4 ms·
Hypothes.is: an open platform for scholarly discussion on the web
- sohkamyung 11y agoFound via an article on the service at Nature News [1] [1] "Annotating the scholarly web" [ http://www.nature.com/news/annotating-the-scholarly-web-1.18900 http://www.nature.com/news/annotating-the-scholarly-web-1.18... ]
- dang 11y agoMore at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10655563 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10655563.
- chx 11y agoHey, the first Kickstarter I backed! Four years ago. Why is this on HN front page...? Did something happen?
- IshKebab 11y agoThis would be great for documentation. The number of times I've found something incorrect in the Android documentation and had no way to note it for others... That said, I think it would have to be officially recommended by a website before many people would use it.
- dwhly 11y agoThat's the thinking behind this coalition for the scholarly community.
- kristopolous 11y agoI'm seeing yet another metaweb ... I think either NS4 or IE4 had a built-in tool do this and even with half the web having it at its fingertips it still flopped. The only real metaweb that has worked has been the indirect "share a link" on a link aggregator + comments - exactly what reddit, slashdot, digg, metafilter (funny name huh?) and hn are. The insight is that there Needs To Be A Central, Browsable Repository of What Pages Have this Meta Content. Without what is effectively a 21st century web-ring, it's not happening. There should be a page that shows new stuff and a search engine ... I mean essentially reddit + wikipedia. The layer has to a centralized interface
- MasterScrat 11y agoI did a fun experiment last year with Chrome extensions: for some websites, it adds comments about the current page from Reddit. For some websites it actually works quite well. Some users reported it actually "adds a dimension" to the page. So while i agree universal metaweb is doomed, I do believe in some specific additions from relevant sources.
- cven714 11y agoThats interesting, there's been many times I've stumbled on a page "organically" and wished there were reddit or HN comments I could read about it. I would use an extension that found them for me.
- ivan_ah 11y agoIt exists for HN: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/hacker-news-discussion/iggcipafbcjfofibfhhelnipahhepmkd https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/hacker-news-discus...
- chx 11y agoalientube will replace the (awful) youtube comments with reddit threads. Neatly presents a tabbed interface with each being a subreddit. It can get really useful.
- 11y ago
- mintplant 11y agoThe video emphasizes that this is controlled by users, not site owners, and that annotations are permanent. So if, hypothetically, I ever managed to incite the wrath of an internet mob, they could use this to tack up my family's personal information over my homepage and various profiles, without me being able to do anything about it. Great.
- dwhly 11y agoThey're "permanent" in that they're not controlled by the site owners. But without effective moderation, a public channel of annotations will become unusable, so spam and trolls must be dealt with effectively.
- pervycreeper 11y agoThis is being run as a coalition of corporations, academics, and publishers. This leaves me with some concerns over just how open, accessible, and ultimately successful this enterprise will be. It is clear to me, however, that an annotation layer for the internet is the future. The time to build this is unquestionably now.
- merraksh 11y agoInteresting to see not all major publishers are involved, e.g. Springer and Elsevier are missing. Given their (especially Elsevier's) policies toward making content publicly available I'm not too surprised. https://hypothes.is/annotating-all-knowledge/ https://hypothes.is/annotating-all-knowledge/
- dwhly 11y agoWe've had discussions with them, they'll take a little longer to engage, but I'm encouraged that they probably will-- I think annotation is inevitable for scholarship, regardless of whether it's using our technology or not.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- messo 11y agoI can see myself using this tool. A lot. But I'm missing a vote up(down?) button on annotations already.
- messo 11y agoI can see myself using this tool. A lot. But I'm missing a vote up(down?) button on annotations already.