3 ms·
Things don't have a single cause. "ISIS grew out of staggeringly unequal distribution of Mideast oil wealth" and "ISIS is motivated by extreme interpretations o
by mikeash 11y ago
Things don't have a single cause. "ISIS grew out of staggeringly unequal distribution of Mideast oil wealth" and "ISIS is motivated by extreme interpretations of Islam" are able to coexist perfectly well.
Do you have any examples of "the same people" being inconsistent here? Because usually when people complain about inconsistency like this, it's actually different people being mentally categorized together, not actually the same people.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoLast sentence is an excellent point. This is a group of groups of groups. Acting like ISIS is one entity with one set of attributes is like claiming the same for the workforce of a city. They're one thing in one way with similar goals, direction, and activities but substantially different in other ways.
- notacoward 11y agoUnbelievably well stated. Kudos. (And I get downvoted for saying something nice? Some people have way too much invested in the opposing POV, and way too little courage.)
- scott_karana 11y ago> And I get downvoted for saying something nice? Some HN (and possibly its rules) frowns on "+1" or "I agree" style posts that don't add additional content to a discussion, and people will sometimes downvote you accordingly. Hopefully that's all that the downvoting was...