agoIf you ran a survey to every firefox user asking "Would you prefer this Pocket bookmarklet show up by default or not", I'm sure this wouldn't have been a "vocal minority" group. Most people (in terms of ratio) hadn't heard of Pocket and to them it's just a spammy new bookmarklet. Most people are not "vocal" about it because they don't know where to complain. Just because you don't see vocal people doesn't mean it's all fine.
- bobajeff 11y agoI wouldn't mind using a polished phone from Mozilla if it gave me full control over it (ie. not limit all software to non-overridable restrictions) and was well supported (ie. not abandoned or put on maintenance after 2 years) and didn't assume I want to send personal data to a server by default.
- funkyy 11y agoThis is silly. People openly criticize Mozilla for their action, there is general uproar - yet company decides to ignore its "power users" and do whatever they think they should. While this might work for some (where leader is visionary and strong), I believe that the problem is here - companies that are seeing drop in growth are fixated on getting better numbers instead of increase engagement and user value. They will forsake their core functions, ignore users and make a "better" clone of existing competitor for short term bump in engagement. Every huge company did that before sliding downhill.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kozukumi 11y agoI would have been interested to see a Firefox OS in the same vein as Chrome OS. A clean, functional Linux distro that works out of the box with a simple (yet maybe hidden) switch to open it up to running native apps. With XUL extensions they were actually in a get position years ago to provide more powerful extensions than Chrome could. But they are killing off XUL in the future to be some kind of Chrome-copy. Unfortunately I feel the world is going to be Webkit oriented in the future with Chrome, Safari and even Edge being mostly compatible (extension wise, apparently, time will tell). I understand them wanting to make it in mobile space but the bar to entry in the mobile market is so damn high not even Microsoft can do it.
- muddi900 11y agoThe biggest reason I use Firefox over Chrome is because of DownThemAll; an extension that would stop working when turn off XUL support. Trying to follow market trends is whats gonna kill Firefox.
- pcwalton 11y agoEliminating XUL isn't being done for the fun of it—there are significant benefits. This comment also presupposes that there's no way to implement DownThemAll in the Web Extensions model. See this thread (including my replies to it) the last time this came up: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10099816 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10099816
- throwaway2048 11y agoFirefoxOS cant even offer a more meaningfully free experience than android, because they used the same brain damaged closed source driver model. Meaning not only is your OS partly non free and unable to be modified, you are locked into a single kernel version forever, that is very likely soon to have exploits. I have absolutely no idea why it even exists.
- jessedhillon 11y agoDoes anyone who shares this criticism have a reasonable, realistic plan for how Mozilla can make money? There's a very large payroll keeping this project alive, and apart from advertising revenue, I just don't see how you monetize a browser.
- funkyy 11y agoIf you cannot monetize core product create some additional ones that will bring you revenue. They do not need to make money from browser, but they can make money by using this platform to promoting other, paid products.
- scrollaway 11y agoPocket is not monetized. The sponsored tiles happened to be, but the symptoms are not related to greed... which arguably is even scarier.
- detaro 11y agoWell, apparently there is a "revenue sharing agreement" with regards to Pocket, despite the previous statements that Pocket didn't pay for the integration.
- dao- 11y agoPocket didn't pay for the integration, period. Now, whether there's money flowing as a result of the integration is an interesting question. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10681622 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10681622
- sangnoir 11y agoThe question is how much money and at what (ideological) cost? Employing people is not Mozilla's core mission. As the recent Wired article[1] says "...the Mozilla Corp. must still find ways to make money so it can pay the people to develop Firefox. But if its money-making schemes stray too far from Mozilla’s ideological roots, there will be little to distinguish Mozilla from every other Silicon Valley outfit" I hold Mozilla to a higher standard, just as Mozilla ought to. 1. http://www.wired.com/2015/12/mozilla-is-flailing-when-the-web-needs-it-the-most/ http://www.wired.com/2015/12/mozilla-is-flailing-when-the-we...
- bcoates 11y agoOnce they sold out on DRM my attitude to the whole project was "why bother". If I want a browser made by people who cheerfully assist my enemies I may as well use one that's not mediocre in every other aspect.
- dao- 11y agoSold out how? They tried but at some point it was a lost cause with every other relevant browser and the content industry pushing for DRM. Within a few years, users would have been unable to access services like Netflix in Firefox and switched to other browsers. How would that have helped save the web? With double the market share, maybe Mozilla could have pushed back longer and harder, but unfortunately that's not the reality we live in anymore.
- burnte 11y ago> it's a symptom of high level decisions taken without running them past anybody else As much as I love and respect many of the people at Mozilla, and the project itself (I spent 5 years of my life volunteering in the early years), this has been a systemic problem all along, pretty much from day one. Certain types of decisions get made by a very small group of people who somehow acquire a tone-deafness when it comes to outside criticism. Then, when the decisions become public, the negative reaction is not only not understood, sometimes it's not believed, or not taken seriously, and simply serves to retrench the decision makers in their choice and they go radio silent. Then after a while, they may or may not reevaluate that without any form of communication as to what's going on inside. Then, a year or two later, it'll happen again. I am NOT insulting people, there's no malice in that process, no lack of intelligence, no evil intents. I use the phrase "tone deafness" purposefully because I feel it conveys the idea that these bad decisions come simply from some acquired inability to perceive and understand. They're all god, smart people, but something happens in the Mozilla culture where communication with the outside world becomes difficult and of lessened importance. It's odd.
- scrollaway 11y agoThat's really sad to hear. I was hoping it was a more recent symptom, but something that has been ingrained much longer is ... much harder to get rid of. If anyone from Mozilla is reading this, what can be done to fix it?
- burnte 11y agoI think it was inherited from the Netscape culture, because it was present early on. And frankly, given that for so long NSCP could do no wrong, it's understandable to a point.
- devsquid 11y agoTo be fair tho, it seemed like a decent revenue path to pursue. I can't see how it would bother users much. While revenue has increased this year that doesn't mean it will next year. I am all for Mozilla trying new ways to generate cash to stay around. If FF died, Chrome would be a lonely browser :)
- frik 11y ago> Mozilla has really lost touch with its users Most developers and the community are great. But the management level incl. their new CEO and their UI designers have little clue about their products and what their community is all about. Mr Eich was part of Netscape and Mozilla from the very beginning and created the Javascript language in a few days - he understood the community definitely better. The transition from Gecko to Servo in their products will be critical for Mozilla. It will give them a competitive advantage. FirefoxOS runs highend Android smartphone just as fast as Android 5x. So it definitely has a future, like WebOS is nowadays in every LG SmartTV, and Bada/Tizen is in every Samsung SmartTV (they use a 4 or 8 core ARM board with 2+GB RAM). And ChromeOS works fine on lower end notebooks.
- Khaine 11y agoMozilla has become a shadow of itself. Sadly I think it is like yahoo and going to slowly fade away. I hope new management can come on board and bring back life, energy and trust to mozilla
- dao- 11y ago> Most developers and the community are great. But the management level incl. their new CEO and their UI designers have little clue about their products and what their community is all about. Mr Eich was part of Netscape and Mozilla from the very beginning and created the Javascript language in a few days - he understood the community definitely better. Their new CEO Chris Beard has been with Mozilla for a long time as well, with a break. I also expect it was his decision to pull the plug on sponsored tiles in order to focus 100% on making content discovery awesome for users (maybe with monetization as an afterthought). Saying he has little clue about the community just when he made a decision I imagine the majority of the community supports seems a bit odd. One could argue he should have done this earlier, but don't forget that Mozilla needs revenue to survive, and 90+% of the revenue coming from a single partner is a risk that will bite Mozilla sooner or later. So in order to diversify revenue, this was a reasonable experiment. > FirefoxOS runs highend Android smartphone just as fast as Android 5x. So it definitely has a future, like WebOS is nowadays in every LG SmartTV, and Bada/Tizen is in every Samsung SmartTV (they use a 4 or 8 core ARM board with 2+GB RAM). And ChromeOS works fine on lower end notebooks. And Firefox OS is on Panasonic smart TVs.
- nnethercote 11y ago> Mozilla has really lost touch with its users. Good on them for backtracking on this, but... This kind of negativity is really common on HN and it makes me sad. "This group of people did something I don't like, and then they changed their mind and stopped doing it. But rather than being happy about fixing their mistake, I'm going to keep criticizing them for making the mistake in the first place." People (and groups of people) make mistakes. Spending your whole life holding grudges like this is a recipe for permanent grumpiness.
- tedunangst 11y agoThe mistake is being highlighted as a symptom of a larger problem. There's little indication the larger problem has been addressed to prevent the recurrence of such mistakes.
- scrollaway 11y agoI understand you don't like the negativity. So tell me now, how did this happen? "Sponsored tiles", nobody batted an eye? Will you try telling me the devs themselves did not see this as a potential source of problem? (I know for a fact that's not the case) OK, let's assume this is a simple mistake. Now what happened with Pocket? We all know devs want to make it into an extension (and are working on it)... so why was Pocket pushed so hard and couldn't wait a couple of Fx versions before being released in a way that would obviously create drama? If you step back and think about these issues you'll see they're systemic. God damn right I'm concerned about Mozilla, a company I respect a lot, becoming a shell of what it claims it stands for.
- Manishearth 11y ago> so why was Pocket pushed so hard Was it? All I saw was it being integrated into Firefox, and there being a lot of backlash. Against that backlash, there were a couple of people pushing hard to justify it, but they were either independent or Mozilla employees (often from a different team) posting independent opinions. I don't think Mozilla pushed Pocket a lot. Pushing features through the release cycle is pretty common. Bear in mind that Mozilla integrated Pocket because it was the kind of feature it wanted to have in Sync (or Accounts, whatever it's called), but decided to use a third party service instead of making their own. From that POV it's much more reasonable. Not denying that it could have been done better with a pluggable open API and an open source equivalent (or whatever), but it's not that bad from that lens. Sponsored tiles was an experiment, IIRC. Mozilla wanted to see if non-annoying, easy-to-disable ads could be used to fill otherwise blank space. It seems to have failed. But I would guess that a lot of the devs were hopeful about this experiment. I (not a Mozilla employee, but I do contribute a lot) was, at least.