9 ms·
Silicon Valley Is Not Driving Jobs Growth
- mikelyons 11y agoIt doesn't have to! In fact, it should be driving everyone OUT of a job. It should be driving us to evolve away from the way we survived in the past, by trading time for money.
- kiba 11y agoThere's only so many jobs you need to create. The US have a population of about three hundred million. Not all of them work. So, let cut it in half. You have a labor force of one hundred fifty million people. But they're not all employed. Some of them have great jobs, some don't. Their wages are sometime shit, the working condition's terrible. Some people sucks at keeping a job. Some just don't have the skills. Businesses aren't exactly the paragon of efficiency either. They find it easier to just reject an entire category people, such as convicts. So, you have this massive inefficiency where people who wants job can't get them. High demand job can't be filled because they can't train the right people or they reject too many suitable candidates, such as old programmers. Other factors conspire to make living more difficult. For example, real estate costs mean your cost of living is high, and you need to make X amount of money to have a roof over your head. Pressure is often not relieved because of housing policies and local politics. Everything else gets cheaper to an approximation. Though it seemed that the price of computer remain constant, meaning your dollars buy more bang for its buck rather than decreasing in nominal price.
- augustocallejas 11y agoHere's a though experiment I came up with several years ago: Say one day you created a copy of the Earth and with that copy, it had the same population as the current Earth, and they were connected so you can travel between them easily. I can see that these two worlds would need twice as many barbers as the current world. Would these two new worlds need twice as many Google/Facebook/etc. employees?
- _-__--- 11y agothere would be a hell of a lot more snapchats of people driving over that interplanetary bridge
- myth_buster 11y agoThe snaps would be at best fuzzy what with you traveling at the speed of light...
- bpodgursky 11y agoHaving twice the market would allow specialization into technology we don't have now because they are not profitable; division of labor works better the more people you have. Intel would never be possible in a world with 1mm people; their fab centers are spectacularly expensive fixed costs. So no, we wouldn't need 2x the Google employees, but there would be a need for employees in a market that doesn't exist now.
- ethbro 11y ago> Intel would never be possible in a world with 1mm people; their fab centers are spectacularly expensive fixed costs. I think that's an interesting point that's the continuation of OP's line of thinking + Ford's original thinking. Facebook/etc (to return to the pure-digital companies) would not be possible in a world without X people with disposable income. It's tough to make money on people who can't afford things. How's MySpace doing vs Facebook? Which imho is a rebuttal the opinion that these kinds of "pure tech" jobs do scale -- true, but only in relation to the number of other jobs people are already earning income from. You can't squeeze blood (revenue) from an (unemployed) stone.
- kiba 11y agoSome communities/field/industry could use some injection of brainpower. For example, creative writing communities can always use more manpower, to churn ideas, to work on stories, and to experiment, and to edit. Not every story niches or original ideas is filled or explored.
- 11y ago
- steverb 11y agoThe lack of jobs growth doesn't seem that surprising, but the lack of productivity growth does. Is it just that new technologies aren't really all that relevant to increasing productivity? Are we just not adopting technologies that would make us more productive? I'd love to have a glimmer as to what the root cause of that is.
- lintiness 11y agoa lot of multi-millionaires minted by social networking sites which do nothing but impede productivity.
- MAGZine 11y agoProductivity has grown tremendously since the 70s in non-construction segments. The largest improvements have been made. Arguably, in the last 5-10 years, tech improvements have been only incremental compared to the last 15+.
- laotzu 11y agoIt may be that the core problem of production is one that was already solved by hardware at the end of the industrial revolution. Software can now be used to solve the 2nd part of the problem, which is distribution. >In technology's "invisible" world, inventors continually increase the quantity and quality of performed work per each volume or pound of material, erg of energy, and unit of worker and "overhead" time invested in each given increment of attained functional performance. This complex process we call progressive ephemeralization. In 1970, the sum total of increases in overall technological know-how and their comprehensive integration took humanity across the epochal but invisible threshold into a state of technically realizable and economically feasible universal success for all humanity -Buckminster Fuller, Grunch of Giants Our means of production have already served to produce a renewable surplus of all the physiological needs of humanity (food, water, shelter etc). The problem is in distributing it fairly which is why almost 50% of the world population struggles to obtain these necessities. >The white man knows how to make everything, but he does not know how to distribute it. -Sitting Bull
- austenallred 11y agoWe're really using 24-year periods of time to determine what jobs were created by technology? I mean, I didn't expect rigorous statistical analysis, but this is nothing.
- homogeneous 11y ago> in 2010, only 0.5% of the US labour force is employed in industries that did not exist in 2000 Well that doesn't seem too surprising, I can't really think of many industries that exist today that didn't in 2000.
- staticint 11y agoFor comparison, software developers make up about 0.7% of the labour force (2012)[1]. It is always surprising to me how small the industry actually is. [1] http://www.bls.gov/ooh/computer-and-information-technology/software-developers.htm http://www.bls.gov/ooh/computer-and-information-technology/s...
- bunnymancer 11y ago"The magnitude of workers shifting into new industries is strikingly small: in 2010, only 0.5% of the US labour force is employed in industries that did not exist in 2000…" Pretty sure we had computers prior to 2000... Considering the whole millennium bug scare.. So "Software Developer" isn't part of the statistic.
- myth_buster 11y agoOptimists argue that throughout the history of capitalism, new technologies have always led to new jobs in the long run. But pessimists say that this trend isn’t guaranteed to continue, and the chance that we are in an era where wealth is created without jobs raises very thorny questions about how that wealth will be distributed fairly. Nothing keeps the populace employed as good ol' agriculture does! Sure there are "new jobs" but job creation doesn't have a fundamental law analogous to the law of conservation of momentum. Efficient tech is at it's very heart a job destroyer. So with growing population and shrinking meaningful jobs what we end up with is civil unrest. Hence we have people employed doing busy works who come home to constant stream of "news" and "entertainment" and another section doing the busy work churning out these contents! Apart from breeding inequality it also breed discontent. Perhaps evolutionarily humans are wired to feel satisfaction at the end of a hard days work.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Apocryphon 11y agoWall Street burned up a lot of its goodwill with the public with the various financial scandals. Certainly, they're still in business and will be in for the foreseeable future. But can Silicon Valley have the foresight to preemptively defuse future backlash against job destruction brought upon by automation? Perhaps it's time to get some major tech CEOs pushing forward proposals for basic income. Certainly some VCs have already been making public statements about it.
- hwstar 11y agoSilicon valley doesn't produce much hardware like it did in the past. Instead it creates businesses with questionable customer value such as social networking, personal assistant services, short term house rental services, and other software-as-a-service businesses. There will be an implosion of these SAAS businesses at some point. After the dust clears, it will be interesting to see if Silicon Valley still is able to produce goods which customers want, or if some other area of the world will take over (e.g. Bangalore, Shenzhen).
- j10t 11y ago> There will be an implosion of these SAAS businesses at some point. Why?
- hwstar 11y agoNothing is ever done for free by businesses (Even though it appears like it is free, you do pay for it indirectly) At some point the profit motive will drive businesses to take things too far and threshold will be crossed. This will either result in customer defections, or increased government regulation. A shakeout will ensue, and only businesses strong enough be profitable will remain.
- kapilkale 11y agoThere are so many faulty premises here * silicon valley doesn't produce much hardware (evidence for this being true? obviously we hear a ton about software, but what about tesla, intel, nest, apple, google, etc?) * businesses such as social networking, personal assistance services, short-term house rental services, and other saas have questionable customer value (why?) * there will be an implosion of these saas businesses (why?)
- laotzu 11y ago>silicon valley doesn't produce much hardware (evidence for this being true? obviously we hear a ton about software, but what about tesla, intel, nest, apple, google, etc?) Consider the amount of hardware that a modern smart phone replaces such as the calculator, phone, video camera, television, radio, clock... They are producing less hardware because hardware is becoming increasingly integrated as software: >The hardware world tends to move into software form at the speed of light. -Marshall McLuhan
- rattray 11y agoThis article doesn't actually seem to provide any evidence to support its claim - the actual factoid at the heart of the article is that Total Factor Productivity (TFP) has fallen since the 90's, which is irrelevant. The only pieces of evidence supporting the "No Jobs Growth" claim are Facebook's employee count from _2013_ (which has since grown by almost 50% to 12000 [0]), and the claim that "in 2010, only 0.5% of the US labour force is employed in industries that did not exist in 2000", which has nothing to do with "Silicon Valley" since the industry existed in 2000, too. Remarkably low-quality reporting. [0] - http://newsroom.fb.com/company-info/ http://newsroom.fb.com/company-info/
- electic 11y agoYou make a valid point. I would also to add that most tech companies that are consumer facing also tend to create a "halo effect" and drive additional job growth in parallel markets. For example, take Ad Tech. The number of jobs that have been created in the advertising sector as a result of tech is large: http://chiefmartec.com/2013/05/the-very-cool-marketing-technology-lumascape/ http://chiefmartec.com/2013/05/the-very-cool-marketing-techn...
- rwmj 11y agoWhat do 12000 people do at Facebook? Edit: (Apart from sitting around and downvoting me). Does it really take 12000 people to run a site where people write about what they're doing, and upload some photos and videos? Instagram had 13 employees when they were acquired by Facebook.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- diziet 11y agoTo get a sense of what kind of work is done at facebook, please visit their careers page: https://www.facebook.com/careers/teams/ https://www.facebook.com/careers/teams/
- pconner 11y agoA huge amount of infrastructure is needed for Facebook's scale. People have to create, manage, and maintain that infrastructure. And that's ignoring the multitude of complex user-facing products Facebook has (the number of which has grown significantly over the last few years).
- optimusclimb 11y agoIf you had a chunk of savings and you invested in a business - would you optimize on needing to hire more people as the business grows? Or prefer that the growth of your business doesn't scale linearly with employee head count? Every time I hear people make these complaints, I wonder, "Would you prefer to get your cash from an ATM, or wait in line for a teller?"
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pbreit 11y agoConsidering the point of Silicon Valley is to eliminate jobs, that doesn't seem entirely surprising.
- programminggeek 11y agoSoftware does two things generally - automates things, and improves information transportation (communication). Neither of those create new jobs. If anything, they both seek to remove jobs and displace existing middlemen.
- jondubois 11y agoThis article resonates with my observations. I think most of the companies which have been making a lot of money are entertainment companies. Facebook is an entertainment company, it probably delivers negative economic efficiency growth - Today it's common for employees to check their Facebook and instagram during work hours (which reduces their productivity). People also spend more time playing games (there are so many options available; social games, virtual reality, iPhone apps...). Then there is YouTube which helps create jobs for more entertainers and at the same time it lowers productivity efficiency in the workplace - It's a tool for procrastination. Even enterprise companies aren't delivering efficiency improvements. Docker has gotten a lot of hype but I am yet to see it deliver efficiency improvements in industry - Particularly on the deployment side. I dont see how hiding complexity inside containers actually reduces the overall complexity of the system. Maybe the real solution is to use fewer tools which have simpler boot logic? You could argue that Docker is great for PaaS, but then you have to ask the question of whether PaaS itself delivers efficiency improvements? Maybe platforms like Amazon Lambda will deliver, but so far what I've seen is that big companies in general don't use PaaS. I think companies which deliver real efficiency at the moment are being ignored by the market in favour of companies which have a large marketing budget.
- garagemc2 11y agoYoutube, facebook, twitter, instagram have all created jobs in my organisation. People are hired to create content and maintain the accounts. They have made/forced the organisation to be more customer facing and friendly.
- garagemc2 11y agoYoutube, facebook, twitter, instagram have all created jobs in my organisation. People are hired to create content and maintain the accounts. They have made/forced the organisation to be more customer facing and friendly.
- zacharycohn 11y agoThat first graphic is terrible data vis. Four columns. First one is for 80 years of data. Second is for 30 years. Last two are for 8 years. Then they draw conclusions based on the differences??
- jonesb6 11y agoWith the latest trend of hiring employees who are already masters of their craft, it really becomes a process of regurgitation. You don't train up new employees, you hire them. Thus no job growth IMO.
- matchagaucho 11y ago"Free" web services, such as Facebook, do not necessarily benefit from high employee/end user ratios.