5 ms·
I'm having a hard time understanding why this is bad. If people experiment on themselves, then it seems the worst that could happen is they injure themselves t
by rwmj 11y ago
I'm having a hard time understanding why this is bad.
If people experiment on themselves, then it seems the worst that could happen is they injure themselves to such an extent they require expensive ongoing medical treatment paid for by the rest of society (if they die, they just win a Darwin Award).
There will be charlatans (as with stem cell treatments) who try and sell this to desperate people with terminal diseases, but that's already covered by fraud statutes.
The upsides from human enhancement are pretty limitless and exciting in the long run.
- kragen 11y agoFrom the point of view of someone who wants to use CRISPR in more mainstream research, that's not the worst that can happen. Worse would be that someone experiments on themself and the result is so horrifying that it generates a movement to ban CRISPR or gene therapies in general, and that that movement is successful, so your research career is over — along with the possible benefits of gene therapies to humanity, condemning, for example, hundreds of thousands of children to horrible deaths each year from curable genetic illnesses.
- pmoriarty 11y agoThis is exactly what happened to LSD, which was a very promising research chemical when it was first introduced. Over a thousand research studies were done on it before research on it was effectively banned due to the public's fear and outrage over sensationalistic news stories of its non-medical use. It took about 40 years for psychedlic research to start up again, and even now the handful of studies that make up the "psychedelic renaissance" are almost all on compounds other than LSD, because of the stigma LSD still has attached to it.
- wlesieutre 11y agoGreat quote from Doudna in the article I linked elsewhere: “We have seen it in movies before: When a new technology comes along, of any type, people tend to get very, very excited about it and it stimulates lots of thinking and ideas. But the danger is that there is a race to do something that the field isn’t really ready for, or that causes either perceived or real danger to the community in some way, or something unethical,” she said. “That creates a backlash that can really set a field back.” “Gene therapy is a great example of that,” she added. “There was a race into the clinic, with lots of excitement, and then when patients died there was a backlash that destroyed the field for more than a decade. We would really love to avoid that here.”
- wlesieutre 11y agoThe significant change with CRISPR (compared to other ways that transhumanists might accidentally kill themselves) is that it can make heritable genetic changes. Experiment on yourself, sure, but to pass your untested experimentation along to children is a totally different ethical question. Recent news: http://news.berkeley.edu/2015/12/01/crispr-inventor-calls-for-pause-in-editing-heritable-genes/ http://news.berkeley.edu/2015/12/01/crispr-inventor-calls-fo... > A three-day international summit on the ethics of making permanent, hereditary changes in the human genome begins today in Washington, D.C., the fruit of an informal discussion organized in January by Jennifer Doudna, the inventor of the CRISPR-Cas9 technology that makes such changes cheap and easy. AFIAK this should only come up if people are messing with sperm/eggs, but it's definitely something to be aware of. Can CRISPER change existing DNA that would alter future sperm production? (am not a biologist)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- krasin 11y agoWhat can be done with m̶a̶g̶i̶c̶ CRISPR, can be undone with CRISPR. I don't see anything really permanent here.
- pasbesoin 11y agoThe financial 1% becomes the genetic 1%? As one scenario. (Even if CRISPR itself is not that expensive, the computational power to determine effective scenarios likely will be. Not to mention IP "rights" and lawyers as an additional bludgeon.) (Additionally, we appear to be just beginning to really understand folding and DNA/RNA 3D and 4D geometry. I'm uncertain we can really determine the full scope of such scenarios, yet. Including perhaps transmissible negative repercussions.)
- narrator 11y agoNaaah. That would be ok. The problem comes when this technology gets too cheap and people decide they want to live longer than they are supposed to. Same problem with stem cells. The elite can do whatever they want with this stuff. It's the masses adopting it that is troublesome.
- joe_the_user 11y agoWell, The fear could be that society would come to view gene editing as a dangerous, subversive or crank activity and so impose regulations that would be so stringent even scientists couldn't use it. Whatever one thinks of LSD, it's notable that it went from an "exciting exploration" to a thing that had to be suppressed at all costs fairly quickly in the 1960s. Despite this society presenting itself as a capitalist meritocracy, numerous examples show it doesn't generally follow the paradigm of "it's your body and you can do what you want with it".
- thescriptkiddie 11y agoSame here. I don't understand how designer babies, preventing premature aging, or stimulating muscle growth are any more "sticky" than the potential eradication of diseases like HIV, Huntington’s, and Alzheimer’s. Usually I'm pretty good at paying devil's advocate but I really can't see the argument here. Are they worried that we're going to accidentally cure death and have an overpopulation problem? That just seems silly. Or maybe they are worried that we'll anger the gods if we look into things too closely? But then I'd think they'd be after physicists.
- phkahler 11y ago>> I don't understand how designer babies, preventing premature aging, or stimulating muscle growth are any more "sticky" than the potential eradication of diseases like HIV, Huntington’s, and Alzheimer’s Thanks for reminding me that CRISPR should be able to cure HIV in short order. There is a gene variant that can make one immune if you've got two copies. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Berlin_Patient https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Berlin_Patient
- thescriptkiddie 11y agoThanks, but that part was literally quoted from the third paragraph of TFA.
- thwarted 11y ago"Think of the undertakers" and "think of the gravediggers" are pretty far fetched appeals to compassion.
- nanofortnight 11y agoThe issue with something like CRISPR is that it is inheritable. Not "inheritable and may eventually die out" inheritable, but "inheritable and all future generations from that point on would have it" inheritable. Usually, a genetic change in one organism takes a long time to spread through a population. But in this case, we have what is called a 'gene drive', where the trait can rapidly spread after a number of generations. http://www.genetics.org/content/201/2/425.full http://www.genetics.org/content/201/2/425.full Any mistake will persist in the population even against selection pressure.
- undersuit 11y ago>Any mistake will persist in the population even against selection pressure. Unfortunate for those afflicted but then they are just waiting for another CRISPR to come along and knock out the offending change.